Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How would you feel about family members eloping?

262 replies

Elopenope · 19/03/2023 11:29

Me and DP are considering marrying quietly, just us two.

Initially when we started speaking about it, it was clear our parents thought we would invite them still (I think had just assumed it was a destination wedding?)

We are now beginning to firm up plans and it seems like our gently introducing the idea isn't going well.

On top of that a minor celeb (ish) eloped recently and I saw a lot of comments about how people would be devastated if their sister etc did that, how they clearly aren't close with the families and how hurtful it is.

In all honesty would you be hurt if your ds, dd etc did this? If your dc didn't get to be bridesmaids etc.

We get on well with our families, I'm just by nature an introverted person with not much interest in a party. I'd hate for them to think it was anything to do with them

Im also neurodiverse so can struggle with this stuff. In my head it's quite clearly a thing between a couple, but realise that's not how it works.

I've got no idea if I should then invite them to dress fittings etc or just do the whole thing alone. Which is worse? Is it better to be really clear that on September 12th we will be marrying (and leave them feeling odd that day) or just say after

I'm mostly interested in families points of views. Lots of friends that have eloped have told us it was fine, but when speaking to others they've been hurt

Yabu- I would be hurt if my family did this

Yanbu- I wouldn't mind if my sister eloped

OP posts:
UsingChangeofName · 20/03/2023 07:26

LauraIAm · 19/03/2023 11:42

One of my siblings did this. Good relationship with my parents, no big backstory. We were all outwardly supportive but my mum was heartbroken. Dress fittings, bridesmaids etc don’t matter at all. Not inviting siblings is mean but personally I could live with it. Not inviting parents assuming normal circumstances I think is pretty much unforgivable. It’s one of the most important days of your life and a day most parents think about during their child’s childhood etc and would desperately want to be a part of.

I agree with this.

If you have a normal, loving family relationship with parents / siblings, I think it is very strange to not recognise that this is an important life event, and that to exclude them is hurtful.

If you were my close family, I'd respect your decision but would be hurt you didn't feel close enough to want me at your special day
MN is full of people who don't like to socialise, which will skew answers

I think this is spot on, too.

There are SO many options between eloping and "having a big fuss".
I mean, what you are proposing isn't eloping. It is arranging a wedding, telling everyone about it and adding on "but you can't come". That seems the most hurtful option of them all. If the 2 of you slipped away and then told people after it was done, (as eloping tends to be done) it wouldn't be quite as bad. I can understand that when people who have already been living together / have dc together get married years down the line.

Of course it is up to the B&G to do what they want to do. I am expecting 'unorthodox' from at least one of my dc. But you specifically asked us to be honest about how we would feel. Personally, I would be sad, and disappointed, and it would make me question the whole relationship.

WandaWonder · 20/03/2023 03:07

I could never have done it without my and dh parents atleast

CheshireCat1 · 20/03/2023 02:37

The most important part of a wedding is the vows and you only need the bride and groom to make them. Have a great day and enjoy yourselves. My son got married when on holiday, it wasn’t planned, it just felt like the right thing for them. I was over the moon for them both, we all celebrated when they got home.

nicetoseetgesunsout · 20/03/2023 02:33

I would be delighted for you!
Congratulations,

Phoebo · 20/03/2023 02:24

I also don't know anyone who has eloped that has regretted it

Phoebo · 20/03/2023 02:23

Although I loved my wedding, it was so stressful to plan it so I'd think my family members eloping was smart!

Bansheed · 20/03/2023 02:07

TedMullins · 19/03/2023 23:00

Same. My parents didn’t have a big white wedding and think they’re a tacky waste of money the same as I do. Even if they were into that, I’m not, and that’s what matters. I think my parents would actually think I’d lost my mind if I started planning a wedding like that

You think they are a "tacky waste of money", as they do, not the other way around. Clearly learnt behaviour and, frankly, rude to state it too.

Bansheed · 20/03/2023 02:04

AlltheFs · 19/03/2023 18:59

I’m sorry but you have batshit MIL written all
over you. God help your childrens partners. Will you be insisting on being at the births of your grandchildren too and having overnights of newborns too?!

What an incredibly mean and bitchy thing to say to someone who is voicing their upset.
My kids aren't married yet, but after funerals of young and old I cannot wait for a symbolic, happy event. Registry office/ pub meal or whatever they want. But yes, I want to be there. I also want to love and know my grandchildren.

You are allowed to love and be part of your children's lives FFS.

TedMullins · 19/03/2023 23:00

SallyWD · 19/03/2023 21:48

Speak for yourself. My parents have never had any interest in weddings. They were happy we got married with only witnesses. They did exactly the same thing themselves 40 years earlier!

Same. My parents didn’t have a big white wedding and think they’re a tacky waste of money the same as I do. Even if they were into that, I’m not, and that’s what matters. I think my parents would actually think I’d lost my mind if I started planning a wedding like that

Templebreedy · 19/03/2023 22:56

Exactly, @Changingplace and @CheersForThatEh. People don’t get to emote all over something that just isn’t a big deal for the people actually involved, and translate their failure to invest their own wedding with Big Significance into some kind of deficiency and insult to family members who cling to the idea that this SHOULD be terribly important therefore they should be invited.

Changingplace · 19/03/2023 22:43

Definitely don’t think it’s about being mother of the bride, big party etc just to be there on the day that’s marking the start of their married life and commitment together and be happy together making very precious memories.

If anyone had said my wedding was about them making ‘very precious memories’ I’d have wanted to elope on the spot, shortly after feeling very nauseous…

It’s exactly this kind of overly emotive taking over of someone else’s decision to just get married that makes some people want to elope.

CheersForThatEh · 19/03/2023 22:36

I think if you are doing dress fittings and talking about a wedding then you are doing a wedding and they ought to be invited if you are including them on planning talks. Otherwise of course they will feel pushed out. I think you're now too far down the rabbit hole to not invite them without them feeling shunned.

I eloped 5 years ago and still haven't told my family. Not because they wouldnt approve but because I wasnt having a "wedding", I was signing a legal document with 2 witnesses. I wouldnt invite my parents to watch me sign a pension document so made no sense to have them attend my legal marriage. But I certainly wouldnt have told them what we were planning and what I wanted to wear or where I was going to have it and then not invite them!

Templebreedy · 19/03/2023 22:33

Hollyhocksandlarkspur · 19/03/2023 22:05

I would be very very sad if my DDs eloped and we weren’t invited to their marriage ceremony. Disagree with PP who say it is purely about the bride and groom because in loving families it is welcoming someone in to being part of their family in good times and bad and making a commitment to supporting them as a couple. Definitely don’t think it’s about being mother of the bride, big party etc just to be there on the day that’s marking the start of their married life and commitment together and be happy together making very precious memories.

Again, this is your personal interpretation. The people getting married are allowed to think entirely different things about their own circumstances and marriage. I didn’t join DH’s family, though I’m fond of them, nor he mine. I’d been committed to him and he to me for years before we married, and don’t need anyone’s ‘help’ with that. And the day had nothing to do with making ‘precious memories’, it was for us a legal rubberstamping, not some big deal. Our relationship is important, sure, but the actual wedding, no. You may not agree, but you get to decide on your own personal marriage/s, not your children’s.

Changingplace · 19/03/2023 22:17

SallyWD · 19/03/2023 21:48

Speak for yourself. My parents have never had any interest in weddings. They were happy we got married with only witnesses. They did exactly the same thing themselves 40 years earlier!

Same, my parents always joked they’d pay for my wedding to be exactly like theirs, registary office booked for next available slot, two witnesses and a pub lunch - they didn’t even take any photos!

Not everyone is obsessed with the concept of a wedding, a lot of people are more interested in it being a happy marriage.

Hollyhocksandlarkspur · 19/03/2023 22:05

I would be very very sad if my DDs eloped and we weren’t invited to their marriage ceremony. Disagree with PP who say it is purely about the bride and groom because in loving families it is welcoming someone in to being part of their family in good times and bad and making a commitment to supporting them as a couple. Definitely don’t think it’s about being mother of the bride, big party etc just to be there on the day that’s marking the start of their married life and commitment together and be happy together making very precious memories.

bubblec · 19/03/2023 22:00

I actually eloped but that wasn't a first choice, and my family made it difficult to attend anywhere.

If It was completely my way, I would want me family there because eloping is beautiful but having the people closest to you, adds that even more beautiful touch.

Also, if my children eloped in future with their partners, I wouldn't ruin it for them but inside I would be quite sad because I would want to see my child on their most special day.

SallyWD · 19/03/2023 21:48

Lesvacances · 19/03/2023 20:42

Sorry to disappoint but my dil adores me because I don’t interfere.
Theres a huge difference between thinking something and saying it out loud.

Dd’s wedding wasn’t what I wanted but she doesn’t know that because I keep it to myself. And it wasn’t her fault anyway.

I still think eloping is selfish unless you have awful parents.
And most pp’s have said they would be disappointed if their dc eloped.
Not saying you have to have a big flashy wedding, just invite your parents. It means a lot to them.

Speak for yourself. My parents have never had any interest in weddings. They were happy we got married with only witnesses. They did exactly the same thing themselves 40 years earlier!

Templebreedy · 19/03/2023 21:43

Lesvacances · 19/03/2023 20:42

Sorry to disappoint but my dil adores me because I don’t interfere.
Theres a huge difference between thinking something and saying it out loud.

Dd’s wedding wasn’t what I wanted but she doesn’t know that because I keep it to myself. And it wasn’t her fault anyway.

I still think eloping is selfish unless you have awful parents.
And most pp’s have said they would be disappointed if their dc eloped.
Not saying you have to have a big flashy wedding, just invite your parents. It means a lot to them.

It means a lot to you.

Bananalanacake · 19/03/2023 20:52

I refused to waste thousands on pointless faff just to impress people I don't see much cos it's the 'done thing'. Instead we did the registry office, grabbed a takeaway on the way home. Spent 55 grand paying off the mortgage just before the interest rates went up.

misskatamari · 19/03/2023 20:44

We did it and our families were fine with it. We had a reception back home, which was all the fun bits of the wedding, but we got married abroad, just the two of us, and I’m so glad we did. It was great, we steamed it live so family could watch it if they wanted, but it was so stressfree and we could just enjoy it. I haven’t rtft, but my view is it’s your wedding, you should do what makes you happy and whilst family might not like it, they should want you to do what feels best for yourself ultimately, and should support you

Lesvacances · 19/03/2023 20:42

AlltheFs · 19/03/2023 18:59

I’m sorry but you have batshit MIL written all
over you. God help your childrens partners. Will you be insisting on being at the births of your grandchildren too and having overnights of newborns too?!

Sorry to disappoint but my dil adores me because I don’t interfere.
Theres a huge difference between thinking something and saying it out loud.

Dd’s wedding wasn’t what I wanted but she doesn’t know that because I keep it to myself. And it wasn’t her fault anyway.

I still think eloping is selfish unless you have awful parents.
And most pp’s have said they would be disappointed if their dc eloped.
Not saying you have to have a big flashy wedding, just invite your parents. It means a lot to them.

CeriB82 · 19/03/2023 20:28

We eloped. Proper eloped and not said anything to anyone.

i didnt care who i upset. Our wedding, not my guests

Changingplace · 19/03/2023 20:14

legalseagull · 19/03/2023 19:56

I think it's selfish. If your parents are there for you through the bad times, they should also be able to witness and celebrate the good. I can't imagine not wanting my mum, sibling and children at my wedding. It doesn't need to be a big wedding. Even just a registry office with my mum and sibling would be lovely.

Expecting a wedding to be about anyone other than the couple getting married is selfish.

Changingplace · 19/03/2023 20:13

LookingOldTheseDays · 19/03/2023 14:32

What's the purpose of telling close relatives that you are "eloping" (i.e. telling them, "we plan to marry but you aren't invited"). Are you still expecting gifts? Are you expecting them to get excited about planning it with you, choosing a dress etc.?

Either just get married on the quiet with no announcement and no fuss (which is what eloping actually means), or invite people to a proper small wedding. This halfway house of announcing an elopement just smacks of attention seeking.

Totally agree, the minute you tell people you’re not eloping at all, you’re just having a v small wedding.

Eloping is just going off, getting married and telling people after the wedding.

TedMullins · 19/03/2023 20:04

Fairyliz · 19/03/2023 19:55

I don’t think my kids ‘owe’ me a wedding I would just like to think they love me so much that they would want me to be there to share one of the happiest day of their lives.
@TedMullins would you really just shrug your shoulders if your kids say ‘no we don’t want Ted to come’?

Yes. But then I don’t think weddings are the pinnacle of achievement or necessarily the happiest day of someone’s life. I think traditional weddings are a load of patriarchal wank.