Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People who identify as Trans Abled …

212 replies

TequilaSunrose · 19/03/2023 19:54

We have all head about transgender, but recently I’ve heard more and more about transableism. These are healthy people who think they were born in the wrong body and that they should have been born into a disabled persons body.

Surely this is the line. People cannot identify as disabled. People cannot pretend to be disabled. This is the point we must say that this is now mental illness. You cannot just go around identifying as whatever you want.

AIBU to say this is ridiculous and must be stamped out and the fact it even has a name is insanity.

OP posts:
sweetcomicvalentine · 19/03/2023 22:04

Isn't some of the limb stuff linked to e.g. alien hand syndrome? That has a basis in neurology - can happen after certain epilepsy surgeries for example to feel your hand doesn't belong to you and have no control over its movements. Think it has a lot to do with the frontal lobe.

Could see that if you felt your arm or leg didn't belong to you... maybe a similar sort of issue - where it's less societal and more some sort of mental illness or something to do with the brain?

It's 'amazing' (awful) what brain damage can do, have a relative with frontal lobe damage who was utterly convinced her mother was dead, despite looking at her mother - and later insisted her daughter was a clone/imposter. Was utterly convinced in the latter to the extent her daughter couldn't be in the same room as her as was threatening violence.

It would make sense that certain types of neurological damage/psychiatric illness with a more neurological basis such as psychosis/schziophrenia could lead to feelings of thinking one ought to be disabled...

It is confusing though. Recently did fairly intensive training on mental illness by a person who was insistent mental illness did NOT exist as a neurological/biological thing in itself and that it was always a reaction to trauma or being somehow marginalisied in society, and to medicalise it was wrong, that the solution lay in solving all society's problems. That to me is bull, and a far more dangerous way of thinking. Mental illness very much does exist, and it is in no way always linked to some sort of trauma.

marchella · 19/03/2023 22:02

The person who gets around in a wheelchair is also an academic at a university, Her name is Chloe Jennings-White

Laura856 · 19/03/2023 22:01

Do you mean people who self-diagnose?

MotherOfPuffling · 19/03/2023 21:59

fgdk · 19/03/2023 21:49

@MotherOfPuffling oh wow, there really is no hope then is there?!

Don’t! My fear is that how this mental illness is treated could go very weird. Back when I studied it, the broad approach was to avoid surgery etc. unless the person was pretty much at the stage of taking a hacksaw to themselves. Focus was on therapy (talking, drugs etc.) Essentially it was seen as extreme self harm. Someone mentioned munchausens and it is a type. With this talk of people ‘self identifying’ as disabled though, will this mental illness now be pandered to? That… doesn’t feel like it would be a good idea…

dawngreen · 19/03/2023 21:58

But don't they keep going until they die from taking some thing to make them ill.

Justalittlebitduckling · 19/03/2023 21:56

I remember this was on an episode of casualty or something like that years ago. I think they did amputate the limb in the end.

dawngreen · 19/03/2023 21:55

Different illnesses can affect a persons weight. I don't agree with hospital staff reading the riot act to patients that do smoke, While they smell of smoke after standing smoking at the entrance.

SaySomethingMan · 19/03/2023 21:53

TequilaSunrose · 19/03/2023 21:32

Bet they then got treatment on the NHS for this self inflicted wound! Definitely not acceptable

Should people who smoke be treated by the NHS? How about those who are obese? Addicts?

moveoverye · 19/03/2023 21:50

This is just Munchausen’s.

fgdk · 19/03/2023 21:49

@MotherOfPuffling oh wow, there really is no hope then is there?!

OnTheThames · 19/03/2023 21:49

All of this ‘identifying as’ shit needs to be treated as what it is - lunacy.

These people aren’t well and should not be indulged.

dawngreen · 19/03/2023 21:47

Sadly they are sick ppl who would be happy to chop bits off for them. People are strange.

MotherOfPuffling · 19/03/2023 21:47

fgdk · 19/03/2023 21:37

I'm assuming someone has come up with this to show what a mockery the trans stuff is. Like the bloke that went to court over his age. Publicity stunt?

Nope, was studying this nearly 30 years ago!

MsFogi · 19/03/2023 21:46

I think that logic dictates that if you can identify as the opposite sex there is no reason why you should not be able to identify as anything else - disabled, younger/older, a different race or culture etc etc. At the moment the main impact of self-id has been on women and the only people really speaking up about it have been middle-aged women so no one has cared or listened and instead have attacked the women who have been raising concerns about the impact on women's rights and safeguarding of children. However, there may come a tipping point - people other than middle aged women just may be horrified if self-identification seeps into other 'identities'.

mamacattiva · 19/03/2023 21:46

MoirasSaggyBundles · 19/03/2023 21:35

We live in a time where being "the norm" - in the West, that is white, heterosexual, NT, no disabilities- is not interesting and is viewed as "privileged" - i.e., it makes you inherently a bad person. All teenagers are expected to be Greta Thunberg, otherwise they are wasting their time. Victimhood is not something to be transcended, something one can triumph over, but is something to be celebrated, wallowed in, and attracts kudos and social capital amongst peers that a "normal" uneventful life will never bring you. This is why today's insecure young is finding any way to make themselves "special" in some way. This is just another step on the transgender, trans-racial road to hell.

This is it. Everyone is desperate to be oppressed, and not be labelled an oppressor.

MotherOfPuffling · 19/03/2023 21:45

It is a form of mental illness/ I remember studying it many years ago as an undergrad. Deeply disturbing, and challenging ethical questions regarding the surgeons asked to maim physically healthy people.

dawngreen · 19/03/2023 21:45

I suppose some people who feel alone see pictures of ill ppl being cared for by crowds of ppl. Then feel jealous or some thing and decide to make their life the same.

Crutcher · 19/03/2023 21:45

It's a logical extension of the whole identity nonsense. The correct response to 'I identify as' should be 'who gives a shit?'

You either are or you aren't, and that is something that can be objectively determined. But merely that someone identifies, aka thinks they are, something, who cares? It's a free country, you can think whatever you want in your head, but that's all the implications it should ever have - your own fantasy.

Beelezebub · 19/03/2023 21:44

I find the concept so utterly beyond offensive that I can’t articulate just how deeply awful it is

DeadbeatYoda · 19/03/2023 21:43

It's mental illness, not identity politics. There are people out there that think they are Jesus Christ, doesn't mean we are all going to have to put our Jesus status on our email sign offs.

BellePeppa · 19/03/2023 21:40

stbrandonsboat · 19/03/2023 21:34

I think there's a big difference between people who are genuinely mentally ill with psychosis and severe depression and these transabled people who appear to be suffering from some sort of neuroses. People in other parts of the world can't afford to be so neurotic about things, they're too busy just trying to survive. I'd hazard a guess that these situations only occur in western society. People need to get a grip, it's becoming seriously embarrassing.

You definitely have a point. People who are literally fighting for survival day in day out don’t have the navel gazing luxury of choosing which of the million genders they want to identify as or fussing about being called ‘they/them’. It’s mostly a lot of self indulgent nonsense by people who don’t feel special enough just to be ordinary. (I don’t mean genuinely mentally ill people) just the stuff and nonsense of the Sam Smiths of the world.

Didactylos · 19/03/2023 21:39

Well, that was a complete linkage failure. Lets try again....

www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2000/12/a-new-way-to-be-mad/304671/

Didactylos · 19/03/2023 21:38

attraction to the idea of being an amputee This article in the Atlantic from 2000 is interesting (and I think there might be a documentary on it too

The article details a rise in apotemnophilia"—an attraction to the idea of being an amputee," and the issues around providing surgery for this.
There are a lot of parallels to current 'trans' issues - the consideration of whether the body modification arises from a paraphilia and how this should be responded to, the rise in demand being led by communities developing on the then nascent internet. The gender specialist psychiatrist Russel Reid in was involved in promoting surgery for these individuals as analogous to providing body modification for individuals expressing a transgender identity. (Its worth noting Russel Reid was disgraced and found guilty of serious professional misconduct in 2007 for hurrying people into 'sex changes' with recommendations being made for treatment on inital appointments, without appropriate exploration, investigation and diagnosis)

Its very clear to see the injustice of and impact of able bodied people being able to claim a disabled identity, with or without modifying their otherwise healthy body to experience or simulate a functional impairment.

The ethics of converting a functioning body to one with impairment aside, its clear that these individuals put pressure on and compete for the limited resources available for disabled people in our society with those who have not had the luxury of choosing the condition they live with - and the general attitude to this is outrage at the injustice of the situation and the selfishness and entitlement of the apotemnophiles. It surprises me that more people cannot see how analogous this is to the issues of trans inclusion in single sexed spaces and resources.

fgdk · 19/03/2023 21:37

I'm assuming someone has come up with this to show what a mockery the trans stuff is. Like the bloke that went to court over his age. Publicity stunt?

Whammyyammy · 19/03/2023 21:36

Well, it's the same as transgender in my eyes, and therefore should be accepted thr same way, including entitlement to disability benefits.
I don't agree with transgender or transabled, or anyone identifying as a tin opener etc. But we either completely stop this nonsense or completely get on board! Can't have it half-way