Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How would you feel about family members eloping?

262 replies

Elopenope · 19/03/2023 11:29

Me and DP are considering marrying quietly, just us two.

Initially when we started speaking about it, it was clear our parents thought we would invite them still (I think had just assumed it was a destination wedding?)

We are now beginning to firm up plans and it seems like our gently introducing the idea isn't going well.

On top of that a minor celeb (ish) eloped recently and I saw a lot of comments about how people would be devastated if their sister etc did that, how they clearly aren't close with the families and how hurtful it is.

In all honesty would you be hurt if your ds, dd etc did this? If your dc didn't get to be bridesmaids etc.

We get on well with our families, I'm just by nature an introverted person with not much interest in a party. I'd hate for them to think it was anything to do with them

Im also neurodiverse so can struggle with this stuff. In my head it's quite clearly a thing between a couple, but realise that's not how it works.

I've got no idea if I should then invite them to dress fittings etc or just do the whole thing alone. Which is worse? Is it better to be really clear that on September 12th we will be marrying (and leave them feeling odd that day) or just say after

I'm mostly interested in families points of views. Lots of friends that have eloped have told us it was fine, but when speaking to others they've been hurt

Yabu- I would be hurt if my family did this

Yanbu- I wouldn't mind if my sister eloped

OP posts:
Zwicky · 19/03/2023 13:05

I don’t care much for weddings and I’m very introverted but I’d be pissed off if my dc kept something as big as getting married from me. It indicates that the closeness I feel isn’t really there and, given that we speak, they have essentially lied through emission by not saying that they are getting married. People are entitled to do what they want but given that I get phone calls and messages about stuff like “look at my pancakes!” And “the guard on the train is so nice” and “finally got a dentist appointment” and “I have to buy a lightbulb” and “I still don’t have my rota” then excluding “I’m getting married!!!!” Would be a blow tbh.

If they planned a wedding and didn’t want any guests but told me about it then I would feel a bit odd about it but I wouldn’t be upset as such. I wish I’d had a smaller wedding in hindsight but not so small that it left my mum out of it.

PrincessHoneysuckle · 19/03/2023 13:05

The nicest wedding I've ever been to was a very quiet one.Bride was very introverted so they went registry office with no fuss and just 4 guests.
We all went to the train station cafe for a cuppa then they went straight to Paris fir a few days away alone.

saymynamex · 19/03/2023 13:04

Weirdly I would be upset if my children did it but we are considering doing a ceremony at the local registry office with just our kids there (2 over 18 so will be the witnesses)

Whiteroomjoy · 19/03/2023 13:03

My DS are reaching age when marriage is possible - not saying probable as who knows these days 🤣
im all for doing a wedding that’s quiet, limited attendees and at last minute. I had one line that myself- 9 guest and registry and a nice meal at lunch time. I’m an introvert, was quite shy back then and didn’t want fuss and all the attention.

but I would be disappointed and a tadge upset if my sons didn’t even want me there for their marriage, even if it was a quick registry office. It is a moment in their life that is a milestone and marriages are about publically legitimising a relationship along with legal/financial commitments historically . If it wasn’t we wouldn’t get married. I would want to be able to be there to see them make that commitment and support them, and to have the memory of that important day.

its like a close relative of mine. He and his wife had a very small wedding. Lovely occasion and just very them, in a remote uk place with limited facilities . Immediate family only and about 12 in wedding party only. I wasn’t invited. No problem with that , I got to hear about the plans, and I got to see the photos and hear all about it first hand when they got back. A part of me was quite glad to not have to travel to this remote place. But all that wedding day I was thinking about them, what was happening, were they enjoying themselves? What happened, etc etc. I didn’t miss going as such, but a little part of me does feel that I missed out on seeing the happy couple on their day, seeing their reactions, hearing their vows etc. if I had been their mum, I’d have been very sad and felt quite upset on that day

washingmachineheart · 19/03/2023 13:03

If the wedding has no guests beyond obligatory witnesses, you as a mother or sister haven’t really “not been invited”. Nobody has been.

It’s not a personal slight it’s the wish of the woman and her new partner on the one day that’s entirely about them. Massively self absorbed to make it about you and if it was someone I cared about I would be thrilled they’d had the chance to make a choice that suited them.

CoffeeBeansGalore · 19/03/2023 13:01

We eloped. Couldn't afford a big white wedding and were trying to sort out a very low budget event. We were paying everything ourselves. Yet MiL was telling us we had to invite xy&z who I'd never met. And how we should be doing things.
How wonderful Sil's wedding was (which PiLs paid for).
So we cancelled the few arrangements we'd booked and quietly disappeared to Gretna Green. We told everyone afterwards.

PiLs were not impressed but got over it. My mum was disappointed but said as long as we were happy she was.
My sister didn't speak to me for weeks & then didn't have me as a bridesmaid when she got married several years later.
So there was some fall out initially but it was fine in the end. (30+ years later we are still together & happy).

If you are paying it is your day & your choice. But I would suggest doing things quietly, don't announce plans & just get on with it.

TenoringBehind · 19/03/2023 12:59

I wouldn’t be even the slightest bit upset! I’d rather someone had the wedding that they wanted.

BritInAus · 19/03/2023 12:57

If you were my sister / daughter / cousin / friend I would be thrilled for you that you were celebrating your marriage in the way that you wanted - not doing it a certain way to please other people. Especially if that would make you uncomfortable. I might be sad to not be there, but if I was a close family member, I would offer to take you for a lovely meal sometime afterwards to celebrate and would hope you'd share lots of photos with me! Congrats on your upcoming wedding.

gogohmm · 19/03/2023 12:57

If I remarry it will be in church anyway, number of guests is irrelevant, I will have an open invitation to anyone who wants to attend and a buffet (I'd do it) and band after, no hassles with tables etc that way either as sit where you want.

So much of weddings seems to be about logistics and extreme costs, doesn't have to be - I can do the lot for under £1000, byob

RedToothBrush · 19/03/2023 12:54

begoneday · 19/03/2023 12:43

We did it and haven’t heard the end of it since. Just made us realise we definitely did the right thing because it showed how weird people are about other peoples weddings. Do what you want to and ignore the moaners .

This.

LadyMargaretDevereux · 19/03/2023 12:54

We just went off and got married without telling anyone for a year! Reactions varied, but there were no dramas. That was a long time ago in the 1980s, so maybe everyone would be upset at missing out on a big event these days. In the 80s weddings were less of a big thing, I think.

GotABeatForYouMama · 19/03/2023 12:54

Personally I wouldn't mind. My ExMiL is a spiteful cow and DD's elder half sister will pick a fight with her own shadow when she's had a few to drink. I'd rather DD had a happy, stress free day than spending the day worrying about certain people ruining the day for her.

noscoobydoodle · 19/03/2023 12:53

We got married with just our DD while we were on holiday. Planned sort of last minute with a couple of months notice. We had a mixed reaction from very supportive to heartbroken. A big wedding is never something I wanted but we did have a party when we got back for family and friends- so I guess a bit of a middle ground.

PinkArt · 19/03/2023 12:53

I'd be a tiny bit gutted for me because I love an excuse to put on a hatinator and dance to Abba! Dressing up opportunities aside though, I'd just be happy for you that you were doing something you wanted to do and in the way you wanted to do it.

gogohmm · 19/03/2023 12:53

Yes, a bit. A small wedding is fine, what's wrong with a registry office followed by lunch at a nice restaurant with close family who wish to be there on the understanding they pay for their own food each.

SallyWD · 19/03/2023 12:51

We got married with only witnesses. I think my parents were delighted! Avoided all that fuss and expense. They did they same too. My in-laws seemed completely fine with it too. Only one friend complained because she thought she'd have been my bridesmaid. She wouldn't have been and it was about us not her. Do what you both want.

FleetIlya · 19/03/2023 12:49

It's what I'm planning to do. My relationship with my partner isn't about other people, it's about my partner and me.

If people feel "upset" it'll be mostly because they didn't get to enjoy a free party at my expense, and they can die mad about it, I guess. If they feel upset because of some souped-up nonsense about "weddings are about family and community blah blah" then they can die mad about that too.

It's not illegal to make other people cross by living your own life. Women are tired of performing for other people these days. Do it anyway.

Gumbo · 19/03/2023 12:46

Like PP have said, the mistake you're making is telling people about it.

We eloped, my mother wasn't happy (but then again, she was never happy about anything) but my Dad was thrilled for us, as was everyone else. I don't regret it for a second.

begoneday · 19/03/2023 12:46

DelphiniumBlue · 19/03/2023 12:37

I'd be really hurt if my sons or siblings didn't invite me to their wedding. Weddings are a family thing, it's bringing a new person into the family. To exclude the 'old' family makes it very clear that they are no longer important. I can't imagine how anyone who is close to their family would do such an unkind thing.
I understand the wish for a small, low key wedding, even no party, but to not invite them to the marriage ceremony shows no concern for their feelings. You couldn't do that and then expect the new bride/groom to be welcomed whole heartedly into the family, with the best will in the world it would create a distance.

It only creates a distance if older family members have a weird sense of ownership over their children, it’s a bit creepy if I’m honest . Let your DC go and live their lives and you live yours .

Ponderingwindow · 19/03/2023 12:44

I wouldn’t care if my cousin eloped.

I would be very upset if my child or sibling eloped.

I would try to and lie and say I was ok with it, but I am not a good actress.

LoobyDop · 19/03/2023 12:43

My brother did it. I was mildly disappointed, as I would have enjoyed a family get-together. But I got that he would have been incredibly uncomfortable and hated it, so I was glad he could do what made him happy.

begoneday · 19/03/2023 12:43

We did it and haven’t heard the end of it since. Just made us realise we definitely did the right thing because it showed how weird people are about other peoples weddings. Do what you want to and ignore the moaners .

TollgateDebs · 19/03/2023 12:43

We went on holiday and got married, no witnesses and $50 later job done. Reasons, we were in our 40s, having been together a while, my Mum had died some years before, big families of cousins but only a couple of siblings and difficult relationship with one of them, had a mortgage (money was tight) and we really don't like big productions or the fuss that goes with it. The day was about our commitment to one another and so we did it the way that gave us joy. We did tell the parents and they knew us well enough to know this is the way that would make us happiest.

Throughabushbackwards · 19/03/2023 12:42

I'd honestly be delighted for them.

GalileoHumpkins · 19/03/2023 12:42

I'm good with anything that means I don't have to attend a wedding.

Swipe left for the next trending thread