Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

dinner just went to shit - why?

419 replies

Whatjusthappenedthen · 19/03/2023 17:59

Call me overdramatic but I'm trying to process exactly what went on and dinner just now and would appreciate advice on how it went so badly and how to avoid it happening again?

First of all, we're probably all neurodiverse - DS1 and DS2 both diagnosed, I have anxiety and probably adhd but haven't been diagnosed yet, my DD acts 'strangely' for her age so I think she's probably autistic like DS1 and the same goes for my partner.

Anyway.

We sat down for a roast dinner and DD (14) grabbed the gravy jug just as I was about to reach for it. I jokingly said "it's okay, you have the gravy first" with a smile on my face, to which DD asked what I'd said and I just said I was joking, but next time ask before just taking the gravy jug.

She immediately got stroppy and started sulking, so I told her to quit it as she does this a lot and was kind of done with her behaviour for today (she had one of these strops earlier when she took offence to something else I said).

She then sat there with a face like thunder, picking at her food so I told her to stop it, then just lost it and said I couldn't cope with sitting opposite her with a face on her. Left her table and went into the other room - 30 seconds later decided that was childish and started to walk back into the dining room to be met by my partner bringing my plate to me, saying my food was going cold.
I told him it was fine and we sat back down at the table.

Started eating, had to tell DD again to drop the attitude because she was picking at her fold, sighing dramatically and looking like she was about to cry, then my partner got up and turned the tv down to a whisper in the other room (open plan room), came back and sat down but then when I said it was so quiet it may as well have gone off, the whole point I'd put it on was to avoid us all sitting in silence at the table, partner got up and turned the TV back up again then finally came back to statt eating.

He got halfway through his dinner then sat for a minute not eating, then he got up, took his plate out to the kitchen and went and sat in the other room.

Just to clarify, we don't have a rule to stay at the table until everyone's finished, so him leaving the way he did wasn't an issue, aside from the fact he didn't eat all his food like usual.

DD was on the verge of tears and ate slowly, both DS deemed oblivious and when I finished my food I went to ask dp what had been wrong and he said he'd not fancied his food because of the atmosphere (created by my telling dd off - he said I wasn't wrong to do that but it created an awkward atmosphere which put him off his food).

Now, I'm baffled by how it all spiraled - it was such a small thing that escalated and dd end dd up finishing her dinner and going upstairs in tears.

I've spoken to her and apologised for how things went, but how can I stop that happening again? Should I have just not made that joke in the first place or was dd overreacting...was the atmosphere really my fault or should my partner have ignored the fact I told dd off or was it all me and I should've just brought it up with dd after dinner?

Any advice appreciated!

OP posts:
Indigoshift · 19/03/2023 19:11

You can strop off to the other room sulking and so can your oh who is equally ridiculous but your teen can't sulk for a bit which is what teens do. You ignore them unless it's really serious ( it wasn't though).
Both parents can have emotional outbursts but gid forbid your dd dares to show emotion. Keeping on picking at her is really unpleasant. Who would come out of a sulk with someone going on like that!

EggBlanket · 19/03/2023 19:10

BloomForever · 19/03/2023 19:07

I'd be close to tears and lose my appetite if I was 14 and my mother stormed out of a meal after saying she couldn't cope sitting opposite me. I'd probably be close to tears now and I'm in my 30's.

I agree. What a horrible response to someone just reaching for the gravy jug at the same time. I’ve never had dinner with someone who insisted people ask before picking up the gravy jug.

It’s also weird that the OP deliberately leaves the tv on when she sits down to eat because she anticipates an awkward atmosphere. It sounds like there’s a lot more going on here than this one incident.

OP, you owe your family an apology.

LapinR0se · 19/03/2023 19:10

That dinner sounds like the meals of my childhood. I think I developed anorexia as a direct consequence. I simply could not handle the tension, pressure and strain around dinner time.
Please listen carefully and bear this in mind

Novatherova · 19/03/2023 19:08

Toottooot · 19/03/2023 18:06

Do you have a gravy hierarchy? 💁🏻‍♀️

Hahaha!!!!

Thefriendlyone · 19/03/2023 19:07

I also don’t understand why she needs to ask for the gravy. And I have no idea why you “lost it” as she was upset.

the dinner went to shit as you behaved badly .

treneton · 19/03/2023 19:07

And that's why in a nutshell we are going to the dogs ! Neurodiverse my arris !

BloomForever · 19/03/2023 19:07

I'd be close to tears and lose my appetite if I was 14 and my mother stormed out of a meal after saying she couldn't cope sitting opposite me. I'd probably be close to tears now and I'm in my 30's.

dooneyousmugelf · 19/03/2023 19:07

Wasn't one* (

CountryMouse22 · 19/03/2023 19:06

It's kind of nice how parents apologise to a wayward offspring. When my father threw my radio out of my bedroom window because he thought it was too loud, he never apologised - wouldn't occur to him. But I did get a new one a few days later.

dooneyousmugelf · 19/03/2023 19:05

What was the joke? :/ there wasn't kid in your OP. You described telling your DD she could have it first with a big smile on your face. Which is weird. You then told her you had been joking. She was then pissed off. Instead of picking your battles and just ignoring the huffing and puffing, you escalated the situation. You then tried to regain control by fussing over other tiny things. Very controlling of you. Thoroughly unpleasant sounding dinner all in all, for no reason at all.

JudgeRudy · 19/03/2023 19:04

Your daughter did exactly as you did, so simply reached for the gravy. It just so happened to be at the same time. You sniped at her with sarcasm. She wasnt cheeky or rude and didnt challenge you in any way (which i would have done btw). She had difficulty hiding how hurt she was so rather than apologise for the 'miscommunication ' you upped the pressure by telling her the new rules for gravy acquisition and how she has transgressed them and further aggregated you so you can't bear to look at her and need to leave the room. Poor girl. In the midst of this your husband is chastised for not having the TV on at the correct volume (determined by you). This, coupled with you unnecessarily upsetting your daughter resulted in him losing his appetite and unable to eat his meal.
Luckily the boys were oblivious and tucked in.
What could you have done differently? Depends how far back you want to go
At gravy grab...'No, after you sweetheart'
After sarcasm... Sorry DD, I was just teasing...hey, I'm not cross sweetie
After glum face "What shall we do after dinner/how did things go with X yesterday/ I was thinking about making a cake ...blah blah smile smile
After flouncing to kitchen ...stay there
After TV volume ...thanks Hon, it was a bit loud. What do you fancy watching tonight
After husband finished....leave daughter and son in peace.

This was your making. Who made you the Gravy Queen?

Topseyt123 · 19/03/2023 19:04

I don't really see why DD was supposed to ask for the gravy. Surely it is there to help yourself from. In our house it is just dive in.

Your flouncing into the other room and back was odd. I wouldn't have been comfortable watching that and I can imagine how sensitive a teenage girl may have felt. It should have been relatively easily sorted though with an apology from you, though that didn't happen for a while.

With regard to DD's attitude during the meal, I think it was probably mainly caused by your own poor behaviour. It might have been better to just leave her alone for me duration of the meal, but instead you continued to pick at her.

Babyroobs · 19/03/2023 19:01

I think you need to pick your battles ? Honestly she may not have even realized you were going towards the gravy jug and then felt picked on.

FrosteeFlake · 19/03/2023 19:00

BanditsGravyStain · 19/03/2023 18:13

Look at how many times you’ve picked at her and negatively spoken towards her in such a short space of time. She wasn’t rude or out of line for reaching for the gravy, so she probably felt like she was being told off for no reason (she is correct), which upsets her and all you do is tell her off for failing to conceal her feelings.

This is why I hated my parents at this age. Nothing I did was right and when I had the nerve to be upset I was still wrong.

Yup, that shitty PA making up new rules on the spot to put kids down, complete with the fucking smile. Nasty power trip.

StrawberryMacaron · 19/03/2023 19:00

Whatjusthappenedthen · 19/03/2023 17:59

Call me overdramatic but I'm trying to process exactly what went on and dinner just now and would appreciate advice on how it went so badly and how to avoid it happening again?

First of all, we're probably all neurodiverse - DS1 and DS2 both diagnosed, I have anxiety and probably adhd but haven't been diagnosed yet, my DD acts 'strangely' for her age so I think she's probably autistic like DS1 and the same goes for my partner.

Anyway.

We sat down for a roast dinner and DD (14) grabbed the gravy jug just as I was about to reach for it. I jokingly said "it's okay, you have the gravy first" with a smile on my face, to which DD asked what I'd said and I just said I was joking, but next time ask before just taking the gravy jug.

She immediately got stroppy and started sulking, so I told her to quit it as she does this a lot and was kind of done with her behaviour for today (she had one of these strops earlier when she took offence to something else I said).

She then sat there with a face like thunder, picking at her food so I told her to stop it, then just lost it and said I couldn't cope with sitting opposite her with a face on her. Left her table and went into the other room - 30 seconds later decided that was childish and started to walk back into the dining room to be met by my partner bringing my plate to me, saying my food was going cold.
I told him it was fine and we sat back down at the table.

Started eating, had to tell DD again to drop the attitude because she was picking at her fold, sighing dramatically and looking like she was about to cry, then my partner got up and turned the tv down to a whisper in the other room (open plan room), came back and sat down but then when I said it was so quiet it may as well have gone off, the whole point I'd put it on was to avoid us all sitting in silence at the table, partner got up and turned the TV back up again then finally came back to statt eating.

He got halfway through his dinner then sat for a minute not eating, then he got up, took his plate out to the kitchen and went and sat in the other room.

Just to clarify, we don't have a rule to stay at the table until everyone's finished, so him leaving the way he did wasn't an issue, aside from the fact he didn't eat all his food like usual.

DD was on the verge of tears and ate slowly, both DS deemed oblivious and when I finished my food I went to ask dp what had been wrong and he said he'd not fancied his food because of the atmosphere (created by my telling dd off - he said I wasn't wrong to do that but it created an awkward atmosphere which put him off his food).

Now, I'm baffled by how it all spiraled - it was such a small thing that escalated and dd end dd up finishing her dinner and going upstairs in tears.

I've spoken to her and apologised for how things went, but how can I stop that happening again? Should I have just not made that joke in the first place or was dd overreacting...was the atmosphere really my fault or should my partner have ignored the fact I told dd off or was it all me and I should've just brought it up with dd after dinner?

Any advice appreciated!

As someone who was frequently picked up at the dinner table for all sorts of things which weren't important by my parent (who now has far worse table manners than me), I feel bad for your DD. And no you shouldn't "joke" about things which are passive aggrieve comments and continually pick and pick at someone. They tend to find it annoying, upsetting, angering or some combination thereof.

I jokingly said "it's okay, you have the gravy first" with a smile on my face, to which DD asked what I'd said and I just said I was joking, but next time ask before just taking the gravy jug.
So she has to ask before taking the gravy, but you can take it as you please. And if she does help herself to gravy then she gets passive aggressive "jokes" thrown her way.

She immediately got stroppy and started sulking, so I told her to quit it as she does this a lot and was kind of done with her behaviour for today
She was upset and probably indignant at being admonished for a non issue, spoke up for herself and was told to pipe down and no-one wants to hear her.

She then sat there with a face like thunder, picking at her food so I told her to stop it, then just lost it and said I couldn't cope with sitting opposite her with a face on her. Left her table and went into the other room - 30 seconds later decided that was childish and started to walk back into the dining room to be met by my partner bringing my plate to me, saying my food was going cold.
I told him it was fine and we sat back down at the table.
This made her lose her appetite, but she was quiet and doing what she was told. You picked a further fight with her and stormed off, which would have created a lot of tension.

He got halfway through his dinner then sat for a minute not eating, then he got up, took his plate out to the kitchen and went and sat in the other room.

Just to clarify, we don't have a rule to stay at the table until everyone's finished, so him leaving the way he did wasn't an issue, aside from the fact he didn't eat all his food like usual.
"We have a rule to stay at the table" but it';s fine for you to storm off and that should be immediately forgiven. Any negative atmosphere and tension you have created should also be immediately forgotten.

DD was on the verge of tears and ate slowly, both DS deemed oblivious and when I finished my food I went to ask dp what had been wrong and he said he'd not fancied his food because of the atmosphere (created by my telling dd off - he said I wasn't wrong to do that but it created an awkward atmosphere which put him off his food).
"I picked an unnecessary fight, upset my daughter and husband with the atmosphere I'd created and they continued to have feelings about it after I was magnanimous enough to grace them with my presence again"

Stressyfab · 19/03/2023 18:59

God I’d hate to live in your household

Inyournewdress · 19/03/2023 18:59

I think it was mainly you that caused the problem, though hard to be sure without seeing how dramatic DD was being. No reason why she should have to ask before taking the gravy, how bizarre! Or was that part of the joke, either way it obviously fell flat. Unless she literally snatched it from your hand it’s fine, no need for a joke anyway.

After that you really needed to be the adult and just calmly go on with tea, I sympathise because I mess up all the time but you were setting a really bad example. I am not surprised your dd was upset.

Choconut · 19/03/2023 18:58

Sugargliderwombat · 19/03/2023 18:45

It was you. You were silly to tell her to ask for the Gravy (do you?!), and then rather than letting her get over it you went on and on at her.

This.

Lordofthebutterfloofs · 19/03/2023 18:57

SittingNextToIt · 19/03/2023 18:55

You aren’t coming back are you?

You’re a bully and if this interaction is anything to go buy your relationship with your daughter is not looking good for the foreseeable, if things don’t change.

why on earth does she need to ask to get herself some gravy? Jesus Christ.

Course she ain't. I'm sure she expected lots of "what a rude child" and "omg yeah hun my kid is the same aren't they rubbish" type comments.

Backfired

SittingNextToIt · 19/03/2023 18:55

Whatjusthappenedthen · 19/03/2023 17:59

Call me overdramatic but I'm trying to process exactly what went on and dinner just now and would appreciate advice on how it went so badly and how to avoid it happening again?

First of all, we're probably all neurodiverse - DS1 and DS2 both diagnosed, I have anxiety and probably adhd but haven't been diagnosed yet, my DD acts 'strangely' for her age so I think she's probably autistic like DS1 and the same goes for my partner.

Anyway.

We sat down for a roast dinner and DD (14) grabbed the gravy jug just as I was about to reach for it. I jokingly said "it's okay, you have the gravy first" with a smile on my face, to which DD asked what I'd said and I just said I was joking, but next time ask before just taking the gravy jug.

She immediately got stroppy and started sulking, so I told her to quit it as she does this a lot and was kind of done with her behaviour for today (she had one of these strops earlier when she took offence to something else I said).

She then sat there with a face like thunder, picking at her food so I told her to stop it, then just lost it and said I couldn't cope with sitting opposite her with a face on her. Left her table and went into the other room - 30 seconds later decided that was childish and started to walk back into the dining room to be met by my partner bringing my plate to me, saying my food was going cold.
I told him it was fine and we sat back down at the table.

Started eating, had to tell DD again to drop the attitude because she was picking at her fold, sighing dramatically and looking like she was about to cry, then my partner got up and turned the tv down to a whisper in the other room (open plan room), came back and sat down but then when I said it was so quiet it may as well have gone off, the whole point I'd put it on was to avoid us all sitting in silence at the table, partner got up and turned the TV back up again then finally came back to statt eating.

He got halfway through his dinner then sat for a minute not eating, then he got up, took his plate out to the kitchen and went and sat in the other room.

Just to clarify, we don't have a rule to stay at the table until everyone's finished, so him leaving the way he did wasn't an issue, aside from the fact he didn't eat all his food like usual.

DD was on the verge of tears and ate slowly, both DS deemed oblivious and when I finished my food I went to ask dp what had been wrong and he said he'd not fancied his food because of the atmosphere (created by my telling dd off - he said I wasn't wrong to do that but it created an awkward atmosphere which put him off his food).

Now, I'm baffled by how it all spiraled - it was such a small thing that escalated and dd end dd up finishing her dinner and going upstairs in tears.

I've spoken to her and apologised for how things went, but how can I stop that happening again? Should I have just not made that joke in the first place or was dd overreacting...was the atmosphere really my fault or should my partner have ignored the fact I told dd off or was it all me and I should've just brought it up with dd after dinner?

Any advice appreciated!

You aren’t coming back are you?

You’re a bully and if this interaction is anything to go buy your relationship with your daughter is not looking good for the foreseeable, if things don’t change.

why on earth does she need to ask to get herself some gravy? Jesus Christ.

thaegumathteth · 19/03/2023 18:55

None of us are perfect parents and ok your Dd was moody but what went wrong, was, unfortunately, you.

You were passive aggressive and overly dramatic and then acted amazed when everyone was pissed off with it?

Forgottenpeeves · 19/03/2023 18:54

YABU. You were passive aggressive and kept telling your DD off. You doing awful tbh.

MissingMoominMamma · 19/03/2023 18:53

You embarrassed her and made her feel less than. That’s why she looked like she was going to cry.

It clearly wasn’t meant, but perhaps a talk and a cuddle might help?

Leafblow · 19/03/2023 18:53

" how can I stop that happening again? Should I have just not made that joke in the first place or was dd overreacting...was the atmosphere really my fault or should my partner have ignored the fact I told dd off or was it all me and I should've just brought it up with dd after dinner?"

You shouldn't have made that joke in the first place- it wasn't a joke it was a pass agg way of telling her off when she had done nothing wrong.

She was upset and being told off for no reason, not really overreacting.

The atmosphere was your fault as you created it (by snipping at her for nothing) and then made it worse by continually telling her off for being upset.
Telling someone off for being upset is never going to make then suddenly not upset- so you should have just ignored it at the table and apologised later for snipping at her.

Your partner couldn't ignore the fact you tokd her off- you did it continuously and stropped off in the middle of it.

The entire weird thing could have been avoided at any point by not telling someone off for using communal gravy. Apologising for overreacting to your child being upset. Changing the subject so the focus isn't all left on the poor kid who was trying not to cry. Just moving on imstead of wanin on about her being upset. Your poor kid.

Spiderboy · 19/03/2023 18:53

Yeah you are the problem here.