Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Got "told off"- annual leave for teachers strike

283 replies

Skyblue81 · 20/03/2023 10:31

Feeling confused. AIBU??

Got 3 kids. Teachers were on strike last Weds & Thurs. School said it would remain open, but changed their minds Weds morning.

I worked from home on Weds with all 3 kids at home. It was exhausting, so I then put in for 2 days annual leave for Thursday (teachers strike) and Friday (to recover from my exhaustion).

Got back to work today to an HR call where I basically got told off for submitting and then taking leave!!!!! Yes OK I didn't give loads of notice, but then neither did my school.

Feeling really beaten-down by my workplace. I work hard, and have earned that annual leave. I took it to take care of my children, then have a recovery day. FFS it's not like I went on a bender to Ibiza!

AIBU???

OP posts:
PsychoCandy23 · 20/03/2023 14:38

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Your entire second paragraph? It’s just made up, isn’t it? Genuinely, I hope you’re okay.

Ffsmakeitstop · 20/03/2023 14:38

Really disappointed to have come on here looking for support, only for people to respond with sarcasm and unkind comments. Hope your comments made you feel big and clever.

Welcome to the new and improved version of Mumsnet where 30% are trolls, 50% are horrible bitches and if you're lucky 20% are helpful and supportive.

Anyway if your manager authorised your leave who is complaining after the fact? You're not wrong life is very hard at the moment for lots of us. I hope you are rested and better able to cope.

Canthave2manycats · 20/03/2023 14:37

Skyblue81 · 20/03/2023 10:48

Thanks all. Yes I told my line manager. Yes I logged the request on the HR system. Yes it was approved before I took it.

That's why I'm pretty pissed off to return to work today and be chastised for it! Just feeling really deflated as I feel like you're damned if you do, and damned if you don't. It's so hard trying to work when you have family commitments :(

Never mind the sanctinmonious twatty twats. They just sit in cyberland like vultures waiting to put someone down.

Speak to your line manager about this. You went through the correct procedures and the leave was approved. It's no business of HR to reprimand you - you don't work for them. The decision is with your line manager as that is who you report to; if it was an issue then it was for him/her to raise with you. You should have refused to discuss it with jumped up administrator ad referred them to your manager.

It's hard working with 3 young children - been there, and my managers at the time were reasonable. Dread to think if it was now with the pricks I'm forced to report to these days!!

As a one-off I don't see the problem with working from home in an emergency. We don't all have alternative childcare on tap.

It's really disheartening. No wonder employees take sick leave in situations like this when you're treated like this for being honest.

PsychoCandy23 · 20/03/2023 14:36

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

nuttynet · 20/03/2023 14:36

To be fair, you could have pre-empted the strikes by booking leave in advance and being more prepared

You were warned it would probably happen

But then maybe next time you can just call in sick

Chickenly · 20/03/2023 14:32

PsychoCandy23 · 20/03/2023 14:19

I don’t know. I didn’t report it. My hide is several metres thick. And even I was astonished by the vitriol. Didn’t get the reference either. So a double fail. Chalk it up to experience and move on. Hope this helps!

It wasn’t vitriol, it wasn’t even an insult. If your hide were so thick you wouldn’t have responded with such horror - and if you didn’t understand the reference then I’m unsure why you were so deathly offended and certain that you’d been insulted.

“She said I was like a character in a film I’ve never heard of and I was so shocked by the vitriol that I was completely unable to put together a coherent sentence”. Sound like someone with a thick skin to you?

Chickenly · 20/03/2023 14:28

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I’m not to respond in kind to your Wilkie Collins jibe as I’m sure you’ll find a reason why my comment should be removed and use that to convince yourself that you’ve been a delight to engage with.

You have such a poor understanding of the law that you implied it’s a-ok as long as you can’t be prosecuted. You’ve used the word “discrimination” incorrectly on multiple occasions. You’ve said you didn’t realise you shouldn’t call in sick unless you’re sick. The fact is, you’re giving OP factually incorrect advice and then acted like people are completely out of order for saying you’re wrong on the facts. Further to that, you’ve tried to correct people giving factually correct advice with comments that are incorrect. The only person getting irate is you.

You’re entitled to whatever opinion you like but it’s flatly not true to say this is discrimination and it’s flatly not true to say she could’ve called in sick (and not been in breach of contract to do so).

Not sure what your long ramble was intended to communicate to be honest. OP’s employer is fully entitled to expect OP follow the rules like everyone else even if you wouldn’t expect your employees too (even though you’re not an employer and don’t have employees). You have no idea how OP being off work impacted output so not sure why you’re commenting on it.

PsychoCandy23 · 20/03/2023 14:27

LemonTT · 20/03/2023 14:20

I’ve approved annual leave and then spoken to people about the way they have planned and requested it. It is not telling them off but explaining that it was exceptional and future requests need to follow protocol. However, this is when individuals have really messed up their leave and are causing problems with cover. I wouldn’t involve HR and I would just speak to the person directly as adult to adult in the first instance.

IMO Taking leave with little or no notice requires a conversation with a manager not an online request. That could have resulted in the manager explaining entitlement to time off during the strike but that the late booked AL was inconvenient.

This. Perfectly put.

on reflection, I’ve had to have those conversations too after approving leave. But wouldn’t then run to HR.

this is actually a weak line management issue.

Probably because the poor line manager has been got at.

LemonTT · 20/03/2023 14:20

I’ve approved annual leave and then spoken to people about the way they have planned and requested it. It is not telling them off but explaining that it was exceptional and future requests need to follow protocol. However, this is when individuals have really messed up their leave and are causing problems with cover. I wouldn’t involve HR and I would just speak to the person directly as adult to adult in the first instance.

IMO Taking leave with little or no notice requires a conversation with a manager not an online request. That could have resulted in the manager explaining entitlement to time off during the strike but that the late booked AL was inconvenient.

PsychoCandy23 · 20/03/2023 14:19

Chickenly · 20/03/2023 14:00

The post removed said that using the phrase “me thinks” sounds like the Head Girl from Wild Child and isn’t an indication that you understand employment law. How on earth is that breaking talk guidelines? 😂

I don’t know. I didn’t report it. My hide is several metres thick. And even I was astonished by the vitriol. Didn’t get the reference either. So a double fail. Chalk it up to experience and move on. Hope this helps!

PsychoCandy23 · 20/03/2023 14:13

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Eleganz · 20/03/2023 14:12

ScramblePud · 20/03/2023 13:55

@Eleganz @ChocSaltyBalls I disagree. From HR’s perspective, they don’t want the managers to turn down last minute annual leave requests - they want employees to only make those requests when absolutely necessary. So, they don’t achieve that through telling managers, they do that through telling employees not to make the unnecessary requests. If they ask managers to only approve the reasonable requests then it’s too late - employees are already in a sticky situation and there’s unnecessary stress and hostility. The aim of HR here is to be the big bad wolf so that relationships don’t sour between the OP and their manager.

As a line manager I completely disagree. This is HR overstepping and interfering on how I manage my team. I am the manager, not them.

If they need to remind managers about policy that is fine, if they need to change policy that this also fine, but telling staff that they should not submit last minute leave requests because it puts line managers in difficult situations is both a) an unrealistic situation, b) directly undermines their managers by implying that they are not able to manage effectively.

Behaving in the way you suggest is a good way for HR to alienate itself from line managers.

Lovelynondriver · 20/03/2023 14:05

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Aye the only person who looks like the idiot here, is you! What a ridiculous comment.

GoodChat · 20/03/2023 14:03

Chickenly · 20/03/2023 14:00

The post removed said that using the phrase “me thinks” sounds like the Head Girl from Wild Child and isn’t an indication that you understand employment law. How on earth is that breaking talk guidelines? 😂

I'd guess it's seen as a personal attack. There are some strange decisions made over what goes and what stays Grin

Lovelynondriver · 20/03/2023 14:02

Awful isn't it OP

You're dammed if you and you're damned if you don't on here!

Cuntbadgers everywhere. The scary thing is - theyre allowed to vote 😂 x

Chickenly · 20/03/2023 14:00

The post removed said that using the phrase “me thinks” sounds like the Head Girl from Wild Child and isn’t an indication that you understand employment law. How on earth is that breaking talk guidelines? 😂

Chickenly · 20/03/2023 13:57

PsychoCandy23 · 20/03/2023 13:53

Seriously, have you got me confused with someone else? I haven’t been at all abusive or ‘kicked off’? I didn’t report the post you made which was removed, by the way. That was a personal attack. Presumably, that’s why it was deleted. In accordance with the rules. My relative is with a physio currently. Thanks for asking. I’m on unpaid sabbatical. They will have me back when I am able/ready to return. They’re actually just really supportive. Which is tremendous. I have been a hiring manager for a long time. And I don’t give two hoots if a valued employee needs time off for any reason. I grant leave as and when. And I have/sort of have a team with a very low absence rate. I would never allow a member of my staff to be admonished for taking approved leave. I would be very cross if an employee was spending my time spouting vitriolic bile on Mumsnet though. Or is unlimited personal internet use part of your contract?

I didn’t see anything that was removed. I haven’t confused you with anyone else at all. Nothing I’ve said broke any rules so I have no idea why any of it would be removed. I’d be very concerned if a hiring manager I worked with had no understand at all of contract law and kept making wildly ignorant statements when giving advice.

ScramblePud · 20/03/2023 13:55

@Eleganz @ChocSaltyBalls I disagree. From HR’s perspective, they don’t want the managers to turn down last minute annual leave requests - they want employees to only make those requests when absolutely necessary. So, they don’t achieve that through telling managers, they do that through telling employees not to make the unnecessary requests. If they ask managers to only approve the reasonable requests then it’s too late - employees are already in a sticky situation and there’s unnecessary stress and hostility. The aim of HR here is to be the big bad wolf so that relationships don’t sour between the OP and their manager.

PsychoCandy23 · 20/03/2023 13:53

Chickenly · 20/03/2023 13:35

You’re not an employer. Of course you wouldn’t care. You’re not the one it’s being done to. Things aren’t allowed in law because @PsychoCandy23 doesn’t mind people doing them.

You can’t be prosecuted for violating contract law. That’s not possible in our legal system. That kind of comment is why your input is so infuriating to read. Jesus Christ.

I am working, thanks. Why aren’t you looking after your relative? I don’t dislike you. You started this, did you forget that? You responded to me rudely and you kicked off.

Seriously, have you got me confused with someone else? I haven’t been at all abusive or ‘kicked off’? I didn’t report the post you made which was removed, by the way. That was a personal attack. Presumably, that’s why it was deleted. In accordance with the rules. My relative is with a physio currently. Thanks for asking. I’m on unpaid sabbatical. They will have me back when I am able/ready to return. They’re actually just really supportive. Which is tremendous. I have been a hiring manager for a long time. And I don’t give two hoots if a valued employee needs time off for any reason. I grant leave as and when. And I have/sort of have a team with a very low absence rate. I would never allow a member of my staff to be admonished for taking approved leave. I would be very cross if an employee was spending my time spouting vitriolic bile on Mumsnet though. Or is unlimited personal internet use part of your contract?

Zodfa · 20/03/2023 13:51

If the line manager makes a decision HR think they shouldn't have taken, then surely HR should be telling off the line manager, not the person they manage.

It's the manager's job to ensure leave requests are reasonable, not the person requesting them.

Eleganz · 20/03/2023 13:50

ScramblePud · 20/03/2023 13:37

Absolutely. And it’s HR’s job to be the bad guy and point out the rules so that, next strike day, every parent in the team isn’t asking to take a full week off at the last minute just because OP took an extra day this time and got away with it.

They should be pointing out to line managers then, rather than employees who have had line manager approval for leave. If I had approved leave for one of my team under exceptional circumstances and subsequently HR did not agree with my decision their problem would be with me, not with my team member.

ChocSaltyBalls · 20/03/2023 13:48

ScramblePud · 20/03/2023 13:37

Absolutely. And it’s HR’s job to be the bad guy and point out the rules so that, next strike day, every parent in the team isn’t asking to take a full week off at the last minute just because OP took an extra day this time and got away with it.

To the manager, not to the OP

isitjustmey · 20/03/2023 13:48

berksandbeyond · 20/03/2023 12:51

I do think the ‘day off to recover’ makes you sound a bit precious and wonder if that’s why you’ve been ‘told off’. It’s not your employers problem that you have 2 jobs, multiple young children and an absent husband

Oh stuff it! People are allowed to take annual leave for any reason.

ScramblePud · 20/03/2023 13:41

Rosscameasdoody · 20/03/2023 13:34

Well no, not really. It wasn’t the OP being less than a ‘good employee’. What else was she supposed to do ? In the event they had refused annual leave, she would have been entitled to dependants’ leave to deal with the issue created by the decision to close.

She could’ve worked on Friday. She could’ve looked into childcare options when the strikes were announced and she could’ve let her employer know weeks ago that she might be requesting annual leave at the last minute if the schools close. There were better ways she could have behaved - but who among us is perfect all the time? I’m not criticising, I’m just acknowledging she could have done better in the circumstances.

It’s not a big issue. She hasn’t been told off or sacked. They just don’t want it to become a habit (for OP or anyone else) so they’ve mentioned it. Unless OP is intending to do it repeatedly, there’s not a problem here.

GoodChat · 20/03/2023 13:40

To be fair if OP called in sick on the Friday because she wasn't feeling well enough to work if would've been a perfectly valid sick day.

Swipe left for the next trending thread