Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a break with my baby is ok?

58 replies

Dazedandconfused2023 · 20/03/2023 07:59

Appropriate name change here.
My husband and I had a falling out yesterday, we have three children 5 and under and he didn’t get me anything for Mother’s Day.
I got so upset, expressed enough for the baby for a couple of bottles and left him with the children to take myself out for a few hours. Came home later, having bought my own flowers, and didn’t speak to him.
I cooked myself and the children dinner and went to bed.

This morning I saw a texts he’d accidentally sent his Mum on the group message I am on too. He called me childish for not talking to him and not cooking his dinner. His Mum thinks I have post natal depression, what??!!!

Then I thought I might take myself near to my parents house with the baby (in an air bnb) in the Peak District for a few days just for a break. My other children would be in school / pre-school this week. I was thinking I may do this on maternity leave anyway. The drive is over 3 hours so not looking forward to it on my own with the baby…. But maternity leave boring, something to do, and let’s see how dh cracks on doing his own dinners for a few days!

Then…. My Dad phoned me and told me not to come, he said my place is with my children, to sort it out with dh, and not to come visit them?! He’s in his late 70’s.

What!!??? The break is because maternity leave is boring, to see them, give dh a kick up the bum etc. The kids will be fine as he’s mostly taken the lead with the other two anyway as I’ve had the baby.

AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Bertiesmum3 · 10/10/2023 17:51

Jezzzz, what a performance over a cake!
if it’s that important make one with your children yourself!

Dazedandconfused2023 · 23/03/2023 22:04

My reaction to stuff like that is always to take myself off. I take the time to calm down and also in this instance I didn’t want to shout or cry in front of the kids.

I was never going to storm off to the Peak District not having spoken to him but I did think the timing might serve to remind him exactly how much running around I do after everyone.

Just think my parents should have said “you’re welcome to come anytime, we’d love to see the baby. Just try and clear the air with DH first so it can be a relaxing holiday.” Or something like that.
I have accepted that’s not going to happen!

I should have known, I remember phoning home to tell them I was engaged. Mum was home alone and asked me to get DH to phone my Dad to ask for permission to marry me… then announce it. His other son in laws did… I thought it was more tradition and respect than misogyny. But my Dad is my Dad and in many ways has been a good one.

OP posts:
MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 20/03/2023 18:21

Your dad sounds awful, OP. Very sexist and not supportive at all.

I think you're being OTT about the mother's day stuff. I mean, yes, it was shit that your dh didn't get you anything and didn't even respond to your dd's suggestion by going out to buy a cake - I think you're entitled to be pissed off by this and to tell him that you are disappointed that he didn't make an effort. But to say that you're "distraught", to stop speaking to him for a few hours, and then to want to "punish" him by buggering off for a few days with the baby...sorry, but I think that's a massive overreaction. (Fine to go away on a preplanned trip - though in your case, I wouldn't go to your parents - but it's clear in this instance that you are doing it at least partly to get back at him, and I don't think that's OK.)

As a pp said, I think you need to work on your communication skills as you could have handled this better. You can then use those improved communication skills to make it clear to your dh that you expect him to make more effort, and that actually, it is a big deal to you even if it isn't to him.

Sceptre86 · 20/03/2023 17:59

I'm not sure why you are getting a hard time. On all the other posts about mothers day the advice is almost always, take yourself off, leave him to it with regards to the kids and when someone actually has the audacity to do it, oh the horror! I should be clear it is never the advice I would give, I disagree with it as I don't think it solves anything. I'm all for communicating and I'd just be direct and tell him why I was hurt. I'm starting to realise that most people don't take the most obvious or sensible approach though, not a dig at you just a general observation on the mother's day posts I've read.

I think it was incredibly juvenile of him telling his half arsed side of things to his mother and I would have been angry at that. Judging by your dad's message he told him too. I don't blame your dad for thinking that it is better for you to stay at home and sort the problems out.

Your text was a great response to his mother! This doesn't sound like a hill you'll die on your annoyed eventually he'll realise, apologise (hopefully) and you'll move on. Fair enough if this is your preferred way of handling things.

ElonsMusky · 20/03/2023 17:59

I haven't read the whole thread but my guess is the "falling out" started before mother's day. He either didn't get you anything bc you were already fighting ...OR he totally just forgot.

If the former is true, what do you expect?

If the latter is true then that really sucks but you're acting like a child isn't helping.

The only thing that works in a marriage is communication. So your dad is right....go talk to your husband.

I also think it's hilarious when some of my girlfriends talk about their husbands this way, like he can't make himself dinner. LOL...oh I'll show him by going away for a few days and laugh at how his universe collapses without me there to cook.

Do you both agree on you going away for a few days? He's ok with you spending the money of a little vacation for yourself? If so, great. If not, would you be ok with him doing the same?

Lordofthebutterfloofs · 20/03/2023 17:57

Urgh, a family group chat with your in laws where you air your dirty laundry?

PinkSyCo · 20/03/2023 17:50

I get that you’re upset but don’t take it out on your children. I’m sure they would all love to go to visit your parents. Don’t make the others feel left out just to spite your husband. 😞

urrrgh46 · 20/03/2023 17:26

tbh i'd just ltb now. and i say that as someone who's nearly 23yrs down the line with more children than you and has filed for divorce. he's showing you what he thinks of your contribution to the household...ie he doesn't value you or have the same values as you. Your father is appalling although i wouldn't leave a 3 & 5 yr old unless they were used to being left for overnights tbf

thedogsmum · 20/03/2023 12:51

Your dad is a misogynistic dinosaur, you're very patient to just roll your eyes at him. Why not go somewhere else with the baby for a couple of days - they're so portable when they're tiny.

Dazedandconfused2023 · 20/03/2023 12:49

MiddleParking · 20/03/2023 12:32

The people in their seventies of today have literally no excuse for thinking a woman’s place is at home with children, much less saying it. If he thinks that it’s because he’s a misogynist and was probably one all his life. Sounds like you’ve married one too, not getting you anything for Mother’s Day when you’ve got three young kids and at least one of them was excited about it is so poor.

Exactly!

Imagine if my reaction was so OTT because I did have PND and I asked my parents if I could visit them and they said no. It just makes my DF’s reaction worse doesn’t it. It could be the last straw hearing “your place is at home” if you reach out.

I wouldn’t like to leave my children at the weekend or for a long time but midweek is ok surely.DH works from home 9-5 so covered by school hours and childminder.

My one mum friend with 3 kids has similar ages and her DP was talking about going to Dubai for 3 months on a work secondment. She had told him to apply because she didn’t want him to resent her even though she knew it’d be a struggle without him (not least because her baby wakes up a lot).
Of course what they do is up to them but is anyone telling him his place is at home, nope!!

OP posts:
MiddleParking · 20/03/2023 12:32

The people in their seventies of today have literally no excuse for thinking a woman’s place is at home with children, much less saying it. If he thinks that it’s because he’s a misogynist and was probably one all his life. Sounds like you’ve married one too, not getting you anything for Mother’s Day when you’ve got three young kids and at least one of them was excited about it is so poor.

smashinggrapes · 20/03/2023 12:23

"I literally don’t do much apart here apart from lonely walks, feed the baby, get the baby to sleep…. Repeat…. Collect the other kids."

Well yeah, that's what happens when you have 3 kids under 5. You both sound childish and like you're competing for "time". You've chosen to have 3 kids, why leave them just to "punish" your husband? Does he only work school hours?

Newyeardietstartstomorrow · 20/03/2023 12:11

As an add on to my pp, which might have come across as harsh, the only times my dh and I fell out were when I was looking after a newborn. I was knackered, boobs hurt, felt like crap, and whilst I didn't have pnd my fuse was very short.

Newyeardietstartstomorrow · 20/03/2023 12:05

Look, you were entitled to tell your dh that it was crap of him not to do anything. When my dc were little they used to make things for me, which was lovely. Mothers day isn't about buying gifts, it's about doing something thoughtful when the children are little. You were being unreasonable though in turning it into a huge strop. Going out for the day and then arranging a break away with just your newborn as a punishment is a huge over reaction. Your mil wasn't unreasonable in asking if you had pnd, as I would have jumped to the same conclusion, and your df wasn't unreasonable in not facilitating you continuing the strop.

pinkunicorns54 · 20/03/2023 11:53

I can empathise with how you are feeling about Mother's Day ❤️. I had a feeling my DH hadn't planned / bought anything the day before - so mentioned it to him and that I'd like to do something and he planned a last minute day out.
I would have liked for him to have arranged something without being promoted, but if I hadn't mentioned anything we would have done nothing and I would have been pissed if (2yr old and 3month old here).

Your dad is being unreasonable and I would be sad about that 😩.

I'm also finding Mat leave very lonely and isolating this time round and that is with my first being born in lockdown! But I do also have PND. Meeting mums was easier the first time round!

Slimjimtobe · 20/03/2023 11:43

i think social media has a lot to answer for (though I’m totally on your side with this)

why people need to brag and boast on a public platform is beyond me

Dazedandconfused2023 · 20/03/2023 11:33

CheersForThatEh · 20/03/2023 11:29

Your dad is right. I'm sure you're welcome to plan a visit to see them but you shouldn't be running away to punish your husband by making him walk in your martyred shoes with the other children.

When you took your vows there was probably a bit in there about supporting you as a couple and your dad is doing that. Hes telling you not to run away from your marriage and to stay and fix the problem.

Just to be clear my Dad has said it before without an argument involved.
He has told me before my place is at home and not to come. My others dc’s are 3 years and 5 years and in the week they’re in preschool/school and childminders, phoned him today and he said a mothers place is at home and not to leave the kids with their father. So it’s not just the drive!

He’s nearly 80 so will just roll my eyes at him and crack on!

(FYI kept them at childminders after school because the childcare provision where I live is like gold dust. Don’t want to lose the space! I pick them up 4:30pm. If DH was here alone he’d pick them up at 5pm as he wfh.)

OP posts:
Ktime · 20/03/2023 11:31

Men and women travel for work and leave kids with their other parent.

People telling OP she must stay home with her 2 other children are sexist as fuck.

CheersForThatEh · 20/03/2023 11:29

Your dad is right. I'm sure you're welcome to plan a visit to see them but you shouldn't be running away to punish your husband by making him walk in your martyred shoes with the other children.

When you took your vows there was probably a bit in there about supporting you as a couple and your dad is doing that. Hes telling you not to run away from your marriage and to stay and fix the problem.

Dazedandconfused2023 · 20/03/2023 11:28

Wishawisha · 20/03/2023 11:14

This is the bit I was referring to, which I thought was childish. It’s the leaving and then not talking to your DH, which your children will have picked up on (not ideal surely?)

Came home later, having bought my own flowers, and didn’t speak to him.
I cooked myself and the children dinner and went to bed.

I wouldn’t say I’m team DH but I will say that if my DH had a strop about Father’s Day and left the house for the afternoon in a strop and came back and didn’t talk to me, I probably would have texted a close friend about him and it wouldn’t have been completely complimentary.

I don’t think women shouldn’t leave their children at all. Everyone needs a break. If you need a break, take a break. BUT I don’t think you should leave your children for a break BECAUSE you were upset about Mother’s Day and following an argument with the children’s father when you have been ignoring him. I don’t think that’s in their interests.

I’ve had time on my own when DH has taken the DC away. It’s great for everyone. I haven’t done it following an argument about something so silly though.

Maybe DH and I have an unusual relationship (quite possibly) but if I’d wanted a cake I would have told him I wanted a cake. Last year I decided I didn’t want a birthday present because there was nothing I particularly wanted but I made sure he knew what kind of cake I wanted. I didn’t get a present and I got the right kind of cake. When his birthday is coming up I ask him what he wants to get or do. I hate the idea of having to read between the lines.. someone is bound to get upset.

Yeah, they’re good points.
TBF… I didn’t want a cake it transpired my oldest DD wanted to get me a cake but she is 5, so DH would have had to do it and even though she asked him he didn’t.

On the not talking to him when I got home no I was still too upset but knew the baby would need feeding and my boobs would probably start leaking if I didn’t get back. I didn’t want to cry in front of the kids.

I grant you it’s a big reaction but all day was getting texts from my sisters what they were doing/presents they had got. Same on the class whatsapp, same on Instagram etc etc. and it did just basically make me feel like shit and upset the whole day. DD talking Mother’s Day up this year made me think he had actually worked with her to sort something!

It’s ok now had a chat about making expectations clear and phoned up DF to tell him the 1950’s are over!
I would really like to visit before maternity leave over in August because I find the weeks lonely and drag out. But I think I’ll leave it as parents obviously aren’t on board with me coming up just with the baby.

OP posts:
Viviennemary · 20/03/2023 11:27

You both need to grow up and talk about what you want from the relationship. All this fuss and upset from so many women about mothers day is beyond common sense. Having a strop and storming out isnt really on with young children.

Meandfour · 20/03/2023 11:25

PortiasBiscuit · 20/03/2023 08:10

Talk to your bloody husband. You have three kids, you owe it to them to stop acting like a pair of infants yourself.

Also, yes Mummy disappearing off with new baby, that’s not traumatising to an under five-year-old at all!

This. It’s sounds ridiculous and your dad is right; sort it out with your husband, at least for the sake of your young children instead of stropping off like a sulking teenager.

journeyofsanity · 20/03/2023 11:22

OP how long have you been on MN. Have you not realised that there are people on here that will take any opportunity to condemn you.

You sound very measured and balanced in your approach. These same people would call you toxic and abusive if you said you shouted. Ignore them.

Wishawisha · 20/03/2023 11:14

This is the bit I was referring to, which I thought was childish. It’s the leaving and then not talking to your DH, which your children will have picked up on (not ideal surely?)

Came home later, having bought my own flowers, and didn’t speak to him.
I cooked myself and the children dinner and went to bed.

I wouldn’t say I’m team DH but I will say that if my DH had a strop about Father’s Day and left the house for the afternoon in a strop and came back and didn’t talk to me, I probably would have texted a close friend about him and it wouldn’t have been completely complimentary.

I don’t think women shouldn’t leave their children at all. Everyone needs a break. If you need a break, take a break. BUT I don’t think you should leave your children for a break BECAUSE you were upset about Mother’s Day and following an argument with the children’s father when you have been ignoring him. I don’t think that’s in their interests.

I’ve had time on my own when DH has taken the DC away. It’s great for everyone. I haven’t done it following an argument about something so silly though.

Maybe DH and I have an unusual relationship (quite possibly) but if I’d wanted a cake I would have told him I wanted a cake. Last year I decided I didn’t want a birthday present because there was nothing I particularly wanted but I made sure he knew what kind of cake I wanted. I didn’t get a present and I got the right kind of cake. When his birthday is coming up I ask him what he wants to get or do. I hate the idea of having to read between the lines.. someone is bound to get upset.

albapunk · 20/03/2023 11:14

I think its absolutely fine to go away and visit family without taking DH and all DCs. I don't think it's okay to see it as a "punishment" and make DH realise how much you do for him.

Mothers Day is a very minor holiday. I'm sorry your expectations weren't met, but there is obviously huge communication issues going on that need to be resolved. Your DF sounds old fashioned, and MIL sounds like she may be concerned, DH is allowed to chat to his Mum about things, as long as he then discusses any issues and concerns with you too.

Swipe left for the next trending thread