Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask everyone to be grateful for their Mother's Day gifts?

142 replies

MyMumsOnMN · 18/03/2023 22:04

Am I being unreasonable to ask everyone to be grateful for whatever gifts they do/don't get for mothers day tomorrow?

I've seen a few threads on here tonight from selfish cows people expecting their kids to have done a better job and tried harder.

Some people will be dreading tomorrow so if you're lucky enough to be able to spend it with you mum/kids then just be grateful.

OP posts:
Nimbostratus100 · 19/03/2023 01:28

Essexexile · 18/03/2023 22:57

I rarely spend Mother’s Day with my DD’s now that they’re all adults and living too far away but I’m extremely grateful for the cards they each send me. I also have very fond memories of the cards and other stuff they made when they were at primary school and going to Mother’s Day assemblies.

Doesn't the waste and and environmental damage of all that card sending bother you at all though?

Cards and flowers are very much last century, surely we live in more enlightened times now

Nimbostratus100 · 19/03/2023 01:26

ElegantlyTouched · 18/03/2023 23:19

I totally agree. The church we went to when I was a child would give out bunches of daffs to children to give to their mothers, and to the rest of the women in the congregation too. Mymum and I would be part of a small group who sorted the bunches every year. I still (40 years on) remember the time my bunch had an extra flower than my friend's so I gave her the extra one, partly as I thought I may have been responsible, partly because my mum knew I loved her so it didn't matter if she got one less, and partly as it seemed the right, and Christian, thing to do.

My mum went ballistic, moaning how I couldn't love her if I could do that to her. I wad confused and upset by her reaction, and still am. My dd is too young to do anything but even when she's older a card will be more than enough. I love her, she loves me, that's all that matters.

I've walked out of churches where people have given out flowers on Mother's day, in anger at the sheer waste and environmental damage. Somebody chased me once with a bunch of flowers as I was leaving, and were surprised when I said no thanks, I was leaving because I didn't want flowers

Devpatelslaughingeyes · 19/03/2023 01:21

I don’t care about cards or gifts the best thing for me is just to be with them. No demands, no expectations. It’s enough just to see them, spend time with them, and to share love with them. My daughters have children at university who can’t be with them so we spend the day together. I know I am lucky and that we are not all the same but it’s not Christmas, it’s not your birthday, it’s really just a day for appreciating family, just being loved for being their mum - not expecting gifts. For me just giving out love and receiving it back is enough. Please just accept the day for what it is and stop feeding into the commercial hype.

SarahAndQuack · 19/03/2023 01:06

Thedogscollar · 19/03/2023 00:59

Your post is the unthinking one.
My son is a young adult with his own son now.
You have absolutely zero idea of the life I have led and the experiences we have gone through to get to this point.
When I said it's just nice to spend time with your children it was thinking of my own experiences with my son. His childhood was very difficult then teenage years just horrendous.
We have now come to a time in our lives where we are entering a different phase in our relationship that I never thought we would have.
Apologies if I touched a nerve with you my post was not meant to come across as smug. Tbh I sent my son a text yesterday inviting him over for lunch today and I've yet to hear back, yet I know he is on his phone all the time.
I hope he does come over. All I meant was time spent with a loved one is the best gift. Mothers day seems to cause so much unrest over gifts given and gifts not given.
And yes I know mothering Sunday can be very hard for some myself included as my own lovely Mum is no longer with me.

No, I thought hard. I thought about why people might not feel simply 'happy' about Mothering Sunday.

I get why you say you were just thinking about your own experiences with your son. It sounds as if you had a really rough time, and I am so sorry for that. But - you can't just think about yourself, and judge people. It's not fair. It's really important to recognise that people react really different to these sorts of 'significant' events.

I agree with you that, for some, spending time with loved ones is the best gift. But ... we are all different. It matters to remember those people for whom this is not the best gift - people who are estranged from family, or who know their families can't manage a visit; people who would love only too much to be with family, but know it will end in more hurt. I do understand you are upset and hurt and it feels as if you're missing out (and so many of us are), but I still do honestly think it's fairer and better to realise that people who don't seem to celebrate the way you do may still be doing their best.

I'm so very sorry for the loss of your mother.

Thedogscollar · 19/03/2023 00:59

SarahAndQuack · 19/03/2023 00:28

This sort of unthinking smug attitude is the problem, though. Yes, it is lovely that your son wrote you a thoughtful card, and that you get to spend time with him. You assume that everyone should 'just be happy' to spend time with their children. But plenty of people don't have that luxury. There are women whose entire time with their children is clouded by abusive ex's, or by fear things are going wrong. There are women who won't possibly be able to take Sunday off just because it's Mothering Sunday. There are mothers of grown children who don't get to see them, and mothers of children who are separated from them.

Saying you are happy 'just' to spend time with your children is all very well, but please try to recognise that some of the mums who may seem, to you, to be putting strange emphases on gifts or actions, may be those who know Mothering Sunday will be a rather sad day.

Your post is the unthinking one.
My son is a young adult with his own son now.
You have absolutely zero idea of the life I have led and the experiences we have gone through to get to this point.
When I said it's just nice to spend time with your children it was thinking of my own experiences with my son. His childhood was very difficult then teenage years just horrendous.
We have now come to a time in our lives where we are entering a different phase in our relationship that I never thought we would have.
Apologies if I touched a nerve with you my post was not meant to come across as smug. Tbh I sent my son a text yesterday inviting him over for lunch today and I've yet to hear back, yet I know he is on his phone all the time.
I hope he does come over. All I meant was time spent with a loved one is the best gift. Mothers day seems to cause so much unrest over gifts given and gifts not given.
And yes I know mothering Sunday can be very hard for some myself included as my own lovely Mum is no longer with me.

SarahAndQuack · 19/03/2023 00:56

Ishouldgodostuff · 19/03/2023 00:46

Oh yes, with bells on. Happy Mothers Day to all the wonderful Mums everywhere celebrating in the morning & be happy if you can be together or share something with your kids on the day.

Its become very very commercialised - all around the world - & I think that the idea of thanking & remembering our Mums has been lost with the rush to buy bigger, better (& more expensive) gifts instead.

A handwritten card, maybe a cup of tea made for you & a cuddle are all lovely thoughtful things to receive from those who love you the most. I used to just wish my lot didnt fight (between themselves) for just one day of peace - any thing else was a bonus! 😍

Absolutely! It's like the way wedding proposals are. All I expect is a lovely ring, a romantic kiss, and a holiday to Paris. Anything else is a bonus! I can't think why other people aren't happy with their lot.

Bookendsinglass · 19/03/2023 00:50

God, how I feel this! I tell my kids I don’t want them spending much, am happy with a nice bar of soap or favourite sweets. My own mother, meanwhile, doesn’t want: flowers, chocolates, anything else edible, anything for the house, scented candles, anything bath and body, champagne, books she won’t like (break out the crystal ball), scarves….my sister suggested we go halves on a Gucci belt 😂😂😂
I got her some White Company cashmere bed socks. I’m betting socks will be on the forbidden list for next year

Ishouldgodostuff · 19/03/2023 00:46

Oh yes, with bells on. Happy Mothers Day to all the wonderful Mums everywhere celebrating in the morning & be happy if you can be together or share something with your kids on the day.

Its become very very commercialised - all around the world - & I think that the idea of thanking & remembering our Mums has been lost with the rush to buy bigger, better (& more expensive) gifts instead.

A handwritten card, maybe a cup of tea made for you & a cuddle are all lovely thoughtful things to receive from those who love you the most. I used to just wish my lot didnt fight (between themselves) for just one day of peace - any thing else was a bonus! 😍

smashinggrapes · 19/03/2023 00:39

"I’ve got 4 girls, eldest is 20 and at uni, others teenagers, I won’t get anything for Mother’s Day, not even a card, even though I do so much for everyone and have struggled so much -because I have no DH or DP to make a fuss and the girls are all ND and forget/it’s too much trouble/better things to spend their money on. So yeah it does get a bit grating when people are moaning their gifts/meals/coffee in bed isn’t good enough lol"

Lol? What the fuck? 4 kids and not one of them acknowledges Mother's Day?

smashinggrapes · 19/03/2023 00:36

"My mum passed away this week… I have to get up tomorrow and smile for my very loving children. Would much rather do or have nothing x"

I'm so sorry xx

SarahAndQuack · 19/03/2023 00:32

TeenLifeMum · 19/03/2023 00:31

How about, for some tomorrow will be lovely and for others it’ll be hard. Let’s just feel how we feel with no worry about others judging us?

Yes, this.

Workinghardeveryday · 19/03/2023 00:31

Mummapenguin20 · 18/03/2023 22:35

My mum passed away this week… I have to get up tomorrow and smile for my very loving children. Would much rather do or have nothing x

I really am so sorry for your loss xxx

TeenLifeMum · 19/03/2023 00:31

How about, for some tomorrow will be lovely and for others it’ll be hard. Let’s just feel how we feel with no worry about others judging us?

BreviloquentBastard · 19/03/2023 00:30

My husband let slip that my daughter has been crocheting me a jumper for weeks. It's the most lurid shade of purple. I will love it and treasure it and wear it until it falls to pieces.

SarahAndQuack · 19/03/2023 00:28

Thedogscollar · 19/03/2023 00:16

I've just opened my mother's day card from my son. Lovely words and that will do for me.
Just be happy to spend time with your children.

This sort of unthinking smug attitude is the problem, though. Yes, it is lovely that your son wrote you a thoughtful card, and that you get to spend time with him. You assume that everyone should 'just be happy' to spend time with their children. But plenty of people don't have that luxury. There are women whose entire time with their children is clouded by abusive ex's, or by fear things are going wrong. There are women who won't possibly be able to take Sunday off just because it's Mothering Sunday. There are mothers of grown children who don't get to see them, and mothers of children who are separated from them.

Saying you are happy 'just' to spend time with your children is all very well, but please try to recognise that some of the mums who may seem, to you, to be putting strange emphases on gifts or actions, may be those who know Mothering Sunday will be a rather sad day.

TeenLifeMum · 19/03/2023 00:27

er no. Some people have young dc and terrible dh’s who don’t make any effort. mum have every right to feel upset on Mother’s Day if their family make no effort. Other people having more difficult/sad circumstances doesn’t mean they can’t have feelings.

Thedogscollar · 19/03/2023 00:16

I've just opened my mother's day card from my son. Lovely words and that will do for me.
Just be happy to spend time with your children.

JMSA · 19/03/2023 00:10

I understand some people's disappointment. Maybe they just don't feel like feeling grateful.

SoShallINever · 19/03/2023 00:08

Mummapenguin20 · 18/03/2023 22:35

My mum passed away this week… I have to get up tomorrow and smile for my very loving children. Would much rather do or have nothing x

Ahh that's very hard Mummapenguin, good luck with tomorrow.

Mummyratbag · 19/03/2023 00:00

Mother's Day is so painful for those who have lost their mum or are nc with them or have lost a child or are infertile...I would not miss it if it didn't happen ..along with Father's Day, Valentine's Day etc .. I have 2 lovely kids who have drawn me cards and a DH who will have organised a gift(s)..I will spend the day with family, but I have lost a child and had miscarriages -there were many years that it hurt.

Spectre8 · 18/03/2023 23:51

There is always a point in people's lives when they look back and realise time is the most valuable gift of all, you cannot buy it. Often by then its almost too late.

I dont ask for gifts, I ask for time. Time to spend doing something together, or a long phonecall for a chat. That is what is most valuable at least to me.

In a world where people are so busy its easy to just order a gift online or pick something up. Whats harder is making time to see people or to chat to them and tell them how much they appreciate you etc.

So when someone I care about makes time for me I treasure it more than anything.

Its shame some people find value from material things

caringcarer · 18/03/2023 23:49

I saw my eldest son last weekend and he gave me flowers and a card I have not opened yet. I got a card in post from DD today and youngest son who still lives at home told me she put money in his account to get me flowers but will wait until other ones die first. Youngest son taking me to breakfast tomorrow morning. I love a good breakfast out. Foster son will have a card for me and usually gets me chocolates or perfume. I am always very happy with my gifts and cards. I just wish my own Mum was still alive. I've sent MiL a Moonpig card she will know I picked it because it has nice words in and DH always used to get her a plane or funny one. Seeing her next weekend and will give her flowers then.

BloodyThursday · 18/03/2023 23:46

I don't think social media helps. Lots of people posting their Mother's Day gifts online for all to see. It seems to be that they feel this is their worth. Like a competition.

Personally I'd be happy with a lay in. I don't care what people think on social media. So you got a Mulberry handbag? Good for you. I got a lay in, coffee and biscuits in bed. Grin

Thedogscollar · 18/03/2023 23:36

Sharkpenis · 18/03/2023 23:17

My ex husband is a pedophile who sexually abused my daughter. Tbh, i dont care about gifts. Ive got my kids. Theyre safe! Thats all i need.

💐so sorry.

Testina · 18/03/2023 23:26

Some people will have legitimate complaints.
You don’t get to tell them they can’t have feelings because at least they have kids, or a mum, or whatever your issue is.

Mine’s a useless sack of shit and I was taken into care as a result.

Still not going to tell other people to be grateful.

Some people are living in the Ukraine war zones, and children are starving in Africa.

Doesn’t mean nobody else can complain about something, ever.

Sometimes the right thing isn’t to suck it up and be grateful… and we should stop socialising women that way.