Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

1 to 2 VS 2 to 3 (babies)! Please advise!

36 replies

ABCD88 · 19/03/2023 14:15

Hey,

I have read so many threads saying that going from 1 to 2 babies was harder than 2 to 3 and equal many threads that said the opposite!

So, I decided to make a poll about it to clear things up in my mind.

We currently have 2 little kids (DD & DS) and I would love a 3rd! But I am going in circles in my mind when I read all the pessimistic comments and how much harder life was after the third.

My first was a challenging one but my second is a dream! Like we don’t have a second kid, so for us 1 to 2 was extremely easy.

Any help is very welcome!

YABU - 1 to 2 is much harder and the 3 just slotted in

YANBU - 2 to 3 is way more harder than having 2 kids

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
RandomMess · 20/03/2023 21:14

Cost is a huge factor. A third whilst they are young is "cheap" not much additional cost as you have the lot etc.

The pre-teen and teen years are so expensive!

Our economy is in a bad way and won't improve soon so think very carefully about the reality. Most people are only an accident or serious health issue away from struggling financially.

CuteCillian · 20/03/2023 20:51

One baby between two parents was a doddle for me, so I voted 1 to 2 as being harder. DC2 was not challenging though, and DC3 was an equally easy baby. The big consideration in going to 3 in my opinion, is a financial one. Our society is geared for 2 DC and bringing a third into the mix brings lots of not proportional,ongoing costs

ToriLynn · 20/03/2023 20:40

There's pros and cons to both (obviously)

We have a DD (2 yrs 9months) DD (1yr 7months) and DS (16 weeks) and honestly I love it! It's so much easier when my DH is at work with 3 than 2! If 1 needs my attention, the other 2 have each other to entertain. It's a squeeze but can still fit in a standard car. The problems for us only start when we're looking for holidays and mini breaks as it's now either 2 hotel rooms or an apartment/villa. I don't get the problem with family tickets as it's easy to just buy an extra child ticket 🤷‍♀️

ZebraKid71 · 20/03/2023 19:21

Activities wise we just plan - again, helps me and dh both work part time so are both around a lot. We also use the things they do do seperately as 1-2-1 time with them, so after ds rugby class him and my dh go for brunch. The eldest two are in the same gymnastics class, they do back to back swimming lessons, dh does rugby on Saturday mornings with eldest and I take younger two to parkrun. Once they have friends in their activities it also helps to share with other parents or alternate giving lifts etc.

We don't get much homework yet but reading and spellings we do in a morning as it is calmer in our house than after school, younger two listen to my eldest read over breakfast and we practice spellings on way to school but I really do think homework will be our issue as they get older!

ABCD88 · 19/03/2023 22:01

Thank you all for your responses! It's really useful!

To those of you that you are having a 3rd baby soon, huge congratulations! The responses didn't put me off to be honest.

@Hankunamatata Do you think that if you have stopped at 2 babies, your relationship with your other half wouldn't be that much challenging? How and why the third made life trickier?

In our case, my 2nd DC (DS), is so easy and almost feels non-existent, in comparison to my DD who is a real struggle, a proper drama queen at the age of 3!

I crave for a 3rd baby but I won't be as a good mum to 3 as I would have been to 2 babies.

I won't have much of a life out of our family life, no particular hobbies or days out with friends, so a 3rd won't be upsetting from this point of view.

We have a 3 bed house (meaning that two will share) and a company leasing car but this easily is changed to something bigger.

Having 3 teens doesn't scare and 3 uni fees should be alright as by the time the first will graduate the third will start.

It's the homework and activities that stress me! Any advise on that please?

OP posts:
Libmama · 19/03/2023 19:50

1-2 was hard as you’ve got two to deal with instead of one only child. Our DC3 is currently 13 weeks old and has so far just slotted in. She’s a dream. I do have 4 years between each of mine though, my eldest is now 9 so he’s really helpful. The 4 year old is the hardest by far but he starts school in September.

MagAmberson · 19/03/2023 19:36

I have a 7, 4 and 1 year old. My third has been a good sleeper compared to my other babies so I had a lot more energy even with juggling 3 children. I think the fact my other two were out of the toddler phase made a big difference, they could help a little and understand if I tell them something is dangerous for the baby (like a choke hazard).

Will it be difficult as they get older? Probably but they're only young for a few years and my baby is adored by his siblings, it's been lovely to watch how kind they are to him😍

ZebraKid71 · 19/03/2023 19:36

We have 3 and it is chaotic yet brilliant, eldest is 5, youngest just turned 2 so fairly close together and just got to a stage now where all three of them play together and it has actually made my life easier.

In contrast to some of the above posts I am finding it easier now they are slightly older than when we had a preschooler, toddler and a baby!

Hotel rooms are my main issue but we usually just get an air b and b instead or take the hit. We already had a 4 bed house and big car but it is more expensive when out and about (but in the same way having 2 is more expensive than having 1 so I don't always see the value in this point).

I'd say you need to be very organised, and me and dh both work part time so have the availability when they need to be in different places and to make sure we both get 1-2-1 time with each of them. I'd struggle a lot more if either of us worked full time. Absolutely no regrets for us, we just felt our family wasn't finished with 2.

GraceGW · 19/03/2023 19:36

RandomMess · 19/03/2023 19:29

I have 4

The third was hell as she had undiagnosed silent reflux.

4th was a breeze!

I think with 3+ if you accept you need to be family oriented rather than trying to carry on as you did it's ok. You need to accept adult hobbies/activities have to take a back seat for a while (not altogether).

Honestly the amount of people that would cause themselves less stress if they just embrace family life and go with it instead of constantly trying to continue on as they were pre kids.

2022again · 19/03/2023 19:35

There’s always an odd one out with 3!

MargaretThursday · 19/03/2023 19:33

2-3 was harder than 1-2 for me.

However part of that was that with 1-2, dd1 did preschool 2 mornings a week, and slept in the afternoon. So I didn't have the time constraints and I also got the afternoons fairly clear.

2-3, dd2 did preschool mornings 4 days a week and didn't nap, dd1 did school 5 days a week. Dd1 was also doing after school things 2-3 days a week. So if ds didn't nap at the right time I had to get him up to pick up (in his words as a grumpy toddler) his "silly sisters from doing silly things."
He also was almost constantly ill from ear infections, barring the year he had grommets in. So we also had a lot of doctor's appointments too, and a number of A&E trips as he got frequent (like 5-6 times a year+) non-fading viral rashes.

Plus dd1 was very keen to be helpful, and very keen on playing with the new baby when dd2 was born. Dd2 was similar when ds was born, but far less predictable, so it was less relaxing, shall we say.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 19/03/2023 19:32

It's worth remembering that things like holidays, cars and days out become much more expensive with three.

Hankunamatata · 19/03/2023 19:31

3rd nearly broke me and us as a couple. No time, no one wants babysit 3 kids, trying to manage 3 going in different directions, the financial cost now they are teens

Milkand2sugarsplease · 19/03/2023 19:30

Having had 2 very difficult babies, not a cat in hell's chance am I risking number 3!! I'm lucky that DS1 has been so patient with ds2 because in no way whatsoever has DS2 just slotted into life with 1. DS1 was older (9) when ds2 arrived, so he already had established hobbies and clubs and DH and I have had no choice but to each take one child the majority of the time and we've both said many times we're sad about the amount of time we spend apart in what should be family time.

For me, having lived with 2 difficult babies (DS2 is still a 'glass is half empty' kinda guy at nearly 2) I decided that there was no way I could see myself managing with another baby in the mix (amongst other reasons too). If you had a difficult baby first time around, I'd just make your decision based on whether you think you could do your current family life with another dc1 in the mix and go from there.

igglepigglegingin · 19/03/2023 19:30

Argh! Me too, I have two DD, aged 5&6 and my 3rd baby is due in the next few weeks.
How can I un-see this thread?! 😂

RandomMess · 19/03/2023 19:29

I have 4

The third was hell as she had undiagnosed silent reflux.

4th was a breeze!

I think with 3+ if you accept you need to be family oriented rather than trying to carry on as you did it's ok. You need to accept adult hobbies/activities have to take a back seat for a while (not altogether).

ALLIS0N · 19/03/2023 19:26

Do you want three teenagers or three at university at the same time?

PeekAtYou · 19/03/2023 19:24

0-1 was hardest for me. Dc2 and Dc3 have been very easy (Dc3 is 16 so I think that easy is a fair assessment) and we earned much more when dc2 and dc3 were born.

BCxx · 19/03/2023 19:23

We have a two year gap and if there was to be a third I’d make sure there was a three year gap at least, just to make sure my oldest is at school as I’m not sure how I could manage three of them with basic things like dog walks etc

Holliegee · 19/03/2023 19:22

3 is definitely harder especially with an age gap - the thing that bothered me (quite pathetically) was that I only have 2 hands and crossing the road meant one had to not hold my hand.

Kit Kats come in packs of 6 so there was always 1 left over.

and other random inconsequential things.

BCxx · 19/03/2023 19:21

I think I’m going to end up in this boat too. Having our second just now, will have a girl and boy and in theory could close the baby-making book there and live happily ever after but it kind of doesn’t feel like the last time 🙈 our first was extremely easy so I think it will depend if this one ends up being a nightmare or not!

popopop · 19/03/2023 19:19

I am due baby #3 in a couple of days and this thread has made me so anxious 😭

Justputitdown · 19/03/2023 19:08

ABCD88 we're currently trying to make the same decision with similarly aged children...

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 19/03/2023 18:26

I think once your kids go to school you will see life ramp up- extra activities, homework, after school play dates.

ABCD88 · 19/03/2023 17:38

Omg so many different answers and all of them useful!

My DD is 3, my DS is near 1 at the moment.

I would really really really love a third, as I feel that he/she will complete our family.

However, we are so balanced at the moment as a family of 4 and life seems easy, maybe a bit too easy for my liking but I am worried that a third will make it too hard for my liking…

Such a hard decision to make in a short time, as I don’t want to get out of the baby stage and then re-enter in a few years down the road.

I am happy for a few more years of chaos while they are all young but the point a few of you made that I want be able to supervise their homework properly, it really does scare me!

OP posts: