Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People who identify as Trans Abled …

212 replies

TequilaSunrose · 19/03/2023 19:54

We have all head about transgender, but recently I’ve heard more and more about transableism. These are healthy people who think they were born in the wrong body and that they should have been born into a disabled persons body.

Surely this is the line. People cannot identify as disabled. People cannot pretend to be disabled. This is the point we must say that this is now mental illness. You cannot just go around identifying as whatever you want.

AIBU to say this is ridiculous and must be stamped out and the fact it even has a name is insanity.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Advicerequest · 26/03/2023 08:45

I don't think we know whether people in developing countries have half the whims we have as they would be expressed in different ways - or, if completely socially unacceptable, hidden.

Willyoujustbequiet · 23/03/2023 11:10

I know quite a few people plaster all over social media that they are autistic or have ADHD when they clearly don't and have been told on assessment they don't meet the diagnostic criteria (know them well and have experience in this area)

Its attention seeking behaviour. They want to be a victim in some form. Ime its younger generations. I find it utterly bizarre.

TobeLeRone · 20/03/2023 18:28

Justalittlebitduckling · 19/03/2023 21:56

I remember this was on an episode of casualty or something like that years ago. I think they did amputate the limb in the end.

This has probably been said before, but iirc the limb was amputated because the man went and stuck it under a train, mangling it beyond repair.

TheKeatingFive · 20/03/2023 11:16

I read about this many years ago, it's been around in the margins forever. For what it's worth, I'm sure people genuinely feel like this. That doesn't mean we should accommodate it in any way - to do so would be very offensive to genuinely disabled people.

Anyone who feels like this should get therapy.

All these conditions where people want to 'identify' into something they're not should be treated the same way, transgender, trans race, trans age. There's no justification for accommodating some and not others.

stbrandonsboat · 20/03/2023 10:57

People are infantilised now. Toddlers and young children like to pretend their fluffy animals or whatever, now we have adults doing it too. These people are not functioning adults and will not be able to hold down jobs or undertake other adult responsibilities.

There's a massive difference between psychosis and being a self indulgent navel gazer. Not all of these people are clinically delusional, they're just refusing to grow up and prefer to live out their fantasies instead.

Always4Brenner · 20/03/2023 09:54

SilverGlitterBaubles · 19/03/2023 20:39

Teen DCs say that this is a thing in school fuelled by the internet and SM where some kids are trying to out do each other with more and more bizarre labels or something to identify as. One girl has identified as a dolphin for a while now and another has identified as a fox and has an actual tail. The teachers are just supposed to go along with this nonsense. The pendulum has swung way too far.

I give up I really do, I pity the five year olds now what’s it going to be like when they reach year 7 in school.

Naunet · 20/03/2023 09:41

I fucking hate these offensive, naval gazing larpers

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 20/03/2023 09:39

Headoutofplace · 19/03/2023 21:22

The line should clearly be that no-one should be able to identify as something biological/physical that they biologically/physically aren't. Once you say one type of self-ID is ok then all have to be ok, else that's grossly unfair. It seems breathtakingly arrogant that a man can declare he's a woman and no-one should be arguing but can also decide that a 40-year old isn't allowed to self ID as a 5-year old. (I don't agree with self ID in either case to be clear!)

Exactly. This is why the Gender Recognition Act was so harmful - the Law started pretending to believe a lie, and forcing the rest of us to pretend to believe it. That is a much bigger issue than the small number of people (so far) who have obtained Gender Recognition Certificates.

Once you allow the Law to enforce compliance with something that everyone knows is a lie, you have fundamentally undermined the integrity of the Law.

This is different from other legal fictions e.g. adoption - the law recognises the adoptive parents as having the rights that biological parents would normally have, but it doesn't force anyone to pretend that the child isn't adopted or forbid mention of the adoption process. By contrast, it is now a criminal offence under the Data Protection Act 2018 for an organisation to disclose someone's gender identity, even inadvertently. They have made it a crime to tell the truth.

KimberleyClark · 20/03/2023 09:01

It may have a neurological basis in some cases. Like phantom pain in an amputated limb, the brain thinks the limb is still there. So perhaps someone could feel that their limb shouldn’t be there because their brain doesn’t recognise it. Not sure amputation is the answer in this case though.

Mitsahne · 20/03/2023 08:58

Well it's all batshit. Transsexualism, transracism, transableism. It's denial of reality which is you are born as you are born and you can't change it. Why is a healthy person saying they identify as a sick person more batshit than a man saying he feels like a woman? It's all fucking bollocks.

Mrsjayy · 20/03/2023 08:50

TequilaSunrose · 19/03/2023 19:54

We have all head about transgender, but recently I’ve heard more and more about transableism. These are healthy people who think they were born in the wrong body and that they should have been born into a disabled persons body.

Surely this is the line. People cannot identify as disabled. People cannot pretend to be disabled. This is the point we must say that this is now mental illness. You cannot just go around identifying as whatever you want.

AIBU to say this is ridiculous and must be stamped out and the fact it even has a name is insanity.

I'm a "proper " disabled person and this isn't new its been bubbling away for years. Some of it is a fetish < shudder> other I think is a mental illness .I read something years ago that people try and amputate limbs ! It's very bizarre.

Kernackered · 20/03/2023 08:46

sst1234 · 19/03/2023 20:00

It is no more ridiculous than a man saying he is a woman or vice versa. It’s simply that somehow there is a debate about transgenderism when there really should be no debate. A man cannot be a woman, and a woman cannot be a man. Period.

No doubt, this this trans ableism nonsense will become a debate when there is nothing to debate. I guess the lowest common denominator in intelligence is now so low in Western society that it takes this kind of nonsense for people to feel special. Giving themselves a label.

If anything, I'd say it's less ridiculous than transgenderism. I mean obviously it's abhorrent, but if you ARE going to chop a leg off or pour acid into your eyes, I guess you are now disabled. No matter how stupid that was. But if you chop your penis off you still don't become a woman and if you pour testosterone don't your throat you still don't become a man.

Whatsnewpussyhat · 20/03/2023 07:51

It is a form of mental illness/ I remember studying it many years ago as an undergrad. Deeply disturbing, and challenging ethical questions regarding the surgeons asked to maim physically healthy people

Yet it's now perfectly acceptable to cut off the healthy breasts off teenage girls or man's penis because they say so.
Completely unethical.

It's no different to gender identity. Only children are now actively encouraged, even at school, to dissociate from their body. Hailed as heroes, applauded for being brave etc.
It is not kind or healthy to pander to delusion or mental illness.

Binglebong · 20/03/2023 00:52

Rinoachicken 💐

I'm very glad you're doing well now. Look after yourself.

Binglebong · 20/03/2023 00:51

For those interested in Cotard's Harry Bingham's Fiona Griffiths series has the main character suffer from it (mostly cured). No idea how realistic but great books.

Rinoachicken · 20/03/2023 00:46

ok so I have personal experience of this.

i have a long history of mental illness, thankfully now very well managed, but that wasn’t always the case.

During one episode of psychosis about 20yrs ago, I became convinced that I want real, that I had no bones, no skeleton, that I was just stuck inside a sort of person suit looking out through the eyeholes. Now, this was actually severe dissociation which tipped into psychosis, but of course being in it I was not aware of this - I fully believed I was correct and that the people around me didn’t believe me was very distressing to me.

It got to the point I was very very close to attempting to cut off my own arm, with an axe, to prove to everyone that there was nothing inside. To me, it was a completely logical thing to do and once I’d thought of it I was full of relief that finally I could prove that I was right.

Thankfully (and I am SO thankful) I was sectioned, medicated, and in time regained connection with my body and was no longer in a psychotic or dissociative state.

I am horrified to think that if that had happened today, and I had ventured online, I would have been encouraged to do it.

I didn’t need to cut off my arm - I needed urgent psychiatric care - and I am very glad I live in the UK and was able to receive it.

Sarahcoggles · 20/03/2023 00:11

IClaudine · 19/03/2023 20:55

Pretty soon paedophiles will start to identify as children so they can play in parks, join brownies/cubs, play in kids sports teams, go to soft play on their own and play with the kids

I bet my house that this is not going to happen.

I have a feeling this thread won't be around for too long.

I agree the thread won’t be around long, but why are you so sure paedophiles won’t use self ID to their own advantage? Some men are already using it to access women’s spaces.

ThereIbledit · 20/03/2023 00:10

As a woman who has disabilities, I'm weary. I'm not any more offended by transableism as I am transgenderism, it is a logical extension if you believe that people can be female gender in a male sexed body. Both are offensive to me. My sex and my disabilities are not yours to co-opt, and if you seriously believe you are something you are biologically not the solution is mental health treatment, not physical adjustment, and not forcing others to buy into your delusions.

VerityUnreasonble · 20/03/2023 00:03

I would quite like to be trans-abled if possible and just identify out of the physical and mental health conditions that are a massive pain in the arse for me.

Sadly, I am not sure I can identify the symptoms away quite as easily as people seem to identify symptoms in.

(That said I have a lot of sympathy for those with significant dysmorphia of any sort, must be awful and would be great if there were better support)

FrillyGoatFluff · 19/03/2023 23:40

Wonder how many people in the developing world want to faff about with their identity?

Identifying outside of reality always seems to happen to those with the luxury of time, support and lack of external pressures. Almost like they've got nothing better to do 🧐

Difficult to be hung up on wanting to transition from an adult male to a one-legged, three year old hamster when you're back is against the wall just keeping alive day-to-day isn't it?

ticktickticktickBOOM · 19/03/2023 23:32

The lengths people will go to to get PIP

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 19/03/2023 23:17

SaysRelaaxxx · 19/03/2023 22:23

The ignorance on this thread is eye opening. Didn’t realise Daily Mail readers had another place to hang out online! Before you spread this hateful rhetoric without a shred of personal experience, please look to meet and talk with at least one real life person who can give you some kind of personal insight. I’m astounded by the comments here.

I have to admit that I haven’t yet met a trans disabled person in my very long life.
Can you tell me how to ‘meet and talk’ with a ‘real life person’ ( who suffers from this syndrome, obviously I have met lots of real life persons, in well, real life). They obviously don’t crop up that often, although who knows.

I knew two pioneers of male to female identity in the 1970’s , fairly unusually - now they seem to be everywhere; if I can manage to hang on for another decade perhaps I will have the privilege of being run over by a trans disabled person in a buggy in Tesco.

pettysquabbles · 19/03/2023 23:10

The line was crossed as soon as trans anything was accepted. You're born into your body, end of.

ForTheLoveOfSleep · 19/03/2023 22:57

RumandSpinach · 19/03/2023 22:32

None if your fictional examples have anything to do with the OP, nice slippery slope argument though.

It genuinely is a slippery slope. If trans identities are to be taken seriously to the point that society must recognise them as fact where is the line? My examples, though mostly just to make a point of the ridiculous place this could go, are not all as fictional as you might think. Though the "transracial" guy has now detransitioned following his realisation he was being a totally racist idiot.

www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/stefonknee-wolschtt-transgender-father-leaves-family-in-toronto-to-start-new-life-as-a-sixyearold-girl-a6769051.html

www.newsweek.com/ben-shapiro-supports-white-instagram-star-who-identifies-korean-1605095

Swipe left for the next trending thread