Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People who identify as Trans Abled …

212 replies

TequilaSunrose · 19/03/2023 19:54

We have all head about transgender, but recently I’ve heard more and more about transableism. These are healthy people who think they were born in the wrong body and that they should have been born into a disabled persons body.

Surely this is the line. People cannot identify as disabled. People cannot pretend to be disabled. This is the point we must say that this is now mental illness. You cannot just go around identifying as whatever you want.

AIBU to say this is ridiculous and must be stamped out and the fact it even has a name is insanity.

OP posts:
Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 19/03/2023 22:55

Stepuptowardsinfinity · 19/03/2023 20:27

The pink news article mentions a man who is transabled and wants his penis removed but fails to recognize the irony. For those unaware, pink news is hugely pro trans. In the meantime, I am identifying as trans-parent. Now I am invisible you must pretend not to see me at all times.

😂

Boomboom22 · 19/03/2023 22:54

I do think both serious mh issues exist and also that people pretend / identify into illnesses. Did I'm not convinced definitely exists but generally same, some prob genuine and many want to be special.

Boomboom22 · 19/03/2023 22:53

I think that's the point, like gender dysphoria used to be recognised as a serious mental illness with trans surgery being a last resort when treatment failed but has now been normalised to the point you don't need intervention, so is this illness also being identified into so the logical conclusion is accepting them as disabled without needing to damage themselves to be accepted by society as what they believe they are. Like we do for isla bryson etc.

Lemonandorange · 19/03/2023 22:49

Is this the same as those people who actively seek to be disabled? Like that woman who poured bleach into her eyes because she wanted to be blind? She had perfectly healthy vision but she wanted to be blind, she used a cane and walked around with her eyes shut even before she became blind.

I believe this is an actually recognised mental disorder, I can't remember the name but I recall watching a documentary about it, another person chopped their own arm off because they felt they should have been an amputee and that their arm wasn't actually part of their body

Minimummonday · 19/03/2023 22:39

The ignorance on this thread is eye opening. Didn’t realise Daily Mail readers had another place to hang out online! Before you spread this hateful rhetoric without a shred of personal experience, please look to meet and talk with at least one real life person who can give you some kind of personal insight. I’m astounded by the comments here

@SaysRelaaxxx You want people to meet with someone who believes they’re disabled when they’re not to gain personal insight? Why?

MonkeypuzzleClimber · 19/03/2023 22:39

It seems there may actually be a neurological impairment underlying this.

To put it simply we all have an internal neurological ‘body image’. Phantom limb pain/feeling is common after amputations, as this internal body image still contains the missing limb.

In body integrity identity disorder brain scans have shown less grey matter in the area corresponding to the offending limb.

In a related delusional disorder, Somatoparaphrenia, the person denies ownership of a limb or an entire side of their body. This is similarly linked to damage or deficiency in related areas of the brain.

I have migraines which as a teen and young adult causes a sensory condition called Alice In Wonder Land Syndrome, which in my case amongst other symptoms temporarily made parts of my body feel much larger and others smaller than actually are. I was aware mine was a sensory illusion (though at the time I didn’t have a name for it), but definitely helps me understand how someone suffering from a permanent neurological impairment could feel a part of their body was alien to them. As ditalini said, the brain is indeed a wonderful and terrible thing!

rampagingrobot · 19/03/2023 22:38

Who else doesn't require NHS treatment? What about anorexics. They "do it to themselves". Shall we not treat them? What someone injured in a failed suicide attempt?

Let's just not treat anyone with a mental illness, would that make you happy?

Livinginanotherworld · 19/03/2023 22:36

As a disabled person I am appalled by this. What kind of sick vile creatures do this ? This is now beyond a joke…..try living my life on a daily basis, they would soon change their minds.

Boomboom22 · 19/03/2023 22:35

Did i hear that video right, the psych Dr told her to research it and then put the drops in her eye himself? And they didn't go to er for 30 mins? Sounds off to me and very much like he blinded her not poured drain cleaner in her own eyes?

HelloWorldMessage · 19/03/2023 22:34

@Bryzzle in a way I take your point - it should not really be my business/concern what other people (who are not in my immediate family) do with their bodies. It is their business/concern.

However, when (typically) these men truly believe they are women and insist others should think the same and try to share single sex spaces with me then it DOES become my business. It also becomes my business when they wish to compete with me in sports.

stbrandonsboat · 19/03/2023 22:32

sweetcomicvalentine · 19/03/2023 22:04

Isn't some of the limb stuff linked to e.g. alien hand syndrome? That has a basis in neurology - can happen after certain epilepsy surgeries for example to feel your hand doesn't belong to you and have no control over its movements. Think it has a lot to do with the frontal lobe.

Could see that if you felt your arm or leg didn't belong to you... maybe a similar sort of issue - where it's less societal and more some sort of mental illness or something to do with the brain?

It's 'amazing' (awful) what brain damage can do, have a relative with frontal lobe damage who was utterly convinced her mother was dead, despite looking at her mother - and later insisted her daughter was a clone/imposter. Was utterly convinced in the latter to the extent her daughter couldn't be in the same room as her as was threatening violence.

It would make sense that certain types of neurological damage/psychiatric illness with a more neurological basis such as psychosis/schziophrenia could lead to feelings of thinking one ought to be disabled...

It is confusing though. Recently did fairly intensive training on mental illness by a person who was insistent mental illness did NOT exist as a neurological/biological thing in itself and that it was always a reaction to trauma or being somehow marginalisied in society, and to medicalise it was wrong, that the solution lay in solving all society's problems. That to me is bull, and a far more dangerous way of thinking. Mental illness very much does exist, and it is in no way always linked to some sort of trauma.

I would hazard a guess that the cases that are caused by a genuine neurological problem are quite rare. I think it's a psychosocial phenomenon in many cases. Like mass hysteria. Stuff like this is socially contagious.

RumandSpinach · 19/03/2023 22:32

ForTheLoveOfSleep · 19/03/2023 22:29

So where is the line then? Adults identifying as children to get into primary schools? Identifying as another race? Identifying as the owner of someone else's property therefore it's theirs? Identifying as a Dr? A god? A predatory animal with killing instincts?

Sounds ridiculous right? Because it is.

These people believe they are something they are not. This is a mental illness. A dangerous mental illness.

By transphobic I assume you are referring to the transwoman debate? So I'll clear it up for you. A transwoman is just that. A Transwoman. Not a woman. It's not transphobic to say this. Transwomenn deserve the same respect and dignity as everybody else. That said, trans rights do not trump women's rights. When you start to erode the rights of women to satisfy the feelings of biological males (no matter how they "see themselves" or feel) you are going backwards.

None if your fictional examples have anything to do with the OP, nice slippery slope argument though.

GilbertNo4 · 19/03/2023 22:30

I'm an amputee. Admin for a couple of FB amp groups. Often get 'wannabees' trying yo join.

ForTheLoveOfSleep · 19/03/2023 22:29

Bryzzle · 19/03/2023 22:06

What a transparent excuse for a transphobic pile on. Why the flying fuck does anyone care what anyone else is doing to their own bodies?! Don't like it? Great, don't do it to yourself then. Jesus wept. Get a life.

So where is the line then? Adults identifying as children to get into primary schools? Identifying as another race? Identifying as the owner of someone else's property therefore it's theirs? Identifying as a Dr? A god? A predatory animal with killing instincts?

Sounds ridiculous right? Because it is.

These people believe they are something they are not. This is a mental illness. A dangerous mental illness.

By transphobic I assume you are referring to the transwoman debate? So I'll clear it up for you. A transwoman is just that. A Transwoman. Not a woman. It's not transphobic to say this. Transwomenn deserve the same respect and dignity as everybody else. That said, trans rights do not trump women's rights. When you start to erode the rights of women to satisfy the feelings of biological males (no matter how they "see themselves" or feel) you are going backwards.

LollipopViolet · 19/03/2023 22:28

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

OK OP, I'm wading in here as someone who is visually impaired.

The lady mentioned, is BLIND. Doesn't matter how it happened, if you have vision below a certain level, you are medically classified as blind. Your comments referring to "naturally blind" are NASTY and offensive. I say this as someone born with a sight condition that affects every aspect of life. Do you know what was written on my registration document by the consultant? Partially blind. So kindly stop, you have no right to tell someone they cannot use the word blind.

Back on topic, I am really, really uncomfortable with this idea of trans-able. I wouldn't wish my disability and the issues it causes on anyone. Anyone who WANTS that, needs serious mental health support - and yes, that should be available on the NHS.

JacquelinePot · 19/03/2023 22:28

Not sure if this has already been shared either, BBC Horizon documentary from 2000 entitled Body Dysmorphia: Complete Obsession

https://www.veoh.com/watch/v15555821DTx4AaNp

RumandSpinach · 19/03/2023 22:28

Bryzzle · 19/03/2023 22:24

Obviously I wasn't referring to people maiming themselves with chainsaws. As if this thread is anything to do with genuine care for humanity.
If that were the case all those so deeply concerned would instead be researching and firing emails off to their local MPs or other representatives. I'm a pretty GC individual but this is such a sad thinly veiled excuse. Enjoy what's left of mother's day, take a breath, and put down the phone

You're right, it's a leering pile on.

marchella · 19/03/2023 22:28

That "doctor" who put the eyedrops in should be in gaol. Also, note how she says she found a group online. It's always the same.

ticklemepinker · 19/03/2023 22:27

Sst1234 you are not right. I visited a family in a very remote part of a developing country where the daughter in law was (to my mind) having a psychotic episode, but to hers/theirs, identified as/thought she was a monkey. She was swinging in trees. It was completely horrifying and shocking and they were trying to find someone to cure her - they believed she had been bewitched into this.
It was terrible and not a whim. Mental illness in poor countries w no access to medicine or therapies is beyond terrible.

StressedToTheMaxxx · 19/03/2023 22:27

I'd say that people can 'identify' as whatever they like but legally, you'll be treated as what you are on paper.

Spambod · 19/03/2023 22:27

Sadly this isn’t new. The unquestioning acceptance and promotion of transgenderism inevitably leads to other forms of identity politics. We have people identifying as animals and most worryingly as babies and young children. So many people have highlighted this and been shot down and called bigoted.
can you imagine a grown man saying he is a toddler and wanting childcare…. Don’t think it’s going to happen? Think again.
children have been put on puberty blockers, teenagers have had healthy body parts removed by the nhs because they say they are the opposite sex ( the tavi stock clinic has only now been closed because of whistleblowers and was audited once in 20 years) What is the difference in saying you want a leg or arm or eyes removed?

cherrychappstick · 19/03/2023 22:26

I'm really confused 🤯

Bryzzle · 19/03/2023 22:24

Obviously I wasn't referring to people maiming themselves with chainsaws. As if this thread is anything to do with genuine care for humanity.
If that were the case all those so deeply concerned would instead be researching and firing emails off to their local MPs or other representatives. I'm a pretty GC individual but this is such a sad thinly veiled excuse. Enjoy what's left of mother's day, take a breath, and put down the phone

RumandSpinach · 19/03/2023 22:24

sweetcomicvalentine · 19/03/2023 22:21

I think in this case of this, most people do!

Although I'd be hesitant of describing any mental illness as nonsense (or indeed lunacy as someone said up thread), it clearly has massive implications for the patient and they deserve the correct, evidence based treatment and respect as much as anyone else with any illness or disorder.

Agreed

You might not have psychosis if you put bleach in your eyes, but I would be very surprised if you didn't have a personality disorder.

Sectioning won't help but this will still be a person who very desperately needs treatment

SaysRelaaxxx · 19/03/2023 22:23

The ignorance on this thread is eye opening. Didn’t realise Daily Mail readers had another place to hang out online! Before you spread this hateful rhetoric without a shred of personal experience, please look to meet and talk with at least one real life person who can give you some kind of personal insight. I’m astounded by the comments here.