Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for ways to blast Honda?

62 replies

Staffielove23 · 20/03/2023 16:48

This is a follow up from my previous thread but I’ll give a quick summary of events:

  • I brought my car into Honda Edinburgh last Monday following a recall for passenger airbags.
  • I waited five hours to be told they needed to order a part (apparently they didn’t anticipate needing this particular part as it’s an issue with my car or something).
  • They said they didn’t have a courtesy car and they couldn’t give me my keys back because it’s an MOT fail, and I was left stranded 40 plus miles from my home.
  • Phoned Honda customer services to try and get a hire car as advised by Honda Edinburgh, and told no because we didn’t meet the criteria.
  • Eight days on and my car is still at the garage because they are still waiting on this part. We were initially told 3-4 days then told it will need a few more days and I am fearful that this will go on and on. We have another car but my husband needs it to get to work so myself and DD who is only two years old are stranded Monday to Friday as we are very rural.

I think they should provide me with a hire car or a courtesy car because it’s at the garage due to a manufacturing recall. Customer service has been at best unhelpful, and at worst quite rude and dismissive. I can’t even get the car towed to another garage as apparently it needs to be Honda who fits the airbag. I have twitted them (no response unsurprisingly) and am thinking of contacting the motoring ombudsman and Watchdog but where else can I turn? Any ideas?

Honda need to recognise that they cannot treat people like this.

OP posts:
EmbracingTheEyeBags · 21/03/2023 07:32

My DF has been without his car since 2nd feb.... also due to not being able to get hold of the part they need. There must be a delay on parts? He's luckily got a courtesy car but it's ridiculous and the customer services is no help, he's spoken to the branch manager a few times but he just says still waiting and should be done by the weekend (he says this every week). It's Evans Helshaw.
My dad has had to suspend his insurance as it's now coming up to 2 months without his car.

Hope u get it sorted quicker than him

rwalker · 21/03/2023 07:32

It’s deemed not road worthy
the issue is no courtesy car

Poppins2016 · 21/03/2023 07:28

*take responsibility!

BlueSpark · 21/03/2023 07:27

A lot of misinformation on this thread.

The car is not roadworthy, therefore it legally cannot be driven. That is a fact. If the police were to pull you over, you would get a punishment.

They cannot refuse to give you your car back but you cannot drive it.

The work needs to be done at a Honda garage. They can get it towed to another Honda that may have the part but there is no point going to any other mechanic as they cannot do the work.

They should be providing a courtesy car. The waters are muddied as the actual reason they are not able to fix has nothing to do with the recall. You would have to reason with them. You could get that part done at another mechanics.

Go on LinkedIn and tag Honda in a post. Always works. The dealer and the manufacturer.

Go to pistonheads and get advice from people who know. Not Mumsnet, where they don't.

Poppins2016 · 21/03/2023 07:25

Staffielove23 · 20/03/2023 21:15

Thanks. I will phone back tomorrow and ask to speak to the DP. Can they legally refuse me my keys?

I'd second the advice that JustLikeJasper gave, but I would add a plea on behalf of the majority of the staff... please remember that most of them won't be able to influence the situation and it isn't their fault. I'd absolutely go in, tell the receptionist that you're not leaving until you see the right person/things have been sorted and have a very firm discussion with the right person. But please make sure that it is the right person (i.e. a decision maker) that you kick up a fuss with (...from someone who used to work in a dealership and left due to being used as a verbal punching bag over matters I had no influence over whatsoever). It sounds as though you've been polite and reasonable, OP, but I'm just adding some food for thought for others reading this thread.

There will be a manager/someone superior who does have the clout to approve a courtesy car. Keep asking for people further up the chain until you reach a decent solution (and tell them what that solution is, i.e. courtesy car or repair within x days).

At the end of the day, the car should never have been booked in by the garage in until the parts were delivered. They've deprived you of the opportunity to make an informed decision about your property and your means of transport. It was piss poor planning on their part and the consequences for you are high impact. Someone should have thought about this and someone therefore needs to testify responsibility and rectify this (I'd also ask how they're going to stop this from happening to another customer, otherwise I bet the same old 'act now, think later' system will keep running).

The motor ombudsman could be useful:
www.themotorombudsman.org/consumers/make-a-complaint

Threatening to approach the motoring columns of x/y/z newspaper 'in order to warn other consumers of the appalling service' might also be worth your while.

Wrongsideofpennines · 21/03/2023 07:25

I would speak to the dealership manager about a courtesy car again. I know they said you don't qualify for one but that was when you took your car in expecting them to take a day to fix a known fault. They've now had it 8 days and not given you a timescale. This should surely make a difference about the circumstances they provide them. Particularly as they are basically holding you to ransom as they won't give you your own car back.

But you're going to have to speak to the dealership and not Honda itself.

LlynTegid · 21/03/2023 07:18

Can you travel back to the Honda dealer concerned, take a sleeping bag with you and say you are refusing to leave until they provide a car for you? Let the press know about your sit in.

KateAusten · 21/03/2023 07:16

I work at a main dealer, not Honda

We do hundreds of recalls a year

Something doesn't add up here as the garage would have done many, many recalls already so to not have the parts is bizarre

They would know exactly what is required for the job

An airbag fault is a serious fail on the mot and puts the car in the do not drive category

Whether they can legally stop you is another thing

Just bare in mind your car will almost certainly be sitting outside with a stripped dash

I'd speak to Honda UK or the Director or the dealership

They could put you in a demo if you kick up a fuss

sorrynotathome · 21/03/2023 07:06

You do realise that the dealership is not owned by Honda? You need to be naming and shaming the dealership no the manufacturer.

GPTec1 · 21/03/2023 07:02

ZeroFuchsGiven · 21/03/2023 06:55

Surely you just wait till they have the part and the car is fixed? Why all the hoohah about it, shit happens and sometimes you end up with no car for a while, it happens to us all. Why oh why would you want to drive your daughter about in an unsafe car? They are fixing it just let them get on with their job and stop being a pita, if you cant go out for a while, you cant go out.

Do you work for Honda? How absurd of you.

This situation was a 100% avoidable, its a well known, world wide fault with airbags and Honda shouldn't have started the work without all the parts required.

However, big companies can do whatever they want and Honda know they have a good rep, all you can do OP is get it out there on FB Tweeter etc

Having once had a terrible experience with a Toyota and their dealership, would never get a Japanese car again.

ZeroFuchsGiven · 21/03/2023 06:55

Surely you just wait till they have the part and the car is fixed? Why all the hoohah about it, shit happens and sometimes you end up with no car for a while, it happens to us all. Why oh why would you want to drive your daughter about in an unsafe car? They are fixing it just let them get on with their job and stop being a pita, if you cant go out for a while, you cant go out.

Fluffodils · 21/03/2023 06:50

Could you sign a peice of paper to say if you die in a car crash its not their fault and they've told you it's unsafe but you are fine with that?

AdInfinitum12 · 21/03/2023 06:50

I didn't think it was the MOT failure aspect that was the problem here. I am under the assumption that if a car should have airbags (not all do) then that car cannot legally be driven without them.

GoodChat · 21/03/2023 06:50

They should have given you a courtesy car if the cars in for a recall

www.rac.co.uk/drive/advice/buying-and-selling-guides/car-recalls-what-should-i-do-if-i-get-one/

LordEmsworth · 21/03/2023 06:47

Monoplane · 21/03/2023 01:13

There's absolutely no way you can have this done at another garage. This issue has to be fixed by the dealer. It's not currently roadworthy. So there's no point in taking the keys or the vehicle. It's better off there so they can start the repair ASAP.

I don't know what you're expecting them to do if they don't have the part yet. They can't repair it yet. You're not entitled to a courtesy vehicle so there's no point asking further. You've been told no. No amount of tantrums will change this situation.

You're going to have to hire a vehicle or get taxis. Them's the breaks.

The OP had a pre booked appointment, due to a recall of a fault. Why hadn't they pre ordered the parts they knew they were going to need? "Nothing they can do" is bollocks, they should absolutely provide a courtesy car - it's Honda who's at fault here not the OP...

Pipsquiggle · 21/03/2023 06:46

Ask this question on Piston heads - the closest men get to mumsnet, loosely based on liking cars /bikes - I am sure there will be an expert on there.

JustLikeJasper · 21/03/2023 06:36

They shouldn't have stripped the car without knowing they had all the correct parts to repair it. Ask them to put the vehicle back to it's condition it came in and you will bring it back when they have all the parts. Tell them you will sign a waiver saying you are aware the car is not fixed and you would not hold them responsible should an accident occur due to the fault. If the car is completely stripped they are unlikely to want to put it back together so that's when you can demand they give you an alternative vehicle to use.

Monoplane · 21/03/2023 01:13

There's absolutely no way you can have this done at another garage. This issue has to be fixed by the dealer. It's not currently roadworthy. So there's no point in taking the keys or the vehicle. It's better off there so they can start the repair ASAP.

I don't know what you're expecting them to do if they don't have the part yet. They can't repair it yet. You're not entitled to a courtesy vehicle so there's no point asking further. You've been told no. No amount of tantrums will change this situation.

You're going to have to hire a vehicle or get taxis. Them's the breaks.

jcyclops · 21/03/2023 00:59

The team at www.honestjohn.co.uk/ deal with motoring problems - go to the ASK HJ tab.

Staffielove23 · 20/03/2023 21:15

JustLikeJasper · 20/03/2023 18:17

Have you spoken to anyone higher up at the dealership? I would either call and ask for the dealer principle or if you can go there demand to see him/her (maybe call before to check he/she are there) and tell them you aren't leaving until you see them.
Those who shout loudest and all that.
When you speak with the dealer principle (they might have an aftersales manager if DP not there) tell them you aren't leaving until they get you transport. You have been patient enough and if a part is on back order the manufacturer has a duty to keep you mobile regardless if your car is in warranty or not.
When you call/speak to them really kick up a fuss (in front of other customers if you can!).
I work in the industry (not Honda) feel free to PM me if you like.

Thanks. I will phone back tomorrow and ask to speak to the DP. Can they legally refuse me my keys?

OP posts:
vipersnest1 · 20/03/2023 19:13

Thing is, @Staffielove23, even if you do manage to get it to another garage they may not be able to help.
Three years ago I needed a new heater matrix. To replace it, the dash and airbags had to be removed. The local garage I usually use looked at it for me and diagnosed the problem, but wouldn't do the work as they weren't insured to remove and replace the airbags. I then rang around and got the same answer, so ended up taking it to the not so local dealer. As for the issue of customer service, I'd suggest going as high up the ladder as you can to complain. The least they can do is provide a courtesy car IMO.

Georgieporgie29 · 20/03/2023 19:04

Could you repost this in the legal section and see if you get any help there?

I saw your last post and find it disgusting that they can leave you with no transport and with no end in sight, it has certainly put me off using Honda for my next car

TwoLeftSocksWithHoles · 20/03/2023 18:39

If they have removed the existing airbags I would suspect that the car will currently be in pieces. I doubt they would reassemble it with the airbags missing as they would have to take it apart again to fit them.

It might also be that the engine management system won't let the car start without them.

I would pursue a loan car and raise it on twitter (actually know almost nothing about twitter, but everybody seems to say that what one should do!

JustLikeJasper · 20/03/2023 18:17

Have you spoken to anyone higher up at the dealership? I would either call and ask for the dealer principle or if you can go there demand to see him/her (maybe call before to check he/she are there) and tell them you aren't leaving until you see them.
Those who shout loudest and all that.
When you speak with the dealer principle (they might have an aftersales manager if DP not there) tell them you aren't leaving until they get you transport. You have been patient enough and if a part is on back order the manufacturer has a duty to keep you mobile regardless if your car is in warranty or not.
When you call/speak to them really kick up a fuss (in front of other customers if you can!).
I work in the industry (not Honda) feel free to PM me if you like.

Staffielove23 · 20/03/2023 18:14

Shade17 · 20/03/2023 18:07

Apparently that’s an MOT fail and they aren’t allowed to give my keys back.

They have no such power. My response to that would be “Give me my fucking keys back right now you lying cunt”

If that’s the case it’s theft so maybe I should phone the police? (Non emergency obviously).

OP posts: