Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there should be some kind of national reflection on the pandemic?

470 replies

23rdmarch2020 · 20/03/2023 18:46

It’s coming up to three years since the first lockdown. In many ways, it feels an absolute age ago. From personal experience, my life completely changed in the space of a week and so many things happened in my life that never would have because of the pandemic (some good, some bad). For some, it has been an absolute tragedy. In the space of a few weeks we went from being in our normal lives to it being a criminal offence to step outside our homes without a valid excuse. Obviously people are keen to move on but AIBU to think there should be more reflection on the pandemic than there has been?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 25/03/2023 16:29

shrimp88 · 25/03/2023 10:50

No, but people who are or were immusupressed will know more about it than you about the benefits and risks of lockdown for them.

You really need to do better at remembering who you're replying to. I haven't used the word immunosuppressed once, and this isn't the first time in this thread you've confused me with another poster.

It isn't a matter of opinion that there were barriers to accessing healthcare in person during lockdown, barriers that weren't going to be solved by better communication, and that these barriers have consequences. This isn't affected by you merailing.

Buzzinwithbez · 25/03/2023 11:58

Teafor1please · 25/03/2023 11:56

The same happened to my friend, prescribed antibiotics. She in fact had very aggressive breast cancer. Only 27.

I'm so sorry to hear this.

Teafor1please · 25/03/2023 11:56

Buzzinwithbez · 25/03/2023 11:46

I'm glad their policies to protect vulnerable people worked on the whole for you.

I was prescribed antibiotics over the phone for a breast lump in the hope it went, rather than referral for more investigation. I wonder how common this sort of thing was.
I'm not someone who felt a need to stay away from services to protect me, so that wasn't the reason.

It does seem harder to get through to a GP now than even before COVID but I'll agree, getting through was very easy during COVID. I wonder why that was.

The same happened to my friend, prescribed antibiotics. She in fact had very aggressive breast cancer. Only 27.

Buzzinwithbez · 25/03/2023 11:46

I'm glad their policies to protect vulnerable people worked on the whole for you.

I was prescribed antibiotics over the phone for a breast lump in the hope it went, rather than referral for more investigation. I wonder how common this sort of thing was.
I'm not someone who felt a need to stay away from services to protect me, so that wasn't the reason.

It does seem harder to get through to a GP now than even before COVID but I'll agree, getting through was very easy during COVID. I wonder why that was.

shrimp88 · 25/03/2023 10:50

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 25/03/2023 10:26

Again, this doesn't tell us anything at all about the societal picture or structural barriers to care in person.

No, but people who are or were immusupressed will know more about it than you about the benefits and risks of lockdown for them.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 25/03/2023 10:26

shrimp88 · 25/03/2023 10:00

I didn't want to see anyone in person unless i had too and was more than happy for the majority of appointment to be by phone. I did go in for tests.

Again, this doesn't tell us anything at all about the societal picture or structural barriers to care in person.

shrimp88 · 25/03/2023 10:00

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 25/03/2023 09:56

None of this refutes what I wrote, especially as you talk about phone calls not going in person.

Barriers to seeking medical care in person for those who wanted or needed to do it existed. They just did. That incudes some people whose risk of covid was higher.

I didn't want to see anyone in person unless i had too and was more than happy for the majority of appointment to be by phone. I did go in for tests.

shrimp88 · 25/03/2023 09:58

DemiColon · 25/03/2023 08:44

The fact that some people were more at risk does not mean their terror was proportionate. Those who are immunocompromised, for example, are more at risk for all kinds of diseases and already need to think about being more careful. Covid was not in a totally different category compared to other illnesses.

People felt it was very different in large part because they were getting this crazy advice to basically hide in their house - sometimes even from the other people in their house which was stupid and useless. It was totally different that what is usually recommended for people who have higher risk factors.

Immunsupressed people were getting their advice about risk from their specialist and organisations that specialise in their conditions. I suspect they might know a bit more than about their risk of covid and other infections.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 25/03/2023 09:56

shrimp88 · 25/03/2023 09:50

I was a vulnerable person at the start of the pandemic and the main barrier to my care was that I was very scared of catching covid while in hospital because so many people there had it. It wasn't because no one would answer my phone calls. Quite the opposite. It was a lot easier then than it is today if anything.

None of this refutes what I wrote, especially as you talk about phone calls not going in person.

Barriers to seeking medical care in person for those who wanted or needed to do it existed. They just did. That incudes some people whose risk of covid was higher.

NurseCranesRolodex · 25/03/2023 09:52

Yes but it's too early to maintain any objectivity.

shrimp88 · 25/03/2023 09:50

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 25/03/2023 08:57

There's also the fact that even a covid vulnerable person who felt they needed in person healthcare, despite the risks that might entail, still faced structural barriers to getting it. And that can't be explained as poor communication.

A system that makes it difficult to get eg a GP appointment is going to lead to things being missed, regardless of whether the person who can't get one is at higher risk than average of covid complications. Inadequate or non-existent standards of care have consequences.

I was a vulnerable person at the start of the pandemic and the main barrier to my care was that I was very scared of catching covid while in hospital because so many people there had it. It wasn't because no one would answer my phone calls. Quite the opposite. It was a lot easier then than it is today if anything.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 25/03/2023 08:57

There's also the fact that even a covid vulnerable person who felt they needed in person healthcare, despite the risks that might entail, still faced structural barriers to getting it. And that can't be explained as poor communication.

A system that makes it difficult to get eg a GP appointment is going to lead to things being missed, regardless of whether the person who can't get one is at higher risk than average of covid complications. Inadequate or non-existent standards of care have consequences.

DemiColon · 25/03/2023 08:44

shrimp88 · 25/03/2023 06:44

Covid was actually quite terrifying for people with many underlying conditions. Those with diabetes, heart disease, cancer were not getting the risk out of proportion. They were being realistic. Many were stuck between a rock and a hard place when it came to visiting hospitals or any other health care at the start of the pandemic.

The fact that some people were more at risk does not mean their terror was proportionate. Those who are immunocompromised, for example, are more at risk for all kinds of diseases and already need to think about being more careful. Covid was not in a totally different category compared to other illnesses.

People felt it was very different in large part because they were getting this crazy advice to basically hide in their house - sometimes even from the other people in their house which was stupid and useless. It was totally different that what is usually recommended for people who have higher risk factors.

nether · 25/03/2023 07:14

shrimp88 · 25/03/2023 06:44

Covid was actually quite terrifying for people with many underlying conditions. Those with diabetes, heart disease, cancer were not getting the risk out of proportion. They were being realistic. Many were stuck between a rock and a hard place when it came to visiting hospitals or any other health care at the start of the pandemic.

And of course are back in that same situation now.

If severely immune-compromised, then the vaccines don't work, and there are no mitigations now in hospitals. It's one of the riskiest places to visit but also the one that cannot be avoided.

About 1:40 people have covid on current estimate

There are thousands of hospital acquired infections.

It's all shit for those affected

shrimp88 · 25/03/2023 06:58

Badbadbunny · 24/03/2023 19:11

And some universities actually banned their students from leaving their campus flats during the lockdowns. Campus security would stop students walking around to challenge them as to why they were out, with very limited reasons being accepted such as going to the shop for food, going to do their laundry, going to the library to collect books, etc., all with the threat of disciplinary action if security deemed their reason to be out as unsatisfactory!

Yes, treatment of students was terrible.

shrimp88 · 25/03/2023 06:44

DemiColon · 24/03/2023 23:35

I don't really think so.

If you create a situation where people are terrified of one thing, covid, that will impact their behaviour. They will make crazy decisions about stuff that is actually more serous. Most people are not naturally all that good at risk assessment, if there is a lot of messaging creating fear it will make them afraid out of proportion to the real risk.

If you create a scenario where it's difficult to get an in person doctors appointment, you will find things are missed an overlooked - it's not an adaquate standard of care.

If you create a situation where going out at all is fraught and exhausting, that again will affect behaviour.

Covid was actually quite terrifying for people with many underlying conditions. Those with diabetes, heart disease, cancer were not getting the risk out of proportion. They were being realistic. Many were stuck between a rock and a hard place when it came to visiting hospitals or any other health care at the start of the pandemic.

GoldenAye · 25/03/2023 03:44

JenniferBooth · 24/03/2023 15:06

@GoldenAye It was a right wing government who locked us down

Governments across the globe, regardless of their position on the political spectrum, locked down as this was the accepted health protocol at the time, pre-vaccine.

I'm referring to the swathes of anti-lockdown, anti-vaccine and anti-science misinformation out there. These commonly come from alt-right sources.

DemiColon · 24/03/2023 23:35

shrimp88 · 24/03/2023 17:20

The fact that people avoided the doctor was an issue but it would have improved with better communication rather than no lockdown.

I don't really think so.

If you create a situation where people are terrified of one thing, covid, that will impact their behaviour. They will make crazy decisions about stuff that is actually more serous. Most people are not naturally all that good at risk assessment, if there is a lot of messaging creating fear it will make them afraid out of proportion to the real risk.

If you create a scenario where it's difficult to get an in person doctors appointment, you will find things are missed an overlooked - it's not an adaquate standard of care.

If you create a situation where going out at all is fraught and exhausting, that again will affect behaviour.

Badbadbunny · 24/03/2023 19:11

CornishYarg · 24/03/2023 18:05

I'd also add that the drop in physical activity during lockdowns will have had wide-reaching health impacts. The government could have made it clear that the law simply said leaving the house to exercise was permitted, that it was guidance that this should be limited to once a day, and that the limit of one hour was just something Michael Gove made up on the spot during an interview...but they didn’t.

Those with young children who believed the "one hour once a day" was law probably spent a lot of their "allotted" time ambling around at toddler pace which would be totally insufficient. Those with mobility issues who needed to stop and rest occasionally couldn't so were effectively barred from outdoor exercise. And lots of people don't have gardens and lots live in cramped conditions so even something like Joe Wicks was tricky to do.

And some universities actually banned their students from leaving their campus flats during the lockdowns. Campus security would stop students walking around to challenge them as to why they were out, with very limited reasons being accepted such as going to the shop for food, going to do their laundry, going to the library to collect books, etc., all with the threat of disciplinary action if security deemed their reason to be out as unsatisfactory!

Badbadbunny · 24/03/2023 19:08

Delatron · 24/03/2023 15:10

A telephone appointment is far less effective! and people were reluctant to waste doctors time..

Especially after you had to listen to 10 minutes of them telling you not to bother them with anything less than imminent death on their phone systems before you could even get to speak with a receptionist! And if you went past the GP surgery, you'd see all kinds of "stay away" signage, with hazard tape all over! It's no surprise at all that a lot of people who could have benefitted from a GP consultation thought they'd be wasted their GP's time and simply didn't bother!

CornishYarg · 24/03/2023 18:05

Delatron · 24/03/2023 13:39

You’re looking it from a very short sighted view. Lockdown will have caused deaths - cancer diagnoses will have been missed because it was very tricky to get a doctor’s appointment in lockdown versus if everything had been open and there had not been so much fear. Ditto many other illness that will have been missed. Heart conditions, delayed chemo etc.

Excess deaths are high in every country (higher than peak Covid deaths) yet Sweden has the lowest of all European countries. That gives us a clue.

You are clearly coming at this from a point of view that nothing else mattered at that time apart from Covid and those are the only deaths that mattered and those are what we needed to prevent. Yet what if prolonging lockdown and pushing the second wave in to autumn/winter actually caused more deaths? Because the death toll from that second wave was far higher.

Also, you are just focusing on deaths. What about the lost education, lost businesses, mental health issues, lost uni years. The huge economic impact? People who couldn’t be with loved ones when they were dying? Elderly people who didn’t see family for months. It’s not all about deaths.

I'd also add that the drop in physical activity during lockdowns will have had wide-reaching health impacts. The government could have made it clear that the law simply said leaving the house to exercise was permitted, that it was guidance that this should be limited to once a day, and that the limit of one hour was just something Michael Gove made up on the spot during an interview...but they didn’t.

Those with young children who believed the "one hour once a day" was law probably spent a lot of their "allotted" time ambling around at toddler pace which would be totally insufficient. Those with mobility issues who needed to stop and rest occasionally couldn't so were effectively barred from outdoor exercise. And lots of people don't have gardens and lots live in cramped conditions so even something like Joe Wicks was tricky to do.

shrimp88 · 24/03/2023 17:20

DemiColon · 24/03/2023 17:04

Just to point out, in my area skin cancer deaths have increased massively, because people were avoiding going in to the doctors. So in the last year lots are being diagnosed at stage 4 rather than earlier.

Also in my area, the authorities were hot and bothered over mass resting. In order to create more testing capacity, they suspended routine testing of all pregnant women for STIs. Shock of shocks in the past reporting period there was a big increase of babies born with syphilis, which is a really serious thing.

Many countries are now seeing excess deaths that they can't explain, not caused by covid infections.

The fact that people avoided the doctor was an issue but it would have improved with better communication rather than no lockdown.

DemiColon · 24/03/2023 17:08

GoldenAye · 24/03/2023 11:15

You know, not everyone lives in, nor cares about the UK. I don't live there. I live elsewhere in Europe and couldn't give a fig about what Nicola did or what was in the Whatsapp messages. What I do know is that properly fitted masks are effective. Whatever population they were "imposed" upon, it was proportionate at the time as there were no vaccines available.

Gosh, gullibility to right-wing propaganda runs deep.

I have read the review, and I don't know how you are concluding that. Furthermore, the lead researcher doesn't conclude that either.

What's more, that has been the direction the research has been moving in on respiratory viruses for some years, so it's not like it's new. Which is why at the very beginning of the pandemic no one was recommending masks.

DemiColon · 24/03/2023 17:04

shrimp88 · 24/03/2023 12:56

Sweden didn't do lockdown for the sake of the ecoonomy rather than to reduce non covid deaths. How would not having a lockdown reduce deaths from non-covid disease?

Just to point out, in my area skin cancer deaths have increased massively, because people were avoiding going in to the doctors. So in the last year lots are being diagnosed at stage 4 rather than earlier.

Also in my area, the authorities were hot and bothered over mass resting. In order to create more testing capacity, they suspended routine testing of all pregnant women for STIs. Shock of shocks in the past reporting period there was a big increase of babies born with syphilis, which is a really serious thing.

Many countries are now seeing excess deaths that they can't explain, not caused by covid infections.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 24/03/2023 16:55

Afaik the numbers of people who now think lockdown/restrictions were too harsh is still quite a small minority but the numbers who aren't sure are higher than they were during lockdowns. And the not sure seems to be the group that's increasing. I saw something the other day, I'll try and find it.