Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Enid Blyton and the Brownies etc.

112 replies

EatsYummySprouts · 19/03/2023 20:16

These are things which I grew up with and loved. Now the language Enid Blyton used is not acceptable to the woke ways, and the Brownies is name changing to the Embers (in Canada)
These are just two examples of ridiculous wokeness.
I am a very open person, and am open to the beliefs of all, and sexual identity of all. But honestly, all if these rules, and that people cannot decide for themselves any more if something is okay or not is completely bonkers. AIBU???

OP posts:
rockly · 23/03/2023 17:22

OriginalUsername2 · 23/03/2023 16:55

We can’t woke-wash the past! It’s history.

Let’s take the parts about men not laying with other men out of the bible too.

Funnily enough in the 90’s my mum picked up a whole collection of these books. I read them all. I asked my mum what a the g———g dolls were and got a little history lesson on racism.

Children should be able to read books that don't make them feel alienated though, it's not "woke-washing"

I read loads of things without asking my parents to explain every detail (including Enid Blyton), in the 21st century we shouldn't have a generation of children internalising racism/classism/misogny

Different for teen and adult books

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 23/03/2023 17:01

I still.want to.swim in the Malory,.Towers,swimming pool though !

So do I! I wish I still had my Malory Towers and St Clare's books, it's making me want to read them again!

OriginalUsername2 · 23/03/2023 16:55

We can’t woke-wash the past! It’s history.

Let’s take the parts about men not laying with other men out of the bible too.

Funnily enough in the 90’s my mum picked up a whole collection of these books. I read them all. I asked my mum what a the g———g dolls were and got a little history lesson on racism.

biokult · 20/03/2023 22:04

totally agree with the difference between children and adult fiction

why should kids have to wade through sexist, racist books that make certain groups feel alienated (with their parents stopping to talk about historical context), when they should be just enjoying the magic of reading? @EatsYummySprouts

JemimaTiggywinkles · 20/03/2023 11:48

I'm not a fan of editing books, but I think there is a big difference between adult and children's fiction in this regard. Adults can be expected to understand that the language / stereotypes used in the past belong in the past, and that the world has (rightly) moved on in the last 100 years. I also that re-writing them carries its own risk of pretending that rampant misogyny / racism / homophobia never existed. On balance, therefore, I prefer books for adults to remain unchanged.

However, children's books are a completely different kettle of fish. Children absorb cultural norms from all around them, including fiction books. They may have parents who have the time to explain properly to them, but they may not. Therefore, I prefer (where possible) that the old versions are kept, and that edited versions are available too.

As for the name change - I really don't understand the problem. The name stopped a fair number of girls from joining. The people within the organisation decided to change it so that those girls could join. Fair enough, imo.

ReneBumsWombats · 20/03/2023 10:57

Her books are still in print and being read, albeit with revisions, 90-odd years later. She may not have been the greatest writer technically, and there are obvious problems that need to be addresses, but clearly she did something right.

I still read St Clares sometimes when I'm unable to get through anything more cerebral. They go down very easily.

Nooyoiknooyoik · 20/03/2023 10:33

Ah Cross post, I was beaten by other EB fans

Nooyoiknooyoik · 20/03/2023 10:25

Knullrufs · 20/03/2023 07:15

My primary school ‘banned’ Enid Blyton books in the 1980s. You’ve only just twigged that she was a racist, classist misogynist? Catch yourself on fella.

She may have been racist and sexist but it’s incorrect to say she was a bad writer. She was highly imaginative with superb, original plots. A lot of the earnest and derivative and affectedly “wacky” stuff with lots of references to farts that gets published today for 8 year olds does not come anywhere close to her deeply absorbing universe. The Faraway Tree stories still have to be some of the best children’s stories ever written. Along with the Wishing Chair.

She is dated now in many ways and my DC don’t read her books very much - though they’re not big readers anyway. They did like Malory Towers (though they commented on what bullies Darrell, Alicia and Felicity were which I had never spotted as a child) and, like most children everywhere, they loved The Faraway Tree.

HoneyPotBee · 20/03/2023 10:08

Now the language Enid Blyton used is not acceptable to the woke ways

Imagine starting a thread telling everyone that you want to be racist. 🤣

x2boys · 20/03/2023 09:46

ReneBumsWombats · 20/03/2023 09:25

For all the many, many problems with Blyton, she did have a wonderful imagination. I'd hate to lose the Faraway Tree and Wishing Chair worlds completely. I still quite enjoy the Secret Seven mysteries now my oldest is getting into them, although I don't really like the Famous Five so much.

And Darrell Rivers can fuck right off. I heard she went down for GBH.

I.imagine Darrell,Rivers as a CEO,or NHS,manager ,she had the right temprement,for it 😂
I still.want to.swim in the Malory,.Towers,swimming pool though !

ReneBumsWombats · 20/03/2023 09:25

For all the many, many problems with Blyton, she did have a wonderful imagination. I'd hate to lose the Faraway Tree and Wishing Chair worlds completely. I still quite enjoy the Secret Seven mysteries now my oldest is getting into them, although I don't really like the Famous Five so much.

And Darrell Rivers can fuck right off. I heard she went down for GBH.

x2boys · 20/03/2023 08:56

It's good *

x2boys · 20/03/2023 08:55

Knullrufs · 20/03/2023 07:15

My primary school ‘banned’ Enid Blyton books in the 1980s. You’ve only just twigged that she was a racist, classist misogynist? Catch yourself on fella.

Enid Blyton wrote about what she knew ,so all.the children in her books attended boarding ,school I guess it was normal.in her circle ,I don't disagree there is some very racist and sexist language used in the original books but I think.you have to.read them in the context.of the time it is written ,she clearly grew up in a very white ,privileged environment ,that is what she knew ,obviously times change and language changes ,but I think.it's good to be aware of language and attitudes that were acceptable in the past which are not acceptable.now.

crumpet · 20/03/2023 08:45

I disagree with brushing out, removing or editing books. Cultural context is key - pretending things didn’t exist is a bizarre outlook and leads to such a narrow framed vision of the world and its history - and society’s development.

This is not to say that views expressed in books of earlier times should be lauded either.

I’m in my 50s and even as a child EB books didn’t reflect my world. I understood even then that attitudes in the 80s were different to those in EB books. I understood that the books were dealing with a different time. Children are able to understand these contexts.

JeannieAlogy · 20/03/2023 08:34

Whenharrymetsmelly · 20/03/2023 04:16

But what if you liked these books as a child and want to pass on, but don't want the sexism, racism? I'd rather just read a book, rather than have to stop and keep pointing out how terrible people used to (and still can) be. Maybe have two versions so people who like the racism and sexism can read those too in that case. I don't see anything wrong with removing obvious negative slurs

It's not a case of liking the racism and sexism though, more that they were inherent in much of Blyton's work.

sunmonlight · 20/03/2023 08:22

JoonT · 19/03/2023 22:15

You can be sure of one thing – this isn't going to stop. I knew Enid Blyton would be next in the firing line. And who will follow? Jane Austen? Dickens? Virginia Woolf? The left are having the time of their lives. Eventually, certain books will be declared illegal altogether, and you'll be fined for owning a copy. It will start with controversial stuff like Gone with the Wind, but it won't end there. Think I'm exaggerating? Wait and see.

Hilarious

sunmonlight · 20/03/2023 08:12

Albiboba · 19/03/2023 20:52

I don’t see how either of those things mean that no one can ever think for themselves?

Things change, get over it.
If the people running Brownies found it problematic they are allowed to change the name. Frankly they can change it to Embers for whatever reason they want!

There are definitely elements of Enid Blyton that aren’t acceptable today and they should come with context Imo.
Again I don’t see how that means you can’t think what you want to think.

It comes across a little like ‘you can’t say anything that’s days!’ 9/10 times that means one thing.

This.

Pubesofsoberness · 20/03/2023 08:12

Maybebabyno2 · 19/03/2023 21:32

Please don't tell me they are changing Dick and Aunt Fannies names! Hours and hours of hilarity over their names as children. Juvenile, I know!

They did that years ago!

notsayingmuch · 20/03/2023 08:03

BigCheeseSandwich · 20/03/2023 05:58

If you never updated books or language we'd be reading texts like this: "Of Engelond, to Caunterbury they wende, The hooly blisful martir for to seke, That hem hath holpen whan that they were seeke."

Most of us did read some of that text when we were at school - it's called getting an education. If you read it out loud it is understandable and you can get readers that have a modern gloss to explain archaic word usage etc.

LimeCheesecake · 20/03/2023 07:59

Enid Blyton’s books are being/have been changed because they are so popular historically, most other children’s books of the time that don’t have the same high profile name attached to them, yet share the same racist and sexist content, have just been removed from sale. This is because good parents don’t want their children reading them and there aren’t enough parents who want to raise kids with racists views (like the OP) to make it financially worthwhile printing them.

OP, if you are under 40 you probably read edited versions of Blyton anyway, they were so bad it wasn’t just recent “wokeness “ that led to their censorship- it’s been going on for a long old time. Versions printed in the 1980s and 90s had edits.

If you think editing old books to remove unacceptable content yet still sell them is a new “woke” concept - perhaps look at the Christie book “and then there were none”- particularly the different names this book has had and the years it was changed. (Changed in 1960s then again in 1980s)

TwoLeftSocksWithHoles · 20/03/2023 07:56

Oh gawd, they'll be going after the Chocolate Brownies next...

(that's the Fudgy, Cakey, Biscuity thing. )

Neverplayleapfrogwithmrpipes · 20/03/2023 07:20

The name change of brownies in Canada is specifically a Canadian issue as the word has been used as a slur for indigenous Canadians for many years. It was stopping girls from those communities joining guiding.

Knullrufs · 20/03/2023 07:15

My primary school ‘banned’ Enid Blyton books in the 1980s. You’ve only just twigged that she was a racist, classist misogynist? Catch yourself on fella.

BigCheeseSandwich · 20/03/2023 05:58

If you never updated books or language we'd be reading texts like this: "Of Engelond, to Caunterbury they wende, The hooly blisful martir for to seke, That hem hath holpen whan that they were seeke."

Swipe left for the next trending thread