Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People who identify as Trans Abled …

212 replies

TequilaSunrose · 19/03/2023 19:54

We have all head about transgender, but recently I’ve heard more and more about transableism. These are healthy people who think they were born in the wrong body and that they should have been born into a disabled persons body.

Surely this is the line. People cannot identify as disabled. People cannot pretend to be disabled. This is the point we must say that this is now mental illness. You cannot just go around identifying as whatever you want.

AIBU to say this is ridiculous and must be stamped out and the fact it even has a name is insanity.

OP posts:
AndTheSurveySays · 19/03/2023 22:21

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=t2K-O_9OqtE&bpctr=1679266247

The Dr Phil episode with the woman that blinded herself ^

sweetcomicvalentine · 19/03/2023 22:21

DoubleShotEspresso · 19/03/2023 22:18

When can we start identifying this nonsense for what it is?

Fraudulent behaviour that should and could warrant mental health assessments and sectioning.

I think in this case of this, most people do!

Although I'd be hesitant of describing any mental illness as nonsense (or indeed lunacy as someone said up thread), it clearly has massive implications for the patient and they deserve the correct, evidence based treatment and respect as much as anyone else with any illness or disorder.

GoingMadQuickly · 19/03/2023 22:21

GoingMadQuickly · 19/03/2023 22:20

Nor sure if it has already been mentioned but sounds like this:

Just seen it has (my mumsnet isn't loading properly for some reason so only shows the OP unless I refresh 20 times!)

RumandSpinach · 19/03/2023 22:21

I knew someone who wanted their arm gone. They very much wanted it gone and worked quite hard to remove it. Very gruesome.

It's really hard to understand but definitely a real and distressing feeling. I think there is space between folk like this and people who campaign for a DID/Eating Disorder/other mental illness diagnosis.

GoingMadQuickly · 19/03/2023 22:20

Desertbarncat · 19/03/2023 20:00

I’ve never heard of this, do you have examples of how it is becoming an issue?

Nor sure if it has already been mentioned but sounds like this:

DoubleShotEspresso · 19/03/2023 22:18

When can we start identifying this nonsense for what it is?

Fraudulent behaviour that should and could warrant mental health assessments and sectioning.

AndTheSurveySays · 19/03/2023 22:18

The woman that blinded herself did an interview about it on the Dr Phil show years ago. She said that from a young age age she always felt that she should've been born blind and would often pretend to be.

herecomesthsun · 19/03/2023 22:17

stbrandonsboat · 19/03/2023 21:34

I think there's a big difference between people who are genuinely mentally ill with psychosis and severe depression and these transabled people who appear to be suffering from some sort of neuroses. People in other parts of the world can't afford to be so neurotic about things, they're too busy just trying to survive. I'd hazard a guess that these situations only occur in western society. People need to get a grip, it's becoming seriously embarrassing.

Well, Cotard's syndrome is found in some people with severe depression. it is a psychosis (Psychotic depression). You don't get much more severely ill than that.

Some of these other ideas regarding altered reality could be found in people with psychosis or severe depression. And psychosis and severe depression can be found in other societies than Western.

sweetcomicvalentine · 19/03/2023 22:17

qpmz · 19/03/2023 22:13

Where have you heard about it? This sounds made up. There is no link.

Look up body integrity identity disorder, bits on google -

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3326051/

rare, but a definite thing, with its roots thought to lie in differences within the brain (think one link says they think linked to issues with parietal lobe).

Of course, diagnosis by WebMD and Tiktok might mean that increasing numbers of people are deciding they have it.. but still think it must be pretty unusual.

whatkatydid2013 · 19/03/2023 22:16

Bryzzle · 19/03/2023 22:06

What a transparent excuse for a transphobic pile on. Why the flying fuck does anyone care what anyone else is doing to their own bodies?! Don't like it? Great, don't do it to yourself then. Jesus wept. Get a life.

Does anyone who doesn’t want to have their perfectly functioning arm cut off honestly believe that someone who does want to isn’t suffering from a pretty serious mental illness? Surely even if we don’t have a way to treat it for now the long term aim should be to find a way fix whatever is causing the individuals delusion and not to maim them?

StalkedByASpider · 19/03/2023 22:16

qpmz · 19/03/2023 22:13

Where have you heard about it? This sounds made up. There is no link.

I commented above - I saw a documentary about this many years ago but I've not seen anything recently.

A quick google shows an article from the National Post in 2015 which basically says the same as what I remember from the documentary - healthy people were injuring limbs in an attempt to get surgeons to agree to amputate etc.

It's definitely true - but I think it's exceedingly rare.

nationalpost.com/news/canada/becoming-disabled-by-choice-not-chance-transabled-people-feel-like-impostors-in-their-fully-working-bodies

JacquelinePot · 19/03/2023 22:15

Sorry is someone has already poated, I haven't rtft...this isn't a new thing. Five this fascinating article from 2000 a read and boggle.

Agree with others who have said this is no more outlandish than any other claims to be something other than what one really is.

https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2000/12/a-new-way-to-be-mad/304671/

Advicerequest · 19/03/2023 22:15

Once identity is delinked with anything physically verififiable and is subjective there really is nothing shocking about trans anything. I'm as much a man as I am a ten year old, a cat or chinese

Stopsnowing · 19/03/2023 22:14

I have moved from thinking on the trans debate let people identify as whatever as long as they don’t consider they actually are what they are not to thinking that identifying as something is massively offensive. White people who identified as black would not be tolerated, so why transgender stuff?

Minimummonday · 19/03/2023 22:14

@Bryzzlemust be a man as resorted to ‘rabid’ = hysterical female as his only retort

marchella · 19/03/2023 22:13

Jesus may well be. You are also conveniently ignoring the societal and medical impact of the use of resources. Sure, if you want to buy yourself a wheelchair to get around in then go for it, although I bet they'd stop if they were dropped in a desert for a week or two. The self- indulgence of parts of Western society makes me very sad.

qpmz · 19/03/2023 22:13

Where have you heard about it? This sounds made up. There is no link.

KeeperSweeper · 19/03/2023 22:13

Is this really much of a thing? Just googled it and there are a couple of articles, but years old.

Bryzzle · 19/03/2023 22:12

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Rabid.

StalkedByASpider · 19/03/2023 22:12

I watched a documentary on this years and years ago. It was in America but I remember there was a woman in it who felt that she shouldn't have two legs. She lived in a flat and she had to live for a year or whatever in a wheelchair to see if she could cope before they would agree to the surgery to cut off her leg - funnily enough, the same way that gender non-conforming men used to have to live as a woman for a year etc before being granted gender reassignment surgery. (I don't know what the rules are now....)

I was horrified at the time that a surgeon would chop off a healthy leg just because the person identified as disabled.

The documentary was really disturbing. There were people who were doing all kinds of things to themselves to try and cause a traumatic injury that would allow the offending limb to be removed. It was accepted as a mental illness but some surgeons seem to agree that the only "treatment" would be to remove the limb. And yes, there are absolute parallels with trans surgery now - even though that's not a view that we're supposed to hold because feelings = reality....

TequilaSunrose · 19/03/2023 22:09

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Minimummonday · 19/03/2023 22:09

@Bryzzle you think it’s ok that society approves you can cut your arm off with a chainsaw, pour bleach into your eyes or cut off your penis because of mental illness? What happened to looking after people?

Bryzzle · 19/03/2023 22:06

What a transparent excuse for a transphobic pile on. Why the flying fuck does anyone care what anyone else is doing to their own bodies?! Don't like it? Great, don't do it to yourself then. Jesus wept. Get a life.

Worried234 · 19/03/2023 22:05

The fuck? Nope.

NewCarOldCar · 19/03/2023 22:04

dawngreen · 19/03/2023 21:47

Sadly they are sick ppl who would be happy to chop bits off for them. People are strange.

Like people willing to chop off penises you mean?

No different to this as to thinking you should/shouldn't have been born with an extra genital

It is all beyond human thinking

Swipe left for the next trending thread