Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Living somewhere you hate. AIBU to want to rent in London?

112 replies

Lissaaaaaa · 18/03/2023 15:10

Moved here for husbands study. We’ve now lived here 5 years. He’s a Doctor so can work anywhere. He is a junior doctor and earns around 32k.
We have two children. I don’t work. childcare costs priced me out Of working.
We’ve lived in several different cities and towns and we are personally happiest in London. We also like Bristol and Bath.
We both agree this place is not for us. It’s deprived, rural, not good schools (unless willing to go private), I don’t drive and public transport is poor. I feel very trapped here as there’s no walking distance facilities.

To live in London we need my Husband to be on at least 70k to buy somewhere. We are therefore stuck here for a few more years until he completes GP training. Unless we rent.
Our eldest is 9. Youngest is a baby.

My husband thinks we should stay here until we can buy a property in London. He says if we move to London and rent we will struggle to find the money to buy. Bristol and Bath aren’t much better property price wise so might as well go for our first choice of London. We’re currently renting. Trying to save a deposit. Our rent here is £500 a month for a lovely two bed place.

I am pretty miserable here to be honest. I’m now wondering if we should move somewhere a bit better (at least with some facilities and good public transport) and buy somewhere cheaper while we try and save for London. I was looking at Liverpool and Manchester.

However my husband says that will be disturbing for our eldest changing schools at that stage of his education. He also says the hassle of buying a house, moving etc somewhere we have no intention to live is not worth it. We’d also not be chain free when we move to London.

I am struggling to live happily somewhere I know will never be home. Where I know I won’t be living. Where I can’t even go to the shop without a bus ( that’s always late and goes every hour). That has no facilities or after school clubs. That’s deprived. We made a mistake moving here and it feels now we’re here we’re stuck.

‘’sometimes I think we should just move to London and rent. In fact I am now sure we should move to London and rent. Even if it’s in a less nice area and small it is at least somewhere with transport, facilities and a vibe.
We know many people in London renting on our income. They get some top up from universal credit, rent somewhere smaller and further out then they need. Accept their income will be spent on rent.
AIBU to want to rent in London?

My husband has good earning potential. His income will go up every year plus he can do agency work to earn more, in 5 years he can be on 100k+ which I feel even with renting will allow us to buy somewhere.

OP posts:
dreamingbohemian · 18/03/2023 16:28

OP I really sympathise with you but I'm afraid it's not at all realistic to rent in London on one income of 32K. If you put that in the affordability calculators (which everyone uses) that only qualifies you for rent of £1050/month, you're not going to find a 2BR for that even in the outer zones.

I would suggest moving to Liverpool, which has the city life you want but a lot cheaper, so even if you rent for a few years you can still save, especially when the youngest is 3 and you can go back to work.

It sounds like by the time your husband is earning enough to buy anywhere your eldest will be in secondary, that is not a good time to move.

Ohlalahair · 18/03/2023 16:26

Jesus just get a car

Im guessing you haven’t lived in London before as a family? Unless you’re very well off (I’m talking considerably more than 100k) it can be hard to buy somewhere decent close to a school you like

stay where you are, get a car - try and appreciate what you do have - play the long game. Buying and selling is a pin in the arse and not everyone makes money out of it so I would be reluctant to buy anywhere you don’t intended to stay in for at least 10 years

Beezknees · 18/03/2023 16:25

My single childfree friend lives in London on that salary and he can only afford a room in a shared house. How on earth will you afford to rent a 2 bedroom place?

Ladybird2023 · 18/03/2023 16:25

Forget London, on that salary 20 years ago I was flat-sharing with 2 other (paying) adults, and still not saving very much at all.

Ovidnaso · 18/03/2023 16:24

Lastnamedidntstick · 18/03/2023 15:47

If you’re that miserable you could get a job and learn to drive?

childcare would only be for a couple of years if your youngest is a baby. You could at least look at part time, or evenings/weekends.

does your husband work shifts?

why is it all on him to earn more and enable your lifestyle?

do you have any plans to contribute when your children are older?

She has a baby ffs.

Albiboba · 18/03/2023 16:23

Lissaaaaaa · 18/03/2023 15:26

Not grim for us though. We don’t really mind living somewhere a bit small and rough. We just want to live in London.
only consideration is the wasted money on rent.

It would be a lot worse than a bit small or grim. A family of 4 and 30k in London means no day trips because when the tube is too expensive, no treats for the kids, struggling to keep up with kids growing out of clothes, trying to make a tiny food budget stretch the week, your husband will probably have to get 3 buses to work because a travel card is too expensive.
I struggled in London renting in a flat share on 30 k, it’s not realistic for a family of 4.

Ginmonkeyagain · 18/03/2023 16:21

And obviously as I was sharing the rent and bills with two other working adults it was cheaper than it would be for the same size household with only one working adult. Our "household" income was probably more like £90k. Although that doesn't directly map on to a family income, as adult sharers do not share costs of things like food and tend to use more energy than a same sized family unit.

notprincehamlet · 18/03/2023 16:17

Would you be eligible for any key worker housing schemes that might make living in or closer to London possible?

Ginmonkeyagain · 18/03/2023 16:16

I was on £32k in London in 2007. I was renting a large three bed flat with two friends in Camberwell, South London.

I had a nice enough life - went out, saved a bit, was paying off my student loan, had a few city breaks a year. But I did have to watch the pennies a little. Doing it on the same salary 15 years later with two children and a non working spouse would be pretty tough.

DelphiniumBlue · 18/03/2023 16:10

If you are unhappy living where you are , then that is a good enough reason to move. Not sure that London would work that well on a salary of 32k. You could get a small 2 bed flat in Wood Green or somewhere similar for about £1700 pm, not in a nice area tbh.
But transport is great, schools are good, you won't need to drive and you'd probably be able to get some kind of work yourself. There's lots of free stuff to do, and everything you need on your doorstep.If you could get UC then it might be worth it.
Liverpool is also quite buzzing, don't know about schools or transport links there but it's so much cheaper than London.

Orangepolentacake · 18/03/2023 16:07

You’ll likely be spending 15k/over a year in rent alone.
we spend over £20k and it’s a 2 bed in a not extremely nice area, zone 3 east

Beautifulsunflowers · 18/03/2023 16:05

Op I think you need to find a happy middle ground. Could you move nearer to a town where the transport links are better?
As for your dh saying it would disrupt your eldest education now, he’s wrong! IMO!! Now is the best time to move before secondary school starts.
Are you able to learn to drive? No medical conditions stopping you? I think you would find it useful if you can.

Mitchumforthewin · 18/03/2023 16:05

I couldn’t afford to live in London on 30k back in 2002 on my own, let alone now… you could barely pay rent even in the mankiest areas. Wait til husband is on the big bucks then go - but Bath or Bristol is still much cheaper. You can get decent family houses there for 400k which would be v tough in London unless you’re way out in zone 59293.

Calmdown14 · 18/03/2023 16:05

Even people that love London are unlikely to say they'd live anywhere in London.

The most sensible time to move would be before your child starts secondary school so catchment areas are really going to matter.

Are there not better connected parts of the region that you are currently in you could move to?

oldtree54 · 18/03/2023 16:03

You wouldn't be able to live in London as a family of four on £32k. It's just not do-able. A 2-bed property to rent would be over half your husband's monthly salary, not including bills.

Tinkerbyebye · 18/03/2023 15:58

Learn to drive

Lastnamedidntstick · 18/03/2023 15:57

Cornwallintherain · 18/03/2023 15:50

IF the OP is somewhere like Truro then she's right. And finding a part time job here is rare. We're still in a "Mums shouldn't work" region and recruitment agencies are not afraid to tell you that "having children has ruined your career"....

Also it's very difficult to book driving lessons here. There's still a covid backlog.

Some places in the UK are still decades behind the rest so be kind unless you know OPs details x

She’s been there 5 years and had a baby in that time. She had 4 years while her eldest was at school to learn to drive, including before covid.

sometimes you need to take responsibility and be proactive in making changes to achieve what you want.

Ilikewinter · 18/03/2023 15:54

Whilst I understand the desire to move, I dont see how you can possibly afford to live in London. Have you checked out the rent for 2 bedroom properties?. In fact, £500 rent sounds like an absolute steal and im not sure where you would find that in the other cities youve mentioned.

Cornwallintherain · 18/03/2023 15:50

IF the OP is somewhere like Truro then she's right. And finding a part time job here is rare. We're still in a "Mums shouldn't work" region and recruitment agencies are not afraid to tell you that "having children has ruined your career"....

Also it's very difficult to book driving lessons here. There's still a covid backlog.

Some places in the UK are still decades behind the rest so be kind unless you know OPs details x

Endlesssummer2022 · 18/03/2023 15:49

No don’t do it. You’ll trap yourself into renting forever. Stay where you are and save for a deposit. Also you need to start working as soon as your child reaches nursery age if you want to save /move more quickly.

hopelesslydevotedtoGu · 18/03/2023 15:48

So many GPs are reducing hours or leaving the profession, I wouldn't pin all your hopes on your husband earning the maximum salary to buy a London house. It's a big responsibility to be the sole earner with a large mortgage, and he is in a profession that is losing lots of GPs for various reasons.

If you can't drive, I would move somewhere with better public transport and things in walking distance (unless you can learn to drive). There are loads of places that would be a better fit than where you are now, but aren't as expensive as London.

Don't be miserable for years focusing on a future move to London. Have a sensible think about what would suit your family better, where you can afford, and visit places.

I would really try to avoid choosing an area where you spend all your money on rent, and aren't saving anything. Renting long term will have a huge effect on your family finances.

Also you say you don't mind living in a bad area- when your child is a teenager, the area they live in, school they attend and friends they make there will have a HUGE influence on their life direction.

Lastnamedidntstick · 18/03/2023 15:47

If you’re that miserable you could get a job and learn to drive?

childcare would only be for a couple of years if your youngest is a baby. You could at least look at part time, or evenings/weekends.

does your husband work shifts?

why is it all on him to earn more and enable your lifestyle?

do you have any plans to contribute when your children are older?

Artisticpaint · 18/03/2023 15:46

Move to Liverpool, good transport good nightlife reasonable housing costs. Get on the property ladder now wherever you are.

Cornwallintherain · 18/03/2023 15:45

@Lissaaaaaa are you in Truro??

mumsys · 18/03/2023 15:43

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

Swipe left for the next trending thread