Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the UK needs its ‘Drain the Swamp’ moment

193 replies

FlorentineSunGiver · 19/03/2023 17:53

This quote has now become synonymous with countries burning their governments to the ground and starting again. Often spearheaded by someone outside of politics who says ‘what on earth??’ And runs and gets in.

The UK is on the straight and arrow to one outcome and we all know what that is. I think it’s time we as a country had our collective Drain the Swamp moment and moved this forward!

OP posts:
MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 19/03/2023 20:52

Unfortunately, OP, you're full of angry rhetoric but it appears that you have no real ideas about what do or how to do it.

We don't need people like you leading the country. We need people with real intelligence, creative ideas and a credible plan. You have shown no evidence of these in any of your posts so far.

pointythings · 19/03/2023 20:53

OP, can you please provide as requested the list of countries which have done this and where life is now so much better?

Also yy to seeing your manifesto. I'm very interested to make sure you aren't Laurence Fox

Joking aside, this country really does need PR.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 19/03/2023 20:53

FlorentineSunGiver · 19/03/2023 20:49

Personally I have been considering a political run in a new political party and championing some of my views. This could change the market and make people really start to wonder and actually if elected I could bring some of this change about.

Lol, why not try championing some of your views on here then. Tell us what your new political party would do.

FlorentineSunGiver · 19/03/2023 20:55

Liebig · 19/03/2023 20:51

Give us a taster of your top manifesto pledges and we'll judge on their merit.

Removing 95% of wealth from 5% of people to increase wealth spread.

Prosecuting corruption in politics with life imprisonment to end improper behaviour of political officials once and for all.

Ending gender reassignment surgery and medication via the NHS to free up funds to reinvest into Nhs.

removing all cosmetic surgery from the NHS and making people pay for it apart from with assault related injury.

Abolishing of the licence fee.

Removing church from the state and ending public funding of churches.

These are just a few things I would immediately tackle.

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 19/03/2023 20:56

I think we should have a better way of voting - First past the post means that there only a few constituencies that make a difference, and the spread of Conservative voters versus the more concentrated areas of Labour support, Lib Dem and Green support affect the outcomes.

Much more local involvement and regional involvement.
Less Government interference in the broadcasters - why does the Government get involved in the Chair of the BBC

Look at the influence of the media - the Home Secretary took selected media groups to Rwanda recently.

More critical thinking lessons in schools.

Get rid of the House of Lords. The Monarchy can go as well.

Just for starters.

cakeorwine · 19/03/2023 20:58

Ending gender reassignment surgery and medication via the NHS to free up funds to reinvest into Nhs

And how much would that save?

You do know where most of the NHS resources go? The NHS budget is £180,000,000,000 - that's £180 BILLION

It's the elderly who take up a lot of the NHS resources. But I am sure you wouldn't want to suggest not treating them, would you?

FlorentineSunGiver · 19/03/2023 21:00

cakeorwine · 19/03/2023 20:58

Ending gender reassignment surgery and medication via the NHS to free up funds to reinvest into Nhs

And how much would that save?

You do know where most of the NHS resources go? The NHS budget is £180,000,000,000 - that's £180 BILLION

It's the elderly who take up a lot of the NHS resources. But I am sure you wouldn't want to suggest not treating them, would you?

Ending care for anyone physically past the point of no return would be widely accepted and celebrated and is something I would do further research on to potentially consider. People would be encouraged to be healthy earlier in life to ensure they aren’t a burden. Any self inflicted illness would not be supported until resolved mentally.

OP posts:
Liebig · 19/03/2023 21:00

FlorentineSunGiver · 19/03/2023 20:55

Removing 95% of wealth from 5% of people to increase wealth spread.

Prosecuting corruption in politics with life imprisonment to end improper behaviour of political officials once and for all.

Ending gender reassignment surgery and medication via the NHS to free up funds to reinvest into Nhs.

removing all cosmetic surgery from the NHS and making people pay for it apart from with assault related injury.

Abolishing of the licence fee.

Removing church from the state and ending public funding of churches.

These are just a few things I would immediately tackle.

In order, agreed absolutely.

You'll have problems getting to that level of reform without already being Denmark.

I don't think it's a wise idea to defund the legitimate avenues for gender dysphoria, but I would definitely put more funding into mental health and routine GP care to accommodate where these issues manifest.

Remove of elective surgery gets a vote from me.

The licence fee being killed off has been a thing the Tories have tried for a long time, usually under the guise of breaking up the BBC. You'd need to weigh up how well the Beeb would work in a world where HBO and Netflix exist.

Agreed.

pointythings · 19/03/2023 21:03

I don't think that taking gender reassignment and cosmetic surgery out of NHS provision is going to save the NHS as much money as you think it will...

Life sentences for corruption are ridiculous when you get a paltry 8 years for rape.

Wealth distribution - something that would have to be done very gradually, the best method for this is probably the introduction of maximum pay multiples. I wouldn't be against that per se.

No state funding for religious schools and the removal of the compulsory act of Christian worship - yes, I'm here for that one.

I do think in general your priorities are in the wrong places. What are you going to do to reverse the disastrous economic effects of Brexit? What are you going to do to sort out the domestic energy supply and reduce the dependence on imports? How are you going to reverse the drain of high value research and development from the UK as a result of Brexit?

There's a lot of complex stuff here that you need to think about - I know UKIP and the Tories run on soundbites, but the UK needs to do better than that.

And unless you commit to PR, it will never happen at all.

pointythings · 19/03/2023 21:05

Ending care for anyone physically past the point of no return would be widely accepted and celebrated and is something I would do further research on to potentially consider. People would be encouraged to be healthy earlier in life to ensure they aren’t a burden. Any self inflicted illness would not be supported until resolved mentally.

No. No, and no, and no. That's eugenics. I'm in favour of assisted dying, but you are proposing the wholesale withdrawal of care from anyone who is terminal. Completely unacceptable and immoral.

Liebig · 19/03/2023 21:06

The disastrous economic effects were present well before Brexit. The middle-class is just pissed because now they have to experience what the working class has been dealing with for decades.

Yes, the country only went to shit from 2016 onwards because now my beloved Anne-Marie can't travel all over Europe on ERASMUS now.

cakeorwine · 19/03/2023 21:08

People would be encouraged to be healthy earlier in life to ensure they aren’t a burden

And if not, maybe just put them away somewhere so they aren't a burden?

I don't want to go all Godwin on you...but

Liebig · 19/03/2023 21:09

pointythings · 19/03/2023 21:05

Ending care for anyone physically past the point of no return would be widely accepted and celebrated and is something I would do further research on to potentially consider. People would be encouraged to be healthy earlier in life to ensure they aren’t a burden. Any self inflicted illness would not be supported until resolved mentally.

No. No, and no, and no. That's eugenics. I'm in favour of assisted dying, but you are proposing the wholesale withdrawal of care from anyone who is terminal. Completely unacceptable and immoral.

Canada, a country better then the UK according to people on here whose first and only thought is Brexit, basically made a law saying it's super cool and economically great to kill the invalids in society.

www.theguardian.com/world/2022/may/11/canada-cases-right-to-die-laws

Between this and Trudeau shutting down the bank accounts of truck protesters, I think we have the perfect country.

Exasperatednow · 19/03/2023 21:09

FlorentineSunGiver · 19/03/2023 20:55

Removing 95% of wealth from 5% of people to increase wealth spread.

Prosecuting corruption in politics with life imprisonment to end improper behaviour of political officials once and for all.

Ending gender reassignment surgery and medication via the NHS to free up funds to reinvest into Nhs.

removing all cosmetic surgery from the NHS and making people pay for it apart from with assault related injury.

Abolishing of the licence fee.

Removing church from the state and ending public funding of churches.

These are just a few things I would immediately tackle.

Thank goodness you aren't in charge.

License fee= soft power.

Public funding of churches = heritage. Its not the same as public funding of religion.

We should be encouraging people into politics to get a better cross reference of society

Oh and you are into eugenics. Good for you. Are you going to include the hard of thinking?

Sigh

Liebig · 19/03/2023 21:09

cakeorwine · 19/03/2023 21:08

People would be encouraged to be healthy earlier in life to ensure they aren’t a burden

And if not, maybe just put them away somewhere so they aren't a burden?

I don't want to go all Godwin on you...but

I beat you by several posts. Look up thread.

pointythings · 19/03/2023 21:10

@Liebig I get that you are a Brexit fan, but it's clear that Brexit has had a major negative impact on the UK economy. You can deny it all you want if it makes you feel better, but the UK is the only G7 economy that hasn't returned to its pre-COVID levels of productivity. Major companies are choosing not to invest here. SMEs are going under or are setting up in EU countries to keep their business going, with the accompanying outflow of funds. No, it isn't all Brexit - a lot of it is also Tories. But those things go hand in hand.

Sneering about students and Erasmus just shows you up as someone with no grasp on reality.

Liebig · 19/03/2023 21:11

Guys, we can't get all hung up on the eugenics thing until we see what benefits it does to our GDP. We may be on to a winner.

Liebig · 19/03/2023 21:11

pointythings · 19/03/2023 21:10

@Liebig I get that you are a Brexit fan, but it's clear that Brexit has had a major negative impact on the UK economy. You can deny it all you want if it makes you feel better, but the UK is the only G7 economy that hasn't returned to its pre-COVID levels of productivity. Major companies are choosing not to invest here. SMEs are going under or are setting up in EU countries to keep their business going, with the accompanying outflow of funds. No, it isn't all Brexit - a lot of it is also Tories. But those things go hand in hand.

Sneering about students and Erasmus just shows you up as someone with no grasp on reality.

I voted remain.

pointythings · 19/03/2023 21:12

@Liebig why is Canada the first country you think of when it comes to assisted dying? It's done a great deal better in other places. The Canada model is immensely flawed.

cakeorwine · 19/03/2023 21:12

I assume the death penalty is coming back?

So what if you might get the wrong person. At least it will act as deterrent.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 19/03/2023 21:13

You just sound very naive tbh. I think you massively over-estimate the benefits of some of your proposed policies and massively underestimate the complexity involved in some of the others. And it's a no to eugenics from me, thanks.

Liebig · 19/03/2023 21:16

pointythings · 19/03/2023 21:12

@Liebig why is Canada the first country you think of when it comes to assisted dying? It's done a great deal better in other places. The Canada model is immensely flawed.

Because Canada was literally the country that was talking about the health service cost savings by implementing these measures in the MAID act. It's exactly what OP has later mentioned and strays practically into eugenics.

So I guess my Nazi poster jab on the previous page wasn't without some validity.

FlorentineSunGiver · 19/03/2023 21:19

I am NOT talking about eugenics. I don’t believe we should be altering anyone’s genetic makeup. But there’s a point that life is over and that should be respected. I’m not a nazi and have vastly different views to groups like that

OP posts:
Liebig · 19/03/2023 21:22

FlorentineSunGiver · 19/03/2023 21:19

I am NOT talking about eugenics. I don’t believe we should be altering anyone’s genetic makeup. But there’s a point that life is over and that should be respected. I’m not a nazi and have vastly different views to groups like that

lmao

pointythings · 19/03/2023 21:22

@FlorentineSunGiver eugenics is nothing whatsoever to do with genetics. You really need to look that up because if you don't even know that, then this whole conversation is utterly pointless.