Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse to leave rented property

314 replies

Boymamabee · 20/03/2023 14:16

I’m having an ethical dilemma thanks to my husband…

I’m heavily pregnant (due a c-section next month) and we’ve been served a two month no-fault notice by our landlord (it’s all valid).

We’re struggling to find rented properties within our price range and although we’re at risk of homelessness, the council can’t guarantee temp accommodation before our notice expires. This makes my husband anxious as he says we have no right to stay in a house we don’t own and it’s unfair on the LL whose sale might fall through.

Places for the same amount of rent, or less, than we currently pay are more rural and would cost more fuel. Many of the local schools don’t have specialised facilities for kids with ASD (think rural schools with 20 students and 2 LSAs) and DS LOVES his school!

This is where it gets tricky…

We’ve been advised that if we stay with family or friends before the LL enacts a court possession order, we could be seen as making ourselves “intentionally homeless”. Likewise if we get ourselves into debt/arrears living somewhere we can’t afford.

I’ve proposed we listen to
their advice and stay put for now, but DH thinks it’s selfish and we’ll naturally find another way to make ends meet. He wants to be out before our contract ends and he feels sorry for the LL who’s going through a divorce.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Itsbytheby · 22/03/2023 09:38

As others have said you can live elsewhere you jsut don't want to. I'm not sure why you think that you will get offered soemthing better by the housing authority. Chances are you will have even less choice and more disruption. So I think staying put is a bit shitty to be honest.

Boymamabee · 22/03/2023 09:37

@smashinggrapes rentals have increased exponentially in the past 11 months on top of bills. There are other personal, pregnancy/health-related factors as to why we can’t simply pay more within the space of a few weeks. My point regarding rural locations is that I still feel we’re out-priced when you factor in the cost of fuel (minus one area which doesn’t have a school with asd facilities although I’ll find out more today).

DH wanted to be out of here asap and find a second job or do self-employed stuff after we’ve moved, which I feel is risky. We’re currently unlikely to be accepted anyway as they look at your income and we’d have to find a guarantor to secure a bond. Basically, I feel it’s outside our affordability to rent anywhere we’ve seen, but DH wants to do what you suggest and find a way to just “pay more” as he’s scared of the prospect of a court possession order and our ability to rent again if somewhere suitable does come up.

Two suitable places did come up but they stopped accepting applications after a day. I’ve been losing sleep already and I literally can’t afford to think too deeply into the LL’s circumstances until I weigh up all our options.

OP posts:
saltandshake2 · 22/03/2023 09:35

Your situation is shit, the thing I would be most concerned about in your position is keeping your DS in his existing school as it sounds like he is thriving there.

If you wait for bailiff's and the council to emergency rehouse you, then surely his current school place will be the last thing the council will care about?

I personally think your DH is right, if you are low earners and getting all the benefits you can (I haven't read the whole thread, but please check you are getting all the financial assistance you are entitled to) then he will need to work more hours/get another job until you can go back to work yourself.

In your position I'd be asking the council about transportation for your DS to school (maybe the school can help with this) and just finding yourselves somewhere to live.
I can't imagine living in a B&B for months/years with 2 children, and I'd do as much as I could to avoid that.

Hope it works out for you all.

smashinggrapes · 22/03/2023 08:11

"Places for the same amount of rent, or less, than we currently pay are more rural and would cost more fuel"

Which suggests your landlord has been letting you pay lower rents than she could've. You need to move to the more rural option or find a way to pay more, like most of the country are having to do.

Thefriendlyone · 22/03/2023 08:03

I don’t think anyone is saying she should make her self intentionally homeless, what a daft response. They are saying if she has the means and ability it is in her interests to find someplace else ro live. And it does appear she has the means and ability, just not in her preferred exact location.

im also astounded anyone can be so utterly ignorant to read a thread where a low income family had to move twice in 18 months due to their landlords selling up and are now struggling to house themselves where rhey wish due to lack of affordable rentals and crow it’s a good thing landlords are selling up.

It’s not a good thing for the op and it’s not a good thing for thousands of other families who can’t house themselves due to it.

and that’s the issue, when you make it hard and unprofitable for landlords rhey sell up. As they are doing, Reducing properties available for rent, evicting existing tenants, and leaving a lot of families homeless. There is not enough social housing, so they end up in hostels and b&bs.

we are going to see more and more of this. And it’s those who need to rent who will suffer.

RosemaryAndTim · 22/03/2023 06:47

Brieandcamembert · 21/03/2023 22:28

It's the landlords property. Not yours. You wouldn't steal a car (maybe you would?). You can't steal a house. you will cost someone else a lot of money If you stay.

I literally cannot believe people are saying not to leave and let the landlord incur court and bailiff costs and lose a sale. Imagine the stress and sleepless nights as well as the financial loss.

Sorry but this is absolute balls. Landlords know what the law is (and I've been one- this is not an anti landlord post). In OP's circumstances it would make sense for her to stay until the point at which she's not making herself intentionally homeless. Yes, that's inconvenient for the landlord- this is one of the costs of doing business. The law is as it is for a reason- to give tenants a few rights in a world that is very much stacked against them (tenants' rights in the UK are pretty meagre compared to equivalent countries in Europe). I'm quite shocked that anyone would argue for OP to make herself intentionally homeless- you must know what that would mean.

If you're not willing to deal with the law of L&T, don't be a landlord. There are plenty of other ways to invest your capital.

Charlieiscool · 22/03/2023 02:02

Are you thinking you will be given a nice council house in the exact area you want, where you and DH can keep your current jobs and your DC can stay in the same school? No nasty bnb for who knows how long, who knows where, while you wait to be housed who knows where, and you lose the opportunity to get a private rental because of your history of refusing to leave? Dream on.

ARangaupatree · 22/03/2023 00:35

I had a tenant do this-she was advised to by the council - she actually stayed until the bailiffs cam/court (which i'm guessing was stressful for her as well)
[ just to be clear I used a no fault Section 21 - but she was also not paying- removing tenants for not paying is problematic]
It actually ended up in court where she didn't have a leg to stand on - and she ended up with all my costs as well (including bailiffs)- so i'm not sure how it worked out for her ultimately (not sure if she got a house) - so you need to weigh up the pros and cons,
What have your local council said? what would the temporary accomodation be?
can you speak to the buyer at all and get an extension?

I do hate the local council's attitude on this- it just stretches it out for everyone

HamBone · 22/03/2023 00:27

Boymamabee · 21/03/2023 22:06

@HamBone it’s sold but the buyer wants to live here so we have to leave. We were told it would be sold with us remaining as tenants. I suppose it was always a risk.

Yes, @WomanStanleyWoman2 , he’s already got a buyer and is clearly. determined to get rid of the property. Tbh, even if this sale falls through, it’s unlikely to be sold to another LL in the current climate. The OP’s family can stay until they’re evicted, but the end result will probably be the same.

Ermweareemergencyservices · 21/03/2023 23:59

Would anyone ever rent to you again if you had a court ordered eviction on your record? Do you have to declare such things?

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 21/03/2023 23:23

Yes, she should make her children literally homeless for someone else's extra house.

People keep making comments like this as if, if the OP digs her heels in, the landlord will simply capitulate let her stay forever - probably even with a rent reduction. It won’t happen. There will be months of highly stressful legal wrangling ahead. The end result will be the same; or rather, the OP will be without a home, but with a court ordered eviction on her record. That’s before you even consider that the landlord could whack the rent up in the meantime, stop carrying out maintenance etc.

EscapeRoomToTheSun · 21/03/2023 22:37

Brieandcamembert · 21/03/2023 22:28

It's the landlords property. Not yours. You wouldn't steal a car (maybe you would?). You can't steal a house. you will cost someone else a lot of money If you stay.

I literally cannot believe people are saying not to leave and let the landlord incur court and bailiff costs and lose a sale. Imagine the stress and sleepless nights as well as the financial loss.

Yes, she should make her children literally homeless for someone else's extra house.

Of course, there are no sleepless nights when you are housing insecure. Fuck off.

Brieandcamembert · 21/03/2023 22:28

It's the landlords property. Not yours. You wouldn't steal a car (maybe you would?). You can't steal a house. you will cost someone else a lot of money If you stay.

I literally cannot believe people are saying not to leave and let the landlord incur court and bailiff costs and lose a sale. Imagine the stress and sleepless nights as well as the financial loss.

Boymamabee · 21/03/2023 22:06

@HamBone it’s sold but the buyer wants to live here so we have to leave. We were told it would be sold with us remaining as tenants. I suppose it was always a risk.

OP posts:
EigerMum · 21/03/2023 22:03

Thefriendlyone · 21/03/2023 21:46

It’s a good thing if you relish folks being in the same horrible situation as the op, if you want her to be able to have a home where she wishes and in her budget it’s not now is it.

where do you propose she lives?

Completely agree. It’s absolutely true that it became too easy and too attractive to be a LL. But we can’t change that now and we have to deal with the situation at hand. Shrinking rental market does nothing to help renters, no matter how much you hate landlords.

Quite honestly I think people also need to remember that landlords are not charities. If you want them to act like charities then give them the same tax treatment and obligations. Otherwise they are equally within their rights to make decisions that suit their own priorities within the boundaries of the law.

Thefriendlyone · 21/03/2023 21:46

DonnaBanana · 21/03/2023 17:39

What about the problems that the landlord may have?

Irrelevant to OP. People need to stop being greedy and becoming landlords. Luckily with the rules as they are now most of them are selling up and getting out which is a good thing.

It’s a good thing if you relish folks being in the same horrible situation as the op, if you want her to be able to have a home where she wishes and in her budget it’s not now is it.

where do you propose she lives?

HamBone · 21/03/2023 21:06

This is confusing. So the property has actually been on the market since November? But it hasn’t sold yet so now he wants to sell it as an empty property?

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 21/03/2023 20:14

The landlord has chosen to try to evict a family including a pregnant lady with the legal minimum of notice during a well publicised housing crisis. They could easily have chosen to say to the OP previously “I’m afraid we are going to have to sell in the next 12 months so could you start looking” giving the OP more time and less pressure. Then followed the legal eviction route later if no progress.

Did you miss the bit where he’s getting divorced? Waiting around until it’s more convenient for the OP may simply not be an option.

You think the OP should put herself first and not worry about the landlord - and I do get why. But hasn’t it occurred to you that the landlord is simply doing the same?

Boymamabee · 21/03/2023 20:06

Moraxella · 21/03/2023 19:26

@Winter2020 the landlord already warned them and tried to sell with them in situ last November.

This is true. Although the letting agents told us we didn’t have to worry and asked us to renew our contract for a further 3 months, then told us we’d be protected for a further 6 months after the LL found a buyer. This was before the 1st December - when new legislation giving tenants 6 months notice came into force.

I understand life happen and the LL probably intended to sell with us in situ, but I’m annoyed I didn’t follow my gut and apply for that cheap 2 bed flat we saw on Zoopla.

I’ve put in a housing application with the council and I’m going to find out what their policies are regarding homelessness. I don’t want to make us “intentionally homeless” nor do I
want to wreck our chances of ever privately renting again.

OP posts:
mummyh2016 · 21/03/2023 19:50

CheersForThatEh · 21/03/2023 19:29

The questions are:

how nice do you think temporary accommodation is going to be? There are (close to) entire roads of B&Bs in my town which are no go zones as they have a lot of drink/drug dependent and recently released prisoners in them.

Do you want to be moved around on someone else's schedule with a newborn?

Do you plan to ever rent privately again?

This. One of my colleagues handles moving council tenants into or out of their properties. One building we regularly move people out of into council houses/flats is a block of bedsits. In the past we used to have to send someone once a week just to pick up the used drug needles from outside (we no longer do because I presume the council sort this themselves rather than subcontract). I get your desperate, but desperate enough to potentially be put somewhere like that?

CheersForThatEh · 21/03/2023 19:29

The questions are:

how nice do you think temporary accommodation is going to be? There are (close to) entire roads of B&Bs in my town which are no go zones as they have a lot of drink/drug dependent and recently released prisoners in them.

Do you want to be moved around on someone else's schedule with a newborn?

Do you plan to ever rent privately again?

Moraxella · 21/03/2023 19:26

@Winter2020 the landlord already warned them and tried to sell with them in situ last November.

Mateyduck · 21/03/2023 19:25

If you have a forced eviction on your record, I’m pretty sure you’ll struggle to privately rent again.

WombatChocolate · 21/03/2023 19:24

Thefriendlyone · 21/03/2023 17:26

This is mind boggling. What has made you think the landlord doesn’t know about the eviction process for goodness sake, and it’s more than a bad reference, once the landlord applies for the possession order it’s game over. Selling a property either with sitting tenants or giving notice when sale agreed is very common. There is no rule saying you should sell empty and no odd thought that it’s “greedy”

it’s a tiny percentage that need to be court evicted. There is over 4 million private rental properties in the uk and about 14k are court evicted. It’s less than a quarter of one percentage point for gods sake. . 99.99 percent of tenants comply with the section 21 and leave.

Solicitors advise clients who have had offers accepted on properties with tenants still in situ (who aren’t LLs wanting to take on the property with the tenants) that the sale is problematic. They tell them that mortgage lenders won’t confirm an offer or release funds for exchange until the property is vacant. They point out that there is no knowing when the property will be vacant….you can hope they will vacate by the time their notice expires, but you can’t guarantee it. It is the uncertainty of it that buyers don’t like and rightly so. There are numerous threads on MN where LLs are having trouble selling a tenanted property, and rightly, the advice is always to get vacant possession and then market.

It is greedy to try and market a tenanted property. And I speak as a LL. That tenant has paid for quiet enjoyment and will continue to pay until they vacate in most cases. But marketing invovled them either having to go out when viewings happen (not convenient or what they want) or to be there with strangers traipsing through their home (not what they want). Neither can be described as allowing the quiet enjoyment they have paid for and are contractually entitled to. But many people, both LLs and often non-LLs can’t see why asking them to do this, is not reasonable, nor why if they refuse, it is unreasonable.

What LLs hope for is a tenant who pays rent up to or very close to exchange PLUS the benefits of being able to market, which is unreasonable when tenanted.

Its not acceptable for LLs to say ‘I have a mortgage to pay and can’t afford it without rent, so I have to keep the tenant until I sell’ or ‘The notice period means my tenant won’t be gone for X weeks, but Indint want to wait until then to market it. It is mine after all’. Those tenants have paid and signed legal contracts which enable them to enjoy their home until the end of the contract when they choose to leave OR when the court removes them.

Winter2020 · 21/03/2023 19:21

I am staggered at the amount of people worrying about the landlord and saying for example “morally I couldn’t stay and make someones life more difficult” etc etc.

The landlord has chosen to try to evict a family including a pregnant lady with the legal minimum of notice during a well publicised housing crisis. They could easily have chosen to say to the OP previously “I’m afraid we are going to have to sell in the next 12 months so could you start looking” giving the OP more time and less pressure. Then followed the legal eviction route later if no progress.

When I wanted to move back to my house that was rented out I told the family sometime after Christmas that I hoped to move back in the summer for my child to start the local school in September. They had found somewhere and moved by Easter.

My heart is not bleeding for this landlord at all. The “how you treat people” argument works both ways.