Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there should be some kind of national reflection on the pandemic?

470 replies

23rdmarch2020 · 20/03/2023 18:46

It’s coming up to three years since the first lockdown. In many ways, it feels an absolute age ago. From personal experience, my life completely changed in the space of a week and so many things happened in my life that never would have because of the pandemic (some good, some bad). For some, it has been an absolute tragedy. In the space of a few weeks we went from being in our normal lives to it being a criminal offence to step outside our homes without a valid excuse. Obviously people are keen to move on but AIBU to think there should be more reflection on the pandemic than there has been?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
Delatron · 26/03/2023 10:15

Another interesting (worrying) statistic I’ve found;

NHS modelling cited by the BHF suggested the drop in people having their blood pressure checked because of lockdown could lead to 11,190 heart attacks and 17,702 strokes in the next three years.
There was a huge drop in 40-74 year olds going in for their health checks.

We have no idea the harm we have caused.
But I guess all these excess deaths don’t matter because they’re not Covid…

shrimp88 · 26/03/2023 10:15

Delatron · 26/03/2023 10:04

It’s about whether lengthy lockdowns were a balanced and measured response. We know they caused lots of harm, and we won’t see the long term impact of them for many years.

Why do only deaths from Covid matter? How far do you want to take this? I mean yes if nobody ever left their houses then they wouldn’t pick up any infectious disease. But that would be ridiculous no?

Lockdowns were a very blunt tool. They kicked the can down the road. As we saw we got HUGE spikes the minute we opened up. And deaths soared.

Who has said that only deaths matter? I am asking whether people think that lockdown did reduce overall deaths and morbidy in the UK in 2020. I.e. Do they think they would have been lower or higher without lockdown. Potential pros as well as cons are surely important when reflecting on lockdown.

Delatron · 26/03/2023 10:04

It’s about whether lengthy lockdowns were a balanced and measured response. We know they caused lots of harm, and we won’t see the long term impact of them for many years.

Why do only deaths from Covid matter? How far do you want to take this? I mean yes if nobody ever left their houses then they wouldn’t pick up any infectious disease. But that would be ridiculous no?

Lockdowns were a very blunt tool. They kicked the can down the road. As we saw we got HUGE spikes the minute we opened up. And deaths soared.

shrimp88 · 26/03/2023 10:03

GoldenAye · 26/03/2023 00:57

@shrimp88

I think your opinion on that point is very relevant in this debate and interesting that you don't want to answer.

It is interesting, isn't it. I wouldn't bother with Bashir. If challenged, this poster will only consistently attack you with circular word salads that mean little. These are designed only to wear you down until you back off. However, when asked directly about something of substance - like the above - she won't answer.

Yes, their insults and meaningless word salad are a bit pathetic really.

shrimp88 · 26/03/2023 10:00

sst1234 · 26/03/2023 08:39

The didn’t.

So you think that covid didn't kill anyone?

shrimp88 · 26/03/2023 09:58

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 26/03/2023 08:38

Yes, but you're someone who claims we didn't have any pandemic planning, so you thinking something doesn't really tell us much.

The first reason this is a stupid set of parameters is because nobody thinks all appointments should've been held in person regardless of the view of the HCPs and people involved. I mean, that's just batshit. And you thought it had any relevance to a post explaining to you that some risk factors like obesity and age don't mean you have a consultant?!

The next issue is that when we talk about structural barriers to accessing healthcare and the impact this has on a population level, like I have been doing, that means the population. Not just those with particular conditions, because people's health doesn't stand still. It means people who were at low risk from covid when the pandemic started but whose health worsened for whatever reason during it.

It's interesting that all this has come in response to a completely uncontroversial point I made yesterday, that if people's physical access to healthcare is made more difficult then there are going to be consequences and that this isn't a communication issue. Of all the things we've talked about in this thread where there are genuine controversies, this really isn't one of them. And yet for some reason you merailed, bullshitted and made a load of things up. Telling.

I didn't ask what you think should have happpened. I asked whether you thought that lockdowns combined with telephone rather than in person healthcare appointments ( unless the HCP thought in person necessary) reduced or increased overall deaths and morbidity in the UK. What I think and don't think on pandemic planning etc isn't relevant to your answer so spare me the insults and word salad because you don't want to answer the question.

sst1234 · 26/03/2023 08:39

shrimp88 · 24/03/2023 07:58

I get that some people don't think lockdowns were worth the costs but that doesn't mean that they didn't massively reduce covid deaths. Anyone would think from some of these posts that covid didn't kill anyone and that lockdowns didn't work.

The didn’t.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 26/03/2023 08:39

GoldenAye · 26/03/2023 00:57

@shrimp88

I think your opinion on that point is very relevant in this debate and interesting that you don't want to answer.

It is interesting, isn't it. I wouldn't bother with Bashir. If challenged, this poster will only consistently attack you with circular word salads that mean little. These are designed only to wear you down until you back off. However, when asked directly about something of substance - like the above - she won't answer.

You could've just written waaaaaaaah and saved yourself some time there.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 26/03/2023 08:38

shrimp88 · 25/03/2023 20:00

I think your opinion on that point is very relevant in this debate and interesting that you don't want to answer.

Yes, but you're someone who claims we didn't have any pandemic planning, so you thinking something doesn't really tell us much.

The first reason this is a stupid set of parameters is because nobody thinks all appointments should've been held in person regardless of the view of the HCPs and people involved. I mean, that's just batshit. And you thought it had any relevance to a post explaining to you that some risk factors like obesity and age don't mean you have a consultant?!

The next issue is that when we talk about structural barriers to accessing healthcare and the impact this has on a population level, like I have been doing, that means the population. Not just those with particular conditions, because people's health doesn't stand still. It means people who were at low risk from covid when the pandemic started but whose health worsened for whatever reason during it.

It's interesting that all this has come in response to a completely uncontroversial point I made yesterday, that if people's physical access to healthcare is made more difficult then there are going to be consequences and that this isn't a communication issue. Of all the things we've talked about in this thread where there are genuine controversies, this really isn't one of them. And yet for some reason you merailed, bullshitted and made a load of things up. Telling.

GoldenAye · 26/03/2023 00:57

@shrimp88

I think your opinion on that point is very relevant in this debate and interesting that you don't want to answer.

It is interesting, isn't it. I wouldn't bother with Bashir. If challenged, this poster will only consistently attack you with circular word salads that mean little. These are designed only to wear you down until you back off. However, when asked directly about something of substance - like the above - she won't answer.

shrimp88 · 25/03/2023 20:00

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 25/03/2023 19:39

I haven't offered an opinion on that point, and won't be doing because it's a stupid set of parameters that don't merit my engagement.

Anyway, back to my point, the structural barriers placed in the way of healthcare access in 2020 led to problems that wouldn't otherwise exist, and the idea that they existed because of a communication problem has no grounding in reality.

I think your opinion on that point is very relevant in this debate and interesting that you don't want to answer.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 25/03/2023 19:39

shrimp88 · 25/03/2023 19:26

So you agree that mortality/morbidity among the elderly and those with underlying conditions would have been higher in 2020 if we hadn't had lockdown and all GP/hospital appointments were in person regardless of whether the HCP thought they needed to be?

I haven't offered an opinion on that point, and won't be doing because it's a stupid set of parameters that don't merit my engagement.

Anyway, back to my point, the structural barriers placed in the way of healthcare access in 2020 led to problems that wouldn't otherwise exist, and the idea that they existed because of a communication problem has no grounding in reality.

shrimp88 · 25/03/2023 19:26

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 25/03/2023 19:11

No, if I thought that I'd have written it rather than something that has a completely different meaning. Why do you keep making shit up?

So you agree that mortality/morbidity among the elderly and those with underlying conditions would have been higher in 2020 if we hadn't had lockdown and all GP/hospital appointments were in person regardless of whether the HCP thought they needed to be?

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 25/03/2023 19:11

shrimp88 · 25/03/2023 18:54

Are you actually saying that mortality/morbidity among the elderly and those with underlying conditions would have been lower in 2020 if we hadn't had lockdown and all GP/hospital appointments were in person regardless of whether the HCP thought they needed to be?

No, if I thought that I'd have written it rather than something that has a completely different meaning. Why do you keep making shit up?

shrimp88 · 25/03/2023 18:54

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 25/03/2023 18:28

Yes, being overweight or old not being medical conditions is the exact point. I'm glad you finally got there.

People who were at increased risk from covid did not all have a consultants they could speak to about the risks of accessing in person medical care, not least because some of the risks are not conditions. This is why you conflating them with immunosuppressed people is nonsense, and why I didn't write immunosuppressed people in the first place.

The rest of the post is strawmanning. Nobody said the people with those risk factors would be contacting their GP about those risk factors. Older and obese people need healthcare relating to thinks that don't relate to their age and weight. Do you think none of them had lumps that needed checking during lockdown, for example? Nobody said most people with the conditions you mention were unable to get treatment during lockdown either. There can be structural barriers to healthcare without either of these things being the case.

And again, your claim about outweighing is something you've pulled out of your arse. It's worth nothing. If you like the fact that you found it easy to get remote healthcare during lockdown and benefitted indirectly from the barriers that other people faced, there's nothing wrong in that. You can just say it without all the nonsense.

Are you actually saying that mortality/morbidity among the elderly and those with underlying conditions would have been lower in 2020 if we hadn't had lockdown and all GP/hospital appointments were in person regardless of whether the HCP thought they needed to be?

shrimp88 · 25/03/2023 18:31

DemiColon · 25/03/2023 16:44

Yes, many doctors bought into the hysteria as well and failed to keep a sense of proportion, or ability to see the larger picture in terms of overall health.

Yes I am sure the specialists and organisations that support people with conditions that increase the risk of severe COVID were just being hysterical when they advised people that they were at high risk. 🤔

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 25/03/2023 18:28

shrimp88 · 25/03/2023 18:16

People can weigh themselves and tell their GP over the phone if they wanted help with weight. Regardless, being overweight or elderly isn't actually a medical condition and most people won't be phoning their GP about it. I don't agree that most people with heart disease or diabetes or other chronic conditions that increased the risk of severe covid were unable to get treatment during lockdown. Even if there were some structural barriers (e.g. speaking to HCP on the phone rather than in person) this was outweighed by the fact that lockdown reduced the risk of severe covid for those people.

Yes, being overweight or old not being medical conditions is the exact point. I'm glad you finally got there.

People who were at increased risk from covid did not all have a consultants they could speak to about the risks of accessing in person medical care, not least because some of the risks are not conditions. This is why you conflating them with immunosuppressed people is nonsense, and why I didn't write immunosuppressed people in the first place.

The rest of the post is strawmanning. Nobody said the people with those risk factors would be contacting their GP about those risk factors. Older and obese people need healthcare relating to thinks that don't relate to their age and weight. Do you think none of them had lumps that needed checking during lockdown, for example? Nobody said most people with the conditions you mention were unable to get treatment during lockdown either. There can be structural barriers to healthcare without either of these things being the case.

And again, your claim about outweighing is something you've pulled out of your arse. It's worth nothing. If you like the fact that you found it easy to get remote healthcare during lockdown and benefitted indirectly from the barriers that other people faced, there's nothing wrong in that. You can just say it without all the nonsense.

shrimp88 · 25/03/2023 18:16

People can weigh themselves and tell their GP over the phone if they wanted help with weight. Regardless, being overweight or elderly isn't actually a medical condition and most people won't be phoning their GP about it. I don't agree that most people with heart disease or diabetes or other chronic conditions that increased the risk of severe covid were unable to get treatment during lockdown. Even if there were some structural barriers (e.g. speaking to HCP on the phone rather than in person) this was outweighed by the fact that lockdown reduced the risk of severe covid for those people.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 25/03/2023 17:38

shrimp88 · 25/03/2023 17:32

I didn't say that they did create barriers to care for people with underlying conditions. You did even though you obviously didn't have one so wouldn't really know.

Yes I'm sure you can guesstimate weight accurately through the internet.

Anyways, back to the point that you feebly attempted to take issue with, when there are structural barriers to accessing care in person as there were during lockdown, this leads to some negative impacts that wouldn't have occurred otherwise. The idea that the structural barriers ultimately led to better outcomes is nothing more than a guess you're making. Bearing in mind that so far in this thread you've treated us to gems like Britain didn't have any pandemic planning, there's no reason to take it seriously.

shrimp88 · 25/03/2023 17:32

I didn't say that they did create barriers to care for people with underlying conditions. You did even though you obviously didn't have one so wouldn't really know.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 25/03/2023 17:05

shrimp88 · 25/03/2023 16:54

I mentioned immunosupressed because that applied to me but the same point applies to anyone with an underlying condition that put them at higher risk of severe covid. Even if you want to argue that lockdown created some barriers to accessing care it reduced the risk of severe covid so there was a net benefit.

No, this is you inventing a backstory.

People who were at higher risk of covid, which is the group I talked about, don't only include medical conditions but could be related to age and/or obesity. They will not all have been getting advice on what to do if they felt they needed to see someone in person from specialists. They just won't. You can't possibly think that. You don't get a specialist just because your BMI is over 30 or you've blown out a certain number of candles on a cake! You having mixed me up with another poster would be much less silly than claiming this.

Also, claiming that barriers to accessing care created a net benefit is just something you've pulled out of your arse.

shrimp88 · 25/03/2023 16:54

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 25/03/2023 16:29

You really need to do better at remembering who you're replying to. I haven't used the word immunosuppressed once, and this isn't the first time in this thread you've confused me with another poster.

It isn't a matter of opinion that there were barriers to accessing healthcare in person during lockdown, barriers that weren't going to be solved by better communication, and that these barriers have consequences. This isn't affected by you merailing.

I mentioned immunosupressed because that applied to me but the same point applies to anyone with an underlying condition that put them at higher risk of severe covid. Even if you want to argue that lockdown created some barriers to accessing care it reduced the risk of severe covid so there was a net benefit.

DemiColon · 25/03/2023 16:44

shrimp88 · 25/03/2023 09:58

Immunsupressed people were getting their advice about risk from their specialist and organisations that specialise in their conditions. I suspect they might know a bit more than about their risk of covid and other infections.

Yes, many doctors bought into the hysteria as well and failed to keep a sense of proportion, or ability to see the larger picture in terms of overall health.

DemiColon · 25/03/2023 16:43

Teafor1please · 25/03/2023 11:56

The same happened to my friend, prescribed antibiotics. She in fact had very aggressive breast cancer. Only 27.

I know of a young teenager who is now blind because the easily diagnosed, in person, issue was not diagnosed over the phone. The larger problem was that because remote appointments are not normative, when in person care was finally given to this person, certain things that normally would have been done earlier on were missed again.

There is good reason remote medicine isn't really a great standard of care. It's something done to fill gaps where there is no other option.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 25/03/2023 16:37

YANBU.

I actually have a hard time absorbing how utterly bonkers it all was.

People condoning shouting at elderly people sitting on benches. Or calling the police because the neighbour went out twice. Politicians encouraging people to grass up their neighbours if they go out too much. Hundreds of Linda worth of fines and a court case for being out in public.

All so people wouldn’t get a virus that, however you look at it, barely affected the vast majority of people. We don’t behave this way in flu season, which totally crippled the NHS every single year. Yet people were utterly setting themselves with glee to be spending their days curtain twitching and calling the police and doing what they were told by a demonstrably incompetent and hypocritical government.

Why don’t more people think this wasn’t OK?