Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Preferred pronoun labels at childrens event

730 replies

StopitSarah · 19/03/2023 20:21

I took my primary age children to a science event this weekend. It’s run by university students. Almost all of them had their preferred pronouns on their name labels.

AIBU to feel that was unnecessary and to feel a bit uneasy? One of my children wanted to know why “the man is saying we should say he/him. Isn’t that obvious?”

I asked one of the students who said it was to show support to any trans helpers and was for the benefit of the (adult) students, not the children.

I’m SO BORED and irritated by the trans agenda being every-bloody-where.

But AIBU? I had a good chat with one of the students and he said that they’re all science students and understand that woman = biological female is too simplistic. My brain exploded.

OP posts:
lifeturnsonadime · 20/03/2023 13:40

melj1213 · 20/03/2023 13:37

So essentially if I'm daring to be anything other than ultra feminine - wearing pink, dresses, skirts, make up - then I have to go out of my way to "prove" my gender so that other people don't have to potentially get uncomfortable because they have got my gender wrong?

Or I could just have a badge that says "MJ she/her" which allows people to see at a glance what my preferred pronouns are without the awkward conversations and allows me to wear whatever I want (or is most practical for the task at hand) without having to think "am I going to be repeatedly misgendered if I wear these jeans with my club hoodie as opposed to a skirt?"

No because in 99.9 % of cases your sex is immediately apparent!

No need for a badge at all.

Gender is what is causing the issue here. Labelling people based on notions of gender is unnecessary and ultimately is being used to erode women's rights and to harm children.

melj1213 · 20/03/2023 13:37

Mamamia7962 · 20/03/2023 13:07

melj123 - Well if it bothers you that much you have a choice, either use your full name but write your short name underneath, write female underneath the short name, or correct adults/children when they think you're the opposite sex.

So essentially if I'm daring to be anything other than ultra feminine - wearing pink, dresses, skirts, make up - then I have to go out of my way to "prove" my gender so that other people don't have to potentially get uncomfortable because they have got my gender wrong?

Or I could just have a badge that says "MJ she/her" which allows people to see at a glance what my preferred pronouns are without the awkward conversations and allows me to wear whatever I want (or is most practical for the task at hand) without having to think "am I going to be repeatedly misgendered if I wear these jeans with my club hoodie as opposed to a skirt?"

ImAGoodPerson · 20/03/2023 13:27

PSNonsense · 20/03/2023 11:01

I am as GC as they come and I don't really care about pronouns. I inwardly roll my eyes as I personally think it's bollocks but hey ho, if it makes someone feel better then all power to them.

I think trans people should live they way they want to - to an extent. If that means dressing in ways they perceive makes them a woman, dress, heels, make up (I only do 1 out of these) then fine. Doesn't affect me at all.

It's when it does affect me as a sex class it becomes a problem, which is accessing sex based spaces which women have fought hard for, being comfortable in toilets, changing rooms, places like prisons, sports, rape crisis centres. Hopefully I'll never have to access some of these but I recognise other, mostly vulnerable women, do, and it shouldn't be with biological males, no matter how they identify.

Women are statistically more at risk of harm from men, and unfortunately we don't know the ones from those with a genuine gender dysphoria just wanting to live their lives as authentically and quietly as possible, from those who seek to harm us. They don't come with a flashing warning.

Hence why spaces are separated by sex in the first place. A lot shout 'harmful men will access these spaces anyway!' if they want to harm, but that's like saying what's the point of locking your doors, having a ring doorbell, if burglars are going to burgle anyway. It's called SAFEGUARDING.

Inclusivity doesn't mean getting to access any space you want.

This is an extremely popular feeling IME. Most people I know are more than happy to go along with what others want with regards to pronouns and do their best to respect this.

I am involved in what is traditionally a very laddish sport and there is a man there who is now presenting as a she and no one even batted an eyelid. They call her 'her' and by her new name. No issues at all and they treat her so respectfully, as it should be, however they don't believe she is truly female as it isn't possible to change biological sex. She doesn't access female only spaces (which are very protected in this sport due to how few women are involved).

Abhannmor · 20/03/2023 13:27

Albiboba · 19/03/2023 20:29

Why is it people always say it’s “so boring” when actually you don’t rant for ages about something that is so boring.

Let’s face it I doubt your young child said that because it said he/him under a name tag. It really doesn’t impact you, no need to put yourself in the centre of everything.

What a strange post. Kids are very knowing and perceptive.

Even primary school kids know words like ' obvious '. It's a bit patronising to suggest they can't think for themselves.

CremeEggQueen · 20/03/2023 13:27

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 20/03/2023 13:20

My work have suggested that we should state our pronouns to show customers we are inclusive - 'hi, I'm PinkSparkly, my pronouns are she/her'. At the moment it's voluntary but I can see where it's heading.

Telling everyone is even more ridiculous than having them on a badge or signature!

You literally just said its voluntary.
Then in the next breath made up a scenario in your head where "you can see where it's heading."
Why?

Mamamia7962 · 20/03/2023 13:25

DisappearingGirl - Exactly. I was brought up in the 60s/70s and was a tomboy. Loved playing football, climbing trees, preferred wearing trousers and shorts to skirts and dresses. Also liked dolls. No one back then would ever have questioned whether I wanted to really be a boy, which obviously I didn't, but I can imagine the confusion when children are so impressionable and someone puts an idea into their head. Children should not be having to deal with this kind of thing.

pepperquorn · 20/03/2023 13:24

Chocsandflowers · 20/03/2023 07:38

The students doing this are well-meaning, but they don't realise that trans-ideology as it's being rolled out is harmful to women and children and is homophobic. Because this is not advertised, and 'be-kind' is. If you are a woman, chances are you will be directly affected sooner or later. Many women, children and lesbians are being badly affected by the ideology right now - you may not have noticed, but others have and they care precisely because they do understand what's going on.

This!

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 20/03/2023 13:20

coffeeandcola · 20/03/2023 08:16

So no one was forced to state their pronouns, it was a personal choice so some didn't.

They didn't ask children or parents to state their choice.

You got offended to the point where I bet you haven't stopped complaining about it.

Or you could accept it was a voluntary thing that had nothing to do with you or your children.

My work have suggested that we should state our pronouns to show customers we are inclusive - 'hi, I'm PinkSparkly, my pronouns are she/her'. At the moment it's voluntary but I can see where it's heading.

Telling everyone is even more ridiculous than having them on a badge or signature!

DisappearingGirl · 20/03/2023 13:16

I do not care what anyone wears and have plenty of friends who are fairly gender non-conforming.

However I am not keen on this ideology around kids either. I think it is regressive and harmful. My DD (8) likes dolls but also likes sports. Two of her female friends are quite gender non-conforming and love footie (tomboys, in old language).

I don't want DD and her friends thinking this means they are not actually girls. That DD must be non-binary, and her friends must be trans and need drugs and surgery. Just for not conforming to feminine stereotypes. I'm usually up for explaining most things to my kids (in an age-appropriate way), but I've no idea how to explain non-binary as I think it is so ridiculous.

Jourdain11 · 20/03/2023 13:15

Incidentally, a woman who I studied with was very androgynous in her appearance - short hair, very masculine clothes choices (waistcoats and bow ties on occasion) and strode around like Suranne Jones in Gentleman Jack. She was also a woman. She never once expressed a desire to be known as anything else and she was obviously, physically female. No one would ever have mistaken her for a man.

And as far as I know (2 years or so since I last saw her), she still is a woman who prefers this style of dress etc. It's a great pity that if my daughters decide they want to have short hair and wear waistcoats, they'll probably be assumed to have gender identity issues.

ImAGoodPerson · 20/03/2023 13:15

lifeturnsonadime · 20/03/2023 13:04

No I don't have experience of being trans or having a 'trans child' I do have an autistic daughter who does not conform with gender stereotypes who has been ask several times about whether she considers herself to be a girl, including by health professionals. She is a girl who enjoys stereotypically male things. Despite others encouraging her (I will go so far as to say) to adopt a trans or non binary identity she hasn't because we have told her it is a load of tosh. It is not possible to change sex. It is possible to be a girl and have unlimited expectations.

So sorry I do think we can lead children down a path of believing that if they do not fit societal expectations of what a girl or a boy is that they must be trans.

If a child is anorexic we do not affirm their body image as that would harm them. This is no different.

The Cass report says that affirmation is not a neutral act.

Anyone who thinks that affirming mental health conditions is in the interests of the child is going against the findings of the Cass Report.

It is NOT KIND to children. Any of them. Least of all the female ones.

You have explained this so well here. I couldn't agree more.

justteanbiscuits · 20/03/2023 13:15

CremeEggQueen · 20/03/2023 13:08

What, I'm a man if I dont dress femininely enough?
No.
Fuck that

I think you finally understand! You're not womanly enough to be called a woman. Damn you and doing sports and supporting young people to keep fit and healthy. You should she promenading in your new dainty sun dress and showing that cleavage. I bet you weren't even wearing make up were you. See, you were asking for it...

PSNonsense · 20/03/2023 13:14

*link

PSNonsense · 20/03/2023 13:14

Jourdain11 · 20/03/2023 13:10

Pronouns badges and email signatures are totally self-congratulatory tokenism. They're not even as trans-supportive as you think they are. How do you know that "announce your pronouns" isn't pressurising a trans person to out themselves before they're ready or certain? Or forcing them to misgender themselves because they're not ready to live as a trans person yet?

Completely agree. I'm sure there was an article about how it impacts females negatively who have a gender neutral name, such as 'Chris'. They were treated differently as soon as they put she/her in their email signature as part of an experiment. If anyone could like it that would be appreciated.

justteanbiscuits · 20/03/2023 13:13

StopitSarah · 20/03/2023 13:03

@justteanbiscuits “because of the way he was brought up”? 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Ok.

Yes. He has been bought up around LGBTQ+ people. He's been bought up around discussions like this. So due to this, it isn't something completely new and other worldy to him. But you know, your mockery is really classy

Jourdain11 · 20/03/2023 13:10

Pronouns badges and email signatures are totally self-congratulatory tokenism. They're not even as trans-supportive as you think they are. How do you know that "announce your pronouns" isn't pressurising a trans person to out themselves before they're ready or certain? Or forcing them to misgender themselves because they're not ready to live as a trans person yet?

CremeEggQueen · 20/03/2023 13:08

Minimummonday · 20/03/2023 13:06

Because it is a "big deal" if you're constantly referred to as he or mistaken for a bloke every now and again!
It makes you feel like shit.

but in this scenario you are a man. So what’s the issue?

What, I'm a man if I dont dress femininely enough?
No.
Fuck that

CountZacular · 20/03/2023 13:08

CremeEggQueen · 20/03/2023 13:06

Just wear a badge if you want to wear one. Don’t compel everyone else to do so though
Nowhere do we know that they were "forced" or "compelled" to wear one though.

The OP asked a student and they were told they had to. The ones not wearing it didn’t get the memo in time. OP has said they were compelled to.

Still curious what you do when you are constantly being misgendered elsewhere in public though?

FrostyFifi · 20/03/2023 13:08

Because it is a "big deal" if you're constantly referred to as he or mistaken for a bloke every now and again!

I don't think this would actually have been a thing a couple of decades ago. It's precisely because of all the pronoun stuff that people probably feel compelled to refer to a more masculine-looking woman as "he". It's not that they can't see it's a woman, it's because they believe they'll be being impolite or committing an act of bigotry if they do not.

Mamamia7962 · 20/03/2023 13:07

melj123 - Well if it bothers you that much you have a choice, either use your full name but write your short name underneath, write female underneath the short name, or correct adults/children when they think you're the opposite sex.

CremeEggQueen · 20/03/2023 13:06

Just wear a badge if you want to wear one. Don’t compel everyone else to do so though
Nowhere do we know that they were "forced" or "compelled" to wear one though.

Minimummonday · 20/03/2023 13:06

Because it is a "big deal" if you're constantly referred to as he or mistaken for a bloke every now and again!
It makes you feel like shit.

but in this scenario you are a man. So what’s the issue?

Naunet · 20/03/2023 13:04

CremeEggQueen · 20/03/2023 13:00

Because it is a "big deal" if you're constantly referred to as he or mistaken for a bloke every now and again!
It makes you feel like shit.
Not that I expect those saying "fuck kind" or "hurty feelz" on these threads to ever understand.

So what? No one is entitled to a life where they never feel shit, who promised you that?

CountZacular · 20/03/2023 13:04

CremeEggQueen · 20/03/2023 13:00

Because it is a "big deal" if you're constantly referred to as he or mistaken for a bloke every now and again!
It makes you feel like shit.
Not that I expect those saying "fuck kind" or "hurty feelz" on these threads to ever understand.

I really don’t understand what your issue is. Just wear a badge if you want to wear one. Don’t compel everyone else to do so though.

Though I’m interested how you cope out in public if this happens regularly and it’s this upsetting. I assume you don’t wear a pronoun badge to the supermarket, the shopping centre loos, the local car sales room, etc?

lifeturnsonadime · 20/03/2023 13:04

Tandora · 20/03/2023 12:56

Why don't you try to talk to some trans people and they can explain to their experience to you, rather than assuming what would be received as "kind".

You clearly have no understanding of the experience of being trans, so really you should be spending your time listening and learning, rather than spouting your own (ignorant) ideas about what is "kind" to trans people on social media.

No I don't have experience of being trans or having a 'trans child' I do have an autistic daughter who does not conform with gender stereotypes who has been ask several times about whether she considers herself to be a girl, including by health professionals. She is a girl who enjoys stereotypically male things. Despite others encouraging her (I will go so far as to say) to adopt a trans or non binary identity she hasn't because we have told her it is a load of tosh. It is not possible to change sex. It is possible to be a girl and have unlimited expectations.

So sorry I do think we can lead children down a path of believing that if they do not fit societal expectations of what a girl or a boy is that they must be trans.

If a child is anorexic we do not affirm their body image as that would harm them. This is no different.

The Cass report says that affirmation is not a neutral act.

Anyone who thinks that affirming mental health conditions is in the interests of the child is going against the findings of the Cass Report.

It is NOT KIND to children. Any of them. Least of all the female ones.