Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Preferred pronoun labels at childrens event

730 replies

StopitSarah · 19/03/2023 20:21

I took my primary age children to a science event this weekend. It’s run by university students. Almost all of them had their preferred pronouns on their name labels.

AIBU to feel that was unnecessary and to feel a bit uneasy? One of my children wanted to know why “the man is saying we should say he/him. Isn’t that obvious?”

I asked one of the students who said it was to show support to any trans helpers and was for the benefit of the (adult) students, not the children.

I’m SO BORED and irritated by the trans agenda being every-bloody-where.

But AIBU? I had a good chat with one of the students and he said that they’re all science students and understand that woman = biological female is too simplistic. My brain exploded.

OP posts:
FrostyFifi · 21/03/2023 13:15

OK< let's take twitter. I don't have my pronouns on twitter. I use handle that is gender-less (that I have used on twitter since 2006, and for 10 years online before that so to me, it's as important as my real name). I get accused, at least weekly, of being a man. "How dare you have opinions on a female issue when you are a man". This very rarely comes from men, but always from those claiming to be feminists. When I have stated I am a woman. When I have opinions they don't agree with

I deliberately have a male-sounding handle on twitter now. I get so much less abuse and unpleasantness. I love it. It's freeing.

lifeturnsonadime · 21/03/2023 13:15

CremeEggQueen · 21/03/2023 13:13

Wot, goalposts have moved again?
What about what tea actually said, and what she was referring to?

She was on about being assumed to be a bloke on twitter. So absolutely nothing to do with either pronoun badges or perceptions of femininity. I have no idea what she was on about tbh which is why I am asking what the connection is.

CremeEggQueen · 21/03/2023 13:13

lifeturnsonadime · 21/03/2023 13:10

Right, and what's that got to do with whether wearing a pronoun badge does more harm to women, as a sex class, than good?

Wot, goalposts have moved again?
What about what tea actually said, and what she was referring to?

justteanbiscuits · 21/03/2023 13:12

Chocsandflowers · 21/03/2023 13:11

People would possibly think @justteanbiscuits was a transwoman as opposed to a woman. Maybe she'd be fine with that, but she seemed uncomfortable to be thought of as a man...

or because people are GC
Ah yes, look, there you go.
There's nothing wrong with being gender critical. You really should do a little more reading and research @CremeEggQueen.

I'm sorry. Are you accusing me of being a trans woman?? But no, they just thought I was a boy.

nothingcomestonothing · 21/03/2023 13:11

you're only supportive of those who match your ideals. Who are nice and girly, who only behave and feel things the exact same way you dictate they should. Telling my 17 year old self that I shouldn't have been upset. I should have stood up to management and superiors and professors. I should have spoken up in a room of 40 people, as the only girl

Who has said that? You absolutely should not have been put in that position, it was a huge failing of the adults around you, not of you. It's also hard to see how it would have been avoided by pronoun badges, how did no one know you were a girl in any other way? ID, records, surely paperwork of some kind was involved? I don't get how this happened to you, but I haven't seen anyone here blaming you for it.

justteanbiscuits · 21/03/2023 13:11

PSNonsense · 21/03/2023 13:08

I'm sorry that you felt like you couldn't speak up and say you were actually a girl in a room full of boys but I feel you are massively projecting. And twisting what people on this thread are actually saying.

Please read my previous post explaining why I outlined these experiences. I explained that while a badge wouldn't have helped me in these situations, I posted in solidarity with @CremeEggQueen who was being told she was lying about being misgendered, being told to wear more feminine clothing, and being told she was asking for it. I was just backing up that actually, misgendering can be a painful experience for many women and girls. That just because your child doesn't find it upsetting, doesn't mean that many others don't. But this is something that has gone way way over the head of most of this thread unfortunately.

Chocsandflowers · 21/03/2023 13:11

CremeEggQueen · 21/03/2023 12:59

The pronoun badges wouldn't necessarily help you - people might think you were a man identifying as a woman. You'd still be misgendered, more quietly perhaps.
Even though it would clearly say she her, they'd still get misgendered? What, by people doing it deliberately to stick one to trans people?

I don't think they should get cross with people who get it wrong (as described by OP), whether this is by accident or because people are GC

or because people are GC
Ah yes, look, there you go.

People would possibly think @justteanbiscuits was a transwoman as opposed to a woman. Maybe she'd be fine with that, but she seemed uncomfortable to be thought of as a man...

or because people are GC
Ah yes, look, there you go.
There's nothing wrong with being gender critical. You really should do a little more reading and research @CremeEggQueen.

lifeturnsonadime · 21/03/2023 13:10

justteanbiscuits · 21/03/2023 13:08

OK< let's take twitter. I don't have my pronouns on twitter. I use handle that is gender-less (that I have used on twitter since 2006, and for 10 years online before that so to me, it's as important as my real name). I get accused, at least weekly, of being a man. "How dare you have opinions on a female issue when you are a man". This very rarely comes from men, but always from those claiming to be feminists. When I have stated I am a woman. When I have opinions they don't agree with.

Right, and what's that got to do with whether wearing a pronoun badge does more harm to women, as a sex class, than good?

justteanbiscuits · 21/03/2023 13:08

OK< let's take twitter. I don't have my pronouns on twitter. I use handle that is gender-less (that I have used on twitter since 2006, and for 10 years online before that so to me, it's as important as my real name). I get accused, at least weekly, of being a man. "How dare you have opinions on a female issue when you are a man". This very rarely comes from men, but always from those claiming to be feminists. When I have stated I am a woman. When I have opinions they don't agree with.

PSNonsense · 21/03/2023 13:08

justteanbiscuits · 21/03/2023 13:05

The reason both @CremeEggQueen have responded repeatedly is because we have been told we should just suck it up, that misgendering doesn't upset anyone, that we're lying, that we should dress more feminine etc etc etc. That we CHOSE to be misgendered. Many of the attitudes displayed in here I thought were left behind 20 years ago.

By a group of women who claim to be feminists and supporting women. But actually, you're only supportive of those who match your ideals. Who are nice and girly, who only behave and feel things the exact same way you dictate they should. Telling my 17 year old self that I shouldn't have been upset. I should have stood up to management and superiors and professors. I should have spoken up in a room of 40 people, as the only girl, as a very uncomfortable teen. I'm pleased you were all such amazing, confident teenagers who would have been able to do this, but please try and understand not everyone was.

I'm sorry that you felt like you couldn't speak up and say you were actually a girl in a room full of boys but I feel you are massively projecting. And twisting what people on this thread are actually saying.

lifeturnsonadime · 21/03/2023 13:07

By a group of women who claim to be feminists and supporting women.

Which group of women who claim to be feminist.

This isn't FWR it's AIBU.

Not a hive mind. I don't speak for anyone except myself. I think pronouns cause more harm than they do good. I have a daughter who wears boys clothes and is often mistaken for trans or non binary because she doesn't conform with stereotypes.

justteanbiscuits · 21/03/2023 13:05

The reason both @CremeEggQueen have responded repeatedly is because we have been told we should just suck it up, that misgendering doesn't upset anyone, that we're lying, that we should dress more feminine etc etc etc. That we CHOSE to be misgendered. Many of the attitudes displayed in here I thought were left behind 20 years ago.

By a group of women who claim to be feminists and supporting women. But actually, you're only supportive of those who match your ideals. Who are nice and girly, who only behave and feel things the exact same way you dictate they should. Telling my 17 year old self that I shouldn't have been upset. I should have stood up to management and superiors and professors. I should have spoken up in a room of 40 people, as the only girl, as a very uncomfortable teen. I'm pleased you were all such amazing, confident teenagers who would have been able to do this, but please try and understand not everyone was.

lifeturnsonadime · 21/03/2023 13:04

CremeEggQueen · 21/03/2023 13:00

No one has said 'I think pronoun badges are nonsense so no one should wear one'
Have you actually read all the thread?!

I don't think that pronoun badges are nonsense I think they are harmful.

They are a badge which demonstrate an alliance with an ideology which has the aim of removing the rights of women and telling children that if they don't comply with stereotypes they were born wrong.

There you go.

nothingcomestonothing · 21/03/2023 13:02

In fact that seems an awful lot like the same behaviour as " well I love a wolf whistle, it's flattering, why would you get offended, get over yourself "

It's always the overreach, isn't it? TRAs can start out sounding somewhat reasonable, but it doesn't take too long to get from there to 'women who don't like pronoun badges think other women should dress more femininely and like being sexually objectified '. The only people I think I've ever come across saying they like being objectified, are TW like Paris Lees...

CecilyP · 21/03/2023 13:02

I was also, twice, quite seriously misgendered which now a days would have led to a safeguarding enquiry as it put me at risk - both times led to me having to share bedrooms with boys when I was under 18. Once before I was working, on a school trip when I was under 16).

Surely the person allocating the rooms messed up big time. Did you even wear a name badge at that time? Probably not at school, though your sex would have been on your records. Would the people so careless as to have made those mistakes even have noticed anything stating your preferred pronouns?

PSNonsense · 21/03/2023 13:00

CremeEggQueen · 21/03/2023 13:00

No one has said 'I think pronoun badges are nonsense so no one should wear one'
Have you actually read all the thread?!

Have you?!

CremeEggQueen · 21/03/2023 13:00

No one has said 'I think pronoun badges are nonsense so no one should wear one'
Have you actually read all the thread?!

CountZacular · 21/03/2023 12:59

PSNonsense · 21/03/2023 12:57

No one has said 'I think pronoun badges are nonsense so no one should wear one'.

For the hundredth time, most have said they don't care if others wear them (regardless of whether they think they're nonsense), they just don't want to be compelled by others to follow suit.

Not the same as your shite wolf whistle analogy.

Your constant ignoring of this and need for this 'gotcha' that isn't coming is pathetic and a bit cringe.

Yes, I agree. I feel like it’s been said so many times now. Badges don’t correctly sex but wear one of you want. Don’t compel others. Where what you want. Many women (myself included) wear masculine clothing and really don’t care what people think. I don’t know what this ‘your side’ crap because it’s not even a rough estimation of my views or anything I’ve said here.

PSNonsense · 21/03/2023 12:59

Actually, the OP is saying they don't think anyone should wear one.

Hence the word 'most' in my post.

CremeEggQueen · 21/03/2023 12:59

The pronoun badges wouldn't necessarily help you - people might think you were a man identifying as a woman. You'd still be misgendered, more quietly perhaps.
Even though it would clearly say she her, they'd still get misgendered? What, by people doing it deliberately to stick one to trans people?

I don't think they should get cross with people who get it wrong (as described by OP), whether this is by accident or because people are GC

or because people are GC
Ah yes, look, there you go.

lifeturnsonadime · 21/03/2023 12:58

I think we should all wear badges with statements that stop misconceptions and hurt.

The options are endless.

justteanbiscuits · 21/03/2023 12:58

PSNonsense · 21/03/2023 12:57

No one has said 'I think pronoun badges are nonsense so no one should wear one'.

For the hundredth time, most have said they don't care if others wear them (regardless of whether they think they're nonsense), they just don't want to be compelled by others to follow suit.

Not the same as your shite wolf whistle analogy.

Your constant ignoring of this and need for this 'gotcha' that isn't coming is pathetic and a bit cringe.

Actually, the OP is saying they don't think anyone should wear one.

lifeturnsonadime · 21/03/2023 12:57

When my SIL was pregnant with twins in her 40s she'd have liked a badge that said

'Not conceived by IVF'

PSNonsense · 21/03/2023 12:57

CremeEggQueen · 21/03/2023 12:51

In fact that seems an awful lot like the same behaviour as " well I love a wolf whistle, it's flattering, why would you get offended, get over yourself "

No one has said 'I think pronoun badges are nonsense so no one should wear one'.

For the hundredth time, most have said they don't care if others wear them (regardless of whether they think they're nonsense), they just don't want to be compelled by others to follow suit.

Not the same as your shite wolf whistle analogy.

Your constant ignoring of this and need for this 'gotcha' that isn't coming is pathetic and a bit cringe.

lifeturnsonadime · 21/03/2023 12:56

CremeEggQueen · 21/03/2023 12:54

I'm not confused at all.
Nice attempt at gas lighting though.
If "your " side didn't care about gender stereotyping, why are you on the side of those who are telling others that being misgendered is no big deal, that you're asking for it for looking too much like a bloke?
I'm not the confused one here.

Ha ha, no.

Your side thinks children can be born in the wrong body because they play with the wrong toys.