Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there should be some kind of national reflection on the pandemic?

470 replies

23rdmarch2020 · 20/03/2023 18:46

It’s coming up to three years since the first lockdown. In many ways, it feels an absolute age ago. From personal experience, my life completely changed in the space of a week and so many things happened in my life that never would have because of the pandemic (some good, some bad). For some, it has been an absolute tragedy. In the space of a few weeks we went from being in our normal lives to it being a criminal offence to step outside our homes without a valid excuse. Obviously people are keen to move on but AIBU to think there should be more reflection on the pandemic than there has been?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
JenniferBooth · 21/03/2023 14:46

<gets bingo card ready> Have already ticked off one silencing tactic

Delatron · 21/03/2023 14:45

shrimp88 · 21/03/2023 14:42

You would think so but from posts here/facebook/youtube those against lockdown were very often against vaccine too.

Right. But many people who could see the harm that lockdowns were doing were pro-vaccines. So I’m not sure why you keep lumping the two together. Your arguments are vague and make no sense to be honest.

shrimp88 · 21/03/2023 14:44

Delatron · 21/03/2023 14:42

For the second time can you please stop lumping vaccinations and lockdowns together. You’re not coming across well at all.

I’ve said repeatedly that I fully supported the vaccine program- it was one thing we did very well. I also supported the first lockdown but that it should have ended sooner and that schools should have opened before pubs..

Can you not understand the nuances of these arguments?

I’m not excited at all. I’m just sad actually for those that suffered disproportionately throughout lockdowns and I don’t even include myself in that. My lockdown was fine - I just have empathy!

This will be discussed and analysed probably for the rest of time. Just like the wars, the great flu pandemic. It won’t be brushed under the carpet. Thank goodness for that.

As I said the two often went together. Look at all the right wing media here and abroad.

shrimp88 · 21/03/2023 14:42

MarshaBradyo · 21/03/2023 14:38

As said in pp you are linking two separate things. If someone thinks lockdown was harmful they can still see vaccines as good.

It is the latter that allowed us to break from harsh restrictions after all.

You would think so but from posts here/facebook/youtube those against lockdown were very often against vaccine too.

Delatron · 21/03/2023 14:42

shrimp88 · 21/03/2023 14:36

Of course it will be analysed. There will be a lot of research. I doubt that the the general conclusion will be that lockdowns and vaccination shouldn't have happened though so don't get too excited.

For the second time can you please stop lumping vaccinations and lockdowns together. You’re not coming across well at all.

I’ve said repeatedly that I fully supported the vaccine program- it was one thing we did very well. I also supported the first lockdown but that it should have ended sooner and that schools should have opened before pubs..

Can you not understand the nuances of these arguments?

I’m not excited at all. I’m just sad actually for those that suffered disproportionately throughout lockdowns and I don’t even include myself in that. My lockdown was fine - I just have empathy!

This will be discussed and analysed probably for the rest of time. Just like the wars, the great flu pandemic. It won’t be brushed under the carpet. Thank goodness for that.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 21/03/2023 14:41

shrimp88 · 21/03/2023 14:40

Obviously antilockdown and antivaccine shouldn't go together. However many of those who were against lockdown were also against vaccines which says a lot.

For someone who thinks they shouldn't go together you're not making much effort to separate the two. Also, the use of 'many' is vague and meaningless in this context, so actually it says bugger all.

shrimp88 · 21/03/2023 14:40

Delatron · 21/03/2023 13:44

Anti lockdown does not mean anti-vaccine. Two completely separate things. Very simplistic to lump these together…

And many people were supportive of the first lockdown - just that it went on too long and the wrong things were prioritised to open.. and we did not need subsequent lengthy lockdowns. Heaven forbid we can apply some critical thinking to this without being shut down as ‘anti-vax’. I’ve had all 3 vaccines thank you very much.

It’s not about an ‘I told you so’. It’s about accurately assessing what worked and what mistakes were made - not even just in our country but across the world. But don’t worry it is all coming out. This isn’t closed. This will be discussed and analysed for many, many years to come. Our grandchildren’s grandchildren will be writing a critique of this in history lessons in the future. Probably judging with horror what happened (especially to children in Spain!).

Obviously antilockdown and antivaccine shouldn't go together. However many of those who were against lockdown were also against vaccines which says a lot.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 21/03/2023 14:39

MarshaBradyo · 21/03/2023 14:38

As said in pp you are linking two separate things. If someone thinks lockdown was harmful they can still see vaccines as good.

It is the latter that allowed us to break from harsh restrictions after all.

Yes, this is an important point. There are a cohort of people who are either against or on the fence about lockdown who are also pro vaccination. That's just plain fact.

IAmTheWalrus85 · 21/03/2023 14:38

Delatron · 21/03/2023 13:07

I agree with this.

It’s not reflection per se. Just an acknowledgment that most of the measures were ineffective, not based on any science and probably made the subsequent waves worse.

The impact on mental health, on businesses, on children’s futures, on those at uni. Those that died alone. The inequality - pubs and garden centres open but children can’t go to school. How women tended to be the ones who had to make the most sacrifices to look after children and home school. Probably whilst the men were playing golf, at the barbers, the pubs and whatever else was open before the schools .

The measures were disproportionate and many people behaved appallingly. However, I’m confident this won’t be swept under the carpet like many want it to be. History will look back and analyse and I think we will, in particular, not look back favourably on how we threw our children under the bus..

I don’t disagree, but my recollection is that the government desperately tried to open the schools but were met with resistance.

I do find it extraordinary looking back. Education is a fundamental human right. We’ve collectively agreed as a society that it should be free and mandatory between the ages of 5 and 18. It’s unbelievable how easily it got whipped away. And anyone who dared express the slightest concern about it on here got their arses handed to them by the Covid police.

MarshaBradyo · 21/03/2023 14:38

shrimp88 · 21/03/2023 14:36

Of course it will be analysed. There will be a lot of research. I doubt that the the general conclusion will be that lockdowns and vaccination shouldn't have happened though so don't get too excited.

As said in pp you are linking two separate things. If someone thinks lockdown was harmful they can still see vaccines as good.

It is the latter that allowed us to break from harsh restrictions after all.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 21/03/2023 14:37

shrimp88 · 21/03/2023 14:36

Of course it will be analysed. There will be a lot of research. I doubt that the the general conclusion will be that lockdowns and vaccination shouldn't have happened though so don't get too excited.

Oh well, if you doubt it then we probably don't even need to bother. The issue is settled!

shrimp88 · 21/03/2023 14:36

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 21/03/2023 13:48

Exactly.

Of course it will be analysed. There will be a lot of research. I doubt that the the general conclusion will be that lockdowns and vaccination shouldn't have happened though so don't get too excited.

JenniferBooth · 21/03/2023 14:29

What i experienced at Christmas 2020 I got PMed through fb several times by a man id never physically met who asked me if i had spent Christmas with my family and then asked if i was still following the rules,and how we should all follow the rules unlike some. It was fucking creepy. A man PMing a woman he has never physically met late at night to make sure ask if she is still following the rules.

I DID go to my parents that Christmas as im a carer so was "allowed" to but i didnt tell him that The way he went on afterwards about how people should follow the rules told me i made the right decision especially as he was in our local fb group (so he is local) and his posts showed he had put his OWN interpretation on the rules like many on here. I have kept these messages I havent deleted them and i wont be doing so.

UpperLowerMiddleClass · 21/03/2023 14:12

@Delatron I completely agree. We need to consider all the trade-offs that were made during the lockdowns, including the medium and long term effects (on education, mental health, etc) which by definition won’t be clear until time passes. We also need to examine the impact the pandemic had on our trust in politicians, media & scientists.

It was impossible even to raise the idea that there were trade-offs at the height of the pandemic. On here you’d immediately get screeched at that you didn’t care that someone’s granny might die, and that you were an uncaring selfish monster. Whereas now hopefully a more measured discussion is possible.

For what it’s worth I think the first lockdown and associated measures was the right thing to do. But then in autumn 2020 when there was more clarity over which groups were at higher risk of death from covid, plus treatment was more developed, the emphasis should have shifted to life getting back to normal for the vast majority of people, who could accurately assess that they were not at serious risk.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 21/03/2023 13:48

Delatron · 21/03/2023 13:44

Anti lockdown does not mean anti-vaccine. Two completely separate things. Very simplistic to lump these together…

And many people were supportive of the first lockdown - just that it went on too long and the wrong things were prioritised to open.. and we did not need subsequent lengthy lockdowns. Heaven forbid we can apply some critical thinking to this without being shut down as ‘anti-vax’. I’ve had all 3 vaccines thank you very much.

It’s not about an ‘I told you so’. It’s about accurately assessing what worked and what mistakes were made - not even just in our country but across the world. But don’t worry it is all coming out. This isn’t closed. This will be discussed and analysed for many, many years to come. Our grandchildren’s grandchildren will be writing a critique of this in history lessons in the future. Probably judging with horror what happened (especially to children in Spain!).

Exactly.

Delatron · 21/03/2023 13:44

shrimp88 · 21/03/2023 13:20

Most people have moved on. The ones that haven't are the ones jumping up and down asking for reflection. They are usually the ones who were against vaccines and lockdowns who are hugely disappointed they didn't get their “I told you so” moment.

Anti lockdown does not mean anti-vaccine. Two completely separate things. Very simplistic to lump these together…

And many people were supportive of the first lockdown - just that it went on too long and the wrong things were prioritised to open.. and we did not need subsequent lengthy lockdowns. Heaven forbid we can apply some critical thinking to this without being shut down as ‘anti-vax’. I’ve had all 3 vaccines thank you very much.

It’s not about an ‘I told you so’. It’s about accurately assessing what worked and what mistakes were made - not even just in our country but across the world. But don’t worry it is all coming out. This isn’t closed. This will be discussed and analysed for many, many years to come. Our grandchildren’s grandchildren will be writing a critique of this in history lessons in the future. Probably judging with horror what happened (especially to children in Spain!).

Hardbackwriter · 21/03/2023 13:25

I'm sure it's true that many people know they behaved badly, but I think probably even more are in denial. It's so easy to look back in a way that convinces you you were more in line with how you think now than you were - it's a cognitive bias we nearly all have.

When I think back I naturally think of the people who judged me for letting immediate family see my newborn outside, I think of the people who told me it was wrong, pathetic and selfish of me to even care what my toddler was missing out when PEoplE ArE DyInG, I think of how angry I felt when people went on about how amazing lockdown was and how great it was not being able to see anyone for Christmas and 'maybe we should always live like this'. I think of the fact that I took DS1 out of nursery for the last six weeks of my pregnancy with DS2 largely because I was so affected by people saying that you were a terrible person who didn't care about your child or the staff if you used nursery when you didn't absolutely have to, so I hobbled around miserably and irritably with SPD and a 2.5 year old all day every day. I remember my complete terror in case I had to give birth alone.

But if I dig really deep I can also remember thinking it was really selfish and irresponsible of my elderly neighbours to be going to the shop daily in the first lockdown, I can remember being shocked when a friend said they'd been having people in their house when that wasn't 'allowed' and I can remember feeling judgemental of other nursery parents who didn't wear masks for pick-up (outdoors!). To be clear I never expressed any of that to the people involved, but those thoughts were definitely in my head. I was scared, exhausted, lonely, isolated and spending far too long on the internet. I was also in a deeply unfamiliar situation where we had very imperfect information. But it's really easy to forget I ever felt like that, looking back, and I suspect it is for lots of other people too.

shrimp88 · 21/03/2023 13:20

Delatron · 21/03/2023 13:09

Yep - my thoughts exactly.

Most people have moved on. The ones that haven't are the ones jumping up and down asking for reflection. They are usually the ones who were against vaccines and lockdowns who are hugely disappointed they didn't get their “I told you so” moment.

Delatron · 21/03/2023 13:09

UserNameTwo · 21/03/2023 11:55

I suspect that people who enthusiastically clamoured for more more more authoritarian measures and became fully paid up members of the covid cult privately know they were had in a big way, and they are the ones who want to move on.

Yep - my thoughts exactly.

Delatron · 21/03/2023 13:07

GrannyWeatherwaxsHatpin · 21/03/2023 11:10

I certainly feel [the stupid rules] need to be critically analysed and the harms spelled out, but I don't see how this is the mechanism for it.

I agree. I don't want some kind of national mourning for what happened but I do want there to be an acknowledgement, at an official level, that the Covid prevention measures often did more harm than good and, at the very least, were not without societal cost. Yes, the measures quite probably reduced your chance of getting Covid, but at what price if it fucked your mental health/wrecked your marriage or business/shut you up with your abuser/kyboshed your children's education and development? There was an endlessly pious air of "It's for your own good, we're saving lives and protecting the NHS". Any criticism or questioning why you could walk past a bench but not sit on it for two minutes automatically marked you out as one of The Terrible People.

But what I REALLY REALLY want to see is an acknowledgment from those who behaved like nasty little cunts, that they were nasty little cunts. Not ONCE have I seen acknowledgment or apology from those who hurled abuse at those who went out twice a day, were out for more than The Regulation One Hour (which never existed), went the wrong way round a one-way system, didn't wear a mask because they couldn't, met up with someone because they were desperately lonely or in any other way tried to keep a foot on the bottom of their sanity pool.

THOSE people who made other people's lives worse at a time when everyone was struggling - EVERY SINGLE FUCKING ONE OF THEM - should hang their heads in utter shame. May you never be forgiven.

I agree with this.

It’s not reflection per se. Just an acknowledgment that most of the measures were ineffective, not based on any science and probably made the subsequent waves worse.

The impact on mental health, on businesses, on children’s futures, on those at uni. Those that died alone. The inequality - pubs and garden centres open but children can’t go to school. How women tended to be the ones who had to make the most sacrifices to look after children and home school. Probably whilst the men were playing golf, at the barbers, the pubs and whatever else was open before the schools .

The measures were disproportionate and many people behaved appallingly. However, I’m confident this won’t be swept under the carpet like many want it to be. History will look back and analyse and I think we will, in particular, not look back favourably on how we threw our children under the bus..

JeanniesDiary · 21/03/2023 13:04

Mitchumforthewin · 21/03/2023 12:13

@GrannyWeatherwaxsHatpin yes!!! This is exactly how I feel too. I know so many people locally who were total cunts on Facebook about people walking their dogs in the ‘wrong’ village, not sanitising bloody farm gates etc - they were absolutely vile.

They’ll never admit it though. They were ‘good’ and you were ‘bad’. Absolutely appalling. Banging fucking pots in the front garden but snitching on people for daring to go on 2 walks a day. I hate every single one of them still - and I know who a lot of them locally are and I still judge them. It’s made me really hate so many people.

I bet a lot of them are still on mumsnet too like they were at the time, telling people off for buying a mascara with their Tesco shop as it wasn’t ‘essential’ (WHY DID IT MATTER?!) There was a thread about a lady dropping off some homemade cakes to a neighbour and everyone saying what a stupid thing to do, don’t you know homemade cakes will KILL YOUR NEIGHBOUR. Fucking hell. Any dissenting voices (I was one of them) were quickly shut down in a really nasty manner. There was no place to reason, or to question. This is what frightens me, how many people just loved being fucking covid marshals and being total cunts to everyone else.

yes, I remembered a similar one about a girl dropping brownies on a friend's doorstep from a distance.
I just looked it up and, bloody hell, the responses... Now I know why I was a nervous wreck at the time, too scared to do anything, even take a walk or post a letter, lest I be branded A Bad Person.
And half of the screechers likely went back to normal, restaurants and pubs the minute restrictions were lifted while the others they terrified took months/years. Like the "hurrah, the schools are shut" lot were first to send theirs back when r/y1/y6 opened and we were given a "choice" whereas others felt shamed into not sending them.

DanceMonster · 21/03/2023 13:01

shrimp88 · 21/03/2023 12:55

So you don't want national reflection so that we can learn from it in case there is another one? In that case, I don't see the benefit.

One of the reasons I said I don’t think there’s any point in a ‘national reflection’.

shrimp88 · 21/03/2023 12:55

DanceMonster · 21/03/2023 12:25

I’m not talking about a future unspecified pandemic, I’m talking about it this one. If there is a future pandemic in which there is a 90% chance of death, and the vaccination prevents spread, then there may be a case for mandated vaccinations. Why does that make it ok that care workers and HCP’s were threatened with the sack for not taking the covid vaccination?

So you don't want national reflection so that we can learn from it in case there is another one? In that case, I don't see the benefit.

PropellerDance · 21/03/2023 12:45

Lockdown pissed me off to no end.

My young sibling has terminal cancer, I was unable to see them throughout. My dad and my uncle were also diagnosed with cancer during lockdown.

I had to wear a mask to and from work and then at work for 10 hours a day. So for 12 hours I had to wear a poxy mask in an active job role, including during the heat waves.

Buying lunch was out of the question as everyone decided 1pm during the week was when they were going to stockpile on toilet rolls. Meanwhile the poor shop staff are getting abused and also having to slave away in masks.

Meanwhile I'm driving past Tom, Dick and Harry on my way to/from work living it up in the park in the sun with their newly purchased cockapoo being paid furlough and loving life.

PropellerDance · 21/03/2023 12:29

MySugarBabyLove · 20/03/2023 19:53

Honestly? I think people don’t actually realise how easy we had it here.

Our measures were minimal compared to the majority of the rest of the world, and still people think that there should be a national reflection?

Reflection on what?

On the fact you didn’t have to have a letter to leave your house? (Spain/Italy)

The fact you were able to drink alcohol? (South Africa)

The fact no-one came round to inspect your house every day to make sure that you hadn’t been out? (China).

The fact that our borders weren’t closed for almost two years? (New Zealand.

Honestly the Uk had probably one of the least harsh lockdowns in the whole world.

Disagree.