Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

dinner just went to shit - why?

419 replies

Whatjusthappenedthen · 19/03/2023 17:59

Call me overdramatic but I'm trying to process exactly what went on and dinner just now and would appreciate advice on how it went so badly and how to avoid it happening again?

First of all, we're probably all neurodiverse - DS1 and DS2 both diagnosed, I have anxiety and probably adhd but haven't been diagnosed yet, my DD acts 'strangely' for her age so I think she's probably autistic like DS1 and the same goes for my partner.

Anyway.

We sat down for a roast dinner and DD (14) grabbed the gravy jug just as I was about to reach for it. I jokingly said "it's okay, you have the gravy first" with a smile on my face, to which DD asked what I'd said and I just said I was joking, but next time ask before just taking the gravy jug.

She immediately got stroppy and started sulking, so I told her to quit it as she does this a lot and was kind of done with her behaviour for today (she had one of these strops earlier when she took offence to something else I said).

She then sat there with a face like thunder, picking at her food so I told her to stop it, then just lost it and said I couldn't cope with sitting opposite her with a face on her. Left her table and went into the other room - 30 seconds later decided that was childish and started to walk back into the dining room to be met by my partner bringing my plate to me, saying my food was going cold.
I told him it was fine and we sat back down at the table.

Started eating, had to tell DD again to drop the attitude because she was picking at her fold, sighing dramatically and looking like she was about to cry, then my partner got up and turned the tv down to a whisper in the other room (open plan room), came back and sat down but then when I said it was so quiet it may as well have gone off, the whole point I'd put it on was to avoid us all sitting in silence at the table, partner got up and turned the TV back up again then finally came back to statt eating.

He got halfway through his dinner then sat for a minute not eating, then he got up, took his plate out to the kitchen and went and sat in the other room.

Just to clarify, we don't have a rule to stay at the table until everyone's finished, so him leaving the way he did wasn't an issue, aside from the fact he didn't eat all his food like usual.

DD was on the verge of tears and ate slowly, both DS deemed oblivious and when I finished my food I went to ask dp what had been wrong and he said he'd not fancied his food because of the atmosphere (created by my telling dd off - he said I wasn't wrong to do that but it created an awkward atmosphere which put him off his food).

Now, I'm baffled by how it all spiraled - it was such a small thing that escalated and dd end dd up finishing her dinner and going upstairs in tears.

I've spoken to her and apologised for how things went, but how can I stop that happening again? Should I have just not made that joke in the first place or was dd overreacting...was the atmosphere really my fault or should my partner have ignored the fact I told dd off or was it all me and I should've just brought it up with dd after dinner?

Any advice appreciated!

OP posts:
Schoolchoicesucks · 20/03/2023 09:39

You were a bit snarky. She was a bit snarky. You were a bit childish. She was a bit sulky. You were a bit snarky again. Then your dh got a bit snarky. Poor ds's sitting in silence.

Dd is a teen, being snarky is kind of expected. No-one behaved terribly, but the combination and escalations meant it went from hardly anything to shit quickly. This happens in my family too.

Try de-escalating situations. Don't attempt jokes that have some pa behind them. Take the pressure of family meals. Have a calm chat with dd about it another time and discuss what both of you could have done better. Ideally when you're driving or walking the dog or something so it's not a serious "heart to heart".

Chalk this one up OP. You (and dd) probably owe dh and ds's an apology for an uncomfortable meal.

StrawberryMacaron · 20/03/2023 09:30

red78hot · 20/03/2023 09:10

She made a joke about gravy, daughter over reacted

She made a passive aggressive criticism disguised as a “joke” over the gravy, evidenced by the fact she said she was joking, but actually don’t take the gravy. When the daughter was upset by this she kept on telling her daughter off for having feelings (and daughter was just quietly trying not to cry rather than being disruptive). I don’t think any upset person has ever had a turn around in their mood by being told off for their emotions. This culminated in the OP telling the daughter she couldn’t bear to look at her and had to leave because of her.

It doesn’t really matter if you feel she overreacted, because people have emotions that aren’t always rational. The OP said there was another incident earlier that day so she could have been fragile at the start of the meal so the barrier to her getting upset was lower. The OP will have a much better relationship with her daughter is she accepts her negative emotions as valid rather than telling her she’s being stroppy, overreacting and to knock it off. And that’s leaving aside the fact that taking a gravy boat on the table is totally normal behaviour in the first place.

red78hot · 20/03/2023 09:10

bussteward · 20/03/2023 08:53

She was going to eat until OP picked on her for no earthly reason. How would sending her away from the table help neutralise the situation?

She made a joke about gravy, daughter over reacted

bussteward · 20/03/2023 08:53

red78hot · 20/03/2023 08:50

Dd should have been told to remove herself from the table if she,wasn't going to eat.
Possibly Pmt? I used to be a bit moody as a teen.

She was going to eat until OP picked on her for no earthly reason. How would sending her away from the table help neutralise the situation?

gencritdd · 20/03/2023 08:51

That's the bit I don't understand. What did she do wrong going for the gravy before the op? Is there some sort of rule about gravy hierarchy?

red78hot · 20/03/2023 08:50

Dd should have been told to remove herself from the table if she,wasn't going to eat.
Possibly Pmt? I used to be a bit moody as a teen.

CoffeeMama1 · 20/03/2023 08:47

You sound like a lot. Why does she need to ask permission to reach for any food in the table? You don't get an automatic right to first dibs because you're the parent. why make such an upsetting situation out of absolutely nothing?

Thefriendlyone · 20/03/2023 07:44

TiedUpWithABlackVelvetBand · 19/03/2023 23:02

But if neurodiversity doesn’t have anything to do with it, don’t you think ‘just chilling out and setting the tone’ would be easy, and come naturally…………?

It clearly doesn’t - so isn’t there just a chance that something else might be at play?

The OP has said the people explaining how she should have handled it is really helpful, because she doesn’t know. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Again, handled what exactly? The only thing the daughter did wrong was apparently get the gravy first. The op had a go at her, and then kept having a go. Even losing it and leaving the room. The daughter just sat there taking the bullying and being upset. She’s allowed to be upset. Most folks would have been.

there was literally nothing to handle. All the op had to do was accept she didn’t get the gravy first with good grace

GoodChat · 20/03/2023 06:33

Even better give everyone a miniature gravy jug - that’s what I do. You can get them cheap from amazon.

They don't hold enough gravy for our family Grin

HoppingPavlova · 20/03/2023 05:58

I jokingly said "it's okay, you have the gravy first" with a smile on my face, to which DD asked what I'd said and I just said I was joking, but next time ask before just taking the gravy jug.

okay, but with the updates I still have no idea why she had to ask before picking up the gravy jug? Surely the gravy jug is there for people to pick up if they want gravy? It is immaterial you both went for it at the same time, why does she specifically have to ask before picking it up? It’s just weird tbh. Surely someone, somewhere on the table, really shouldn’t matter who or where, picks it up, pours some then it gets passed around for anyone who wants to use it. Or, have I gone mad 😂.

begoneday · 20/03/2023 02:38

I think it sounds like you may be overly critical, which teens are hypersensitive to. I’m guilty of this too and am trying to bite my tongue these days , otherwise I nag about every tiny detail which is tiring for everyone .

user1492757084 · 20/03/2023 01:27

You have a DD who is 14 and loves gravy. That alone is a win in this day of anorexia.
Try happily bringing food to the table and only ever saying nice things ie The gravy does look delicious tonight, might I have some next.
Consentrate on yourself. If you want lovely manners at the table - you model tham. If you see snatching of gravy, maybe next meal you say "Would anyone else like some gravy before me!". Perhaps they will take that in, perhaps they will not notice but over time the example you set is the most important. Only correct, gently, young children - under ten years of age. Praise kids when they do use great table manners.
You need to treat teenagers like adults and expect adult behaviour. It is hard, they are often rude but often amazing.

RobertaFirmino · 20/03/2023 01:05

This is horrible. Gravy is a basic human right. Furthermore, it is widely accepted in polite society that you need not ask permission to pour gravy from a communal jug on the dining table.
You sound very dictatorial. Do you want her to feel as if she's walking on eggshells at home? I do wonder what other petty rules are enforced in your house.

CrinklyLoveStick · 20/03/2023 00:51

This is on you. You sound incredibly hard work. She reached for
the gravy before you did but she was “grabbing”? Why should she ask before helping herself? Ludicrous.

xprincessxjanetx · 20/03/2023 00:47

Sorry, just caught up and rtft, I am glad you recognised that you were responsible for the issue and have rectified the situation. Hopefully you can all communicate better going forward to avoid unnecessary unpleasant situations like this again as it's never nice for anyone.

xprincessxjanetx · 20/03/2023 00:42

Sounds like my life as a teenager. YABU...that "joke" (we all know it was a sarcastic comment that you are trying to now dress up as a joke) would have humiliated her and made her feel unimportant. Why the fuck should she have to ask to pour some bloody GRAVY that was put on the table for, presumably, whole table use?? But apparently you did not have to announce that you were about to use it? Would it have been okay if you had got to the gravy first but then your DP made a sarcastic "joke" to you about you having it before him? No, I think not.

It may seem like something small and insignificant to a lot of people but if you have lived through moments like this then you know.

NoSquirrels · 20/03/2023 00:01

Adaptability is an underrated thing, I find. There’s room for all grades of manners!

MrsTerryPratchett · 19/03/2023 23:51

"Well that's going to be batshit" is a common thought on here Grin

MrsTerryPratchett · 19/03/2023 23:50

NoSquirrels · 19/03/2023 23:46

MrsTP, I read the ‘grades of manners’ and thought, we’ll, that’s going to be batshit.

But you have perfectly described our family mealtime manners too. Grin

LOL.

It really works. And it means I just say, "A manners DD" and she knows it's posh.

NoSquirrels · 19/03/2023 23:46

MrsTP, I read the ‘grades of manners’ and thought, we’ll, that’s going to be batshit.

But you have perfectly described our family mealtime manners too. Grin

MrsTerryPratchett · 19/03/2023 23:40

RosesAndHellebores · 19/03/2023 22:47

@MsAmerica I would absolutely expect every member of the family either to offer the serving dish to the person next to them before serving themselves and to ask for the gravy to be passed, preferably having offered it to someone else first.

It's basic good manners.

In our house we have grades of manners. ABCD.

A - Restaurants and grandparents. DD knows it's all manners on deck. Asking people if they would like some first, giving the last piece to others, excusing oneself, clearing up and doing the dishes (at grandparents).

B - Nice family dinners. Nice manners, nothing overegged. You can grab the gravy but not over someone else's plate.

C - Do basically what you like. Relaxed and pretty much everything except pigginess goes. Saturday night takeaway style.
D - Lick your plate, use your fingers, behave like a raging pig. Family BBQs and pizza. When we're sick or can't be bothered. Only when specifically allowed.

This way, DD has 'lovely manners' but every day is not like we're at the Palace.

emptythelitterbox · 19/03/2023 23:25

Whatjusthappenedthen · 19/03/2023 20:27

Also exactly like my mother, nothing was ever good enough.

I realise that now and that I need to stop it before dd ends up exactly the same as me.

I think you mean you ending up like your mother.

Also, stop labeling your DD. She really isn't you. She's her own person.

Maybe some therapy for you to learn about and recognize toxic patterns from your family.

cherish123 · 19/03/2023 23:22

She's probably confused as to why she is expected to ask if she can help herself to gravy. She's 14!

Ndd135632 · 19/03/2023 23:22

You are upset over your daughter reaching for the gravy jug? Have I read this right ?

RosesAndHellebores · 19/03/2023 23:03

@MsAmerica if people don't eat properly and courteously at home, how can they be confident when eating out?

Napkins, knives, using a butter knife, tasting before seasoning, not grabbing or taking more than one's share.

Swipe left for the next trending thread