Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Preferred pronoun labels at childrens event

730 replies

StopitSarah · 19/03/2023 20:21

I took my primary age children to a science event this weekend. It’s run by university students. Almost all of them had their preferred pronouns on their name labels.

AIBU to feel that was unnecessary and to feel a bit uneasy? One of my children wanted to know why “the man is saying we should say he/him. Isn’t that obvious?”

I asked one of the students who said it was to show support to any trans helpers and was for the benefit of the (adult) students, not the children.

I’m SO BORED and irritated by the trans agenda being every-bloody-where.

But AIBU? I had a good chat with one of the students and he said that they’re all science students and understand that woman = biological female is too simplistic. My brain exploded.

OP posts:
CountZacular · 21/03/2023 10:53

justteanbiscuits · 21/03/2023 10:43

As yesterday, I am still blown away by so many of you simply not caring that someone who has shared their experience of being misgendered and saying it made them uncomfortable. (it happened to be a lot as a teen. Short haired female, small busted, in jeans and tshirt in a mainly male workplace, with a name that could be construed as either gender, and YES, it was upsetting. I was also, twice, quite seriously misgendered which now a days would have led to a safeguarding enquiry as it put me at risk - both times led to me having to share bedrooms with boys when I was under 18. Once before I was working, on a school trip when I was under 16).

Why are YOUR feelings about having pronouns on badges more important than someone's actual experiences of being misgendered?? Why are you claiming people are lying just because their real life experience doesn't match your, obviously narrow, life experiences?? Rather than having a pronoun on a badge, you think people should simply dress to your feminine standards??

I have already said wear a badge if you want but don’t compel others. I’d say it’s similar to wearing a crucifix. It’s your personal choice but shouldn’t mean others need to show their support for your religion by also wearing one.

I’ve also asked posters what happens in the general public - you know, like the supermarket and taking public transport? If it’s happening at least 3 times at one event (as a poster had said) it must be happening all the time? So how do you deal with it in the general public?

Apologies if I missed this, but has someone actually told you to wear more feminine clothing? Presumably you are aware that many, many women prefer jeans and hoodies and aren’t misgendered because of it so I can’t see what difference that would make.

FrostyFifi · 21/03/2023 10:51

Rather than having a pronoun on a badge, you think people should simply dress to your feminine standards??

Quite the opposite. People should be able to wear whatever the hell they want. I must admit I'd slightly confused as to why someone would both be happy to dress in a less feminine way and also upset at being "misgendered". I honestly wouldn't care.

CremeEggQueen · 21/03/2023 10:49

It's just another way of policing women's looks dressed up as "feminism."
In quotes as that's really not feminism.

CremeEggQueen · 21/03/2023 10:47

justteanbiscuits · 21/03/2023 10:43

As yesterday, I am still blown away by so many of you simply not caring that someone who has shared their experience of being misgendered and saying it made them uncomfortable. (it happened to be a lot as a teen. Short haired female, small busted, in jeans and tshirt in a mainly male workplace, with a name that could be construed as either gender, and YES, it was upsetting. I was also, twice, quite seriously misgendered which now a days would have led to a safeguarding enquiry as it put me at risk - both times led to me having to share bedrooms with boys when I was under 18. Once before I was working, on a school trip when I was under 16).

Why are YOUR feelings about having pronouns on badges more important than someone's actual experiences of being misgendered?? Why are you claiming people are lying just because their real life experience doesn't match your, obviously narrow, life experiences?? Rather than having a pronoun on a badge, you think people should simply dress to your feminine standards??

Well said.
It seems its fine for some women to feel uncomfortable as they dont fit feminine standards, but not for women who just don't want to use pronouns as they feel "can't make me" - and if you aren't a feminine enough woman, tough shit what do you expect going around like a bloke?! 🙄

justteanbiscuits · 21/03/2023 10:43

As yesterday, I am still blown away by so many of you simply not caring that someone who has shared their experience of being misgendered and saying it made them uncomfortable. (it happened to be a lot as a teen. Short haired female, small busted, in jeans and tshirt in a mainly male workplace, with a name that could be construed as either gender, and YES, it was upsetting. I was also, twice, quite seriously misgendered which now a days would have led to a safeguarding enquiry as it put me at risk - both times led to me having to share bedrooms with boys when I was under 18. Once before I was working, on a school trip when I was under 16).

Why are YOUR feelings about having pronouns on badges more important than someone's actual experiences of being misgendered?? Why are you claiming people are lying just because their real life experience doesn't match your, obviously narrow, life experiences?? Rather than having a pronoun on a badge, you think people should simply dress to your feminine standards??

lifeturnsonadime · 21/03/2023 08:16

My eldest is often mistaken for a boy because she likes joggers & dark colours and she prefers short hair. I have noticed lately sometimes even if I correct people they keep using male pronouns. I had worked on the assumption they just forgot but if people think like you maybe I should consider the possibility they are just being dicks about it 🤷🏼‍♀️

Yes so does my daughter.

She's autistic CAMHS even asked questioned her gender identity, which was interesting to say the least.

But she's not bothered. She's herself. Girls can wear and do what they want. If a person misgenders my daughter it really doesn't ruin her day. But yes it tends to happen less now she's hit puberty, her body shape gives it away.

ReadersD1gest · 21/03/2023 08:14

sashh · 21/03/2023 03:55

Also they are like vegans and Yorkshire men, they will tell you.

How true 😂

ReadersD1gest · 21/03/2023 08:13

whatkatydid2013 · 20/03/2023 23:19

How do they tell the difference? My primary age daughter gets quite upset sometimes as people keep thinking she’s a boy. It’s because she has super short hair and likes joggers. I’m not a big fan of pronoun labels for other reasons but there is no question you can’t always tell someone’s sex by looking at them.

She's a young child. When she gets older there will be far less confusion...

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 21/03/2023 07:53

HipTightOnions · 20/03/2023 19:42

Where are the equal opportunities for people who are gender critical?

"Where are the equal opportunities for the racists?' Sounds ridiculous doesn't it?

Gender-critical belief is protected by law though!

This.

A lazy and childish comparison.

Believing in biology, safeguarding young people from unnecessary meds and surgery and protecting females places in sport is not a comparison to racism.

Such utter utter bollocks

Huggybear16 · 21/03/2023 07:21

He - for a male
She - for a female
They - for more than one person

The vocal minority wants me to use language that I am uncomfortable with. It also doesn't make sense. That's not inclusive.

whatkatydid2013 · 21/03/2023 07:01

Deathbyfluffy · 20/03/2023 08:38

Don’t feel bad for not conforming to their nonsense.
I couldn’t give two shits if I ‘mis gendered’ someone - if someone looks like they’re a certain gender I’m just going to assume, and not pussyfoot around.

If they want to get all bent out of shape about it, that’s a ‘them’ problem and not a ‘me’ problem.

Would you care if you made a mistake in someone’s biological sex and it upset them?
I ask as while I also have concerns about ensuring single sex spaces can be protected I don’t understand the attitude that it’s ok to use the pro nouns you believe best fit someone you see even if someone has told you they’d prefer different ones. You might well forget/make a mistake and I don’t think that’s some unforgivable mistake but doing it on purpose is just rude and it’s pretty nasty.

My eldest is often mistaken for a boy because she likes joggers & dark colours and she prefers short hair. I have noticed lately sometimes even if I correct people they keep using male pronouns. I had worked on the assumption they just forgot but if people think like you maybe I should consider the possibility they are just being dicks about it 🤷🏼‍♀️

sashh · 21/03/2023 03:55

SinnerBoy · 20/03/2023 08:01

How would you know if you had? It’s not always as obvious as people here like to think.

That's not true, size, gait, facial features, hand & foot size and general body shape are dead giveaways. Transw don't pass, no matter how much they like to fantasise that they do.

Also they are like vegans and Yorkshire men, they will tell you.

Codlingmoths · 20/03/2023 23:22

Jourdain11 · 20/03/2023 19:13

It's a pity that the female suffragists never thought of changing gender. It would have solved the whole question of the right to vote.

Then, we would have gender change laws that say women can be men BUT they cannnot inherit estates passed through the male line (ie the law in place currently) NOR can they vote NOR own property or whatever else men can do but women can’t. Play sport. How fun and enlightened.

whatkatydid2013 · 20/03/2023 23:19

StopitSarah · 19/03/2023 21:47

@Everydayimhuffling have you met primary age children? If I said that to a 6 year old they’d say “it is easy. Men are him and women are her”

How do they tell the difference? My primary age daughter gets quite upset sometimes as people keep thinking she’s a boy. It’s because she has super short hair and likes joggers. I’m not a big fan of pronoun labels for other reasons but there is no question you can’t always tell someone’s sex by looking at them.

whatkatydid2013 · 20/03/2023 23:16

OneFrenchEgg · 19/03/2023 20:36

I don't really have a strong opinion anymore, recently realised there's much shouting either end but a lot of middle ground.
But I just realised that being a trans ally is the only one I can think of where you kind of muddy the waters by declaring yourself; you don't do that for other things do you? Like if I'm a black ally I don't wear a name tag saying white. Maybe because trans is the only one where you change something? I don't know, I'm making no sense.

I find the whole thing a bit odd too. Work are very keen on adding pro nouns to email signatures on basis it helps include trans people but what if they are trans and don’t want to be “out” at work. Surely it’s then just making things harder as you either are forced to come out and give your preferred pronouns when you may not feel ready or you give the ones that fit your sex and that likely makes you feel uncomfortable too. It feels like it helps a subset of trans people but doesn’t help them all and it likely isn’t helpful for women to have she/her at end of all mails either.

TheShellBeach · 20/03/2023 23:08

Some of your kids are going to feel non-binary, some of them are going to experience gender dysphoria. What are you going to do? Try and talk them out of it?

YES.

CremeEggQueen · 20/03/2023 23:04

Howdoyoulikeyoureggsinthemorning · 20/03/2023 15:45

I'm sorry I genuinely have no idea what you're talking about. Where have I mentioned a child at any point? Why do you keep saying child?

Thank goodness it's not just me, was wondering the same myself!

HockeyJock · 20/03/2023 22:08

I would never ever ever stand by passively whole my wonderful child with their healthy body was subjected to unnecessary surgery and condemned to a lifelong dependency on unlicensed drugs.

Of course I would talk to them! And get them any help and therapeutic support they needed to help them feel comfortable with their body as it is. I would support them to dress how they wanted and follow any path in life they chose, whilst supporting to accept their biological reality. And no, the fucked up kids are not the ones who are kept away from experimental surgery and unlicensed drugs

AudTheDeepMinded · 20/03/2023 22:05

@MaryMcCarthy It's so interesting hearing your thoughts. What do you think about the Transabled?

DdraigGoch · 20/03/2023 22:03

MaryMcCarthy · 20/03/2023 18:46

What would you do if one of your kids or grandkids had these thoughts?

Would you try and talk them out if? Tell them it was bollocks?

What would you do if one of your kids or grandkids was anorexic?

Would you look at their emaciated body and agree with them that they're fat? Would you start fundraising for a gastric band?

Of course you bloody wouldn't.

StopitSarah · 20/03/2023 21:58

@HockeyJock thank you so much for the book recommendation. I’d encourage anyone to look it up and read the reviews. “time to think” by Hannah Barnes

OP posts:
DdraigGoch · 20/03/2023 21:58

MaryMcCarthy · 20/03/2023 18:37

But the thread isn't about women's sports, women's prisons, women's changing rooms, women's rape crisis services. That's a different discussion.

This is about pronouns and respecting how people want to be referred to.

It's the way the world's going. It's the way the world will be once we're gone so I don't understand why there's so much impotent railing against it. Every time a thread like this recurs I'm left thinking about all the fucked up kids that will result from the sort of attitudes shown by parents here.

Some of your kids are going to feel non-binary, some of them are going to experience gender dysphoria. What are you going to do? Try and talk them out of it?

What about the fucked-up kids who are the casualties of the drive to affirm every delusion? They're the ones who will grow up infertile, with ongoing health conditions.

AudTheDeepMinded · 20/03/2023 21:54

'Chill'

AudTheDeepMinded · 20/03/2023 21:53

To all those not understanding why this is the tip of an important iceberg, and that it does not affect them so they are 'chi'' with it:
can-sg.org/2023/02/23/open-letter-to-nhs-chiefs-the-importance-of-the-word-woman/

WeeWillyWinkie9 · 20/03/2023 21:47

Cosyblankets · 20/03/2023 07:58

Can you ask John if he has sugar in his tea?

John may only be in the next room. This is not rude. It's not quite the same as the cat's mother!

If John is in the other room then why care what pronouns you use?