Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Emergency alerts to your phone

333 replies

TheFirstOfHerName · 19/03/2023 02:27

From April, the government will be able to send emergency alerts to our mobile phones.

www.gov.uk/alerts

A siren will go off, even if your phone is on silent. You won't be able to do anything else on your phone until you turn it off. They plan to test this on 23 April.

I understand the reasons why this can be helpful, and in areas where people need to suddenly evacuate due to wildfires, earthquakes, tornadoes etc it could save lives.

However, personally I don't want it, and have disabled it on my phone.

  1. Of the emergencies I might experience, I'm not sure I'd want to be alerted to any of them via this method. If a flood or storm is imminent, I'll find out through the usual channels. If a nuclear missile is heading my way, having a few minutes' warning will not help.
  1. This system is being run / overseen by the UK government, and my trust in them has been somewhat eroded over the past few years.
  1. I have an anxiety disorder (reasonably well managed with combination of medication and other methods) and I think the cost to my anxiety levels of having my phone suddenly sirenning at me outweighs the negligible probability of this system saving my life.
If you are the kind of calm, resilient person who could have these alarms going off and it not completely throw you, then great.
OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Alexandra2001 · 26/03/2023 17:30

When will the next major tsunami deluge the south West? You don't know, not do I, nor does the government - hence the alert

At risk of repeating myself... WE have no Tsunami Western Atlantic warning systems, so what exactly is the use of an alert in this circumstance?
The Portuguese Tsunami was caused by an earth quake 100miles offshore, it took minutes to reach Spain/Portugal & was 100s of years ago, so if i lived in Portugal i might want to consider moving to higher ground!

The one that is believed to have hit the north east of England was 800 years ago, caused by a land slip in Norway. ... there has been TWO in all of recorded history.

Its a non issue, focus on things that matter, like getting an Ambulance for that stroke or heart attack victim, instead of imaginary threats... this is just more Govt dead cat stories.

Elphame · 26/03/2023 12:26

Didn’t we all get some alerts about covid lockdown already?

Yes we did and very annoying they were too. Stating the blindingly obvious and far too generic and patronising to be of any use whatsoever.

If the Govt wants to use my mobile phone to further their own agenda then they can pay for it.

BungleandGeorge · 26/03/2023 11:18

Didn’t we all get some alerts about covid lockdown already? I’m not sure about a siren going off, maybe for significant, unpredicted events which are a risk to life. I can’t think of very many instances where that would be the case.

Nimbostratus100 · 26/03/2023 11:07

Alexandra2001 · 26/03/2023 07:50

@Nimbostratus100 We don't suffer from natural disasters, a few houses burned down, extremely rare and no lives lost
Flash floods? the EA have advanced warning alerting vulnerable households, via email, mobile and landline.

We had a tidal surge half a century ago.

Panic causes injuries and death and i think it would be very difficult to evacuate a large city safely in a few hours, let alone a few minutes, esp as meteor strikes are highly unpredictable, precise location is almost impossible until its too late.

Manchester etc isn't going to be hit by wild fires.

We don't have Tsunami warning systems in the Atlantic.

You like the Govt are over reacting, in Hurricane prone areas etc yes a good idea but the UK isn't.

we haven't suffered from recent natural disasters, but the UK has in the past and will again suffer tsunamis, and there will be more and worse wild fires, an plenty of others manmade problems, like water pollution, toxic clouds, etc.

Other people in the world dont panic and kill each other when there is an alert - I am repeating myself over and over again.

When will the next major tsunami deluge the south West? You don't know, not do I, nor does the government - hence the alert.

When will the next major pollution event contaminate tap water - ditto

I just don't understand people who say we don't have disasters - (natural or manmade) as if we are somehow immune or superior

we are not

just we have been lucky recently

Alexandra2001 · 26/03/2023 07:50

@Nimbostratus100 We don't suffer from natural disasters, a few houses burned down, extremely rare and no lives lost
Flash floods? the EA have advanced warning alerting vulnerable households, via email, mobile and landline.

We had a tidal surge half a century ago.

Panic causes injuries and death and i think it would be very difficult to evacuate a large city safely in a few hours, let alone a few minutes, esp as meteor strikes are highly unpredictable, precise location is almost impossible until its too late.

Manchester etc isn't going to be hit by wild fires.

We don't have Tsunami warning systems in the Atlantic.

You like the Govt are over reacting, in Hurricane prone areas etc yes a good idea but the UK isn't.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 25/03/2023 17:50

I don’t necessarily want to know if I’m asleep! If a meteorite is going to hit or we’re going to be nuked I’d rather go in my sleep thanks. If someone is missing I won’t be doing anything until the morning so it can wait.

Nimbostratus100 · 25/03/2023 17:45

Alexandra2001 · 25/03/2023 11:52

In the grand scheme of things, when folk can't get hospital treatment or an ambulance, this is a total waste of money.

Prepping for things that happen once every 1000 years but not doing the things that we all need each and everyday that really would save lives.

e.g such as not shutting down vaccine development programs whcih we ve decided to do......

Like i said... we don't have the means or ability to accurately determine these things, just as likely to drive people into a danger zone as out of it, not to mention the mass panic, with associated injuries/deaths... this alone will cause.

why would it cause mass panic and injury?

Other countries use these alerts and they save lives

Arer the UK population particularly low intelligence do you think? Is that what you are arguing? We are too thick to cope with being given safety instructions in an emergency???

We could have certainly used this in the local wild fires we had last summer, and are likely to have again, it isn't a once in a 1000 year occurrence, is it? Nor are flash floods, which are becoming ever more likely and ever more dangerous. Toxic pollution happens quite regularly all around the word too.

You are making absolutely no sense.

first argument - we don't suffer natural disasters- yes we do, and will do more so, and this isn't just for natural disasters, but many other (manmade) eventualities, such as a toxic pollution incident, etc.

second argument - we can get the information from the news - but only if it is constantly being checked, so noone who is working, or asleep, or away from the TV for any reason, such as having a life.

third argument - "in the grand scheme of things" "there are more important things to worry about" - more important than safety information that can cheaply and easily save lives in a deadly emergency - right. Ok

fourth argument - the UK population is too thick to cope with being given safety information in an emergency - well, if you genuinely feel you personally are too thick to cope with being given safety information in an emergency, then by all means, cut yourself off from it, but most normal people wont.

Like I said, it is people who somehow think that reflexive noncompliance makes them clever and superior that is against this, not anyone who actually has the sense to properly think about it and evaluate it

steff13 · 25/03/2023 13:38

JenniferBooth · 25/03/2023 12:57

So do i get an emergency alert to my phone if a relative has had a fall and has to wait hours for an ambulance

My phone has the option to alert people that I chose in case of an emergency. I have to press the side button 3 times in a row. And my watch has fall detection. You could set those up.

JenniferBooth · 25/03/2023 12:57

So do i get an emergency alert to my phone if a relative has had a fall and has to wait hours for an ambulance

Elphame · 25/03/2023 12:03

Nimbostratus100 · 25/03/2023 10:44

so you are against giving people the information and opportunity to evacuate ahead of a natural disaster? Or to take shelter?

Sorry, I dont follow your logic - we dont warn people to evacuate in case too many of them try to, and it gets difficult? Instead we leave them to be obliterated on the spot?

Evacuations save hundreds of thousands of lives every year.

If a warning arrives that your city is in the danger zone, and you need to move as far south as possible straight away, and you decide not to move with your family, rather wait and be incinerated, because you prefer that to a possible traffic jam, then thats your choice, but dont deny the choice to evacuate to everyone else

In theory maybe.

In reality people won't act rationally which will completely mess up any attempts of an orderly evacuation and do you really believe that there are mass evacuation plans and the resources needed already in place for major British cities?

Dream on.

Alexandra2001 · 25/03/2023 11:52

Nimbostratus100 · 25/03/2023 11:29

yes, an alert and instructions could save you from a tsunami, or a meteor strike, or a radiation leak, or a wild fire, or a toxic cloud, or a flood.....

and yes, it might be leave an area, or do not enter an area, or it might be go uphill, or go inside and close the doors and windows or get into a shop basement or underground carpark if you can, or get out of all basement and underground carparks, or fill you bath with water, or don't touch the water coming out of your taps,

or any number of things, but some people think it is o so clever and independent to cut themselves off from sources of safety information, and of course, they will be the people who others have to risk their lives to rescue, and tax payers have to pay to care for, after something bad has happened, and most people have done what they can to keep themselves safe, and some people have considered themselves above it.

In the grand scheme of things, when folk can't get hospital treatment or an ambulance, this is a total waste of money.

Prepping for things that happen once every 1000 years but not doing the things that we all need each and everyday that really would save lives.

e.g such as not shutting down vaccine development programs whcih we ve decided to do......

Like i said... we don't have the means or ability to accurately determine these things, just as likely to drive people into a danger zone as out of it, not to mention the mass panic, with associated injuries/deaths... this alone will cause.

Nimbostratus100 · 25/03/2023 11:29

Alexandra2001 · 25/03/2023 11:09

I ve switched it off already, as soon as i heard about...

You think an alert will save you from a Tsunami or a Meteor strike?

Also, its bloody dangerous as at any moment in time, 10s of 1000s maybe millions of people will be driving....

What the fuck are you supposed to do when told you've 3mins to get out of Devon and Cornwall as a meteor is about to strike but we aren't exactly sure where? or leave Bristol because a Tsunami is about to hit in 45 seconds?

We don't have Tsunami monitoring buoys like they do in the Pacific, so any warning will be very very short.

yes, an alert and instructions could save you from a tsunami, or a meteor strike, or a radiation leak, or a wild fire, or a toxic cloud, or a flood.....

and yes, it might be leave an area, or do not enter an area, or it might be go uphill, or go inside and close the doors and windows or get into a shop basement or underground carpark if you can, or get out of all basement and underground carparks, or fill you bath with water, or don't touch the water coming out of your taps,

or any number of things, but some people think it is o so clever and independent to cut themselves off from sources of safety information, and of course, they will be the people who others have to risk their lives to rescue, and tax payers have to pay to care for, after something bad has happened, and most people have done what they can to keep themselves safe, and some people have considered themselves above it.

useitorlose · 25/03/2023 11:26

We have this where I live. I get severe fog alerts, upcoming stationary traffic due to a crash (both only when driving in the area). In covid lockdown it was a hoot - every night when curfew started we would be startled by this racket as the messages came through reminding us to stay inside. Of course, they didn't call it curfew but we all know that is what it was.

Parker231 · 25/03/2023 11:14

Amazing how these systems can work in other countries but people think it couldn’t in the UK!

Alexandra2001 · 25/03/2023 11:09

Nimbostratus100 · 23/03/2023 15:25

well just in the last couple of years, alerts about flood and wildfires would have saved a lot of danger, difficulties, property ( especially cars) and a few lives, locally to me.

And the UK had been devastated by tsunami in the past, and will be again, but no one knows when

And meteor strikes could happen anywhere, anytime, at a size to cause major damage to an area the size of a city

Why do you think it is funny? What is funny about this?

I ve switched it off already, as soon as i heard about...

You think an alert will save you from a Tsunami or a Meteor strike?

Also, its bloody dangerous as at any moment in time, 10s of 1000s maybe millions of people will be driving....

What the fuck are you supposed to do when told you've 3mins to get out of Devon and Cornwall as a meteor is about to strike but we aren't exactly sure where? or leave Bristol because a Tsunami is about to hit in 45 seconds?

We don't have Tsunami monitoring buoys like they do in the Pacific, so any warning will be very very short.

Nimbostratus100 · 25/03/2023 11:03

I just dont understand the opposition to this - we have the technology to be able to be alerted to possible extreme ( or even moderate) immediate dangers, and be given instructions how to stay safe.

And people are against using it?

Nimbostratus100 · 25/03/2023 11:01

CahierNumberSixPlease · 25/03/2023 10:58

I'm pretty sure that anything like this would be all over the news (they've been going on enough about a harmless asteroid, so one that is a threat will be wall - wall constant news), so an alert will just add to the panic...if it isn't, because it was detected too late, then not sure an alert is going to help in that situation.

so your argument is everybody should be constantly looking at the news, just in case? What if you are working? what if you are asleep? what if you just dont constantly look at the news?

CahierNumberSixPlease · 25/03/2023 10:58

Nimbostratus100 · 25/03/2023 06:15

This is the sort of thing we might need alerts and immediate instructions for. These so called "city killers" are our biggest danger from space, as there are so many of them (tens of thousands) and a potential strike might only be detected with a few hours notice or less.

The bigger dangers, country- killers, or those capable of causing and "extinction level event" are far fewer, and will be detected and dealt with years in advance

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-65061818

I'm pretty sure that anything like this would be all over the news (they've been going on enough about a harmless asteroid, so one that is a threat will be wall - wall constant news), so an alert will just add to the panic...if it isn't, because it was detected too late, then not sure an alert is going to help in that situation.

Nimbostratus100 · 25/03/2023 10:44

Elphame · 25/03/2023 10:39

Yes. Causing mass panic and roads would gridlock and block instantly.

so you are against giving people the information and opportunity to evacuate ahead of a natural disaster? Or to take shelter?

Sorry, I dont follow your logic - we dont warn people to evacuate in case too many of them try to, and it gets difficult? Instead we leave them to be obliterated on the spot?

Evacuations save hundreds of thousands of lives every year.

If a warning arrives that your city is in the danger zone, and you need to move as far south as possible straight away, and you decide not to move with your family, rather wait and be incinerated, because you prefer that to a possible traffic jam, then thats your choice, but dont deny the choice to evacuate to everyone else

Elphame · 25/03/2023 10:39

Nimbostratus100 · 25/03/2023 06:15

This is the sort of thing we might need alerts and immediate instructions for. These so called "city killers" are our biggest danger from space, as there are so many of them (tens of thousands) and a potential strike might only be detected with a few hours notice or less.

The bigger dangers, country- killers, or those capable of causing and "extinction level event" are far fewer, and will be detected and dealt with years in advance

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-65061818

Yes. Causing mass panic and roads would gridlock and block instantly.

Nimbostratus100 · 25/03/2023 06:15

This is the sort of thing we might need alerts and immediate instructions for. These so called "city killers" are our biggest danger from space, as there are so many of them (tens of thousands) and a potential strike might only be detected with a few hours notice or less.

The bigger dangers, country- killers, or those capable of causing and "extinction level event" are far fewer, and will be detected and dealt with years in advance

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-65061818

Image of the ISS over Earth

Massive asteroid to pass by Earth on weekend

The unusually large space object will harmlessly bypass the planet this weekend.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-65061818

MyOldFriendTime · 24/03/2023 21:01

starynight63 · 24/03/2023 20:42

Haven't heard anything about this and I'm so glad you've posted. I've got severe PTSD and alarms send my into pure panic, I'll be turning mine off and hoping to stay in that day so I don't end up having a panic attack when it goes off unexpectedly x

I’m glad you’ve heard about it now. I think it hasn’t been advertised enough and like pps worry about secret phones hidden from abusive partners and anxious people. Maybe they should’ve had it as an ‘opt in’ thing rather than a compulsory thing.

starynight63 · 24/03/2023 20:42

Haven't heard anything about this and I'm so glad you've posted. I've got severe PTSD and alarms send my into pure panic, I'll be turning mine off and hoping to stay in that day so I don't end up having a panic attack when it goes off unexpectedly x

steff13 · 24/03/2023 20:39

In case anyone was concerned about the kids in the Amber Alert from my phone, they were found safe. Their mom left them in the car while she went into the gas station and someone stole the car with them in it.

Golightly133 · 24/03/2023 00:16

My concern is victims of DV who have emergency phones