Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there should be some kind of national reflection on the pandemic?

470 replies

23rdmarch2020 · 20/03/2023 18:46

It’s coming up to three years since the first lockdown. In many ways, it feels an absolute age ago. From personal experience, my life completely changed in the space of a week and so many things happened in my life that never would have because of the pandemic (some good, some bad). For some, it has been an absolute tragedy. In the space of a few weeks we went from being in our normal lives to it being a criminal offence to step outside our homes without a valid excuse. Obviously people are keen to move on but AIBU to think there should be more reflection on the pandemic than there has been?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 21/03/2023 12:27

Badbadbunny · 21/03/2023 08:04

It could only have happened, and lasted so long, because of the internet, so that people could shop and work and be educated from home. The lockdowns would have been a lot shorter without that as society would have failed to function.

I think we need to properly examine less developed countries where the internet isn't as widespread to see how they coped without the lockdowns (as they couldn't have locked down like we did). Was their death rate a lot higher? If not, why not?

What I'd hoped for after Covid was better hygiene, larger/better ventilated spaces, etc., but it seems lessons havn't been learned. I was aghast last weekend at the football match to see so many people leaving the loos not washing their hands. Our local hospital has gone back to patients being crowded into tiny unventilated waiting rooms, their pharmacy has been moved back into a tiny cramped corner, etc. Even the oncology dept which had moved into a huge ward so patients could be spread out has been squeezed back into it's tiny suite. My OH is back to having his chemo treatment squeezed into a small room with a dozen other people, no room to swing a cat - these are vulnerable people.

The internet made it possible, higher population density, higher proportion of people being vulnerable or ECV (and not just the elderly) made it, perhaps, more necessary.

It would be interesting to know what happened in less developed countries, I seem to recall that at the time it was felt they might be less severely effected as they tend to have a younger population.

Bookist · 21/03/2023 12:26

No point in looking backwards because I'm just not heading that way. I rarely think about Covid or lockdown because it was just something that happened for a while and then it stopped. I just cannot summon up any angst about any of it. A couple of friends on Facebook are still continuously posting about all things Covid and I believe they genuinely regret the lockdowns finishing and life returning to normal. I think there's a lot of damaged people out there who actually preferred their lives during the lockdowns which is rather worrying.

DanceMonster · 21/03/2023 12:25

shrimp88 · 21/03/2023 12:22

Just because it wasn't necessary for COVID, it doesn't mean it wouldn't be necessary for a future virus. If there was an infectious virus with a 90% chance of killing your child, and there was a vaccine that could completely prevent the spread, would you want him to be treated by a non-vaccinated HCP?

I’m not talking about a future unspecified pandemic, I’m talking about it this one. If there is a future pandemic in which there is a 90% chance of death, and the vaccination prevents spread, then there may be a case for mandated vaccinations. Why does that make it ok that care workers and HCP’s were threatened with the sack for not taking the covid vaccination?

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 21/03/2023 12:25

shrimp88 · 21/03/2023 12:22

Just because it wasn't necessary for COVID, it doesn't mean it wouldn't be necessary for a future virus. If there was an infectious virus with a 90% chance of killing your child, and there was a vaccine that could completely prevent the spread, would you want him to be treated by a non-vaccinated HCP?

Or who? The second part of that completely irrelevant example is missing.

shrimp88 · 21/03/2023 12:22

DanceMonster · 21/03/2023 11:19

Ah ok, they were just threatened with the sack then.

Just because it wasn't necessary for COVID, it doesn't mean it wouldn't be necessary for a future virus. If there was an infectious virus with a 90% chance of killing your child, and there was a vaccine that could completely prevent the spread, would you want him to be treated by a non-vaccinated HCP?

shrimp88 · 21/03/2023 12:16

UpperLowerMiddleClass · 21/03/2023 11:31

Rather than ‘reflection’ which, though potentially useful to some people, has no concrete output, I’d much rather see a clear-sighted assessment of the long term societal problems caused by the pandemic. And then concrete policy actions to help e.g. children still suffering from missing education, or who have ongoing mental health issues from the lockdowns.

My overall broad view of the pandemic is that children and young people sacrificed so much for a illness that didn’t affect them much, in order to protect the elderly. In return I think any reflection on the pandemic should result in actions that recognise this generational aspect. Such as ending the ridiculous triple lock on pensions at a time when many younger people are in poverty. We cannot just view the pandemic in isolation - it has to be connected to broader issues and policies.

The next pandemic could effect children and young people much more though. They are often the most vulnerable.

Mitchumforthewin · 21/03/2023 12:13

@GrannyWeatherwaxsHatpin yes!!! This is exactly how I feel too. I know so many people locally who were total cunts on Facebook about people walking their dogs in the ‘wrong’ village, not sanitising bloody farm gates etc - they were absolutely vile.

They’ll never admit it though. They were ‘good’ and you were ‘bad’. Absolutely appalling. Banging fucking pots in the front garden but snitching on people for daring to go on 2 walks a day. I hate every single one of them still - and I know who a lot of them locally are and I still judge them. It’s made me really hate so many people.

I bet a lot of them are still on mumsnet too like they were at the time, telling people off for buying a mascara with their Tesco shop as it wasn’t ‘essential’ (WHY DID IT MATTER?!) There was a thread about a lady dropping off some homemade cakes to a neighbour and everyone saying what a stupid thing to do, don’t you know homemade cakes will KILL YOUR NEIGHBOUR. Fucking hell. Any dissenting voices (I was one of them) were quickly shut down in a really nasty manner. There was no place to reason, or to question. This is what frightens me, how many people just loved being fucking covid marshals and being total cunts to everyone else.

UserNameTwo · 21/03/2023 11:55

I suspect that people who enthusiastically clamoured for more more more authoritarian measures and became fully paid up members of the covid cult privately know they were had in a big way, and they are the ones who want to move on.

MarshaBradyo · 21/03/2023 11:45

UpperLowerMiddleClass · 21/03/2023 11:31

Rather than ‘reflection’ which, though potentially useful to some people, has no concrete output, I’d much rather see a clear-sighted assessment of the long term societal problems caused by the pandemic. And then concrete policy actions to help e.g. children still suffering from missing education, or who have ongoing mental health issues from the lockdowns.

My overall broad view of the pandemic is that children and young people sacrificed so much for a illness that didn’t affect them much, in order to protect the elderly. In return I think any reflection on the pandemic should result in actions that recognise this generational aspect. Such as ending the ridiculous triple lock on pensions at a time when many younger people are in poverty. We cannot just view the pandemic in isolation - it has to be connected to broader issues and policies.

I agree with this. We let young people down hugely

SkyandSurf · 21/03/2023 11:43

UpperLowerMiddleClass · 21/03/2023 11:31

Rather than ‘reflection’ which, though potentially useful to some people, has no concrete output, I’d much rather see a clear-sighted assessment of the long term societal problems caused by the pandemic. And then concrete policy actions to help e.g. children still suffering from missing education, or who have ongoing mental health issues from the lockdowns.

My overall broad view of the pandemic is that children and young people sacrificed so much for a illness that didn’t affect them much, in order to protect the elderly. In return I think any reflection on the pandemic should result in actions that recognise this generational aspect. Such as ending the ridiculous triple lock on pensions at a time when many younger people are in poverty. We cannot just view the pandemic in isolation - it has to be connected to broader issues and policies.

I agree with this. It would be good to see some real looks resources in recognition of the generational inequality.

UpperLowerMiddleClass · 21/03/2023 11:31

Rather than ‘reflection’ which, though potentially useful to some people, has no concrete output, I’d much rather see a clear-sighted assessment of the long term societal problems caused by the pandemic. And then concrete policy actions to help e.g. children still suffering from missing education, or who have ongoing mental health issues from the lockdowns.

My overall broad view of the pandemic is that children and young people sacrificed so much for a illness that didn’t affect them much, in order to protect the elderly. In return I think any reflection on the pandemic should result in actions that recognise this generational aspect. Such as ending the ridiculous triple lock on pensions at a time when many younger people are in poverty. We cannot just view the pandemic in isolation - it has to be connected to broader issues and policies.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 21/03/2023 11:22

It was care workers who were required to leave their jobs if they didn't have the vaccine, not NHS staff. A fucking terrible policy, one that the government were told well in advance was going to decimate the sector, and which we continue to feel the effects of now.

DanceMonster · 21/03/2023 11:19

Ah ok, they were just threatened with the sack then.

shrimp88 · 21/03/2023 11:18

DanceMonster · 21/03/2023 11:09

There weren't vaccine mandates in the UK

Tell that to the HCP’s who were sacked for not having the vaccine.

They might have left because they thought the mandate would come in but health care professionals weren't sacked.

GrannyWeatherwaxsHatpin · 21/03/2023 11:10

I certainly feel [the stupid rules] need to be critically analysed and the harms spelled out, but I don't see how this is the mechanism for it.

I agree. I don't want some kind of national mourning for what happened but I do want there to be an acknowledgement, at an official level, that the Covid prevention measures often did more harm than good and, at the very least, were not without societal cost. Yes, the measures quite probably reduced your chance of getting Covid, but at what price if it fucked your mental health/wrecked your marriage or business/shut you up with your abuser/kyboshed your children's education and development? There was an endlessly pious air of "It's for your own good, we're saving lives and protecting the NHS". Any criticism or questioning why you could walk past a bench but not sit on it for two minutes automatically marked you out as one of The Terrible People.

But what I REALLY REALLY want to see is an acknowledgment from those who behaved like nasty little cunts, that they were nasty little cunts. Not ONCE have I seen acknowledgment or apology from those who hurled abuse at those who went out twice a day, were out for more than The Regulation One Hour (which never existed), went the wrong way round a one-way system, didn't wear a mask because they couldn't, met up with someone because they were desperately lonely or in any other way tried to keep a foot on the bottom of their sanity pool.

THOSE people who made other people's lives worse at a time when everyone was struggling - EVERY SINGLE FUCKING ONE OF THEM - should hang their heads in utter shame. May you never be forgiven.

DanceMonster · 21/03/2023 11:09

There weren't vaccine mandates in the UK

Tell that to the HCP’s who were sacked for not having the vaccine.

shrimp88 · 21/03/2023 11:05

Aishah231 · 21/03/2023 06:02

But if we don't seek to understand what went right and what went wrong we could make the same mistakes again. The lockdown and the vaccine mandates seem to have been terrible mistakes. We need to know if that statement is true or false. We spent hundreds of billions on these policies we deserve to know if they were the right ones.

There weren't vaccine mandates in the UK. Most people don't think lockdown was a "terrible mistake" although there were some stupid non sensical rules. Even if it was decided it wasn't necessary for Covid in retrospect that doesn't mean it wouldn't be necessary another more dangerous virus. A new virus/disease isn’t going to be exactly the same and it could affect a different demographic such as young healthy people.

shrimp88 · 21/03/2023 10:56

Ruffpuff · 21/03/2023 10:19

My mh has never recovered. I’ve developed poor coping methods that I never had before. I feel traumatised from it, and now no one talks about it. It’s as if this collective thing we all went through never happened. I can’t process it at all.

When I was 22, my dad died of Covid in the first few months. I had to deal with the pitiful funeral of 10 people for 10 minutes, sat socially distanced. I didn’t know my dad’s family, so I essentially had to go through it alone.

I started a new job I was really looking forward to. I’d been off work for a year to look after the baby, and I was already isolated. Instead the job became work-from-home-while-looking-after-a-15 month old baby-for-months, because the nursery couldn’t have him and neither could family.

I was suicidal by the end of the lockdowns. I’d been enveloped by grief, loneliness, stress and guilt.

Something to recognise that horrible event would at least comfort me that people remember. Otherwise I feel like I’ve been left with a load of issues that have been brushed under the carpet. People like my dad were snatched away so suddenly and unexpectedly. The government behaved awfully. It should not be forgotten.

People still are being snatched away by covid though.

shrimp88 · 21/03/2023 10:52

purpledalmation · 21/03/2023 10:49

I think there should be a service in Westminster abbey in memory of the people who died, and the people on the front line who died. It's not all about lockdowns and not visiting families in care homes. A lot of people died and a lot of people are living with the after affects.

They still are dying though.

purpledalmation · 21/03/2023 10:49

I think there should be a service in Westminster abbey in memory of the people who died, and the people on the front line who died. It's not all about lockdowns and not visiting families in care homes. A lot of people died and a lot of people are living with the after affects.

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 21/03/2023 10:42

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 21/03/2023 09:55

Hmm, up to a point. Some of the worst excesses involved police bullshitting, but not all, and we also know from the Hancock leaks that they were being leaned on by the government. It's quite a toxic brew.

Some of the problems stem from the legislation, for example it is not the fault of the police that the rules in the 2021 lockdown in England functionally excluded primary school aged children. It is not the police who decided the curriculum shouldn't be suspended then, creating one class of children who were afforded schooling with reduced ratios and others who were considered unworthy of even the most basic education. Looking outside England, it's not the police who made a law in summer 2021 that Scottish people couldn't go to Greater Manchester. Our legislators shat the bed all by themselves. Obviously there were also things like Derbyshire police telling those women that a cup of coffee was a picnic.

But I agree with your scepticism about what national reflection could actually do. I don't know how it would work and it would inevitably be if not led then influenced by some of the people responsible for the stupidest rules.

Derbyshire police were a particular low.

Not only was there the incident with the two women having a walk and a coffee having travelled mins from a village that was technically in Leicestershire, they were also behind the lake the was dyed, the drone footage of dog walkers, banning people from city council postcodes from a county council park (despite them being within walking distance), and countless other overreaches.

I remember my DH being really anxious about being stopped by the police while walking.

MrsSkylerWhite · 21/03/2023 10:35

CocoFifi · Yesterday 19:31
It's over, look forwards, not backwards and move on with your life.“

On my and my husband’s behalf, I would usually agree with you. It had terrible repercussions for our young people though, that are still being worked through.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 21/03/2023 10:34

I don't think it's helpful to generalise about whether people should or shouldn't be sharing or looking forward. For some people, discussion and reflection will be helpful and for others it won't.

jays · 21/03/2023 10:32

SkyandSurf · 21/03/2023 06:44

@jays

I'm sorry for your loss. The same thing happened here as well. It happened in my family.

This is my point- what good comes of comparing and sharing it.

Sorry I’m not sure how to reply directly yet. I’m truly so sorry that you had this happen too, it’s horrific and I think quite a large section of society don’t actually get how bad many of us are still feeling and probably always will feel. I just can’t begin to imagine hashing over it, hearing about everyone’s hindsight and discussing it all like it was ‘the good old days’, we were all ‘in it together’ or even talking about remembering or learning from …. It’s the worst thing that’s ever happened to me and to my family and it’ll haunt me for the rest of my life. I don’t want to reminisce about all the ‘silly rules’ etc, i genuinely think a lot of people have no idea what happened to some of us during it all.

Wishawisha · 21/03/2023 10:28

Mitchumforthewin · 21/03/2023 07:38

And this is what we should be questioning - that awful message from councils that somehow sitting on a fucking bench was spreading covid somehow! How did that ever be allowed to happen?? Anyone with half a brain knew that was total bullshit but people went along with it! I didn’t - i knew all along that was total shit and carried on sitting down / resting with wild abandon (ha!) but if I mentioned that here on mumsnet I’d be told I was a killer. It infuriated me then and it still does now. How people were so sucked in by all the bollocks. It makes me really truly doubt people’s intelligence that they couldn’t see that stuff like this was utter nonsense. Like the fact you could only go to a pub if you were eating?! Or in the gym - you had to wear a mask to walk up the stairs on your own but take it off in a class of 30 people doing spin.
I think it does need looking at. It should never be allowed to happen again. You can’t spread a disease you don’t have, it was all fucking nuts.

It was crazy but it was bloody terrifying. You heard of people getting moved on by the police or fined for sitting down or drinking a coffee (being out when you weren’t specifically “exercising”).
One time I went for a jog in the evening and at one point I slowed down and started messing around with my phone (I wasn’t out to for a jog, I was out to be without my children for 20 minutes) and a police car saw me and slowed down to crawl along side me I put my phone away and started jogging again and the police car left. It was quite clear what the message was.

I don’t think we can blame people entirely for being sucked in. The police were enforcing zealously and rules were rules - it’s not like I could have had a drink without a “substantial meal” in a pub because they simply wouldn’t have served me. I went back to the gym the day it opened but it’s hardly like I could have gone before. Like so many people I was scared of the police more than any virus.

By the winter lockdown I was breaking some minor rules and sticking very much to law vs guidelines distinction but I’d decided at that point that I would pay a penalty notice or two if it came to it so a lot of the fear was gone. I think a lot of it fell apart with bubbles because there was no register of bubbles so if you said you were in a bubble no one could ask you to prove it.

For most of us, life has gone back to normal, but I have a neighbour who still wears plastic gloves and prowls around the street asking people why they have put their garden bin in such a position or whether they have permission to do anything. Lockdown made her into this person.