Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Preferred pronoun labels at childrens event

730 replies

StopitSarah · 19/03/2023 20:21

I took my primary age children to a science event this weekend. It’s run by university students. Almost all of them had their preferred pronouns on their name labels.

AIBU to feel that was unnecessary and to feel a bit uneasy? One of my children wanted to know why “the man is saying we should say he/him. Isn’t that obvious?”

I asked one of the students who said it was to show support to any trans helpers and was for the benefit of the (adult) students, not the children.

I’m SO BORED and irritated by the trans agenda being every-bloody-where.

But AIBU? I had a good chat with one of the students and he said that they’re all science students and understand that woman = biological female is too simplistic. My brain exploded.

OP posts:
lifeturnsonadime · 21/03/2023 11:57

I actually think it’s appalling what happened to justjean and I’m really concerned about the lack of safeguarding from the adults involved. I’m not sure self-pronoun badges would have made a lot of difference to the situation. After all, pronoun badges were designed to help trans people, not to correctly sex a person.

I know. The pronoun badge could have the opposite result.

Guess that's the fault of women or feminists though. It always is.

lifeturnsonadime · 21/03/2023 11:56

What feminine ideal are you talking about Creme Egg, are you OK?

I've repeated spoken about my daughter being gender non conforming and assumptions being made that she must be trans or non binary.

There is no wrong way for a woman to look. Being female is what matters, not the clothes or a badge. HTH.

CountZacular · 21/03/2023 11:56

CremeEggQueen · 21/03/2023 11:47

Cross posted - look there you go @justteanbiscuits has handily answered, that saves you some trawling 🙂

That hasn’t answered my question at all. I asked what work badges would do to help in the general public. How would that have helped justjean be correctly sexed on an exchange trip?

I actually think it’s appalling what happened to justjean and I’m really concerned about the lack of safeguarding from the adults involved. I’m not sure self-pronoun badges would have made a lot of difference to the situation. After all, pronoun badges were designed to help trans people, not to correctly sex a person.

lifeturnsonadime · 21/03/2023 11:53

CremeEggQueen · 21/03/2023 11:51

It's not feminism to only care about some women you agree with but not others though.

I don't claim to be a feminist.

I'm not going to apologise for caring more about women incarcerated with rapists in prisons and female children who are led to believe they are born in the wrong bodies than a woman being mistaken for being wrong sex apparently for wearing the wrong clothes or for not wearing a badge.

CremeEggQueen · 21/03/2023 11:53

To not care if they're misgendered (suck it up, or insinuated didn't happen) ot when one told you that they felt at risk for it.
Why should we have to conform to a feminine ideal?
Which viewpoint is propping that up again?!

CremeEggQueen · 21/03/2023 11:51

It's not feminism to only care about some women you agree with but not others though.

lifeturnsonadime · 21/03/2023 11:49

CremeEggQueen · 21/03/2023 11:48

Scolding?! 😂
WTF - how is it scolding to hear a different opinion?!
If you feel told off that's a you problem, nobody's telling you off, just disagreeing with you!

What part of telling me I wasn't the right kind of feminist for having a different opinion to yours wasn't scolding?

CremeEggQueen · 21/03/2023 11:49

Well I'm not telling you off anyway, I obviously dont speak for everyone so somebody might have been, who knows 😁

CremeEggQueen · 21/03/2023 11:48

Scolding?! 😂
WTF - how is it scolding to hear a different opinion?!
If you feel told off that's a you problem, nobody's telling you off, just disagreeing with you!

CremeEggQueen · 21/03/2023 11:47

Cross posted - look there you go @justteanbiscuits has handily answered, that saves you some trawling 🙂

CremeEggQueen · 21/03/2023 11:45

CountZacular · 21/03/2023 11:23

Can you tell me what they said because I really don’t see how wearing a pronoun badge at work would stop you being misgendered at a supermarket?

It's on the thread if you genuinely want to know, could go back and have a look, I presume you can just as well as me?

justteanbiscuits · 21/03/2023 11:38

Clymene · 21/03/2023 11:33

Sorry you went on a school trip and you were put in a room with boys? Didn't your teachers know you're a girl?

It was an exchange trip organised by the other end as it were. So no, they didn't. It was a long time ago now, but experiences as a teen really do mould your opinions in life. And was obviously at a time when safeguarding wasn't as much of a concern as now. I was a teen who was, like many teens, conscious of my body. The fashion then was baggy clothing (Think Madchester period). Being told I looked like a boy was horribly uncomfortable when I did my apprenticeship. I didn't want to be singled out as the only girl as I had to try and fit in in a very male environment, but also, I didn't want to be called Mr, or "the boy over there", or put into a hotel room with a male because the organisers hadn't noticed I was female!

lifeturnsonadime · 21/03/2023 11:36

CremeEggQueen · 21/03/2023 11:31

What part of other people apart from yourself have said differently, that they do have a problem with anyone wearing a badge, and that any woman who is repeatedly misgendered for looking too blokish should suck it up etc do you not get?!
That's what's not feminism.
Policing other women's femininity/validity to fit your own feminine ideals.

But yet that's exactly what you are doing? You are scolding women who see the issue with pronoun badges.

I'm not a feminist. I don't claim to be one.

I do believe in women's rights separate from males who claim to be women. I believe that TWAM. I do see the harm in pronouns. I do think gender ideology which is what pronoun badges symbolise leads children to believe they have been born wrong. I think that's horrific. I have a child who could easily have been led down that path because she doesn't do stereotypes, she is often misgendered. She is perfect as she is.

To be clear I couldn't care less if an individual feels the need to wear a badge to clarify their sex. I do care if society is being told that we must adhere to preferred pronouns because It is not benign.

FrostyFifi · 21/03/2023 11:34

Policing other women's femininity/validity to fit your own feminine ideals

How is that policing anyone? Literally no-one has said women should make themselves look more feminine except those using it as a strawman.

I'm just not sure what women who say that they don't dress in a feminine way and then get misgendered, want from this interaction. I genuinely don't.

Clymene · 21/03/2023 11:33

Sorry you went on a school trip and you were put in a room with boys? Didn't your teachers know you're a girl?

CremeEggQueen · 21/03/2023 11:31

lifeturnsonadime · 21/03/2023 11:25

What part of you can wear a badge if you want but you can't compel others to do the same is offending you?

I don't get it?

What part of other people apart from yourself have said differently, that they do have a problem with anyone wearing a badge, and that any woman who is repeatedly misgendered for looking too blokish should suck it up etc do you not get?!
That's what's not feminism.
Policing other women's femininity/validity to fit your own feminine ideals.

DdraigGoch · 21/03/2023 11:31

justteanbiscuits · 21/03/2023 10:43

As yesterday, I am still blown away by so many of you simply not caring that someone who has shared their experience of being misgendered and saying it made them uncomfortable. (it happened to be a lot as a teen. Short haired female, small busted, in jeans and tshirt in a mainly male workplace, with a name that could be construed as either gender, and YES, it was upsetting. I was also, twice, quite seriously misgendered which now a days would have led to a safeguarding enquiry as it put me at risk - both times led to me having to share bedrooms with boys when I was under 18. Once before I was working, on a school trip when I was under 16).

Why are YOUR feelings about having pronouns on badges more important than someone's actual experiences of being misgendered?? Why are you claiming people are lying just because their real life experience doesn't match your, obviously narrow, life experiences?? Rather than having a pronoun on a badge, you think people should simply dress to your feminine standards??

I'm glad you have acknowledged that mixing boys and girls in certain environments is a safeguarding risk. Because the whole "these are my pronouns, I am who I say I am, and you will comply" thing is feeding into this new phenomenon of allowing males into female safe spaces, or even abolishing the segregation entirely.

PSNonsense · 21/03/2023 11:30

justteanbiscuits · 21/03/2023 11:25

And again. Jesus fucking christ. People are sharing their real experience with you of being misgendered and it affecting them, and you simply do not care. To use a good old mumsnet phrase, give your heads a bloody wobble. You claim to be feminists. You claim to support women. But no. You only want to support women who have the same life experience as you. It's truly disgusting and many of you should really be having a long hard think about where your politics are taking you. Over and out.

You are blowing a lot of hot air and not actually answering any questions. If people are bothered by being misgendered due to the way they look then wear a badge all the time. Don't compel others to do so though.

How is that difficult to understand?

CountZacular · 21/03/2023 11:28

I’ve read my responses repeatedly and I can’t see that I’ve said I don’t care? I’ve asked what point you are arguing because I really don’t know. Are you suggesting clothes are sex markers? Are you saying pronoun badges in some situations would solve the problem everywhere? Do you want everyone to wear a pronoun badge all of the time?

What are you actually saying and what do you want?

lifeturnsonadime · 21/03/2023 11:26

Well my politics isn't leading to rapists in prisons and children believing they are born in the wrong body. But you do you.

lifeturnsonadime · 21/03/2023 11:25

justteanbiscuits · 21/03/2023 11:25

And again. Jesus fucking christ. People are sharing their real experience with you of being misgendered and it affecting them, and you simply do not care. To use a good old mumsnet phrase, give your heads a bloody wobble. You claim to be feminists. You claim to support women. But no. You only want to support women who have the same life experience as you. It's truly disgusting and many of you should really be having a long hard think about where your politics are taking you. Over and out.

What part of you can wear a badge if you want but you can't compel others to do the same is offending you?

I don't get it?

justteanbiscuits · 21/03/2023 11:25

And again. Jesus fucking christ. People are sharing their real experience with you of being misgendered and it affecting them, and you simply do not care. To use a good old mumsnet phrase, give your heads a bloody wobble. You claim to be feminists. You claim to support women. But no. You only want to support women who have the same life experience as you. It's truly disgusting and many of you should really be having a long hard think about where your politics are taking you. Over and out.

FrostyFifi · 21/03/2023 11:24

So, in order to not be upset as a teenager, I should have dressed in a more feminine way?!

That's literally the exact opposite of what I said.
But honestly if it upsets you so much, then you are free to wear a badge saying "I'm female" or whatever. Just as long as there's no expectation for others to follow suit.

CountZacular · 21/03/2023 11:23

CremeEggQueen · 21/03/2023 11:19

And how would wearing pronoun badges at work help with the many instances that must take place in the public?
Somebody upthread already answered that.

Can you tell me what they said because I really don’t see how wearing a pronoun badge at work would stop you being misgendered at a supermarket?

Clymene · 21/03/2023 11:21

justteanbiscuits · 21/03/2023 10:43

As yesterday, I am still blown away by so many of you simply not caring that someone who has shared their experience of being misgendered and saying it made them uncomfortable. (it happened to be a lot as a teen. Short haired female, small busted, in jeans and tshirt in a mainly male workplace, with a name that could be construed as either gender, and YES, it was upsetting. I was also, twice, quite seriously misgendered which now a days would have led to a safeguarding enquiry as it put me at risk - both times led to me having to share bedrooms with boys when I was under 18. Once before I was working, on a school trip when I was under 16).

Why are YOUR feelings about having pronouns on badges more important than someone's actual experiences of being misgendered?? Why are you claiming people are lying just because their real life experience doesn't match your, obviously narrow, life experiences?? Rather than having a pronoun on a badge, you think people should simply dress to your feminine standards??

How on earth would a badge have prevented this problem? We all know that makes wear badges that say she/her on them. I'm baffled that you think that pronoun badges would mean you were correctly sexed.