Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Got "told off"- annual leave for teachers strike

283 replies

Skyblue81 · 20/03/2023 10:31

Feeling confused. AIBU??

Got 3 kids. Teachers were on strike last Weds & Thurs. School said it would remain open, but changed their minds Weds morning.

I worked from home on Weds with all 3 kids at home. It was exhausting, so I then put in for 2 days annual leave for Thursday (teachers strike) and Friday (to recover from my exhaustion).

Got back to work today to an HR call where I basically got told off for submitting and then taking leave!!!!! Yes OK I didn't give loads of notice, but then neither did my school.

Feeling really beaten-down by my workplace. I work hard, and have earned that annual leave. I took it to take care of my children, then have a recovery day. FFS it's not like I went on a bender to Ibiza!

AIBU???

OP posts:
ScramblePud · 20/03/2023 13:37

Everanewbie · 20/03/2023 13:35

I see what you're saying, but OPs boss approved the leave, seemingly without any argument. Her boss, on the face of things, looks like the kind of boss that we all deserve that looks at things holistically rather than stick rigidly to a policy dreamt up by some HR consultancy who's cookie cutter templated document was adopted by OP's firm. The manager made a call that on this occasion the OP's circumstances and well being outweighed some jobsworths' clipboard.

Absolutely. And it’s HR’s job to be the bad guy and point out the rules so that, next strike day, every parent in the team isn’t asking to take a full week off at the last minute just because OP took an extra day this time and got away with it.

Chickenly · 20/03/2023 13:35

PsychoCandy23 · 20/03/2023 13:31

I really wouldn’t care. People do it everyday. Illegal is a strong word. No one’s prosecuted. If one were a repeat offender, they’d be out of a job presumably. Remind me why it is you’re not working currently? And why is it you’ve taken such a strong dislike to a complete stranger on the interwebs? Could the two be linked?

You’re not an employer. Of course you wouldn’t care. You’re not the one it’s being done to. Things aren’t allowed in law because @PsychoCandy23 doesn’t mind people doing them.

You can’t be prosecuted for violating contract law. That’s not possible in our legal system. That kind of comment is why your input is so infuriating to read. Jesus Christ.

I am working, thanks. Why aren’t you looking after your relative? I don’t dislike you. You started this, did you forget that? You responded to me rudely and you kicked off.

Everanewbie · 20/03/2023 13:35

ScramblePud · 20/03/2023 13:23

Or, more reasonably, people requesting to take annual leave giving significantly less notice than they should give should only do so when they have a valid reason for giving significantly less notice than they should give.

It’s not about why she took annual leave, it’s about why she gave almost no notice. Almost no notice for unavoidable things is reasonable. Almost no notice for unnecessary things isn’t reasonable. They approved it because they were being a good employer, they’ve simply reminded OP to be a good employee in future. They could’ve said no, they chose to be better than that.

I see what you're saying, but OPs boss approved the leave, seemingly without any argument. Her boss, on the face of things, looks like the kind of boss that we all deserve that looks at things holistically rather than stick rigidly to a policy dreamt up by some HR consultancy who's cookie cutter templated document was adopted by OP's firm. The manager made a call that on this occasion the OP's circumstances and well being outweighed some jobsworths' clipboard.

Dibbydoos · 20/03/2023 13:34

Uanbu.

You could have taken it without pay using flexible working arrangements under carers responsibilities, obvs they could have said NO but presume meetings etc were covered, so what harm has been done?

Rosscameasdoody · 20/03/2023 13:34

ScramblePud · 20/03/2023 13:23

Or, more reasonably, people requesting to take annual leave giving significantly less notice than they should give should only do so when they have a valid reason for giving significantly less notice than they should give.

It’s not about why she took annual leave, it’s about why she gave almost no notice. Almost no notice for unavoidable things is reasonable. Almost no notice for unnecessary things isn’t reasonable. They approved it because they were being a good employer, they’ve simply reminded OP to be a good employee in future. They could’ve said no, they chose to be better than that.

Well no, not really. It wasn’t the OP being less than a ‘good employee’. What else was she supposed to do ? In the event they had refused annual leave, she would have been entitled to dependants’ leave to deal with the issue created by the decision to close.

PsychoCandy23 · 20/03/2023 13:31

Chickenly · 20/03/2023 13:25

And you then wouldn’t accept that it would’ve been illegal for her to do that.

I really wouldn’t care. People do it everyday. Illegal is a strong word. No one’s prosecuted. If one were a repeat offender, they’d be out of a job presumably. Remind me why it is you’re not working currently? And why is it you’ve taken such a strong dislike to a complete stranger on the interwebs? Could the two be linked?

RedToothBrush · 20/03/2023 13:30

ScramblePud · 20/03/2023 13:23

Or, more reasonably, people requesting to take annual leave giving significantly less notice than they should give should only do so when they have a valid reason for giving significantly less notice than they should give.

It’s not about why she took annual leave, it’s about why she gave almost no notice. Almost no notice for unavoidable things is reasonable. Almost no notice for unnecessary things isn’t reasonable. They approved it because they were being a good employer, they’ve simply reminded OP to be a good employee in future. They could’ve said no, they chose to be better than that.

Yep indeed.

OP: "I need emergency leave for tomorrow and Friday because of the strike"
Line Manager: "Ok that's reasonable. I approve it"
OP: "Cheers thanks"

HR: "Oh on what grounds did you give leave? We need a week to ensure cover / that payroll don't muck it up. This was only given with a day's notice"
Line Manager: "Oh it was for a legitimate reason. There's a teacher strike"
HR: "No this isn't legitimate. It's piss taking. The strike is Wednesday/ Thursday but she's taking Friday. She going on a jolly and trying to use this as an excuse to fool us into thinking it's a legitimate reason for emergency leave. Now we will have to review procedure over granting emergency leave cos someone is trying to pull a fast one"

OP: "It's so UNFAIR that HR spoke to me over taking emergency leave for a day I didn't need emergency leave for. Wah wah wah".

Doesthepopeshitinthewoods · 20/03/2023 13:30

Jesus, some posters must be hired this morning to get starting little squabbles with others over someone else’s annual leave. Christ. 🐔

ScramblePud · 20/03/2023 13:29

PsychoCandy23 · 20/03/2023 13:25

Good point. And well made.

Thank you. Given how combative you’ve been on the thread so far I’m shocked you agree.

JackHackettsMac · 20/03/2023 13:27

@Skyblue81

Sounds pretty shitty of HR to chastise you and I think you need to bat it back and make it clear that Leave was approved by your Line Manager so they need to take the matter up with her, if there’s an issue. Then forget about it.

However, YABU to post anything in AIBU when you need support. Post in Chat or a specific (Employment) Board would be much better and you’d get more helpful responses. AIBU is over-populated by a selection of arseholes who look for opportunities to have a go at anyone, because in RL they’re saddos with no friends. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Everanewbie · 20/03/2023 13:26

RedToothBrush · 20/03/2023 13:13

YABU.

Fair enough annual leave for strike.

Booking off Friday citing exhaustion at short notice like this is taking the piss.

You are using the strike as an excuse.

This effects anyone who took the day off for the actual strike, because it causes resentment with other employees.

You did not need Friday off. You wanted it off. And then hide behind the excuse of the strikes to legitimise the short notice and because it would be harder to say no to.

Respectfully, this is rubbish. She asked her boss, and her boss considered every point you've made, workload, fairness and so on an APPROVED her leave. It was her managers job to decide whether to grant holiday, and she decided she could and therefore, would. HR are just sticking their oar in because they have nothing better to do than go round shouting "the policy, the policy" like some stupid jobsworth, Yeah, well, take it up with OP's manager, not OP's problem.

PsychoCandy23 · 20/03/2023 13:25

ScramblePud · 20/03/2023 13:23

Or, more reasonably, people requesting to take annual leave giving significantly less notice than they should give should only do so when they have a valid reason for giving significantly less notice than they should give.

It’s not about why she took annual leave, it’s about why she gave almost no notice. Almost no notice for unavoidable things is reasonable. Almost no notice for unnecessary things isn’t reasonable. They approved it because they were being a good employer, they’ve simply reminded OP to be a good employee in future. They could’ve said no, they chose to be better than that.

Good point. And well made.

Chickenly · 20/03/2023 13:25

PsychoCandy23 · 20/03/2023 13:24

I didn’t. I said she ‘could’ have called in sick. Fact.

And you then wouldn’t accept that it would’ve been illegal for her to do that.

PsychoCandy23 · 20/03/2023 13:24

Chickenly · 20/03/2023 13:19

You said exactly that. You said OP should have called in sick and then thought it was hysterical that you can’t call in sick when you’re not sick.

OP asked if she was being unreasonable to be upset that HR asked her to follow the rules. I think she’s being unreasonable. You started being sarcastic and rude (and incorrect to boot) so don’t try to pretend you’re taking the moral high ground.

I didn’t. I said she ‘could’ have called in sick. Fact.

ScramblePud · 20/03/2023 13:23

PsychoCandy23 · 20/03/2023 13:20

Agree. People taking accrued leave should always be required to tell their employers exactly what they intend to do with every single second of their company’s precious time. In my day, we got two hours off on the sabbath. Plenty enough time for church, conception, a pint and a strip wash. Then it were straight down pit again. Until you got lung disease and died. But we were right ‘appy. Got any Hovis?

Or, more reasonably, people requesting to take annual leave giving significantly less notice than they should give should only do so when they have a valid reason for giving significantly less notice than they should give.

It’s not about why she took annual leave, it’s about why she gave almost no notice. Almost no notice for unavoidable things is reasonable. Almost no notice for unnecessary things isn’t reasonable. They approved it because they were being a good employer, they’ve simply reminded OP to be a good employee in future. They could’ve said no, they chose to be better than that.

PsychoCandy23 · 20/03/2023 13:20

RedToothBrush · 20/03/2023 13:13

YABU.

Fair enough annual leave for strike.

Booking off Friday citing exhaustion at short notice like this is taking the piss.

You are using the strike as an excuse.

This effects anyone who took the day off for the actual strike, because it causes resentment with other employees.

You did not need Friday off. You wanted it off. And then hide behind the excuse of the strikes to legitimise the short notice and because it would be harder to say no to.

Agree. People taking accrued leave should always be required to tell their employers exactly what they intend to do with every single second of their company’s precious time. In my day, we got two hours off on the sabbath. Plenty enough time for church, conception, a pint and a strip wash. Then it were straight down pit again. Until you got lung disease and died. But we were right ‘appy. Got any Hovis?

Chickenly · 20/03/2023 13:19

PsychoCandy23 · 20/03/2023 13:03

I have never suggested anything of the sort. And I explained that I’m taking a sabbatical with the support of HR. I don’t think it’s necessary for you to explain why you are unable to work currently. It’s fairly self evident. The OP asked if they were unreasonable to be vexed by their employment circumstances surrounding a specific incident. I think they have every reason to feel aggrieved. You disagree. Which is fine. But the vitriol is really not needed. Hope this helps!

You said exactly that. You said OP should have called in sick and then thought it was hysterical that you can’t call in sick when you’re not sick.

OP asked if she was being unreasonable to be upset that HR asked her to follow the rules. I think she’s being unreasonable. You started being sarcastic and rude (and incorrect to boot) so don’t try to pretend you’re taking the moral high ground.

Rosecoffeecup · 20/03/2023 13:19

Given your manager approved it I'd be expecting them to back you up here. Are HR aware that it was approved prior to being taken? If they're unhappy it should be with your manager, not you

dontgobaconmyheart · 20/03/2023 13:18

What did HR actually say though, OP. Was it that they said you have done something directly wrong or that you may have felt chastised but the wording doesn't reflect that.

I think for a non emergency reason you were very fortunate that your line manager approved leave with such limited notice. I can't imagine a lot of employers doing the same. YANBU to take it leave that was approved by your line manager but as for the HR conversation who can say, of nobody knows what the wording and purpose actually was.

The situation sounds difficult but ultimately you needed the leave and were grantes ir. If HR spoke to you incorrectly then presumably that can be easily dealt with and apologised for.

Rosscameasdoody · 20/03/2023 13:17

user1496146479 · 20/03/2023 13:12

Oh come on! You don't need to give 20 hrs notice for holidays! Maybe in your job, but other policies & guidelines exist!!

OP discussed it with her manager and her manager approved it!

YANBU OP

Statutory obligations are a lot longer than 20 hours notice for holidays. It’s mostly up to individual employer policies, but where none exist, the statutory obligation is the back up.

Rosscameasdoody · 20/03/2023 13:14

GoodChat · 20/03/2023 12:32

Then statutory rules apply and you should be giving 2x the length of leave notice. So, for a week off, you should give two weeks notice.

Nope.

Er, yep, ‘fraid so. Under Working Time Regulations 1998, where there is no alternative contractual agreement on notice of annual leave, an employee is required to give two days notice for every one day of leave requested, plus one day. So for one week’s leave of five working days, you would need to give eleven days notice. If an employer refuses annual leave, they must give as many days notice of refusal, as have been requested as annual leave.

user1496146479 · 20/03/2023 13:13

justpoppingtotheshops · 20/03/2023 11:10

Your title is misleading - you didn't just take annual leave for the teachers strike you took another one off for "exhaustion" 😳 are you in the middle of a big project or something where had you submitted a request at any other time it would have been refused? to be honest whilst I wouldn't have rung you about it afterwards I'd be a bit bemused why you needed the Friday off to "recover" - how many children do you have??

So what???
Doesn't matter why or how much AL the OP took, her manager approved it!!

RedToothBrush · 20/03/2023 13:13

YABU.

Fair enough annual leave for strike.

Booking off Friday citing exhaustion at short notice like this is taking the piss.

You are using the strike as an excuse.

This effects anyone who took the day off for the actual strike, because it causes resentment with other employees.

You did not need Friday off. You wanted it off. And then hide behind the excuse of the strikes to legitimise the short notice and because it would be harder to say no to.

user1496146479 · 20/03/2023 13:12

ChickenDhansak82 · 20/03/2023 10:49

YABU.
It was annoying that the school shut at the last minute, but that's the whole point of strikes - it's inconvenient.

You need to give more than 20 hours notice to take holiday. Although you worked from home on the Wednesday, you should have contacted HR and requested emergency dependent leave for the Thursday.

I don't see why you needed Friday off as you had holiday Thursday and surely looking after your own kids doesn't need a day to recover?!

Oh come on! You don't need to give 20 hrs notice for holidays! Maybe in your job, but other policies & guidelines exist!!

OP discussed it with her manager and her manager approved it!

YANBU OP

plantingandpotting · 20/03/2023 13:12

Most last minute leave requests are at the manager's discretion. Only they can assess any impact on operations and make an informed decision.

I'd loop my manager into the conversation and ask for clarification of their leave policy, as your manager approved it and had every right to decline.

HR flexing needlessly like this is so irritating when you're an otherwise hard worker, OP.

Swipe left for the next trending thread