Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there should be some kind of national reflection on the pandemic?

470 replies

23rdmarch2020 · 20/03/2023 18:46

It’s coming up to three years since the first lockdown. In many ways, it feels an absolute age ago. From personal experience, my life completely changed in the space of a week and so many things happened in my life that never would have because of the pandemic (some good, some bad). For some, it has been an absolute tragedy. In the space of a few weeks we went from being in our normal lives to it being a criminal offence to step outside our homes without a valid excuse. Obviously people are keen to move on but AIBU to think there should be more reflection on the pandemic than there has been?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
shrimp88 · 24/03/2023 16:52

GreekDogRescue · 24/03/2023 15:35

Good to see quite a few are now challenging lockdowns (better late than never) but interesting to see the Covid Cultist-Shopping Washers are still out in force.

As I said earlier, what makes you think anyone has changed their opinions?. I bet all the people who disagree with you now disagreed with you then and visa versa.

ArcticSkewer · 24/03/2023 16:43

Buzzinwithbez · 24/03/2023 15:42

Spain wouldn't let their children out for exercise, but people could exercise their dogs.

I am so surprised that wasn't a UK thing.

We did exclude shooting (ie of course - pheasant shooting - the toffs sport of choice) from the 'rule of six'

Buzzinwithbez · 24/03/2023 15:42

Spain wouldn't let their children out for exercise, but people could exercise their dogs.

ArcticSkewer · 24/03/2023 15:40

Although global reflection would also be good, each country introduced its own bonkers rules. There's definitely interesting psychological papers in it.

The French might like to reflect on their love of paperwork for example (the little permission slip you had to write yourself to leave the house).

The Italians absolutely loved locking people up, for months on end in some cases, until they finally tested negative after a cobid infection. A national obsession with health tests, perhaps?

And the Chinese ... oh they have a lot of reflecting to do

GreekDogRescue · 24/03/2023 15:35

Good to see quite a few are now challenging lockdowns (better late than never) but interesting to see the Covid Cultist-Shopping Washers are still out in force.

shrimp88 · 24/03/2023 15:30

LastTrainEast · 24/03/2023 15:20

Perhaps the reflection could be global since so many people think the pandemic, lockdowns etc were just something that happened in the UK. Some even imagining that the whole thing was invented to be mean to British People.

😆😆

DanceMonster · 24/03/2023 15:24

I do think there needs to be a global reflection on why existing pandemic plans got entirely thrown out of the window in favour of a ‘lockdown’, which was something that had barely even been considered by the majority of pandemic planners until the concept came out of China in January 2020, yes. Why were our robust pandemic plans ignored?

LastTrainEast · 24/03/2023 15:20

Perhaps the reflection could be global since so many people think the pandemic, lockdowns etc were just something that happened in the UK. Some even imagining that the whole thing was invented to be mean to British People.

shrimp88 · 24/03/2023 15:18

DanceMonster · 24/03/2023 15:04

You’re obviously a massive fan of the government and the measures implemented @shrimp88, and that’s fine. They certainly need some fans! Some of us would have liked to have seen more consideration taken for those locked up with their abusers, those who lived alone and didn’t see another soul for months on end, those who were so scared of catching Covid that they didn’t dare seek medical treatments for other conditions, children who weren’t seen by relevant care professionals when they needed to be seen, those who missed diagnoses, those with mental health issues, the list goes on.

I'm not a fan at all. I think a lot of things should have been done very differently. e.g. lockdown should have been sooner and shorter, borders shut earlier, schools could have opened earlier perhaps using ventilated spaces such as parks and stadiums. The claim that not having a lockdown at all would have benefited people with cancer and heart disease is absolute nonsense though.

JenniferBooth · 24/03/2023 15:15

so how would the telephone appointments have worked for women married to abusers who were trying to renew their contraception that the abusive partner does not know that they are on?!

Delatron · 24/03/2023 15:10

shrimp88 · 24/03/2023 14:58

It wasn't more difficult to get a telephone doctor's appointment during the pandemic than it is now. If they wanted to see you they called you in. They weren't at home with their feet up. There was a problem with getting hospital treatment but that was partly because many hospital doctors were working in ICU or sick with covid itself. That would have be worse if we didn't have lockdown not better would have been higher. Do you actually think that they would have been more available if COVID infections were through the roof and people needed to be seen for Covid too.

No covid wasn't the only thing that mattered but people with heart conditions, cancer etc were the ones at highest risk of COVID and the last thing they needed was to catch it because there was no lockdown.

A telephone appointment is far less effective! and people were reluctant to waste doctors time..

JenniferBooth · 24/03/2023 15:06

@GoldenAye It was a right wing government who locked us down

DanceMonster · 24/03/2023 15:04

You’re obviously a massive fan of the government and the measures implemented @shrimp88, and that’s fine. They certainly need some fans! Some of us would have liked to have seen more consideration taken for those locked up with their abusers, those who lived alone and didn’t see another soul for months on end, those who were so scared of catching Covid that they didn’t dare seek medical treatments for other conditions, children who weren’t seen by relevant care professionals when they needed to be seen, those who missed diagnoses, those with mental health issues, the list goes on.

shrimp88 · 24/03/2023 14:58

Delatron · 24/03/2023 13:39

You’re looking it from a very short sighted view. Lockdown will have caused deaths - cancer diagnoses will have been missed because it was very tricky to get a doctor’s appointment in lockdown versus if everything had been open and there had not been so much fear. Ditto many other illness that will have been missed. Heart conditions, delayed chemo etc.

Excess deaths are high in every country (higher than peak Covid deaths) yet Sweden has the lowest of all European countries. That gives us a clue.

You are clearly coming at this from a point of view that nothing else mattered at that time apart from Covid and those are the only deaths that mattered and those are what we needed to prevent. Yet what if prolonging lockdown and pushing the second wave in to autumn/winter actually caused more deaths? Because the death toll from that second wave was far higher.

Also, you are just focusing on deaths. What about the lost education, lost businesses, mental health issues, lost uni years. The huge economic impact? People who couldn’t be with loved ones when they were dying? Elderly people who didn’t see family for months. It’s not all about deaths.

It wasn't more difficult to get a telephone doctor's appointment during the pandemic than it is now. If they wanted to see you they called you in. They weren't at home with their feet up. There was a problem with getting hospital treatment but that was partly because many hospital doctors were working in ICU or sick with covid itself. That would have be worse if we didn't have lockdown not better would have been higher. Do you actually think that they would have been more available if COVID infections were through the roof and people needed to be seen for Covid too.

No covid wasn't the only thing that mattered but people with heart conditions, cancer etc were the ones at highest risk of COVID and the last thing they needed was to catch it because there was no lockdown.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 24/03/2023 14:25

Well you might do, but you'd still be right.

Delatron · 24/03/2023 14:17

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 24/03/2023 13:59

You're right, but I'd point out that some of the things you list here will also cause premature deaths. Mental health problems rob years off lives. So does inequality, which we increased with our pandemic response: the impact stemming from access to education over the next few decades doesn't bear thinking about. Loneliness is dangerous, it kills.
Ultimately, the economy can't be separated from health either.

Yes I wanted to add that I thought the mental health issues could ultimately lead to deaths. But thought I’d get jumped on 🤣

Very good point that you can’t separate health and the economy..

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 24/03/2023 13:59

Delatron · 24/03/2023 13:39

You’re looking it from a very short sighted view. Lockdown will have caused deaths - cancer diagnoses will have been missed because it was very tricky to get a doctor’s appointment in lockdown versus if everything had been open and there had not been so much fear. Ditto many other illness that will have been missed. Heart conditions, delayed chemo etc.

Excess deaths are high in every country (higher than peak Covid deaths) yet Sweden has the lowest of all European countries. That gives us a clue.

You are clearly coming at this from a point of view that nothing else mattered at that time apart from Covid and those are the only deaths that mattered and those are what we needed to prevent. Yet what if prolonging lockdown and pushing the second wave in to autumn/winter actually caused more deaths? Because the death toll from that second wave was far higher.

Also, you are just focusing on deaths. What about the lost education, lost businesses, mental health issues, lost uni years. The huge economic impact? People who couldn’t be with loved ones when they were dying? Elderly people who didn’t see family for months. It’s not all about deaths.

You're right, but I'd point out that some of the things you list here will also cause premature deaths. Mental health problems rob years off lives. So does inequality, which we increased with our pandemic response: the impact stemming from access to education over the next few decades doesn't bear thinking about. Loneliness is dangerous, it kills.
Ultimately, the economy can't be separated from health either.

ArcticSkewer · 24/03/2023 13:43

Sweden followed their pandemic plan. When pandemic plans are drawn up, all these considerations are taken into account... rather than just a narrow focus on deaths from virus.

Ironically of course, Sweden followed our pandemic plan. We are the ones who didn't - because people wanted a lockdown. They saw it on TV and that's what they wanted.

There are many reasons why the pandemic plan doesn't say 'do whatever the general public thinks is a good idea'.

Delatron · 24/03/2023 13:39

shrimp88 · 24/03/2023 12:56

Sweden didn't do lockdown for the sake of the ecoonomy rather than to reduce non covid deaths. How would not having a lockdown reduce deaths from non-covid disease?

You’re looking it from a very short sighted view. Lockdown will have caused deaths - cancer diagnoses will have been missed because it was very tricky to get a doctor’s appointment in lockdown versus if everything had been open and there had not been so much fear. Ditto many other illness that will have been missed. Heart conditions, delayed chemo etc.

Excess deaths are high in every country (higher than peak Covid deaths) yet Sweden has the lowest of all European countries. That gives us a clue.

You are clearly coming at this from a point of view that nothing else mattered at that time apart from Covid and those are the only deaths that mattered and those are what we needed to prevent. Yet what if prolonging lockdown and pushing the second wave in to autumn/winter actually caused more deaths? Because the death toll from that second wave was far higher.

Also, you are just focusing on deaths. What about the lost education, lost businesses, mental health issues, lost uni years. The huge economic impact? People who couldn’t be with loved ones when they were dying? Elderly people who didn’t see family for months. It’s not all about deaths.

shrimp88 · 24/03/2023 12:56

Delatron · 24/03/2023 12:45

Yes but Sweden are playing the long game and sensibly realising that it’s not all about Covid. It’s about the other deaths and long term impact on various groups (such as the young).

Currently their excess deaths are the lowest in Europe - it’s unclear and hard to unlock why.

Sweden didn't do lockdown for the sake of the ecoonomy rather than to reduce non covid deaths. How would not having a lockdown reduce deaths from non-covid disease?

Delatron · 24/03/2023 12:45

Unpick. Auto correct doing a number on me today.

Delatron · 24/03/2023 12:45

shrimp88 · 24/03/2023 12:19

I've seen mathematical modelling which suggests that cases might have started to go down before lockdown, but we don't really know as there wasn't much testing and surely you're not suggesting we should rely on modelling? That would seem to be a little bit selective.

Sweden had a lot more deaths than other Scandinavian countries with similar demographics so I don't really think they have demonstrated there was no need for lockdown. If they thought lockdown didn't work, they wouldn't have introduced a lockdown themselves later on in the pandemic. I agree we should have introduced lockdown earlier and for a shorter period of time though.

Yes but Sweden are playing the long game and sensibly realising that it’s not all about Covid. It’s about the other deaths and long term impact on various groups (such as the young).

Currently their excess deaths are the lowest in Europe - it’s unclear and hard to unlock why.

Delatron · 24/03/2023 12:43

shrimp88 · 24/03/2023 12:19

I've seen mathematical modelling which suggests that cases might have started to go down before lockdown, but we don't really know as there wasn't much testing and surely you're not suggesting we should rely on modelling? That would seem to be a little bit selective.

Sweden had a lot more deaths than other Scandinavian countries with similar demographics so I don't really think they have demonstrated there was no need for lockdown. If they thought lockdown didn't work, they wouldn't have introduced a lockdown themselves later on in the pandemic. I agree we should have introduced lockdown earlier and for a shorter period of time though.

They could work out cases based on deaths. It was quite a while before we had accurate testing but we could see the peaks and troughs of the virus.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 24/03/2023 12:32

Crikeyalmighty · 24/03/2023 11:16

@BashirWithTheGoodBeard in Denmark they locked down around 11 days before UK but a fair bit of stuff was open again by late April/early May and when we popped over in early July (looking at rentals) we went out for meals etc- albeit with masks and spacing .

Such a shame we didn't do that here.

shrimp88 · 24/03/2023 12:19

Delatron · 24/03/2023 11:31

It is thought that the peak was just before we locked down. So dragging it out for 4 months trying to achieve zero vibe cases with the blind assumption the virus wouldn’t bounce back with a vengeance was wrong.

If we were going to lockdown we should have done it earlier and for a shorter period then opened up to allow the inevitable second wave in summer.

There seems to be an assumption that if we didn’t lockdown then everyone would all get Covid at the same time and the country would be decimated but we have no evidence that this would have happened. It didn’t happen in Sweden. Viruses have natural peaks and troughs. People
would have modified behaviour. Trying to influence these peaks and troughs is only beneficial if you time it right (and get the duration right) otherwise you are causing all the harms of lockdown and still getting huge peaks and deaths when you open up.

I've seen mathematical modelling which suggests that cases might have started to go down before lockdown, but we don't really know as there wasn't much testing and surely you're not suggesting we should rely on modelling? That would seem to be a little bit selective.

Sweden had a lot more deaths than other Scandinavian countries with similar demographics so I don't really think they have demonstrated there was no need for lockdown. If they thought lockdown didn't work, they wouldn't have introduced a lockdown themselves later on in the pandemic. I agree we should have introduced lockdown earlier and for a shorter period of time though.