Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse to leave rented property

314 replies

Boymamabee · 20/03/2023 14:16

I’m having an ethical dilemma thanks to my husband…

I’m heavily pregnant (due a c-section next month) and we’ve been served a two month no-fault notice by our landlord (it’s all valid).

We’re struggling to find rented properties within our price range and although we’re at risk of homelessness, the council can’t guarantee temp accommodation before our notice expires. This makes my husband anxious as he says we have no right to stay in a house we don’t own and it’s unfair on the LL whose sale might fall through.

Places for the same amount of rent, or less, than we currently pay are more rural and would cost more fuel. Many of the local schools don’t have specialised facilities for kids with ASD (think rural schools with 20 students and 2 LSAs) and DS LOVES his school!

This is where it gets tricky…

We’ve been advised that if we stay with family or friends before the LL enacts a court possession order, we could be seen as making ourselves “intentionally homeless”. Likewise if we get ourselves into debt/arrears living somewhere we can’t afford.

I’ve proposed we listen to
their advice and stay put for now, but DH thinks it’s selfish and we’ll naturally find another way to make ends meet. He wants to be out before our contract ends and he feels sorry for the LL who’s going through a divorce.

AIBU?

OP posts:
EigerMum · 21/03/2023 19:17

There seem to have been more and more threads recently whereby people seem to think that leaving a rented property under a S21 is optional, which is worrying.

I can only assume that the change is down to:

  1. Increase in rent on account of rates meaning people can’t afford what’s on offer
  2. Drop in supply, on account of more LLs selling up meaning that much of the stock is no longer there or is now more expensive

Those who seem to hate LLs so much really need to be careful what they wish for, encouraging LLs to sell us only exacerbating this problem. If (1) and / or (2) were not the case, the OP would not be in this position.

i was a LL until last year when we chose to sell because I felt that a wave of uncertainty was sweeping over the market which made me feel uncomfortable because I knew that implicitly, I no longer had sufficient agency over my own property to be assured of long term outcomes.

ButterCrackers · 21/03/2023 19:07

MyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 21/03/2023 17:28

The fact that the OP needs a special school for her child is not the problem of the landlord. I seriously don’t understand how people can think that they can just refuse to move when they are given legal notice and come up with excuses to not leave. OP does not own the property they are living in. Plain and simple. They need to leave. What about the problems that the landlord may have?

Exactly.
The father should sort this all out by finding somewhere else to live. It’s difficult and that’s were the council can help.

mummyh2016 · 21/03/2023 18:57

MyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 21/03/2023 18:19

So, if everyone stopped being greedy and becoming landlords, where exactly would people live?

I think people think that the renters can have the properties instead - where these renters are getting their deposit from god only knows. And the other thing they're not getting is the obvious one; less rental properties mean rents shoot up. But having less landlords is supposed to be a good thing. Madness.

mumwon · 21/03/2023 18:35

I am a landlord - your landlord will have to factor this in. What I did as a landlord is to keep housing in the loop, I rang up the housing officer at each stage as i knew that my tenant (not like yourselves or your landlord they came under the heading of tenant from hell, getting behind in rent and ruining the property, nonetheless I wouldn't want someone on the street) would stay until the they were evicted by bailiff. Eventually I applied for the bailiff about 2 weeks after the court application and informed the housing officer I was doing this and the date and my tenant was given housing 2 days before the eviction.

MyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 21/03/2023 18:19

So, if everyone stopped being greedy and becoming landlords, where exactly would people live?

Winter2020 · 21/03/2023 18:18

Hi OP,
Why are you worrying about the landlord when they clearly couldn’t give a shit about you (evicting you while heavily pregnant) - and I say that as someone that rents out my house.

@Thefriendlyone You accuse the OP of using emotive language then say they will struggle to rent “ever again”. Pot and kettle.

QUOTE: ”Firstly he doesn’t take on responsibilities to home them when he rents a property to them. The contractual terms apply. He doesn’t assume parental guardian responsibilities for tenants and he isn’t providing a charitable service, to put it bluntly. The ops issues are really not his problem, it’s not how it works. They can stay and make it his problem, but a court will ultimately sort it.”

Beyond the contractual terms the law of the land applies and that law is that a tenancy can only be ended by the tenant or the court. Equally the landlords problems are not the OPs problem and it’s not her problem if the landlords sale falls through. They should have made sure they had vacant possession before trying to sell the house.

Spangasspikeywig · 21/03/2023 18:18

DonnaBanana · 21/03/2023 17:39

What about the problems that the landlord may have?

Irrelevant to OP. People need to stop being greedy and becoming landlords. Luckily with the rules as they are now most of them are selling up and getting out which is a good thing.

Most ridiculous comment of the thread. WHERE are people who rent meant to live?

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 21/03/2023 18:06

BCfan · 20/03/2023 21:53

Maybe you need to be a bit more open to rental compromises? I can't believe you'd make your family, including a newborn, homeless because a house wasn't quite in the right area

As one reason is trying to keep her autistic son in a school setting that is both appropriate for him and that he enjoys going to, I completely understand why she doesn't want to move somewhere that means he would have to change schools.

And if councils don't take needs like that into account when allocating housing to homeless families then they absolutely should.

Astralitzia · 21/03/2023 17:53

DonnaBanana · 21/03/2023 17:39

What about the problems that the landlord may have?

Irrelevant to OP. People need to stop being greedy and becoming landlords. Luckily with the rules as they are now most of them are selling up and getting out which is a good thing.

Umm, it wouldn't be a good thing for me! If my landlord sold tomorrow I certainly wouldn't be able to buy anywhere, and if I couldn't rent anywhere I'd need to quit my job to move back in with my mother who lives a couple of hours away.

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 21/03/2023 17:47

DonnaBanana · 21/03/2023 17:39

What about the problems that the landlord may have?

Irrelevant to OP. People need to stop being greedy and becoming landlords. Luckily with the rules as they are now most of them are selling up and getting out which is a good thing.

Except if renters want somewhere to live…

DixonD · 21/03/2023 17:46

Jizzle · 20/03/2023 15:12

I could never find it in me to care about how this might impact a l̶e̶a̶c̶h̶ landlord, for all I care about them and their ilk they can do one, especially if i was pregnant.

Do you own a property or do one of these “ilks” allow you to rent one of their properties?

DonnaBanana · 21/03/2023 17:39

What about the problems that the landlord may have?

Irrelevant to OP. People need to stop being greedy and becoming landlords. Luckily with the rules as they are now most of them are selling up and getting out which is a good thing.

MyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 21/03/2023 17:28

The fact that the OP needs a special school for her child is not the problem of the landlord. I seriously don’t understand how people can think that they can just refuse to move when they are given legal notice and come up with excuses to not leave. OP does not own the property they are living in. Plain and simple. They need to leave. What about the problems that the landlord may have?

Thefriendlyone · 21/03/2023 17:26

WombatChocolate · 21/03/2023 17:00

Some people can’t seem to weigh up the downsides of the various options.

If the OP doesn’t leave, people mention a bad reference. To be honest, that too really isn’t going to be a big issue if she keeps paying rent and keeping the property in a decent state and it is decent when she goes. It is important, as the Council will look at the issue of if there are rent arrears. Yes, the LL won’t be able to sell, but he was being greedy to try and market the property before having vacant possessions anyway. There is always a risk tenants won’t go and legally exert their right to stay until removed by the legal process.

Also, the disadvantages of a grumpy LL are minor in relation to being homeless. They are in no way comparable, especially with a new baby.

I am a LL and I acknowledge the system in this country is crap. Because there is a lack of social housing, councils won’t house people until they are about to be made homeless. This means those who cannot afford to move elsewhere or have nowhere to go, HAVE to remain in order to get council help. If they go if their own accord, they have made themselves homeless and the council is not obliged to help them.

This LL will in likelihood find his sale falls through when the buyer realises they won’t be able to complete on the house in any specific time frame. Mortgage lenders won’t release funds when tenants are still there and you cannot exchange with them still there, unless a LL is buying the property and paperwork has been signed to take over the tenancy. But this is exactly why LLs should get vacant possession BEFORE marketing. Wanting rent and to market is simply greedy or a failure to manage finances properly to cope with the inevitable period of an empty property that is necessary in order to sell.

The LL will be able to market and sell when the tenant moves out. They will just have to wait. All LLs should know this delay is always a possibility and factor it in. It is poor planning not to do it. So the delay is irritating, but in some ways brought on by themselves and their attempt to market before vacant possession.

Yes, of course LLs should be able to re-gain their properties…..but within legal parameters. All tenants are entitled to legal eviction procedures and all LLs should know those might have to be used. It’s annoying, but simply one of the realities of renting. You receive rent, but in return tenants have a variety of rights and this is one of them. You can’t do away with it.

This is mind boggling. What has made you think the landlord doesn’t know about the eviction process for goodness sake, and it’s more than a bad reference, once the landlord applies for the possession order it’s game over. Selling a property either with sitting tenants or giving notice when sale agreed is very common. There is no rule saying you should sell empty and no odd thought that it’s “greedy”

it’s a tiny percentage that need to be court evicted. There is over 4 million private rental properties in the uk and about 14k are court evicted. It’s less than a quarter of one percentage point for gods sake. . 99.99 percent of tenants comply with the section 21 and leave.

WombatChocolate · 21/03/2023 17:00

Some people can’t seem to weigh up the downsides of the various options.

If the OP doesn’t leave, people mention a bad reference. To be honest, that too really isn’t going to be a big issue if she keeps paying rent and keeping the property in a decent state and it is decent when she goes. It is important, as the Council will look at the issue of if there are rent arrears. Yes, the LL won’t be able to sell, but he was being greedy to try and market the property before having vacant possessions anyway. There is always a risk tenants won’t go and legally exert their right to stay until removed by the legal process.

Also, the disadvantages of a grumpy LL are minor in relation to being homeless. They are in no way comparable, especially with a new baby.

I am a LL and I acknowledge the system in this country is crap. Because there is a lack of social housing, councils won’t house people until they are about to be made homeless. This means those who cannot afford to move elsewhere or have nowhere to go, HAVE to remain in order to get council help. If they go if their own accord, they have made themselves homeless and the council is not obliged to help them.

This LL will in likelihood find his sale falls through when the buyer realises they won’t be able to complete on the house in any specific time frame. Mortgage lenders won’t release funds when tenants are still there and you cannot exchange with them still there, unless a LL is buying the property and paperwork has been signed to take over the tenancy. But this is exactly why LLs should get vacant possession BEFORE marketing. Wanting rent and to market is simply greedy or a failure to manage finances properly to cope with the inevitable period of an empty property that is necessary in order to sell.

The LL will be able to market and sell when the tenant moves out. They will just have to wait. All LLs should know this delay is always a possibility and factor it in. It is poor planning not to do it. So the delay is irritating, but in some ways brought on by themselves and their attempt to market before vacant possession.

Yes, of course LLs should be able to re-gain their properties…..but within legal parameters. All tenants are entitled to legal eviction procedures and all LLs should know those might have to be used. It’s annoying, but simply one of the realities of renting. You receive rent, but in return tenants have a variety of rights and this is one of them. You can’t do away with it.

Meeeerkat · 21/03/2023 14:32

Not sure if this is relevant to all councils but I found myself homeless this time last year due to DV. During the process I chose the area of my temp accommodation and insisted that my permanent residence was in the same area so that the kids didn’t have to change schools twice. So the advice of people saying that if you’re housed by the council then you could have to change schools multiple times isn’t necessarily correct. I could have stayed in my original area to begin with so they didn’t even have to change school once but with my circumstances I chose to move away. I’m also currently helping a friend in a different council area who is homeless and she also has been given the option to choose the area of where she lives.

Kay286 · 21/03/2023 12:15

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 21/03/2023 12:06

You obviously don't have a child in a rare good SEN focused school.

They're like hens teeth.

Yes landlords are people... But they are also running a business.

It was clearly mad of landlord to market the property without vacant possession... Presumably to get maximal rent til sale.

That's a business risk, he presumably made a willing choice to enter into.

You are right I do not , so when the council house her she is guaranteed still to be housed by this school ? Or could she end up in a grotty bnb with a worse location?

I didn’t realise running a business gave people an excuse to behave poorly to you if you kept up your side of the bargain ? Would you do something similar to a friend/family member and say well you are running a business so it’s ok ?

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 21/03/2023 12:06

Kay286 · 20/03/2023 21:51

You are being incredibly selfish. From what you’ve added after the fact it seems also
not a desperate need but a choice and preference related to schools/location.

Remember landlords are actual people to with problems and lives ….just because you can stay and exercise rights doesn’t mean u should. You have no idea what turmoil this could
create for them. It’s their legal property not yours and if they have been decent landlords be decent and leave once your notice is up instead of creating a horrible situation for all involved.

Also I presume if u wait for council you will
have no say on area or school you can choose then either ? It would be more sensible to
have control and find somewhere yourself rather than end up in a crappy council house. Paying legal fees and never get the chance of being a private tenant again - so wouldn’t risk it. I also believe in karma … I wouldn’t do a shitty thing just because I can

You obviously don't have a child in a rare good SEN focused school.

They're like hens teeth.

Yes landlords are people... But they are also running a business.

It was clearly mad of landlord to market the property without vacant possession... Presumably to get maximal rent til sale.

That's a business risk, he presumably made a willing choice to enter into.

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 21/03/2023 11:54

Ive rented a couple of very pleasant places without landlord references...

Its not impossible.

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 21/03/2023 11:53

nobabiesyet · 20/03/2023 18:19

I would move out because if you don't you will get a terrible reference and this will impact you for years to come. Landlords have their pick of tenants - why blot your record. I would look to move elsewhere - you'll need a reference and I think you'll regret it long term.

I think this pales into insignificance against potentially losing the SEN provision fir her son.

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 21/03/2023 11:26

ThePants999 · 20/03/2023 15:03

I just want to highlight this as a factually correct and critically important post if you want the council to house you. Read it a second time and do exactly what LakieLady said.

If you're under one of the councils who won't take you until you've been through the court process, you have my sympathy as it's an incredibly dumb system that unfairly heaps extra costs on you (you will be liable for the landlord's court/bailiff costs, though we're talking hundreds not thousands there), but you've still got to follow the system.

Yes this!

We were in a similar position...

In addition :

We were advised by CAB/property lawyer:

Continue paying rent as normal

Contact your local courts and find the local waiting list for evictions to be heard... I think 🤔 that they cant apply to court until the 2 months has elapsed... In our area it was 7 months until a likely court date...

Giving a wadge of time to find a suitable alternative property.

lanthanum · 21/03/2023 11:12

Boymamabee · 20/03/2023 18:18

In regards to other private rentals, rent has become extortionate and it’s only marginally cheaper in rural areas. The cost of driving to work, etc., would outweigh the benefits.

There is one appropriate accommodation in a village by DH’s work. It’s £25 cheaper than what we pay now but it would probably mean having to change schools. The school is tiny and has two LSAs and no suitable facilities for ASD kids. His current school has brilliant facilities, including a sensory room and lots of additional support. Maybe the council would fund a taxi but I don’t know. He’s fairly high functioning but typically loves routine. He was unsettled at school so they brought in a “now and later” picture folder for him and an LSA goes over it with him everyday. He’s also hyperlexic and has one-to-one support with reading. His reading age is now well above average.

So I’m not thrilled at the prospect of moving schools.

You've obviously been very lucky with the school he is currently in. However I would not reject the possibility that the village school could do a good job with him too. I would go and talk to them about the provision he has at the moment, and what they would be able to provide. They might not have the sensory room, but the rest might well be possible, and the smaller setting might actually work well for him. In a very small school, they are able to work with each child as an individual, and the continuity of having the same staff throughout means they will really get to understand what works for him.

The reality is that if you wait to be homed by the council, you've no guarantee what you will get - very likely temporary to start with, so potentially two school moves, as well as two home moves.

Youkilledmyfatherpreparetodie · 21/03/2023 10:29

Justanotherdaytoday · 20/03/2023 21:44

@Youkilledmyfatherpreparetodie I'm confident in the advice I've just given which is right. If you leave a property when evicted and have somewhere else to go, even if it renders you part of an overcrowded property, then you are NOT homeless. If you are capable of finding an alternative independently then is not homelessness either. I agree that absolutely independent advice should be sought, especially in ascertaining that this is a legal eviction, however as stated it depends on where you are in the UK. Scotland etc have different legislation.

The legal test of homelessness is if you have somewhere reasonable and suitable to reside for a period of 6 months or more. Staying with friends/family on a temporary basis is not reasonable. You are still homeless in law. Your advice is all wrong and it makes me cross when people claim to be qualified to give advice on things they don't understand. Please think of the impact your incorrect statements could have on vulnerable families.

Thefriendlyone · 21/03/2023 07:47

Boymamabee · 20/03/2023 22:33

@Thefriendlyone sorry if my post wasn’t clear. Shelter haven’t advised us not to rent somewhere we can afford. What I meant is that some rural places are only marginally cheaper and we’d still be out-priced by the cost of fuel. So far, I’ve only seen one property where this isn’t the case. DH suggested applying for properties regardless and then finding a second job once we’ve moved (not that they’re likely to accept us). I’d rather wait for a financial assessment. If somewhere suitable comes up before our notice expires, of course we’ll take it, but we were advised against staying with family or friends before our notice is up.

i understand that. Although not the financial assessment thing. You can work out your own options.

I do think the issue here is you and your husband are in different places mentally.

i think he’s accepted you’re moving out and is now trying to find a solution. You are hoping you can somehow stay either in the flat or that location . The first is not going to happen the second highly unlikely.

to risk the council finds you someplace acceptable and in that location is a Enormous gamble that you’re likely to loose and will habe long lasting repercussions for you. It is also likely to be very traumatic for everyone concerned. If you’re evicted and put in temp. Which is the likely outcome, what will you even do with your stuff? Other than what many others need to do and leave it on the ground.

I suspect you know deep down it’s best to sort this yourself , but you’re just rallying against the situation now.

id also check all the benefits you’re entitled to. If you have debt speak to step change or citizens advice. Speak to the school today. And the local authority, but you need to come up with s plan and act.

Cj19877 · 20/03/2023 23:33

It sounds as though your LL may have already tried to sell the property with you as sitting tenants.
Unfortunately eviction fees are one of the many causes of rent increases and landlords selling up.

Swipe left for the next trending thread