Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How would you feel about family members eloping?

262 replies

Elopenope · 19/03/2023 11:29

Me and DP are considering marrying quietly, just us two.

Initially when we started speaking about it, it was clear our parents thought we would invite them still (I think had just assumed it was a destination wedding?)

We are now beginning to firm up plans and it seems like our gently introducing the idea isn't going well.

On top of that a minor celeb (ish) eloped recently and I saw a lot of comments about how people would be devastated if their sister etc did that, how they clearly aren't close with the families and how hurtful it is.

In all honesty would you be hurt if your ds, dd etc did this? If your dc didn't get to be bridesmaids etc.

We get on well with our families, I'm just by nature an introverted person with not much interest in a party. I'd hate for them to think it was anything to do with them

Im also neurodiverse so can struggle with this stuff. In my head it's quite clearly a thing between a couple, but realise that's not how it works.

I've got no idea if I should then invite them to dress fittings etc or just do the whole thing alone. Which is worse? Is it better to be really clear that on September 12th we will be marrying (and leave them feeling odd that day) or just say after

I'm mostly interested in families points of views. Lots of friends that have eloped have told us it was fine, but when speaking to others they've been hurt

Yabu- I would be hurt if my family did this

Yanbu- I wouldn't mind if my sister eloped

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Survey99 · 20/03/2023 19:08

sunflowerdaisyrose · 20/03/2023 14:30

@Survey99 I said how I'd feel as that was the specific question asked!

That was my point. Would you really feel nothing about your how your sibling was feeling - understanding, respect, concern over finances, not wanting a do. You would only solely consider your own feelings without taking in any other context at all?

It is not something where you wouldn't encompass the feelings of the main people involved into your own feelings unless you can only operate entirely one dimensionally.

specialkallday · 20/03/2023 14:43

We did it 5 years ago. It went down absolutely fine with 90% of our family. Only DH's chavvy side who are clearly bored and fancied a free meal out got funny but we just cut them out and I'd never have done it differently - go for it OP!

Ahhhhhbisto · 20/03/2023 14:41

legalseagull · 19/03/2023 19:56

I think it's selfish. If your parents are there for you through the bad times, they should also be able to witness and celebrate the good. I can't imagine not wanting my mum, sibling and children at my wedding. It doesn't need to be a big wedding. Even just a registry office with my mum and sibling would be lovely.

That's all very well but with step parents and siblings that would have been 17 people in mine and DH's family. Then you have the asking siblings partners, then nieces and nephews and it's no longer small!

Jazzy21 · 20/03/2023 14:34

I would be hurt, but I wouldn’t say anything as ultimately I’d want my family member to be happy. But it would make me think that we weren’t as close as I’d thought we were.

sunflowerdaisyrose · 20/03/2023 14:30

@Survey99 I said how I'd feel as that was the specific question asked!

FinallyHere · 20/03/2023 14:12

I'm torn on this one.

In theory, I'm all for the 'just us' and eloping approach but then when DSS actually did this, I felt (and did not tell a soul) a song that they didn't want to share that moment with anyone.

When we were getting married, I definitely wanted a low key event, with the emphasis on everyone who had travelled from near and far to be with us.

My test of who to invite was 'if I would be happy to never see them again, then don't invite them', which clarified that the elopement felt a bit 'don't care if never see me again'.

LadyGrinningSoul85 · 20/03/2023 13:01

LadyGrinningSoul85 · 20/03/2023 12:59

I plan on doing exactly this, after our baby is born, later on this year.
I don't see the point in big weddings, it's not all about having a big party, and personally I see it as a massively narcissistic waste of money.

Notice I said 'personally'. I don't need loads of replies from people trying to justify their reasons for spending loads.

Only thing I'll be sad about is our kids not being there, as we are only having 2 witnesses at the actual event, but they will be coming for a little meal with us afterwards.

It's all we need.

To add, I couldn't care less if it offends either of our families.

Neither side are particularly nice people.
They're massively self absorbed and maybe learning the world doesn't revolve around them will do them good.

LadyGrinningSoul85 · 20/03/2023 12:59

I plan on doing exactly this, after our baby is born, later on this year.
I don't see the point in big weddings, it's not all about having a big party, and personally I see it as a massively narcissistic waste of money.

Notice I said 'personally'. I don't need loads of replies from people trying to justify their reasons for spending loads.

Only thing I'll be sad about is our kids not being there, as we are only having 2 witnesses at the actual event, but they will be coming for a little meal with us afterwards.

It's all we need.

RedToothBrush · 20/03/2023 12:53

UsingChangeofName · 20/03/2023 08:45

@RedToothBrush - but everything you are describing in your post, that you didn't want, is about spending ridiculous amounts.
You can have a very low key wedding and still share it with people you love.

This isn't about "not comprehending" that people don't want 'a big fuss' or that people don't want to spend thousands on one day. I certainly understand that, and I suspect most people do, but there are 101 ways to get married without a big fuss, without spending thousands, but also without upsetting people who are very close to you.
I've been to all sorts of different weddings, and one of the nicest ones there were only 11 of us there.

Are you illiterate?

Or did you just read the bits about money and conveniently ignore the bits about stress and mental health?

LauraIAm · 20/03/2023 10:44

FatAgainItsLettuceTime · 19/03/2023 16:43

But it's not "one of the most important days of your life" to lots of people.

I wanted a marriage not a wedding. The day itself was a formality I did to get married.

@FatAgainItsLettuceTime Of course you are entitled to your opinion on whether the day is important or not. The OP asked for the views of families who had experienced this, and I’m giving mine. Actually the general trend on the thread seems to be along these lines ie people who have eloped don’t think it’s a big deal, families do. That doesn’t mean the OP shouldn’t elope, but she wanted intel on how families generally feel about elopements, and she now has that.

HoppingPavlova · 20/03/2023 09:18

I’d be overjoyed if my kids did this. Would spare me any potential Bridezilla behaviour and would avoid having to feel obligated to offer $$ towards it. Win.

2chocolateoranges · 20/03/2023 09:18

I’d be upset if my daughter decided to elope but not fussed if any other family member did it.

UsingChangeofName · 20/03/2023 09:14

Again, why are you assuming that 'wanting to be invited to be present at' equals "insisting on it being some kind of huge emotional day and choking back tears because they always wanted to walk you down the aisle in a white dress and throw confetti and have a wedding album" ? Confused

Templebreedy · 20/03/2023 08:56

UsingChangeofName · 20/03/2023 08:40

But it’s not a ‘special day’ for many of us who chose not to invite family. This has been said multiple times on the thread but seems not to be being heard. Obviously those not invited may feel disappointed, as posters are saying, but they need to recognise that this is because they are projecting their own feelings about weddings and specialness and family and exclusion onto someone else’s wedding. (And that their desire to make a ceremony into a huge emotional deal may well have contributed to the decision not to invite them if the couple see it as a purely practical issue.)

But the OP is talking about possibly inviting family to "dress fittings" and the like, so clearly it is for her, and in her family.
I understand for some people it is a "bit of paper" as is often said on here - in which case, elope properly and don't tell anyone or make it into "an event" - but that isn't the case for the OP from what she says.

I wasn’t responding to the OP’s specific situation, but to the posters saying they would be devastated if excluded from a ‘special day’ — I’m saying that only the people getting married get to decide whether it’s a big deal or something akin to signing a document. @RedToothBrush is absolutely right to suggest that the pressure to regard a wedding as some emotional big deal, regardless of finances or numbers, is a key element in the decision to not invite people.

Surely it’s not that hard to understand that if you regard your wedding as something you want done with minimum fuss and emotion, having people around who are insisting on it being some kind of huge emotional day and choking back tears because they always wanted to walk you down the aisle in a white dress and throw confetti and have a wedding album when what is actually happening is a quick register office thing followed by lunch with everyone casually dressed, would be a strain?

This thread amply demonstrates how pervasive that kind of emotional projection is.

UsingChangeofName · 20/03/2023 08:47

Also, the thread isn't asking "Do you understand why some people might elope?"
The OP specifically asked "How would you feel about family members eloping?"
So I have to presume that is what she wants to know.

UsingChangeofName · 20/03/2023 08:45

@RedToothBrush - but everything you are describing in your post, that you didn't want, is about spending ridiculous amounts.
You can have a very low key wedding and still share it with people you love.

This isn't about "not comprehending" that people don't want 'a big fuss' or that people don't want to spend thousands on one day. I certainly understand that, and I suspect most people do, but there are 101 ways to get married without a big fuss, without spending thousands, but also without upsetting people who are very close to you.
I've been to all sorts of different weddings, and one of the nicest ones there were only 11 of us there.

UsingChangeofName · 20/03/2023 08:40

But it’s not a ‘special day’ for many of us who chose not to invite family. This has been said multiple times on the thread but seems not to be being heard. Obviously those not invited may feel disappointed, as posters are saying, but they need to recognise that this is because they are projecting their own feelings about weddings and specialness and family and exclusion onto someone else’s wedding. (And that their desire to make a ceremony into a huge emotional deal may well have contributed to the decision not to invite them if the couple see it as a purely practical issue.)

But the OP is talking about possibly inviting family to "dress fittings" and the like, so clearly it is for her, and in her family.
I understand for some people it is a "bit of paper" as is often said on here - in which case, elope properly and don't tell anyone or make it into "an event" - but that isn't the case for the OP from what she says.

oioimatey · 20/03/2023 08:28

Although I understand why people do it, I'd be devastated if any members (and a select few cousins who are really close) of my immediate family eloped. Might sound dramatic to some, but I'd be really upset.

Bigminnie1 · 20/03/2023 08:24

Honestly- I would be so incredibly upset. I am from a culture where weddings etc are big family events so I don't know if that makes a difference. I also only have one child.
My parents and in- laws would've been devastated if they had not been invited to our wedding.

Survey99 · 20/03/2023 08:16

I'd be really upset and disappointed quite honestly and take it as a reflection on our relationship.

This or similar is reflected in many posts. It is exactly this that make people choose to elope. Pressure from family for what they want and how they feel, without even mentioning the couple or any appreciation why they might want to do something different or what they choose for their day.

Paesano · 20/03/2023 08:11

I would be ok if my kids did this. I'd be hurt if others were invited and I wasn't but if no one was invited I'd be ok. It's your day, do what feels right for you. I'd want to celebrate with my kids though and want to throw them a party or dinner or something.

sunflowerdaisyrose · 20/03/2023 08:07

I'd be really upset and disappointed quite honestly and take it as a reflection on our relationship. I can't imagine getting married without my siblings and parents there.

RedToothBrush · 20/03/2023 08:06

One of the things I wanted to avoid was this social pressure to create your wedding day as 'the happiest day in your life' where everything had to be perfect and everyone had to be there.

Because I'd have found that too much and got upset if things didn't go to plan or weren't quite right or certain people couldn't come etc etc.

For me it was never about making it the happiest day of my life. It was a special day for me and DH but not necessarily THE day. It was a commitment to make many happy memories together not just one princess day.

I genuinely don't think my parents were upset at not coming because they understood that. My parents didn't have the wedding they wanted; they tried to please everyone else. My mum's parents were divorced and both her parents put on something of a show by all accounts and really upset her. And they certainly they understood that we didn't want to spend £20,000 - 30,000 on a wedding like BIL did. We just don't have the money and understand why we feel it's a gross overindulgence to do so.

My mil was already putting pressure on about the dress and that got too much for me. I just didn't want to spend hundred on a dress I'd wear once. I thought it wasteful and I had huge amounts of trouble finding anything to fit me as it was (I'm tiny). The thought of seeing loads of lovely dresses but none of them being remotely suitable for my size and shape upset me.

A quiet day was right for me without the need to make the single day the most wonderful.

I have many happy and special memories. I don't think building up one day to do that would create that for me. I'd just remember the stress and pressure of it. Which misses the point entirely doesn't it?

My family live all over the world. They've never been that close. Its not something that's important to us. Out of all my family, none have had a big traditional do in my lifetime. We just value things differently.

And that's ok.

The number of posters who can't comprehend that on this thread is quite staggering tbh.

Changingplace · 20/03/2023 08:05

DelphiniumBlue · 19/03/2023 12:37

I'd be really hurt if my sons or siblings didn't invite me to their wedding. Weddings are a family thing, it's bringing a new person into the family. To exclude the 'old' family makes it very clear that they are no longer important. I can't imagine how anyone who is close to their family would do such an unkind thing.
I understand the wish for a small, low key wedding, even no party, but to not invite them to the marriage ceremony shows no concern for their feelings. You couldn't do that and then expect the new bride/groom to be welcomed whole heartedly into the family, with the best will in the world it would create a distance.

The issue is you’re making this all about your feelings and wants and your own sense of importance.

When grown adults decide to get married it’s about them and when families start saying what their wedding should or shouldn’t be that’s exactly the kind of reason people decide to elope.

The fact you’re openly saying you’d then exclude their partner on that basis says a lot, why are you assuming it would be purely their partners decision, why the assumption someone needs to be blamed and found at fault?

Templebreedy · 20/03/2023 07:43

UsingChangeofName · 20/03/2023 07:26

I agree with this.

If you have a normal, loving family relationship with parents / siblings, I think it is very strange to not recognise that this is an important life event, and that to exclude them is hurtful.

If you were my close family, I'd respect your decision but would be hurt you didn't feel close enough to want me at your special day
MN is full of people who don't like to socialise, which will skew answers

I think this is spot on, too.

There are SO many options between eloping and "having a big fuss".
I mean, what you are proposing isn't eloping. It is arranging a wedding, telling everyone about it and adding on "but you can't come". That seems the most hurtful option of them all. If the 2 of you slipped away and then told people after it was done, (as eloping tends to be done) it wouldn't be quite as bad. I can understand that when people who have already been living together / have dc together get married years down the line.

Of course it is up to the B&G to do what they want to do. I am expecting 'unorthodox' from at least one of my dc. But you specifically asked us to be honest about how we would feel. Personally, I would be sad, and disappointed, and it would make me question the whole relationship.

But it’s not a ‘special day’ for many of us who chose not to invite family. This has been said multiple times on the thread but seems not to be being heard. Obviously those not invited may feel disappointed, as posters are saying, but they need to recognise that this is because they are projecting their own feelings about weddings and specialness and family and exclusion onto someone else’s wedding. (And that their desire to make a ceremony into a huge emotional deal may well have contributed to the decision not to invite them if the couple see it as a purely practical issue.)

I do agree though that ‘telling people we are going to elope’ is a contradiction in terms.