Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To buy a £700k house on £67k

544 replies

Polledja · 18/03/2023 19:08

My wife and I are looking to buy a house. I was very foolish with my money during my younger days so am behind my peers.
we want a house near a good school and houses in that area range from £550k to £700k. The ones my wife likes are at the higher end but I don’t think we can afford these. She has become withdrawn and depressed during this process and it caused allot of tension.
I have approx £280k for a deposit (this is all our savings bar £18k). We can borrow £350k based on our joint salaries of £67k. It leaves me £90k short. I think I could borrow this from family.

our net pay is £3900 per month. We would have £2000 tonoay on our mortgage leaving us with £1900 to pay everything else. We have two young kids at school. Our monthly expenses excluding our mortgage are about £1600 so it would meaning having nothing left each month

OP posts:
BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 18/03/2023 20:53

plugin12 · 18/03/2023 20:46

@pinkbaglady You don't live in the south east then? Because you simply wouldn't find a house for that little cost.

3bed house in Kent for £280k

TwoHedgehogs · 18/03/2023 20:52

Madness. We earn more than you (not in a ner ner ner ner way) our joint earnings are nearly 90k, we were looking to move, we'd need to borrow 225k for the houses we'd like (4 bed family home) and I'm just not willing to take the leap right now. House prices and interest rates need to come down and our salary needs to go up before I'll consider taking on a mortgage for over 200k. Our ltv would be v good, we'd get the best rates, but nope.

I just can't understand why you'd even contemplate this, not only is it a huge risk, you will have very little money for anything else. I think your wife is living in la la land. Don't do it, even if a mortgage company is mad enough to lend you that much.

Anotherturnipforthebooks · 18/03/2023 20:51

GiltEdges · 18/03/2023 20:49

Christ, I wouldn't be taking on that mortgage and our household income is 4x yours.

You have an income of £268k a year but wouldn't take on a £350k mortgage?

Embelline · 18/03/2023 20:51

As others have said, you won’t get approved for that. You’ll fail affordability. And I can’t believe you would take money off family when you have no means of paying money back surely, with that much disposable income left over each month?

Idtotallybangdreamoftheendlessnotgonnalie · 18/03/2023 20:51

We had a £280k deposit on a £500k mortgage, with a £90k income. It's worked out at £1k/month which is affordable but I genuinely wouldn't want to go much higher because we have a really good quality of life- it's all about balance. Once day to day life is paid for we have £700 left over for long term goals- holidays, spending etc. I'd hate for that money to be going into housing costs, which it could very well do once our 0.9% fixed rate ends and we go on the svr. We've got 4 years for interest rates to come down or to save as much as we can to reduce a chunk of mortgage when we remortgage. You really don't want to max out your borrowing power and tie yourself to huge monthly payments potentially going into a recession, you just don't.

GiltEdges · 18/03/2023 20:49

Christ, I wouldn't be taking on that mortgage and our household income is 4x yours.

Anotherturnipforthebooks · 18/03/2023 20:49

@bellac11

Assuming a min £30k deposit on a £300k house, that means a £270k mortgage on a £110k income, so quite a bit less than x3

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 18/03/2023 20:48

Her reasoning is that we are only going to buy a house once so we might as well make it the most we can afford

But the houses she wants, she cant afford

sqirrelfriends · 18/03/2023 20:48

dont do it, It’s not worth the stress that will follow.

Big houses have bigger bills and there’s so much uncertainty right now, who know is costs will rise further.

plugin12 · 18/03/2023 20:46

@pinkbaglady You don't live in the south east then? Because you simply wouldn't find a house for that little cost.

Ap42 · 18/03/2023 20:45

When myself and my ex broke up I didn't think I could afford to buy anything, inspite of a healthy deposit. But my mortgage broker worked his magic, and I managed to get approved for a smallish mortgage. But in doing so it meant by budget was low, so I looked at where I could afford to live and moved to a whole new county. Buying a house is a dream for so many, it maybe time to remind your wife your in a fab position with a big deposit, but she needs to compromise. I wouldn't sleep taking on that kind of mortgage with that income. There's no wiggle room for emergencies, home improvements, or general fun. I hope she sees sense as it's such a terrible time to be over stretching yourself.

wineandsunshine · 18/03/2023 20:45

Does this have to be your 'forever home' ?

I would never agree to this based on your calculations. To put it in perspective we earn £90k and our mortgage was £220k at a push.

Cost of living is mental!

OuiLaLa · 18/03/2023 20:44

My house was £750k, we had a similar amount in deposit and the rest is mortgage. We bring home approx 6.5k per month (net). I would not fancy it on less monthly income!

I sympathise with your wife - it’s hard to not be able to buy something you like and in principle I agree with stretching for something great - we lived in a house I had no love for for about 7 years before we bought this one (which I do love).

But I think she is wrong to say you only buy a house once, most people buy more than once! Perhaps your next house will be the dream?

milliondollardress · 18/03/2023 20:43

bellac11 · 18/03/2023 20:39

I havent seen any of those, one poster said their joint income is 110k and wont consider houses over 300k. Thats not too far off 3x income which once upon a time would have been the standard borrowing. Nothing that astounding.

That was decades ago though.

To me, that level of risk aversion seems ridiculous when you’re working hard enough to earn that kind of salary.

I also live in an area where that wouldn’t get you more than a 1 bedroom flat!

HockeyJock · 18/03/2023 20:41

We have a higher household income and a much lower mortgage and yet we still don't have loads of disposable income (we're absolutely fine, have a good quality of life and are not having to worry but we can't go on lots of foreign holidays or eat out much). Children are expensive and become dramatically so as they get bigger - my teen DC are a serious drain on resources and we haven't reached driving lessons and uni yet!

Iirc loans or even gifts from family are viewed suspiciously by lenders, especially if they're immediately prior to an application rather than an inheritance etc. Our broker explained this is because lenders view this as a sign that you haven't managed to save it yourselves and that family members may want relating or try to stake some claim in the home at a later date.

I genuinely don't think you can afford this (or should want to). I get your wife's disappointment and she will need to accept the dream can't be realised. That can be hard but any lender is likely to say no to this proposal. Worth speaking to a broker to hear it from someone else and the reasons why?

milliondollardress · 18/03/2023 20:40

pinkbaglady · 18/03/2023 20:19

My DH and I bring in about £6000 a month and I wouldn’t dream of buying a house over £280,000.

why? Because we’re financially responsible.

Unless you’re in your 60s or something and this would be your first home, this is risk averse in the extreme 😳

LisaD1 · 18/03/2023 20:39

Even if you could loan 90k from family (which frankly you can’t afford to pay back so who will you screw over for that much?) I’d be amazed if the bank would loan you the rest and if they did you would be mad to do this. One internet raise and you’re totally screwed. Our mortgage has gone up £400 over recent months and utilities have doubled. We are “lucky” we can afford this, if we over mortgaged ourselves like you plan to we would be bankrupt.

bellac11 · 18/03/2023 20:39

Anotherturnipforthebooks · 18/03/2023 20:18

As astounded as I am by op's situation, I'm also puzzled by the 'we have a £200k income and wouldn't dream of buy a house costing more than £300k' type posts.

I havent seen any of those, one poster said their joint income is 110k and wont consider houses over 300k. Thats not too far off 3x income which once upon a time would have been the standard borrowing. Nothing that astounding.

TaraRhu · 18/03/2023 20:38

I must be mad because I don't think that's so stupid... but I live in London and everyone is mortgaged to death.

We bought a £655 k home on £100k joint. We had about a £200k deposit. There's not much left every month but we aren't broke. Our costs will go down when the youngest goes to school too. Only 2 more years of nursery to go!

£700 is pushing it but maybe you could find a fixer upper at the lower end that you could do up over time?

NewNovember · 18/03/2023 20:37

Honestly I would buy a £280k house enjoy my life and use tutors if necessary for years 9-11

Pieandchips1234456 · 18/03/2023 20:37

I wish you both the best but this would be a foolish choice to make. Not only that how on earth would you pay back the 90k? You would be living hand to mouth. In my childhood days we called places like this spam valley. The owners took on so much more than they could chew and had to live on spam or beans on toast.

Stravaig · 18/03/2023 20:36

I wouldn't want to leave myself only £18K savings/emergency fund if I were responsible for 2 young children and a property. So let's make that £250K deposit maximum, and £48K savings.

Now, with a £250K deposit, wouldn't it be a happier life with a much cheaper home and (almost) no mortgage, soon paid off?

Your current plan leaves no slack in the budget for interest rate hikes, cost of living continuing upward, or losing one or both salaries.

You say you weren't good with money in your younger years, and that it is your wife driving this over-extension on property. It sounds like you are both still tempted beyond your means: she in her property aspirations; you in your choice of partner. Neither of you have the salaries to match!

Thisgirlcan21 · 18/03/2023 20:35

Surely there is nice areas with good schools which you can afford. Why do this? Your life will be so stressful every single month. I’m not sure you would get the mortgage anyway

EstherHazy · 18/03/2023 20:34

Gosh lots of judgment here!

The affordability has lots of variables... The money from family - depends if this is a gift or not. The borrowing amount - prob your expectations may be too high but if you're in professional jobs (accountants, doctors etc) you can potentially still borrow 5x. Your outgoings- could these change (either way)? Do you have reasonable expectations of growth in salaries? If so then maybe it could all come together.

Unlike most here, I think it's not a bad thing to go for the most you can afford, if you want to. I guess a lot depends on where in the country you are - if you live an area like mine this money won't actually buy a very fancy house at all so it's not unreasonable to stretch yourself in order to get to a relatively basic family home in a safe neighbourhood. I'm borrowing the max I can, and when renting always rented way over the affordability limit (thanks to a guarantee from my parents) - because that's what I wanted to spend my money on.

One thing is prices are dropping quite a lot - especially that family home level - so give it a year and your 700k house is 630k and you can afford it after all.

But if you want 'out', the way to do this is conversations around such a low contingency, what may be compromised with family cars and holidays, your kids education needs (you might want to have tutors / go private etc etc), and what lifestyle you can get if its not tied up in the house.

Raineth · 18/03/2023 20:33

DanceMonster · 18/03/2023 19:10

How would you pay your family back if you have no money spare each month?

This ^^

Swipe left for the next trending thread