Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Got "told off"- annual leave for teachers strike

283 replies

Skyblue81 · 20/03/2023 10:31

Feeling confused. AIBU??

Got 3 kids. Teachers were on strike last Weds & Thurs. School said it would remain open, but changed their minds Weds morning.

I worked from home on Weds with all 3 kids at home. It was exhausting, so I then put in for 2 days annual leave for Thursday (teachers strike) and Friday (to recover from my exhaustion).

Got back to work today to an HR call where I basically got told off for submitting and then taking leave!!!!! Yes OK I didn't give loads of notice, but then neither did my school.

Feeling really beaten-down by my workplace. I work hard, and have earned that annual leave. I took it to take care of my children, then have a recovery day. FFS it's not like I went on a bender to Ibiza!

AIBU???

OP posts:
GenuineNine · 20/03/2023 12:07

Was there any impact on others when you took the holiday? I'm wondering is someone has complained to HR

Chickenly · 20/03/2023 12:07

Mortimercat · 20/03/2023 12:03

I have never come across an employment contract that has any rules on when you can request leave one way or another.

If it’s not explicitly in the contract then the statutory rules apply which is twice as long as the requested length of leave. So, for OP’s two days off, she’d have to give four days notice. Her contract would have to explicitly say that she does not need to give notice in order for her to not have to give notice - like you said, I’ve never, ever, ever, ever seen a contract say that.

www.gov.uk/holiday-entitlement-rights/booking-time-off-

Mortimercat · 20/03/2023 12:03

DinnerThyme · 20/03/2023 11:39

No one is nitpicking except you. As explained multiple times now, them approving her leave doesn’t mean she’s absolved of responsibility for submitting the request late.

We don’t know what’s in her contract because she’s refused to say. I’ve never come across any employment contract that says you can request annual leave with no notice. Have you?

I have never come across an employment contract that has any rules on when you can request leave one way or another.

WindUpPenguin · 20/03/2023 12:02

What has your line manager said? If your manager approved it, then it is their fault, not yours. I am confused!!

sjxoxo · 20/03/2023 12:02

They’re not being v supportive imo. I’d actually ask them about dependants leave policy and tell them next time you’ll take that instead.

If they’re treating you like shit and you feel undervalued or infantalised I’d be tempted to move to a new role.. might be worth looking! X

WigglyWigglyWiggly · 20/03/2023 12:02

So, assuming that OP’s contract is like every other employment contract and she has to give notice for annual leave (because no one has ever come across that not being the case):

Option 1: She requests annual leave after she’s supposed to. Her manager approves it anyway because she/he isn’t a dick. Things get shifted around and are a little bit stressful and other employers get a bit annoyed that she got away with breaking the rules. HR ask OP not to book leave after the deadline again. Some posters say “but they shouldn’t have approved it if they were going to have a problem afterwards”.

Option 2: She requests annual leave after she’s supposed to. Her line manager denies it because they shouldn’t be approving leave after the deadline because it means things are shifted around at the last minute, other employees find it unfair and because mumsnetters jump down their throats. OP now can’t take annual leave and has no childcare or has to take unpaid leave or has a very stressful time of it all.

Either way, the company are the bad guys - either their hypocrites for approving the leave to do OP a favour when they didn’t have to or they’re dickheads for not approving the leave she needed just to avoid being hypocritical.

I’ll apologise if OP does have a contract that says annual leave can be requested at any point up to the very last minute but I highly doubt that’s the case - and her not answering that does indicate that too.

No one is really being unreasonable. She requested it at the last minute, she probably shouldn’t have but it’s not a major issue. They asked her not to - it’s not like they had her tarred and feathered.

melj1213 · 20/03/2023 12:02

Tbh whilst my work would allow it they would get annoyed at the late notice if I hadn't given them at least a heads up previously that "There are strikes planned for Wed/Thurs. My DDs school is planning to be open on Thursday so I shouldn't need to be off but if they do change their mind last minute I'll need leave. Am I alright to book it as AL as opposed to emergency dependant leave so I can still get paid?".

Also my company's holiday year runs April-April so every year in the last couple of weeks of March people realise they have X holiday hours/days left that they will lose if they don't take in the next week or so and so everyone tries to put holiday requests in last minute ... They can't be refused unless there is a genuine business reason as there is a legal right to them so they have to be allowed but it fucks everyone over because we're even more short staffed and then causes a headache in the office as they have to go through a massive justification process with Head Office as to why they are either paying out the holidays or rolling them over to the next holiday year.

QWERTTY · 20/03/2023 12:01

CountZacular · 20/03/2023 11:56

I have read it and I disagree (how do you not get that?). It STILL doesn’t matter if she’s not supposed to book leave short notice. She asked the manager who should be able to check the policy and say ‘nope, not enough notice’. The manager did not and approved instead. It is a management issue.

I actually do work in HR and the fact that the employee asked a senior member of staff and didn’t get reminded of a policy that we don’t even know if exists and just approved would mean a discussion with the manager. Not the employee.

Thank you for clearly stating from a HR perspective what so many others have tried to! It saddens me that some people on here have or work in HR departments that would behave as the OPs have.

latetothefisting · 20/03/2023 12:00

I would go back to whoever criticised you and ask them to put in writing what you should have done in the circumstances as its not clear exactly what they are unhappy about...e.g. are they saying you shouldn't have leave at all or you should have given more notice? Also ask them to refer to the policy if they are saying you did something wrong.

E.g. if your leave policy states you have to give twice as much notice as the time you want off (so you wanted 2 days so have to give 4 days notice) and you should have asked for emergency parental leave instead then, fine technically you were in the wrong and will know for next time.

Although you still want them to confirm that there isn't any paragraph about line managers discretion etc.

Really from their POV they should want you to take AL if possible because even though they don't pay you for the EPL it's still a day you're not working and you still have you're AL (i.e. more days youre not working) to take.

if the policy only says to give as much notice as possible, or there's anything about line manager discretion then go back to them and ask how you possibly could have given more notice before you knew yourself! Extra points if anywhere your company refers to itself as flexible or family friendly etc. - quote this.

It doesn't have to be aggressive -I used to be a trade union rep so got good at wording very nice and polite emails standing up for myself!

This is obviously only if you think your company are being unfair - if you accept you didn't follow the policy and are just annoyed at the situation (which is fair enough, it is annoying!) but you might just have to let it go.

SilverTotoro · 20/03/2023 11:58

Some very unpleasant comments on here in my opinion. OP YANBU. You asked for annual leave and it was approved by your manager. In my mind that’s the end of the discussion - if leave was approved then HR have no business pulling you up on it. It’s clear it was short notice for legitimate reasons and if your manager had an issue with you taking the Friday as well as the Thur then they should have spoken up at the time and not approved it.

Haraebo · 20/03/2023 11:57

Skyblue81 · 20/03/2023 10:31

Feeling confused. AIBU??

Got 3 kids. Teachers were on strike last Weds & Thurs. School said it would remain open, but changed their minds Weds morning.

I worked from home on Weds with all 3 kids at home. It was exhausting, so I then put in for 2 days annual leave for Thursday (teachers strike) and Friday (to recover from my exhaustion).

Got back to work today to an HR call where I basically got told off for submitting and then taking leave!!!!! Yes OK I didn't give loads of notice, but then neither did my school.

Feeling really beaten-down by my workplace. I work hard, and have earned that annual leave. I took it to take care of my children, then have a recovery day. FFS it's not like I went on a bender to Ibiza!

AIBU???

I don't think YABU at all but you do seem very stressed about it.

I would be emailing HR. Something along the lines of; "Dear.. Having had time to process our conversation, I would like to clarify that this time off was approved by... I hope this clears it up. I look forward to hearing from you with confirmation that this is now resolved and has been removed from my record. "

Caramac555 · 20/03/2023 11:57

I've been told to book leave and cancel it at the last minute if the school is open.

It's annoying to both me and my management line, but they understand. I would e mail your HR with how they wish you to play it in future.

My last workplace sound a bit like yours though. I was a keyworker throughout lockdown and also had the school open/shut/half open/open until they're not open to navigate and they weren't supportive at all. I was part of the great resignation.

CountZacular · 20/03/2023 11:56

Chickenly · 20/03/2023 11:50

How are people not getting this? @Sqqueeeeeeee could not have been clearer.

I have read it and I disagree (how do you not get that?). It STILL doesn’t matter if she’s not supposed to book leave short notice. She asked the manager who should be able to check the policy and say ‘nope, not enough notice’. The manager did not and approved instead. It is a management issue.

I actually do work in HR and the fact that the employee asked a senior member of staff and didn’t get reminded of a policy that we don’t even know if exists and just approved would mean a discussion with the manager. Not the employee.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 20/03/2023 11:56

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

  1. Then her boss shouldn't have approved it
  2. The school changed the plan on the morning of the strike so even less time to sort something.
  3. People don't need any reason to take an approved day off - exhausted or not.
Haraebo · 20/03/2023 11:54

DIYpanda · 20/03/2023 11:48

I don't see why you needed Friday off as you had holiday Thursday

Er maybe because slavery was abolished in this country in the 1800's ????

This comment is disgusting. I hope MN remove it.

So offensive. And also VERY untrue. I've dealt with two modern slavery cases in the past 6 months.

fruitbrewhaha · 20/03/2023 11:54

Some companies as part of the ts & cs give a certain amount of 'duvet days' which are annual leave you can book off at the last minute because you are knackered. It's a good policy because if someone is knackered and cba they may as well not be in work mooching about getting paid for doing nothing much. However they do normally stipulate that you cant do this is there's an important deadline or that you cant cancel something /someone vital. But many companies do not have this option and will need x amount of notice prior to annual leave being booked.

Presumably you got into work to find an email saying "we gave you the annual leave without notice last week as a one off, please follow procedure in future". It's no big deal. The thursday you needed off, the friday you didn't. It's nothing to do with them that you have a second job.

QWERTTY · 20/03/2023 11:54

Sqqueeeeeeee · 20/03/2023 11:49

You’re right, I stupidly assumed that the OP was the truth. We have absolutely no idea what OP’s employer are annoyed about because she might be lying when she told us.

She hasn’t stated what is in her contract. She said they’re annoyed that she booked and had time off. She said ‘yes it may have been short notice’ - that doesn’t say ‘they’re annoyed purely because it’s short notice’.

And being rude doesn’t elevate you above others by the way.

ThatsGoingToHurt · 20/03/2023 11:53

If you discussed with you manager beforehand and they approved it I don’t see what’s the problem.

ReneBumsWombats · 20/03/2023 11:52

I don't understand why it's an issue. Whoever has the authority to approve the leave approved it; once that's done, preferences for notice etc don't matter.

This just cements my feeling that HR are evil and you should never trust them.

BumpySkull · 20/03/2023 11:51

DIYpanda · 20/03/2023 11:48

I don't see why you needed Friday off as you had holiday Thursday

Er maybe because slavery was abolished in this country in the 1800's ????

Having a paid job is not slavery and your comment is both ridiculous and incredibly offensive to the victims of modern day slavery. Having to go to work after a day off with your children is not slavery.

Chickenly · 20/03/2023 11:50

CountZacular · 20/03/2023 11:48

It still doesn’t matter. The manager allowed it. The system allowed it. The manager needs better training to turn down requests if they can’t be made at short notice. But thats also your conjecture too. I’ve always been allowed to request leave whenever the hell I want - it’s up to the manager to approve or not and if notice wasn’t sufficient that manager should have said no.

This is 100% a management issue IF it even is an issue and not just an uppity HR officer.

How are people not getting this? @Sqqueeeeeeee could not have been clearer.

freetheunicorn1 · 20/03/2023 11:49

Skyblue81 · 20/03/2023 11:18

Thanks all for your responses. Exhausted because I work 2 jobs, have 3 young children and am essentially a solo parent as my OH works away. Surely any parent of young children knows how exhausting it can get at times??

Really disappointed to have come on here looking for support, only for people to respond with sarcasm and unkind comments. Hope your comments made you feel big and clever.

You never asked for support you asked AIBU so people are entitled to say yes.

FWIW if you spoke to your line manager and they approved it then I think the HR involvement is crappy.

Sqqueeeeeeee · 20/03/2023 11:49

QWERTTY · 20/03/2023 11:48

It’s not that simple, stop being condescending and acting like you’re smarter than the rest of us.

You don’t know that because the OP hasn’t given us all the facts about her contract, so you have zero clue what the policy is or why HR are pissed off.

m but feel free to say nothing else because you’re adding nothing to the debate at this point.

You’re right, I stupidly assumed that the OP was the truth. We have absolutely no idea what OP’s employer are annoyed about because she might be lying when she told us.

CountZacular · 20/03/2023 11:48

Sqqueeeeeeee · 20/03/2023 11:44

It doesn’t sound like HR are annoyed it was approved - they’re annoyed that it was requested late. Not sure why people are struggling with this concept so much. Just because it was approved doesn’t mean that OP was reasonable to request it at the last minute.

It still doesn’t matter. The manager allowed it. The system allowed it. The manager needs better training to turn down requests if they can’t be made at short notice. But thats also your conjecture too. I’ve always been allowed to request leave whenever the hell I want - it’s up to the manager to approve or not and if notice wasn’t sufficient that manager should have said no.

This is 100% a management issue IF it even is an issue and not just an uppity HR officer.

DIYpanda · 20/03/2023 11:48

ChickenDhansak82 · 20/03/2023 10:49

YABU.
It was annoying that the school shut at the last minute, but that's the whole point of strikes - it's inconvenient.

You need to give more than 20 hours notice to take holiday. Although you worked from home on the Wednesday, you should have contacted HR and requested emergency dependent leave for the Thursday.

I don't see why you needed Friday off as you had holiday Thursday and surely looking after your own kids doesn't need a day to recover?!

I don't see why you needed Friday off as you had holiday Thursday

Er maybe because slavery was abolished in this country in the 1800's ????

Swipe left for the next trending thread