Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse to leave rented property

314 replies

Boymamabee · 20/03/2023 14:16

I’m having an ethical dilemma thanks to my husband…

I’m heavily pregnant (due a c-section next month) and we’ve been served a two month no-fault notice by our landlord (it’s all valid).

We’re struggling to find rented properties within our price range and although we’re at risk of homelessness, the council can’t guarantee temp accommodation before our notice expires. This makes my husband anxious as he says we have no right to stay in a house we don’t own and it’s unfair on the LL whose sale might fall through.

Places for the same amount of rent, or less, than we currently pay are more rural and would cost more fuel. Many of the local schools don’t have specialised facilities for kids with ASD (think rural schools with 20 students and 2 LSAs) and DS LOVES his school!

This is where it gets tricky…

We’ve been advised that if we stay with family or friends before the LL enacts a court possession order, we could be seen as making ourselves “intentionally homeless”. Likewise if we get ourselves into debt/arrears living somewhere we can’t afford.

I’ve proposed we listen to
their advice and stay put for now, but DH thinks it’s selfish and we’ll naturally find another way to make ends meet. He wants to be out before our contract ends and he feels sorry for the LL who’s going through a divorce.

AIBU?

OP posts:
HamBone · 23/03/2023 12:29

@Thesharkradar It’s not working out well for the OP’s family, though, is it? The property’s being sold to an owner occupier and they have nowhere to go.

Rental properties will always be needed, many people rent at some point in their lives, don’t they? I did for years.

Thesharkradar · 23/03/2023 12:15

Fewer landlords will result in fewer rental properties and thus drive up rental prices further
Landlords exiting the industry will have to sell to owner occupiers for whatever they can get, some of those owner occupies will be people who otherwise would have had to rent.
Landlords selling up will help to drive prices down so that more people can be owner occupiers... can invest in their own futures rather than lining the pockets of the parasitical rentier class

Thesharkradar · 23/03/2023 12:12

WhatNoRaisins · 23/03/2023 12:02

It doesn't strike me as a good system for individual landlords with a lot to lose if their tennant can't move on when needed.

What's it like in countries where it's more "the norm"? Are there more business landlords who can manage this better?

What strikes me is that there is a huge 'conflict of interest' here; in the main tenants need a stable affordable and secure home. This isn't just a nice extra to have in your life, it's a basic necessity.
If the landlord can turf you out on a whim, increase the rent to squeeze as much profit out of you as possible so that you can barely afford to live, how are you supposed to have stable life 🤷

WhatNoRaisins · 23/03/2023 12:02

It doesn't strike me as a good system for individual landlords with a lot to lose if their tennant can't move on when needed.

What's it like in countries where it's more "the norm"? Are there more business landlords who can manage this better?

nobabiesyet · 23/03/2023 11:58

Well when people complain that they can't find a property to rent think about threads like this. There's already a person going travelling for a year who is not considering renting her property because of issues it will cause. Imagine if she'd rented it for a year - and could give someone a nice place to live for a year, or alternatively get people not willing to move out! What a waste, for her and for some tenants that might have got a good deal. Fewer landlords will result in fewer rental properties and thus drive up rental prices further. Landlords will pick and choose tenants and this will make it much harder for some people to rent. Some people want to rent - it provides flexibility, maybe you are separating and need a house for 6 months or are saving for a house, or are new to an area, etc.

Thesharkradar · 23/03/2023 11:53

It's the landlords property. Not yours
Yes the landlord is the owner of the property but the tenant is the owner of a lease which gives then the right to live in the property in return for payment of rent.

Crikeyalmighty · 23/03/2023 11:29

@Boymamabee good luck - I do feel for you. I can see practically why finding somewhere else is more sensible and looks better on your record, but can also see that if it's not going to be possible and you need to be considered for council/HA that you kind of 'have' to be made homeless. It's the system that is totally screwed.

Boymamabee · 23/03/2023 11:05

Really interesting feedback. My husband’s still insisting it’s wrong to stay, regardless.

I’ve put in an application for a 2-bed flat in the area. It’s around the same price as a house in a more rural area but it’s by the school and will save us fuel, etc. We can just about afford it.

It went up yesterday afternoon and the estate agents said they’ve already had a high amount of interest. We have a viewing at the end of next week. Fingers crossed because they offer long-term tenancy.

It's all so unsettling.

OP posts:
MacarenaMacarena · 23/03/2023 11:01

If OP stays until eviction she will end up in awful temporary accommodation with no control over where it is... This would be the worst option. Her DH is trying to maintain some control of their situation for her benefit.
OP alludes to the portion of staying with family from the point of view of this disadvantaging her chances of emergency housing - I encourage her to look at that option as a way of maintaining control - saving all her rent and bill money for a few months then moving into a new rental with the savings to afford it. By the time the savings run out she'll be ready to tackle it.
Let's help the OP with some useful suggestions and acknowledgement of the fact there are ways to get what she ultimately wants without resorting to destroying her rental chances with court ordered eviction and poor references.

MacarenaMacarena · 23/03/2023 10:49

If you have the chance to stay with family or friends for three months you can save all your rent and bill money, then you'll be in a very strong position to move into a rental in the area you want - the savings will cover the extra rent for a year.
At the end of the year, you might well be ready to get back to work, making the most of family offers to help out with the children, or start a bit of childminding if no one is there to help.
I'd also suggest this might not be a great situation to be in to consider extending family further after this baby arrives - one thing at a time xx

Butteryflakycrust83 · 23/03/2023 10:12

Brieandcamembert · 21/03/2023 22:28

It's the landlords property. Not yours. You wouldn't steal a car (maybe you would?). You can't steal a house. you will cost someone else a lot of money If you stay.

I literally cannot believe people are saying not to leave and let the landlord incur court and bailiff costs and lose a sale. Imagine the stress and sleepless nights as well as the financial loss.

A proper landlord runs a tenancy like a business, as well as an investment. With that investment comes risk, potential costs and paying for insurance for these scenarios.

The tenant's market is FUCKED. You can point fingers at whoever you feel is responsible. But staying until eviction is the process for emergency housing is she is unable to find a suitable new home. A good landlord will always be aware of these risks.

Its also not stealing, dont be so fucking ridiculous.

user1496146479 · 22/03/2023 22:40

DonnaBanana · 21/03/2023 17:39

What about the problems that the landlord may have?

Irrelevant to OP. People need to stop being greedy and becoming landlords. Luckily with the rules as they are now most of them are selling up and getting out which is a good thing.

Biscuit
loislovesstewie · 22/03/2023 21:52

If she then applies on the housing register from the 1 bed, the policy might state that, having deliberately worsened her circumstances by moving to an inadequate property, she will not receive any additional priority for rehousing. I worked in social housing for over 30 years and that is the policy generally. Choosing to move to a too small property is worsening their circumstances, it's not a good idea to to do that. She really needs to discuss the situation with her housing officer who can give advice and explain what her best options are. I would never encourage an applicant to take a too small property in the hopes of being housed.

OverCCCs · 22/03/2023 20:46

loislovesstewie · 22/03/2023 19:20

Please don't move to a 1 bed without discussing it with the housing department. You may well be found to have worsened your circumstances, by deliberately overcrowding, and you may find that you are not awarded any priority.

What difference does priority make if they procure a one bedroom private rental? And it sounds like OP can probably afford the cost of a private one-bed in the location she’s targeting if slightly more rural two bedrooms and local two bedrooms during the winter were affordable.

Avoid weeks or months of stress, OP, and the possibility of bringing your newborn home to a grimy BnB and just modify your search parameters for something you can afford and will put a roof over your head and four walls around you within the boundaries of where your DS can stay at his school.

loislovesstewie · 22/03/2023 19:20

Please don't move to a 1 bed without discussing it with the housing department. You may well be found to have worsened your circumstances, by deliberately overcrowding, and you may find that you are not awarded any priority.

OverCCCs · 22/03/2023 19:08

Boymamabee · 21/03/2023 20:06

This is true. Although the letting agents told us we didn’t have to worry and asked us to renew our contract for a further 3 months, then told us we’d be protected for a further 6 months after the LL found a buyer. This was before the 1st December - when new legislation giving tenants 6 months notice came into force.

I understand life happen and the LL probably intended to sell with us in situ, but I’m annoyed I didn’t follow my gut and apply for that cheap 2 bed flat we saw on Zoopla.

I’ve put in a housing application with the council and I’m going to find out what their policies are regarding homelessness. I don’t want to make us “intentionally homeless” nor do I
want to wreck our chances of ever privately renting again.

If keeping your DS in his current school is the most important thing and you’re currently looking at two bed places, start looking for one beds. They’ll be cheaper and you’ll hopefully find something in the area you need.

Your son can have the bedroom and you, your husband, and the baby can sleep in the living area. It’s far from ideal but it will get you your top priority, and then you can move when your son is ready to move on to secondary or you find a better alternative.

HamBone · 22/03/2023 19:04

@LakieLady Yes, the best case scenario would be for the OP to been given good council accommodation.

What I find ironic though is that some people seem to abhor private landlords and then further hate them when they get out of the business!

loislovesstewie · 22/03/2023 18:54

Any decent landlord understands the law of landlord and tenant, they know their rights and responsibilities, they understand that the tenant is, legally, quite within their rights to await a court order. They understand that it is a notice of seeking possession and is the first stage in obtaining possession, they understand that attempting to make the tenant leave without going through the correct legal process may well cause them to be taken to court themselves for various offences. If the tenant wants to find alternative accommodation then fine, but they don't have to until the possession order is obtained. And even then, only the court bailiffs can legally remove the tenant from the property.

LakieLady · 22/03/2023 18:53

gogohmm · 22/03/2023 18:45

@LakieLady and no landlord will touch her ever again. You have a contract to rent a property, your landlord tells you they are not renewing your contract and gives you the statutory notice to leave, you leave ... advising otherwise gives renters a bad reputation and is one of the reasons why people with shorter term empty properties don't let them. (I'm planning on going travelling for a year but will probably not let the house for this reason)

Look for housing in your price range

But if the council accept a duty, she may never have to look for privately rented property ever again.

LakieLady · 22/03/2023 18:51

Cornishclio · 20/03/2023 20:45

I think it depends very much on your local council and how likely you are to get a property in your chosen area and I have a strong suspicion that the accommodation offered will be temporary and not immediately ideal. In the interests of getting a decent reference from the landlord and being in control of where you end up I would take the best option for you even if it means you travelling to the school for your DS. You could try telling the council your son has special needs and is settled in his current school and see what they suggest.

Eventually you will have to leave so surely leaving on your own terms is better?

You're right about it varying a lot between areas.

My council, the neighbouring council and one just over the border in the next county lease properties from private landlords for homeless families. They are handed over to the council in good condition and the council then becomes responsible for the maintenance for the duration of the lease.

They also have several large houses that have been converted into flats for temporary accommodation for homeless families. Most homeless families here spend a max of two weeks in B&B before they can move on.

ASongOfRiceAndPeas · 22/03/2023 18:50

I’ve read the first two pages and had to stop as it was getting upsetting seeing people who simply can’t afford to move onto another rented property being demonised.

OP, (and everyone advising incorrectly): remember that the only people who can end a tenancy are the tenants by giving notice, or the courts. If you’re able to move out at the end of the landlords notice period, good for you.

Tenants are not ‘bad’ people because they overstay the landlords notice period and follow the councils guidance to stay put if they have no other choice. The whole system is broken.

HamBone · 22/03/2023 18:49

@Thesharkradar You're absolutely right, the new owner won’t complete the sale until the tenants leave. But it makes no difference, if this buyer pulls out, the landlord will continue with the eviction process and find another buyer.

Unless the buyer is another landlord, the OP’s family will have to leave in a few months.

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 22/03/2023 18:48

the tenant is in the premises, therefore they are a sitting tenant, therefore the purchaser has bought a property for which they cannot have vacant possession

No one has bought the property. Someone has had an offer accepted and a sale is in process. Buying with sitting tenants means you accept there is an existing lease and that the tenants will remain in the property at least until that lease ends. The fact that the current owner has served a Section 21 and is attempting to get the OP and her family out suggests that the offer is conditional on vacant possession - otherwise why would he bother?

gogohmm · 22/03/2023 18:45

@LakieLady and no landlord will touch her ever again. You have a contract to rent a property, your landlord tells you they are not renewing your contract and gives you the statutory notice to leave, you leave ... advising otherwise gives renters a bad reputation and is one of the reasons why people with shorter term empty properties don't let them. (I'm planning on going travelling for a year but will probably not let the house for this reason)

Look for housing in your price range

Thesharkradar · 22/03/2023 18:38

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 22/03/2023 18:32

But presumably they haven’t bought it with a sitting tenant - that’s why the current owner is trying to get the tenants out.

the tenant is in the premises, therefore they are a sitting tenant, therefore the purchaser has bought a property for which they cannot have vacant possession

@Boymamabee
you dont have to obey the landlord, you have to do what's in your best interest, the LL has messed up trying to sell the place while you're still in it, you can use thier mistake to give you extra leverage.
Your husband is pathetic