Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse to leave rented property

314 replies

Boymamabee · 20/03/2023 14:16

I’m having an ethical dilemma thanks to my husband…

I’m heavily pregnant (due a c-section next month) and we’ve been served a two month no-fault notice by our landlord (it’s all valid).

We’re struggling to find rented properties within our price range and although we’re at risk of homelessness, the council can’t guarantee temp accommodation before our notice expires. This makes my husband anxious as he says we have no right to stay in a house we don’t own and it’s unfair on the LL whose sale might fall through.

Places for the same amount of rent, or less, than we currently pay are more rural and would cost more fuel. Many of the local schools don’t have specialised facilities for kids with ASD (think rural schools with 20 students and 2 LSAs) and DS LOVES his school!

This is where it gets tricky…

We’ve been advised that if we stay with family or friends before the LL enacts a court possession order, we could be seen as making ourselves “intentionally homeless”. Likewise if we get ourselves into debt/arrears living somewhere we can’t afford.

I’ve proposed we listen to
their advice and stay put for now, but DH thinks it’s selfish and we’ll naturally find another way to make ends meet. He wants to be out before our contract ends and he feels sorry for the LL who’s going through a divorce.

AIBU?

OP posts:
MyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 20/03/2023 23:27

If as you say the notice is valid, I don’t know how you think you should stay. I understand the fact that you are expecting and perhaps you could ask the landlord for an extension for that reason. However, the rest of your reasons are not something that your landlord should have to take into consideration. Costs of rentals aren’t going down any time soon and school systems aren’t going to magically create programs to meet your needs elsewhere. If you don’t move now or in a reasonable time after your baby is born, when do you plan to do so? You don’t own the house.

Kay286 · 20/03/2023 23:09

Boymamabee · 20/03/2023 22:16

We are a low income family. This is the second time we’ve been given a no-fault notice in 18 months (we’ve been in this property 10 months) and our rent has increased by £125 over two years (not to mention gas and electric).

When I say rural areas are marginally cheaper, I mean marginally, and we would likely still be out-priced by the additional cost of fuel (and everything else). Also, there’s nothing stopping the new landlord from upping the rent after six months. It’s happened twice in less than two years.

DH wants to move first then find a second job, or ways to cut costs, after we move. Shelter have advised us against this but DH really doesn’t like the idea of a court possession order and would rather be out before it comes to that. And that’s if we can get a property - one place stopped processing applications after a day due to such high interest.

You have your opinion but it's not that black and white.

I do appreciate it’s a difficult situation especially if you are low income.
will you be entitled to extra benefits when baby comes ?
I would try to negotiate extra agreed time with the landlord so you can explore other options/locations- maybe husband can also look for extra work if he wants a second job to help ?
I really think the eviction process will be very stressful for all involved (including you with a new baby ) and will incur costs you cannot afford and worst case end up in temporary accommodation?
Agreed no situation is black and white , but you need to consider neither is the landlords (a person/family too) ? What if rent was increased as they cannot afford the mortgage (whilst I imagine paying legal fees for a divorce ) what if they are in desperate need to get this property sold because they are in financial mess too ?

Morally I just couldn’t do it and put someone else into difficulty to ease my own problems.
Unless it is literally your only
option and very last resort instead of living on the street rather than choosing to just stay longer. Each to their own id rather try and get the marginally cheaper rural property be in control of where you live and not at the mercy of the council and her husband out to pick up some extra work.

WulyJmpr · 20/03/2023 23:07

If you don't leave when asked you may be given a bad reference by your landlord. There is a shortage of properties to rent at the moment so is this something you'd risk?

Boymamabee · 20/03/2023 22:33

@Thefriendlyone sorry if my post wasn’t clear. Shelter haven’t advised us not to rent somewhere we can afford. What I meant is that some rural places are only marginally cheaper and we’d still be out-priced by the cost of fuel. So far, I’ve only seen one property where this isn’t the case. DH suggested applying for properties regardless and then finding a second job once we’ve moved (not that they’re likely to accept us). I’d rather wait for a financial assessment. If somewhere suitable comes up before our notice expires, of course we’ll take it, but we were advised against staying with family or friends before our notice is up.

OP posts:
Thefriendlyone · 20/03/2023 22:19

Shelter have advised us against this but DH really doesn’t like the idea of a court possession order and would rather be out before it comes to that

i really do not believe shelter has advised you do not rent elsewhere you can afford. You’ve already said there is a place that’s cheaper next to your husbands work. I agree you noth need to sort the finances now. Cutting costs looking for additional work, but if you can find a place in budget you should Jump at it.

Of course a court ordered eviction is the worst.

Thefriendlyone · 20/03/2023 22:17

Greenfairydust · 20/03/2023 22:10

''@drpet49

Hope you’ve got extra money to pay the landlords costs when he is forced to get bailiffs to remove you.''

Hope you can grasp that a pregnant woman can't just end up homeless to keep her landlords happy...if she has no other options she will have to stay put.

I think you’ve misread what she’s said, her husband wishes her to , move to where they can afford. He is not suggesting they go sleep in a cardboard box to make the landlord happy.

Boymamabee · 20/03/2023 22:16

Kay286 · 20/03/2023 21:51

You are being incredibly selfish. From what you’ve added after the fact it seems also
not a desperate need but a choice and preference related to schools/location.

Remember landlords are actual people to with problems and lives ….just because you can stay and exercise rights doesn’t mean u should. You have no idea what turmoil this could
create for them. It’s their legal property not yours and if they have been decent landlords be decent and leave once your notice is up instead of creating a horrible situation for all involved.

Also I presume if u wait for council you will
have no say on area or school you can choose then either ? It would be more sensible to
have control and find somewhere yourself rather than end up in a crappy council house. Paying legal fees and never get the chance of being a private tenant again - so wouldn’t risk it. I also believe in karma … I wouldn’t do a shitty thing just because I can

We are a low income family. This is the second time we’ve been given a no-fault notice in 18 months (we’ve been in this property 10 months) and our rent has increased by £125 over two years (not to mention gas and electric).

When I say rural areas are marginally cheaper, I mean marginally, and we would likely still be out-priced by the additional cost of fuel (and everything else). Also, there’s nothing stopping the new landlord from upping the rent after six months. It’s happened twice in less than two years.

DH wants to move first then find a second job, or ways to cut costs, after we move. Shelter have advised us against this but DH really doesn’t like the idea of a court possession order and would rather be out before it comes to that. And that’s if we can get a property - one place stopped processing applications after a day due to such high interest.

You have your opinion but it's not that black and white.

OP posts:
Thefriendlyone · 20/03/2023 22:15

I understand that life happens and he’s entitled to change his mind but I hope he’ll be somewhat understanding

in what way op? What difference will an extra few weeks make, it’s still not going to change it. I’m sorry. Somewhat understanding is not letting you have his property as long as you wish it.

if I was you I’d start speaking to the school now . Call them tomorrow, contact the local authority, I think you need to accept you’re moving, be it in two months or six months, but you are moving. Even if the sale falls through, he’s going to evict. It is better if possible you leave on your terms.

thinking of ways to delay the inevitable isn’t going to sort your issue. You need to start acting.

Greenfairydust · 20/03/2023 22:10

''@drpet49

Hope you’ve got extra money to pay the landlords costs when he is forced to get bailiffs to remove you.''

Hope you can grasp that a pregnant woman can't just end up homeless to keep her landlords happy...if she has no other options she will have to stay put.

BCfan · 20/03/2023 21:53

Maybe you need to be a bit more open to rental compromises? I can't believe you'd make your family, including a newborn, homeless because a house wasn't quite in the right area

Kay286 · 20/03/2023 21:51

You are being incredibly selfish. From what you’ve added after the fact it seems also
not a desperate need but a choice and preference related to schools/location.

Remember landlords are actual people to with problems and lives ….just because you can stay and exercise rights doesn’t mean u should. You have no idea what turmoil this could
create for them. It’s their legal property not yours and if they have been decent landlords be decent and leave once your notice is up instead of creating a horrible situation for all involved.

Also I presume if u wait for council you will
have no say on area or school you can choose then either ? It would be more sensible to
have control and find somewhere yourself rather than end up in a crappy council house. Paying legal fees and never get the chance of being a private tenant again - so wouldn’t risk it. I also believe in karma … I wouldn’t do a shitty thing just because I can

eastendgirl4 · 20/03/2023 21:50

Also, ask for an OT assessment. This really sped up our application and also meant we didn't ultimately need to stay in temporary accommodation. It also meant the house was suitable for our DC and had adaptions done before we moved in.

eastendgirl4 · 20/03/2023 21:49

DO NOT LEAVE
I have been in your very same shoes. One DS who has SEN and I was heavily pregnant. Spoke to our local council who advised us exactly the same- I.e we couldn't leave as we would make ourselves intentionally homeless.

However, you MUST continue to pay your rent. Our local council checked with the landlord to ensure we didn't have any rent arrears. We contacted the landlord and explained our predicament. He wasn't happy at all and become quite threatening and abusive. However, we stayed put, kept the property tidy and continued to pay rent. The council said there was a high chance we would be put into a hostel or temporary accommodation. However, 2 weeks before I had my baby we were allocated a 3 bedroom house with a garden (we lived in a flat before). It was a state but a few years on its now our beautiful home and we feel so lucky to have it.

Just stay put, box up and continue to pay your rent.

Justanotherdaytoday · 20/03/2023 21:44

@Youkilledmyfatherpreparetodie I'm confident in the advice I've just given which is right. If you leave a property when evicted and have somewhere else to go, even if it renders you part of an overcrowded property, then you are NOT homeless. If you are capable of finding an alternative independently then is not homelessness either. I agree that absolutely independent advice should be sought, especially in ascertaining that this is a legal eviction, however as stated it depends on where you are in the UK. Scotland etc have different legislation.

Autienotnautie · 20/03/2023 21:32

I'd stay and keep looking. I'd also try to keep your son the same school. Good schools are a variety for Sen children. Hopefully you will find something before the sale but don't make yourselves homeless

Youkilledmyfatherpreparetodie · 20/03/2023 21:15

Justanotherdaytoday · 20/03/2023 21:08

Not sure where you are in the UK... this will make a difference. I work in housing and have done so in homelessness under housing act/legislation. Do not leave. If you genuinely cannot find alternative accommodation yourself and you move in with family etc you will lose any duty that the council owe you under that act. You must stay past your eviction date and let the LL take you to court. Doing this will trigger other sections of the housing act to come into place for which your local authority will be responsible for/need to act on. If offered a property though they may rehouse you anywhere within your county, potentially outside but again it depends where you are and the availability of social housing in your area. Just remember if you cannot find yourself for alternative accommodation and you leave the property in your eviction date then you are on your own...

This is absolute nonsense. You will not "lose" a duty. No other parts of the Act will be "triggered" if you go to court. You are not "on your own" if you stay with people on a temporary basis. Please get some advice from your local Law Centre OP.

Justanotherdaytoday · 20/03/2023 21:10

Also, IME cases are all dealt with on a case by case basis - it may not be that whoever is on the 'list' first gets TA/rehoused first. Make clear to your housing solutions dept that your family has vulnerabilities and make sure you evidence these ASAP.

Justanotherdaytoday · 20/03/2023 21:08

Not sure where you are in the UK... this will make a difference. I work in housing and have done so in homelessness under housing act/legislation. Do not leave. If you genuinely cannot find alternative accommodation yourself and you move in with family etc you will lose any duty that the council owe you under that act. You must stay past your eviction date and let the LL take you to court. Doing this will trigger other sections of the housing act to come into place for which your local authority will be responsible for/need to act on. If offered a property though they may rehouse you anywhere within your county, potentially outside but again it depends where you are and the availability of social housing in your area. Just remember if you cannot find yourself for alternative accommodation and you leave the property in your eviction date then you are on your own...

MacarenaMacarena · 20/03/2023 20:54

Are you paying your rent Soubriquet while you overstay your Section 21? Would this be to your advantage when taken to court eg judge might allow you to stay officially a bit longer?
It may be in OP's interests to find somewhere even if it isn't ideal as the prospect of emergency housing with a special needs child, a new baby and getting over a C-section sounds overwhelming...
Good luck, OP XX

Cornishclio · 20/03/2023 20:45

I think it depends very much on your local council and how likely you are to get a property in your chosen area and I have a strong suspicion that the accommodation offered will be temporary and not immediately ideal. In the interests of getting a decent reference from the landlord and being in control of where you end up I would take the best option for you even if it means you travelling to the school for your DS. You could try telling the council your son has special needs and is settled in his current school and see what they suggest.

Eventually you will have to leave so surely leaving on your own terms is better?

Youkilledmyfatherpreparetodie · 20/03/2023 20:44

Awful situation for you OP. Suggest you get some advice from your local Law Centre or Shelter as you legally cannot be intentionally homeless for leaving at the end of a valid s21 ( as long as the notice has not been served due to your behaviour) Some councils are twats and count on people's lack of knowledge of a niche piece of legislation.

KillingLoneliness · 20/03/2023 20:40

100% stay put until you’ve either found a new rental or the council are helping you, you do not need to leave after a section 21 expires but if you can get housed before the eviction process it would be beneficial. Keep in touch with your landlord and hopefully they will be willing to extend the notice period.

I’ve been in this situation twice now, we eventually found a private rental but it took 4 months, luckily my landlord was super understanding and they knew how hard we were looking, I was literally begging landlords to consider us.

In the meantime get in touch with shelter, the council should also allocate you a housing officer and you can provide evidence to support your needs regarding your child and they may bump you up to a higher priority band for the bidding process.

Does your dc have an EHCP? If so you can get transport to the school as long as you are still within the county and that they keep the school as his named setting (you may need to appeal it if you move out of catchment).

Abyss23 · 20/03/2023 20:35

If I were in your position I'd rather be in control of where I end up living, even if it's not ideal, than take my chances with the council.

EscapeRoomToTheSun · 20/03/2023 20:25

You would be an idiot to make yourselves and your kids homeless out of misplaced obligation to your landlord. Does your dh tug his forelock when they do inspections? Bloody hell.

EnthENd · 20/03/2023 20:22

YANBU.

You do have the right, by law, to stay until evicted through the courts. Who will only evict if the landlord has themselves followed the law.

Continue to pay the rent on your current place, and make all reasonable efforts to find a new home. Both private and social renting. And yes, your child changing schools is reasonable.

Do not move out until you either have a signed contract and the keys to your new place, or the bailiffs evict you, or the landlord threatens or uses criminal violence against you.

Any professional landlord will know the drill. They might not like it, but if you keep paying the rent and don't trash the place they should count themselves lucky IMHO.