Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Enid Blyton and the Brownies etc.

112 replies

EatsYummySprouts · 19/03/2023 20:16

These are things which I grew up with and loved. Now the language Enid Blyton used is not acceptable to the woke ways, and the Brownies is name changing to the Embers (in Canada)
These are just two examples of ridiculous wokeness.
I am a very open person, and am open to the beliefs of all, and sexual identity of all. But honestly, all if these rules, and that people cannot decide for themselves any more if something is okay or not is completely bonkers. AIBU???

OP posts:
Whenharrymetsmelly · 20/03/2023 04:16

JeannieAlogy · 19/03/2023 21:21

I agree with this.
However, I don't think the books should be censored. A better approach would be to have a preface in them which outlines how language has changed, along with attitudes, to make it clear that these were written in a very different time and to an extent, promoted certain perspectives.

But what if you liked these books as a child and want to pass on, but don't want the sexism, racism? I'd rather just read a book, rather than have to stop and keep pointing out how terrible people used to (and still can) be. Maybe have two versions so people who like the racism and sexism can read those too in that case. I don't see anything wrong with removing obvious negative slurs

Phoebo · 20/03/2023 04:12

PuttingDownRoots · 20/03/2023 04:01

EB books have been edited for decades. I can remember seeing a 1970 version compared to a 1990s version. Personally think there are a lot better books... EB was just a prolific writer.

If Brownie is used a derogatory term, then it is right to change it. (Sparks and Embers sound quite cool).

Things evolve. Doesn't mean change is wrong.

Well said.

Whenharrymetsmelly · 20/03/2023 04:12

cardibach · 19/03/2023 20:47

Well that’s not woke at all so maybe have a rethink.

This. That's not the meaning of "woke" 😜

Redebs · 20/03/2023 04:09

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

😄👍

PuttingDownRoots · 20/03/2023 04:01

EB books have been edited for decades. I can remember seeing a 1970 version compared to a 1990s version. Personally think there are a lot better books... EB was just a prolific writer.

If Brownie is used a derogatory term, then it is right to change it. (Sparks and Embers sound quite cool).

Things evolve. Doesn't mean change is wrong.

TooBigForMyBoots · 20/03/2023 01:08

GuidingSpirit · 19/03/2023 21:18

Brownie leader here.

If you did any research about the name change in Canada, you would know it is because "brownies" is a racist derogatory term in Canada, which used to be used against people of colour. So a totally different scenario to here. The organisation had a vote to choose the new name because some communities felt they could not participate due to the name.

Brownies in the UK is not planning a name change.

Imagine if there was an organisation for girls in the UK called the "n" word. Of course it would have been changed before now!!! It is ridiculous to think otherwise!!

Thanks for this @GuidingSpirit.🦉

MegIsWhite · 19/03/2023 23:31

I quite liked the name Brownies but if it means something else in Canada, then changing it wouldn't affect anyone's life except those who've found it upsetting.

Nothing "woke" (in the style of mumsnet to mean something I don't like) about this.

snitzelvoncrumb · 19/03/2023 23:30

I feel very strongly about things changing and no longer using outdated terms. But I find changing books wrong.

Rainbow1901 · 19/03/2023 23:27

Books written for children years ago shouldn't be changed or re-written but new books should be written for the children of today if it bothers people so much. Many nursery rhymes and stories came about because of historical events e.g. Ring-a-ring-a-roses or other events. We cannot re-write history, what we can do is learn from history and aim to change what we consider was wrong then.
I enjoyed reading Enid Blyton books when I was young and could relate to some of the adventures that were written about and even liked Swallows and Amazons but children of today cannot, for obvious reasons do half of the things now because it simply isn't safe, but do we write stories about the dangers that children face today? About guns, murder, grand theft auto?
Books I read to my GCs now consist of the Wonky Donkey etc but will we be told we can't read that because he smells, has three legs, a dodgy eye etc?
PC correctness won't ever accceptable in a particular age or era because times do change, women were once never allowed an opinion (I know in some countries/regimes that is unchanged) and so it goes on. Racism is quite rightly being addressed but it works against everyone irrespective of colour or creed at some point depending whose perspective it is viewed from.
There is no complete answer to what has gone on in the past but it isn't possible to obliterate it all -it is part of our history, how we lived, how we changed, what wars were fought and how we have reached the point we are at today. If we go completely woke - how on earth do we explain why we changed x, y or z? You won't be able to because history books have been re-written to fabricate a story that will appease folk. It will not give them the information to make the informed choice of their own free will that something is acceptable or not compared to what happened historically in the past.

Florenz · 19/03/2023 23:25

What are brownies in Enid Blyton? Pixies? It's not like their golliwogs and a deliberate caricature of black people. They're fantasty creatures like elves in LOTR.

BiscuitsBiscuitsEverywhere · 19/03/2023 23:14

You can be sure of one thing – this isn't going to stop. I knew Enid Blyton would be next in the firing line. And who will follow? Jane Austen? Dickens? Virginia Woolf? The left are having the time of their lives. Eventually, certain books will be declared illegal altogether, and you'll be fined for owning a copy. It will start with controversial stuff like Gone with the Wind, but it won't end there. Think I'm exaggerating? Wait and see.

Absolute utter nonsense. No one is going to fine you for owning a book FFS. Don't be ridiculous.

gloriousmulch · 19/03/2023 23:02

I probably wouldn’t change the language in EB’s books, but would consign them to the past - the attitudes represented are very out of date. It seems an odd thing to be all that bothered by, and what does ‘the woke ways’ even mean??

ReneBumsWombats · 19/03/2023 22:52

I honestly never thought about the name Brownies being insensitive. The brownie fairy figure is Scottish in origin and "brownie" is just an English pronunciation of the original name "broonie" in Scottish dialect. I think they might have been an inspiration for house elves, as they're supposed to come out and do chores for you at night but will leave if you give them clothes.

Still, if it's causing a problem then by all means change it. Embers is a bit shit though. Surely there's a better name than that.

ExtraOnions · 19/03/2023 22:47

Society changes over time, we grow as people, and, some of the laws, language and behaviours that are common, becomes outdated. It’s ok that we change .. it’s ok some language isn’t used anymore, it’s not an attack on all things “British”

There is some racist stuff in Enid Blighton, and it’s ok to take it out, in the same way we wouldn’t use the “N” word in a TV comedy anymore. Why should black children need to be exposed to racist tropes?

I am sure that of someone wants them in their full Racist glory, they can go on E-Bay and get them.

Liz1tummypain · 19/03/2023 22:38

Life moves on. That's what happens.

JoonT · 19/03/2023 22:15

You can be sure of one thing – this isn't going to stop. I knew Enid Blyton would be next in the firing line. And who will follow? Jane Austen? Dickens? Virginia Woolf? The left are having the time of their lives. Eventually, certain books will be declared illegal altogether, and you'll be fined for owning a copy. It will start with controversial stuff like Gone with the Wind, but it won't end there. Think I'm exaggerating? Wait and see.

TwilightSilhouette · 19/03/2023 22:14

Brownies isn’t changing here OP.

KimberleyClark · 19/03/2023 22:14

GuidingSpirit · 19/03/2023 21:18

Brownie leader here.

If you did any research about the name change in Canada, you would know it is because "brownies" is a racist derogatory term in Canada, which used to be used against people of colour. So a totally different scenario to here. The organisation had a vote to choose the new name because some communities felt they could not participate due to the name.

Brownies in the UK is not planning a name change.

Imagine if there was an organisation for girls in the UK called the "n" word. Of course it would have been changed before now!!! It is ridiculous to think otherwise!!

Thanks for that. I am now better informed!

cocksstrideintheevening · 19/03/2023 22:13

So boys / men can join a girls / women's group but they can't be called brownies. Ffs.

MsJD · 19/03/2023 22:12

Should Noddy and Big Ears be banned?

gazpachosoupday · 19/03/2023 22:10

I think if you took out the sexism and racism in Blyton's books you would be left with

"That was a good adventure"
The end

ColonelSpondleClagnut · 19/03/2023 22:09

Tbf I'd have loved it it Brownies had a different name when I was one.

"What did the Cub Scout find in the toilet?

"A Brownie!" 💩🙄

BiscuitsBiscuitsEverywhere · 19/03/2023 22:03

FTR I am opposed to censoring Enid Blyton's books (or any books, for that matter). EB's books should exist in their original form: racist, sexist, xenophobic. They are pretty irredeemable IMO, but if people want to read them they should see them for what they are.

Some on this thread would probably be thrilled about some kinds of censorship, e.g. the horrendous attack on public education in Florida by Ron DeSantis. He and his ilk have prohibited classroom discussion of racism and LGBTQ issues. Books have been removed from school libraries and classrooms, the Advanced Placement course on African-American history has been drastically revised under pressure from DeSantis, etc. He's a huge opponent of what he (incorrectly) calls "wokeness." But really he's just a racist and a fascist.

KindergartenKop · 19/03/2023 22:00

They changed it because girls of colour were put off/upset by the name.
If people used the word 'Brownie' as a slur against you, you'd probably want it changed too.

minou123 · 19/03/2023 21:51

GuidingSpirit · 19/03/2023 21:18

Brownie leader here.

If you did any research about the name change in Canada, you would know it is because "brownies" is a racist derogatory term in Canada, which used to be used against people of colour. So a totally different scenario to here. The organisation had a vote to choose the new name because some communities felt they could not participate due to the name.

Brownies in the UK is not planning a name change.

Imagine if there was an organisation for girls in the UK called the "n" word. Of course it would have been changed before now!!! It is ridiculous to think otherwise!!

Thank you @GuidingSpirit

You inspired me to Google 😁

Here you are Op, a link to the reason behind the name change www.girlguides.ca/WEB/GGC/branch_name_change.aspx

It's something you could have easily done before you posted this thread, but never mind.

Is it still "ridiculous wokeness"?

Swipe left for the next trending thread