Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Living somewhere you hate. AIBU to want to rent in London?

112 replies

Lissaaaaaa · 18/03/2023 15:10

Moved here for husbands study. We’ve now lived here 5 years. He’s a Doctor so can work anywhere. He is a junior doctor and earns around 32k.
We have two children. I don’t work. childcare costs priced me out Of working.
We’ve lived in several different cities and towns and we are personally happiest in London. We also like Bristol and Bath.
We both agree this place is not for us. It’s deprived, rural, not good schools (unless willing to go private), I don’t drive and public transport is poor. I feel very trapped here as there’s no walking distance facilities.

To live in London we need my Husband to be on at least 70k to buy somewhere. We are therefore stuck here for a few more years until he completes GP training. Unless we rent.
Our eldest is 9. Youngest is a baby.

My husband thinks we should stay here until we can buy a property in London. He says if we move to London and rent we will struggle to find the money to buy. Bristol and Bath aren’t much better property price wise so might as well go for our first choice of London. We’re currently renting. Trying to save a deposit. Our rent here is £500 a month for a lovely two bed place.

I am pretty miserable here to be honest. I’m now wondering if we should move somewhere a bit better (at least with some facilities and good public transport) and buy somewhere cheaper while we try and save for London. I was looking at Liverpool and Manchester.

However my husband says that will be disturbing for our eldest changing schools at that stage of his education. He also says the hassle of buying a house, moving etc somewhere we have no intention to live is not worth it. We’d also not be chain free when we move to London.

I am struggling to live happily somewhere I know will never be home. Where I know I won’t be living. Where I can’t even go to the shop without a bus ( that’s always late and goes every hour). That has no facilities or after school clubs. That’s deprived. We made a mistake moving here and it feels now we’re here we’re stuck.

‘’sometimes I think we should just move to London and rent. In fact I am now sure we should move to London and rent. Even if it’s in a less nice area and small it is at least somewhere with transport, facilities and a vibe.
We know many people in London renting on our income. They get some top up from universal credit, rent somewhere smaller and further out then they need. Accept their income will be spent on rent.
AIBU to want to rent in London?

My husband has good earning potential. His income will go up every year plus he can do agency work to earn more, in 5 years he can be on 100k+ which I feel even with renting will allow us to buy somewhere.

OP posts:
AnuSTart · 18/03/2023 17:35

Calmdown14 · 18/03/2023 17:23

I'm sorry but the idea that there are regions where women couldn't possibly get a job with pre schoolers is laughable. You don't put in on the application form and it's not legal to ask you.

And I live in a very rural region which would be considered the arse end of nowhere to most. If you don't want or need to work or being at home makes most sense for your family, that's fine but to suggest it's the case for all women seeking employment based on geography is nonsense.

Absolutely.

Your post OP freaks me out a little as you keep speaking about we but essentially the burden is on your husband who is supporting 3 people on a small salary and who will have to work a lot of overtime and move frequenting order to really get the career growth you expect to come.

Even if it wipes out your salary, it makes no sense to not work and build a career of your own. It's the 21st century and relying on someone who isn't a millionaire to support you, in expensive cities, is very short sighted.
I earn 3x what your husband earns and my partner also. We have 3 kids. We wouldn't choose to live in London. Also the stress for him in supporting 3 of you with all the costs could take a toll on your relationship.

Cleethorpes · 18/03/2023 17:25

I've been you OP, I understand. Wait though, it will be worth it. Good luck!!

Calmdown14 · 18/03/2023 17:23

I'm sorry but the idea that there are regions where women couldn't possibly get a job with pre schoolers is laughable. You don't put in on the application form and it's not legal to ask you.

And I live in a very rural region which would be considered the arse end of nowhere to most. If you don't want or need to work or being at home makes most sense for your family, that's fine but to suggest it's the case for all women seeking employment based on geography is nonsense.

SteveBuscemisRheumyEye · 18/03/2023 17:16

@Lissaaaaaa you say you'd live anywhere in London but discount Liverpool for high crime rates and poor schools... have you actually been to a lot of places in London?

We live in a three-bed semi in zone 3, both work (income approx 120k) and have one child. In London, we're no where near rich...

dreamingbohemian · 18/03/2023 17:08

Zanatdy · 18/03/2023 16:30

You’d get help with the rent on 30k and presumably your husbands earnings will increase dramatically over the years. Rent for now. I live near london and love living here. Even with the expensive rents / house prices

But no one will rent them a flat in the first place, it doesn't matter if they can get UC. There is enormous competition for flats, they'll go to people with higher salaries.

MrsMullerBecameABaby · 18/03/2023 17:04

Don't junior doctors move all over the country to progress their training?

I grew up with a doctor parent and we moved at least six times "with daddy's job" while he climbed through all the necessary positions before he got a consultant job - wildly different parts of the UK hundreds of miles apart and two jobs overseas (which were presumably for the money not career progression, not sure whether they were two birds with one stone).

veneeroftheyear · 18/03/2023 16:59

We recently rented a very ordinary house in London and had to prove an income of over £65k in order to pass the credit check. Places are in short supply and I was shocked that you had to bid over the advertised price to secure a property. This is in zone 3/4, not somewhere fancy in the centre. Fortunately it was just a short term thing for us, but the market is brutal and even harder if you're on benefits. Unless you are eligible for subsidied key worker accommodation I don't know how you would manage.

Queenofscones · 18/03/2023 16:57

I visited a friend in London, where I lived for 25 years, the other day. She showed me that the flat she and I shared — a compact 2 bedroom flat in a dull, unattractive or glamorous spot in Zone 3 — was up for rent for £1,600 pm. And the area is still nothing to get excited about. There was a flat a few doors from that one on sale for £435k.

I'm sorry you're having a hard time of things, OP, but you need to stop fantasising, learn to drive and plan some kind of work or career for yourself for the future. Because if you really do want to live in London it'll take two incomes.

Cornwallintherain · 18/03/2023 16:44

Yes it’s a similar area. They won’t employ mothers with pre school children here even though they can’t admit it. Well some will but it’s an old fashioned area so it’s harder.
‘childcare means I’d be working for nothing though. We worked it out. So not worth me working at the moment

I've been through similar. And the hiring people have no shame. 😔 you're better off moving somewhere forward thinking. An area that's progressed. Just last week I was asked in an interview "who does school sick days? You or your husband?"

Its just so sad.

DelphiniumBlue · 18/03/2023 16:44

Kindofthisnotthat · 18/03/2023 16:31

@DelphiniumBlue do you know Liverpool ?
I think a lot on here have no idea how much prices in naice areas of the north have exploded.

I know Liverpool a bit, and DS is currently considering buying there, so we have been looking at prices. It may be more expensive than it once was, but it is much cheaper than London. It's cheaper than Manchester, too.

Ginmonkeyagain · 18/03/2023 16:42

If it was just the 2 of you I would say do it in a heartbeat. But then of it was just two of you your income would be much higher as I assume you would also be working.

Doctors are in demand so getting a job in London should be easy for him. Once your husband is better qualified and your children are older so you can work it might make more sense to move to London.

Kindofthisnotthat · 18/03/2023 16:38

I think you don't realise how fortunate you are.
Some of us up here are stuck forever in dumps that have been forgotten about and will never be able to move to anywhere nice as we are priced out. Public transport crap, schools likewise.
I say count yourself lucky to have a partner with such good earning potential and the opportunity to move at a later date.

Lissaaaaaa · 18/03/2023 16:36

Cornwallintherain · 18/03/2023 16:33

Yes but not all regions in the UK give jobs to women with babies / caring responsibilities. It's very sad and yes these regions are decades behind others but that isn't the OPs fault.

You get an interview here (cornwall) and the interviewer / recruiter will have no shame in asking "why should we give you the role if we had applicants with no responsibilities?"

Again, I repeat - not the OPs fault. I know people who have been hunting for a role for months.

Yes it’s a similar area. They won’t employ mothers with pre school children here even though they can’t admit it. Well some will but it’s an old fashioned area so it’s harder.
‘childcare means I’d be working for nothing though. We worked it out. So not worth me working at the moment,

OP posts:
earsup · 18/03/2023 16:36

The only cheapish area of london i know is manor park...its grim or you go south east...eltham etc....also grim.

Cornwallintherain · 18/03/2023 16:35

@Lissaaaaaa do what it takes to move. Don't become stuck like I am! 😂

Lissaaaaaa · 18/03/2023 16:35

notprincehamlet · 18/03/2023 16:17

Would you be eligible for any key worker housing schemes that might make living in or closer to London possible?

Yes and this would solve all our issues. He is entitled to NHS accommodation which is hugely subsidised but at the moment it’s full.
he does apply for jobs and then accommodation and if we get this we’re off 😀

OP posts:
Cornwallintherain · 18/03/2023 16:33

Shewhois21 · 18/03/2023 16:30

@Ovidnaso
Lots of women with babies manage to work, don't know what century you're living in.

Yes but not all regions in the UK give jobs to women with babies / caring responsibilities. It's very sad and yes these regions are decades behind others but that isn't the OPs fault.

You get an interview here (cornwall) and the interviewer / recruiter will have no shame in asking "why should we give you the role if we had applicants with no responsibilities?"

Again, I repeat - not the OPs fault. I know people who have been hunting for a role for months.

Lissaaaaaa · 18/03/2023 16:32

Zanatdy · 18/03/2023 16:30

You’d get help with the rent on 30k and presumably your husbands earnings will increase dramatically over the years. Rent for now. I live near london and love living here. Even with the expensive rents / house prices

I loved it to when there. It was amazing.
oddly I think renting we’d do better on the lower income. As his income increases we’d have to pay more ourselves.
but I feel you only live once.

OP posts:
Kindofthisnotthat · 18/03/2023 16:31

@DelphiniumBlue do you know Liverpool ?
I think a lot on here have no idea how much prices in naice areas of the north have exploded.

Loraloralaughs · 18/03/2023 16:31

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Lissaaaaaa · 18/03/2023 16:31

Ovidnaso · 18/03/2023 16:28

Maybe she can't learn to drive? Not everyone can.

thank you. I have a disability that means I’d not be safe to drive.

OP posts:
Zanatdy · 18/03/2023 16:30

You’d get help with the rent on 30k and presumably your husbands earnings will increase dramatically over the years. Rent for now. I live near london and love living here. Even with the expensive rents / house prices

Shewhois21 · 18/03/2023 16:30

@Ovidnaso
Lots of women with babies manage to work, don't know what century you're living in.

Lissaaaaaa · 18/03/2023 16:30

The 30k is only temporary (literally a year) and it will increase but obviously won’t increase much until he’s in speciality training. he can bump it up with agency work but that’s not permanent income.
I did consider moving somewhere at least with transport options but it seems to defeat the object as I’d be still moving somewhere I don’t want.
‘I’ve lived in many different cities. I hated Manchester. Quite liked Liverpool but schools aren’t so good and high crime.

main thing for us is facilities of walking difference and decent schools.

I can’t drive due to disability but even if I could there’s a two year waiting list here for driving lessons.

I know in a few years I can afford London and it’s where we want to be. So not sure I want to move anywhere else really. seems to defeat the object a bit.

‘’I want a stable life for my eldest now where he can make friends.

I think overall I feel really trapped here without a car.

OP posts:
Ovidnaso · 18/03/2023 16:28

Lastnamedidntstick · 18/03/2023 15:57

She’s been there 5 years and had a baby in that time. She had 4 years while her eldest was at school to learn to drive, including before covid.

sometimes you need to take responsibility and be proactive in making changes to achieve what you want.

Maybe she can't learn to drive? Not everyone can.