Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So upset, not sure what to do

717 replies

Moonstarssunsky · 20/03/2023 17:04

Posting here for traffic.
I'm not sure what to do over a stray cat I've been feeding etc.

I had my own cat until a few months ago when she sadly passed away. Before she passed however, a stray cat started to visit our garden and play with my cat.

The stray cat 'Tom' was so thin that we'd feed him everyday and provided shelter outside for him. We couldn't get close enough to get him into a cat carrier to take him to the vets.
After our Molly died, Tom became more confident with us and started to come into the house and stay overnight.

He put on weight and started to look healthy again. It was still difficult though trying to entice him into a cat carrier in order to check if he was chipped after all. He.was'nt neutered though, hence why we presumed he wasn't chipped either.
I recently borrowed a different kind of carrier to the one we already had, in the hope that it'd be easier to get Tom into it. Just to say, he's not the type of cat you can pick up easily.

Fast forward to yesterday, I was looking out the window and saw a young man walking past my house carrying Tom tightly in his arms. I ran out to speak to the man and saw that Tom was struggling to get free and was very distressed.
The man claimed that Tom was his cat and that he was taking him home as he hadn't seen him for some time.

I explained that we'd been caring for Tom and were gaining his confidence in us and that we'd love to keep him and get him checked and neutered at the vets.

The man was adamant however that Tom was his family pet, but admitted that he'd not been chipped. He said that his family were going to chip the cat immediately, and added that he'd make Tom into an indoor cat just so that he doesn't try to come back to me and my family.
The man let slip his house number (which was much further down the road) and hurried off with the cat still distressed.

I'm angry at myself for not trying to get Tom out of his arms, but I was concerned about repercussions if I did so. I'm also angry with myself for not ensuring we'd taken Tom to the vets sooner. I've no excuses for that, other than I was trying to gain his trust and needed the right carrier along with help from someone else to force him into the carrier if necessary.
A while after Tom was taken, my Dd and I visited the house where he's at and were told basically to go away (not very politely) once again, and that they'd be keeping the cat inside from now on.

I don't know what to do now. I'd love to offer money for Tom but I don't know whether to leave it for a while, as i.dont want to push things with this family.

They also have a few other cats (according to the going man) and so now I'm so upset that Tom is living with other pets and isn't happy there. If he was he wouldn't have left.
Sorry for rambling.

OP posts:
D0t · 22/03/2023 07:00

This is non of your business. It’s not your cat. You’ve been feeding him when you shouldn’t have been, luring him away from his real home. Stealing their pet. What you’ve done is very unkind to the man and his family.

the cat could be slim for a number of reasons and he may just be acclimatising to household changes, which might take a couple of months without interference.

we had something similar many moons ago, a new baby and some neighbour started feeding our pet cat who got unhealthily fat and immobile. We put a collar on our cat requesting people stop feeding him and they did. He died last year aged 15 having been almost a sibling to my child. We really miss him

Moonstarssunsky · 22/03/2023 06:48

Twdfn123 · 22/03/2023 06:28

This thread is redundant, OP has got her responses but still insists on arguing with everybody who says this situation is not normal. Everyone has their own opinion, deal with it. Deal with how this has played out and move on. This is just desperate and silly.

Since when were you Judge and Jury as to when a thread is 'redundant', as you put it?
If I want to post a thread I will. If you consider it 'silly and desperate' of me to reply to people then why are you on here?
No one is forcing you to read the thread are they?
So please, feel free to move on yourself.

If you can't leave this thread, is it because you just love being nasty to posters because it's an anonymous forum?

OP posts:
Moonstarssunsky · 22/03/2023 06:41

Mortimercat · 22/03/2023 06:24

Is that a real question? The thing you are not letting go is obviously the cat situation. Confused

I lost him only the other day, I didn't know he was owned. Apologies for still feeling sad about that. 🙄

OP posts:
Twdfn123 · 22/03/2023 06:29

lilyak · 22/03/2023 02:03

You don't seem to understand. It was good of you to feed the cat. You were looking out for what you thought was a stray. But once you knew the cat had an owner, you should have backed off.

Thinking you should have snatched the cat away, out from the owners arms, is not normal.

Going to visit them and ask about the cat is not normal.

The cat is not yours. The cat is theirs. The mere fact that this man was able to pick the cat up, and you were NOT able to pick this cat up, even though you'd been feeding it, clearly says the cat belongs to this man. If the cat didn't want to be picked up, the man would not have been able to pick him up. The cat allowed himself to be picked up and taken home by this man. The cat never allowed you close enough. The cat has spoken, but you won't listen.

You've gotten attached and you're trying to find ways to justify your behaviour. You don't seem to understand where the line is, and that you stepped way over it.

100% this ^

Twdfn123 · 22/03/2023 06:28

This thread is redundant, OP has got her responses but still insists on arguing with everybody who says this situation is not normal. Everyone has their own opinion, deal with it. Deal with how this has played out and move on. This is just desperate and silly.

Mortimercat · 22/03/2023 06:24

Moonstarssunsky · 22/03/2023 05:43

What do you mean I just 'won't let this go'?
Because I started a thread asking for advice?

I'm bound to be sad about the cat, but I'm not obsessing over the situation. I've not gone near the house since.
So tell me, what won't I 'let go'?

Is that a real question? The thing you are not letting go is obviously the cat situation. Confused

Moonstarssunsky · 22/03/2023 05:43

Mortimercat · 22/03/2023 05:39

People have called you unhinged because you just won’t let this go. I don’t think there was anything wrong with you feeding this cat at first, but the cat does belong to someone else. Nobody would just pick up a random moggy and insist they were the owner if they were not. Forget about this cat, he is with his owner now.

I am a life long cat owner, I currently have a 13 year old boy and if I picked him up and tried to carry him somewhere he wouldn’t be too happy about it either because he doesn’t like being picked up and carried.

What do you mean I just 'won't let this go'?
Because I started a thread asking for advice?

I'm bound to be sad about the cat, but I'm not obsessing over the situation. I've not gone near the house since.
So tell me, what won't I 'let go'?

OP posts:
Mortimercat · 22/03/2023 05:39

Moonstarssunsky · 22/03/2023 05:28

But I have 'backed off' .... I had no idea who the man was, just because the cat was in his arms didn't at first make me comfortable that Tom must've known him.

With regards to not getting close to Tom initially, I'm quite wary of cats behaviour because my Dad was once bitten on the hand by a cat, this led to sepsis and caused some sort of kidney damage.

Therefore, I wanted to take it gently with Tom and gain his trust. I've already stated this. I've already stated that Tom became more comfortable with me and started to stay over.
We'd swapped the cat case I already had for one that might be easier to get him inside.
He's not daft though and no amount of dreamies were going to coax him into one.

We were going to have to force him though obviously, and I'd arranged for help to do this by others, when they were off work.
Unfortunately the man saw Tom in the street obviously and picked him up.

That doesn't mean that Tom was more comfortable with this man than he'd gotten with me. The man was clearly confident in grabbing him. I wasn'. I do feel better in one respect now assuming that Tom can't have been frightened of him or he wouldn't have got close to him enough to grab him.

I guess I went to the house because I wanted to see where Tom had gone. I was civil there. I can't believe some posters are saying it's 'not normal' to go and speak to them.
I'd bet you'd have a different attitude if you'd been caring for a cat, thought he was a stray then someone was carrying him away. .... I'm sure none of you would just stand there and go "oh ok just take him'
I wanted to speak to the young man's family mainly, as he was young, and I wanted to see if I could discuss what was in the best interests of the cat.

Quite a few of you don't seem to have ANY regard for the wants of the cat. Your attitude is basically 'fuck off OP, let this man take the cat without any discussion'.

In my view, I wouldn't have been 'normsl' NOT TO CHECK that the cat was ok.

Back to being able to get a cat in a carrier, another poster has written that she and her husband have had great difficulty in getting their cat into one.
Does that mean that the cat isn't really comfortable with his family?

Of course it doesn't! Some cats can be quite aggressive, and I've already said I'm nervous of being bitten by one, hence why I knew I needed help trying to get him into one.

As for you saying 'the cat has spoken', but you won't listen'

Yes the cat HAS spoken. He spoke some time back when he decided he wanted to be with us. He was in walking distance of the other families house, and if he was happiest there he wouldn't have come to me.

I'm bewildered that lots of you can't grasp this.
As I've already said though, thankfully lots of you can feel for the cat and would rather do right by it than see it as some sort of posession without any feelings of its own.

People have called you unhinged because you just won’t let this go. I don’t think there was anything wrong with you feeding this cat at first, but the cat does belong to someone else. Nobody would just pick up a random moggy and insist they were the owner if they were not. Forget about this cat, he is with his owner now.

I am a life long cat owner, I currently have a 13 year old boy and if I picked him up and tried to carry him somewhere he wouldn’t be too happy about it either because he doesn’t like being picked up and carried.

Moonstarssunsky · 22/03/2023 05:28

lilyak · 22/03/2023 02:03

You don't seem to understand. It was good of you to feed the cat. You were looking out for what you thought was a stray. But once you knew the cat had an owner, you should have backed off.

Thinking you should have snatched the cat away, out from the owners arms, is not normal.

Going to visit them and ask about the cat is not normal.

The cat is not yours. The cat is theirs. The mere fact that this man was able to pick the cat up, and you were NOT able to pick this cat up, even though you'd been feeding it, clearly says the cat belongs to this man. If the cat didn't want to be picked up, the man would not have been able to pick him up. The cat allowed himself to be picked up and taken home by this man. The cat never allowed you close enough. The cat has spoken, but you won't listen.

You've gotten attached and you're trying to find ways to justify your behaviour. You don't seem to understand where the line is, and that you stepped way over it.

But I have 'backed off' .... I had no idea who the man was, just because the cat was in his arms didn't at first make me comfortable that Tom must've known him.

With regards to not getting close to Tom initially, I'm quite wary of cats behaviour because my Dad was once bitten on the hand by a cat, this led to sepsis and caused some sort of kidney damage.

Therefore, I wanted to take it gently with Tom and gain his trust. I've already stated this. I've already stated that Tom became more comfortable with me and started to stay over.
We'd swapped the cat case I already had for one that might be easier to get him inside.
He's not daft though and no amount of dreamies were going to coax him into one.

We were going to have to force him though obviously, and I'd arranged for help to do this by others, when they were off work.
Unfortunately the man saw Tom in the street obviously and picked him up.

That doesn't mean that Tom was more comfortable with this man than he'd gotten with me. The man was clearly confident in grabbing him. I wasn'. I do feel better in one respect now assuming that Tom can't have been frightened of him or he wouldn't have got close to him enough to grab him.

I guess I went to the house because I wanted to see where Tom had gone. I was civil there. I can't believe some posters are saying it's 'not normal' to go and speak to them.
I'd bet you'd have a different attitude if you'd been caring for a cat, thought he was a stray then someone was carrying him away. .... I'm sure none of you would just stand there and go "oh ok just take him'
I wanted to speak to the young man's family mainly, as he was young, and I wanted to see if I could discuss what was in the best interests of the cat.

Quite a few of you don't seem to have ANY regard for the wants of the cat. Your attitude is basically 'fuck off OP, let this man take the cat without any discussion'.

In my view, I wouldn't have been 'normsl' NOT TO CHECK that the cat was ok.

Back to being able to get a cat in a carrier, another poster has written that she and her husband have had great difficulty in getting their cat into one.
Does that mean that the cat isn't really comfortable with his family?

Of course it doesn't! Some cats can be quite aggressive, and I've already said I'm nervous of being bitten by one, hence why I knew I needed help trying to get him into one.

As for you saying 'the cat has spoken', but you won't listen'

Yes the cat HAS spoken. He spoke some time back when he decided he wanted to be with us. He was in walking distance of the other families house, and if he was happiest there he wouldn't have come to me.

I'm bewildered that lots of you can't grasp this.
As I've already said though, thankfully lots of you can feel for the cat and would rather do right by it than see it as some sort of posession without any feelings of its own.

OP posts:
Moonstarssunsky · 22/03/2023 04:42

Martha645 · 22/03/2023 01:28

Some very nasty posters here. Of course you weren't stealing the cat.
We once had a cat who made friends with the cat next door. They spent a lot of time together and visited each other's houses. Eventually our cat moved next door and didn't come back home although we did see the two of them out and about. We missed her of course but that was what she wanted and the two cats had a happy life together.
I am so sorry for you - you were only doing what you thought was best for the cat. Thank you for that.

Thank you, people like yourself who can see I had good intentions have helped.

And you're also clearly a kind hearted person for putting your cat first.
So many posters obviously view cats as possessions and have no regard for the cats wishes.

OP posts:
custardbear · 22/03/2023 02:27

My male cat looks skinny but vet says she would like him to not put anymore weight on. Sone cats look thinner. Also if unneutered he probably roams too

lilyak · 22/03/2023 02:03

You don't seem to understand. It was good of you to feed the cat. You were looking out for what you thought was a stray. But once you knew the cat had an owner, you should have backed off.

Thinking you should have snatched the cat away, out from the owners arms, is not normal.

Going to visit them and ask about the cat is not normal.

The cat is not yours. The cat is theirs. The mere fact that this man was able to pick the cat up, and you were NOT able to pick this cat up, even though you'd been feeding it, clearly says the cat belongs to this man. If the cat didn't want to be picked up, the man would not have been able to pick him up. The cat allowed himself to be picked up and taken home by this man. The cat never allowed you close enough. The cat has spoken, but you won't listen.

You've gotten attached and you're trying to find ways to justify your behaviour. You don't seem to understand where the line is, and that you stepped way over it.

Martha645 · 22/03/2023 01:28

Some very nasty posters here. Of course you weren't stealing the cat.
We once had a cat who made friends with the cat next door. They spent a lot of time together and visited each other's houses. Eventually our cat moved next door and didn't come back home although we did see the two of them out and about. We missed her of course but that was what she wanted and the two cats had a happy life together.
I am so sorry for you - you were only doing what you thought was best for the cat. Thank you for that.

Moonstarssunsky · 22/03/2023 00:06

Notafanofheat · 21/03/2023 23:37

We’re still hoping she comes back too and posted today on local pages again and people are being very encouraging and supportive.
Thank you for your kind words - it would be hard if she chose a different family, but I just want her alive and safe and loved.

I don't think she'd choose a different family as she'll know you love her and look after her well.
Cats are much more resourceful than we give them credit for, and they will find food and shelter until they get back home, so I know it's a real worry when they go missing, but there's often a happy ending.
I really hope she's back to you soon.

OP posts:
Moonstarssunsky · 21/03/2023 23:55

Novatherova · 21/03/2023 19:46

Blimey there are some vile people on this thread.

What you did is lovely OP. I'd have done the very same thing. No way could I leave a cat outside in my garden distressed and hungry.

My cat is an indoor one, never been out except on a lead. If somehow she escaped and when I eventually found her, I found someone had been feeding and looking after her, I'd be buying that person a massive bunch of flowers, wine and chocolates. I'd even give them a kidney!

No way would I be annoyed and be nasty to you. Also I agree it's cruel to keep a cat indoor after it's been free.

I'm probably going to be called out on this but I'd knock at the house again. Just to check up on Tom. See how that conversation goes. My DP would tell me to leave it alone but I couldn't give up, not until certain he was OK.

Keep us updated and don't stop being kind. The world needs more of it as it is evidenced by the weirdos in this post.

Thank you, I should've expected some very different responses on aibu I guess, but some have been quite offensive.

OP posts:
Notafanofheat · 21/03/2023 23:37

Moonstarssunsky · 21/03/2023 23:33

I'm so sorry about your cat, hopefully she will come home to you soon, just think positively as so many cats do come back.

You're also obviously a very caring pet owner because your showing that your cats feelings come first and that you just want her to be happy.

We’re still hoping she comes back too and posted today on local pages again and people are being very encouraging and supportive.
Thank you for your kind words - it would be hard if she chose a different family, but I just want her alive and safe and loved.

Moonstarssunsky · 21/03/2023 23:33

Notafanofheat · 21/03/2023 19:22

Our indoor cat has gone missing 2 weeks ago…without a trace, somehow she got out…she is loved here, has a family that loves her, but panics outside so wouldn’t be able to find her way back (and why she’s not allowed out without someone in the first place, while her older cat sister is) We miss her terribly and want her back. Even more so we want to know what happened to her, as not knowing is as horrible as people say. But above all we hope some kind person seen her scared and lost and is looking out for her - feeding her and offering a safe, warm home. We’re about to put up a new post on local fb saying that we are honestly grateful if someone has been taking care of her, we’d still love to know and hand on heart if we come to see her and she’s happy, cared for and wants to stay- that would be ok (though we’d love to visit). She’s a cherished family member not a piece of property.
I don’t think you did wrong OP looking out for the cat. Cats often don’t appreciate being carried but it might also not appreciate living with a lot of other cats (could be not eating due to stress - not all cats love company). It’s a hard situation.

I'm so sorry about your cat, hopefully she will come home to you soon, just think positively as so many cats do come back.

You're also obviously a very caring pet owner because your showing that your cats feelings come first and that you just want her to be happy.

OP posts:
rrrrrreatt · 21/03/2023 23:26

Years ago, my very petite slim house cat went missing after she got out and I was distraught. I put posters up and through all the doors and a man called. He said he had my cat but he wasn’t giving her back because she was a “malnourished kitten” and “always hungry”, after I said I’d call the police he let me pick her up.

She was 4 doors down and she was always hungry because he was feeding her exclusively dreamies!! She also stunk of weed which had probably not harmed her appetite. Cats are fickle and will go wherever they get the best food and most fuss, it doesn’t mean they aren’t loved and it’s not ok to try and steal them.

Moonstarssunsky · 21/03/2023 23:12

restingbitchface30 · 21/03/2023 22:58

We have a ‘stray’ that comes to ours and we feed him and have put a cat bed in our outhouse for it. I would never let it in the house as I’m not entirely sure it’s not owned by someone. You are acting slightly unhinged, let it go

Are you kidding me?

Again, another poster saying I'm acting unhinged. Unbelievable. Seriously.

YOU are admitting to feeding a cat AND even wondering if someone owns it.

I wonder if anyone will jump on YOU and accuse you of theft? .... If not, why not?

YOU are encouraging the cat to keep coming to you, so therefore I'm assuming you must have some sort of connection to it else you wouldn't do this.

The difference between you and I though is that I was absolutely convinced Tom was a stray, hence I was very shocked when I suddenly saw his apparent owner carrying him along, and Tom looked terrified.

I'm bound to have been upset by this, who wouldn't?
So tell me, exactly, WHY do you think I'm unhinged?

Tell me, why are you encouraging a cat to your home?

OP posts:
xsquared · 21/03/2023 23:00

Would people's opinion be different if op.took cat to the vet and had him neutered?

If you were the owner of a lost uneautered cat, and suddenly found him neutered because someone had taken him to the vet, what would you do at that point?

restingbitchface30 · 21/03/2023 22:58

We have a ‘stray’ that comes to ours and we feed him and have put a cat bed in our outhouse for it. I would never let it in the house as I’m not entirely sure it’s not owned by someone. You are acting slightly unhinged, let it go

T1Dmama · 21/03/2023 22:50

Moonstarssunsky · 20/03/2023 17:56

Thank you. I agree with you.

Seems it's not about the welfare and the happiness of the cat, it's all about who 'has a claim to it first'

It doesn’t… but you can’t just steal someone’s cat because it’s being neglected!…. You call the necessary charities and report it.
I don’t think it’s unusual either for an un neutered male cat to wander looking for females, not eat and be a bit on the skinny side!
in my view anyone who doesn’t get their male neutered is irresponsible… however we can’t just take things … we had a cat stolen once by an old man in our street.. we didn’t bother reclaiming it though as although it was loved it was clearly happier with him… years later he told us how he’d rescued a stray and was shocked to learn it was actually ours.

Fluffmum · 21/03/2023 22:44

yanbu we were in a similar situation with an uneutered Tom we looked after for years. Someone picked him up on the street took him to the vets and we weren’t allowed to have him back. It broke our hearts. He loved being with us and I wish I’d had him chipped and neutered. It still makes us sad 6 years later 😥

Mamanyt · 21/03/2023 22:44

First, let me say that I think you were right in feeding an obviously hungry cat. And I know how heartbroken you are. IF the young man was telling the truth, then the cat is, in fact, his in the eyes of the law. There is nothing you can do about it now. I am so sorry.

I do, however, know what I think about people who state that you should not feed the hungry, no matter what their species. And I shall leave that, at that.

You did nothing wrong. You were kind. And don't be surprised if that cat turns up again, possibly neglected...again. IF he has, this time, been chipped, you can lodge a complaint for neglecting an animal.

T1Dmama · 21/03/2023 22:06

You’ve said ‘technically it isn’t his cat’….

It is his cat, he’s told you it’s his cat!…. Microchips aren’t proof of ownership. Back off and if ‘Tom’ comes round again do not feed him and do not let him into your house! He isn’t yours!! Drop a note through their door promising not to steal their cat, and apologising… otherwise poor Tom will be forced to be an indoor cat!
Go to a rescue centre and adopt a cat or two that don’t have owners already.
IF you see Tom in a state and skinny again then call the RSPCA, but don’t do this for a while as you may get a brick through your window as they’ll know it’s you!

Swipe left for the next trending thread