Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do people get upset if I say that I don’t believe in love?

290 replies

CantAskAnyoneElse · 18/03/2023 15:10

To be clear, I son’t start lecturing anyone, it’s just that quite often friend or family members ask me how come I never have a partner etc.
Usually I just shrug my shoulders and try move the topic, but few times I’ve said honestly that I just don’t believe love is an actual thing.
Once again, I don’t start speeches, just quick honest remark and move the topic.
Never said anything about anyone else’s partners/lack off…

And let me tell you!
This does NOT go well.
People are adamant I am wrong, sad I’ve ’given up hope’ (I haven’t, it just was never there), soon I’ll meet someone and change my mind (doubtfull) and how I can’t say something like that.

Why not?
I do not understand, at all.

OP posts:
CantAskAnyoneElse · 18/03/2023 20:42

Butchyrestingface · 18/03/2023 20:37

If you tell people that you don't think YOU are capable of love, then I imagine you'll probably get a different response. They may feel quite sorry for you still, but probably won't be as defensive, or believe that you're making judgements about THEIR relationships.

I'd try to rephrasing your view if expressing it is causing problems for you.

But I’d be lying.
It’s not about capability.
I don’t like lying.

OP posts:
ThereIbledit · 18/03/2023 20:41

I get what you are saying, OP. The feelings that some people call love are neurochemical responses to stimuli. There's nothing more or less magical to it than that, even though it can feel like it - hormones are powerful drugs.

Bonding hormones like oxytocin are there for the survival of both individuals and the species. In most cases mothers bond with their child because of a huge dump of it shortly after birth. I'm less clear on the mechanisms for oxytocin release in other bonding situations but it happens, and it feels a bit silly to deny that it does happen, it's just that some people call it hormones, some people call it love. Does it matter what it's called? <shrugs>

I think the reason people take objection to your opinion is that they place so much emphasis on the importance of the concept of love in their worldview. Love is the reason for being, love is the thing that bonds them with their children, love is the reason to get married, love is a thing to pursue, etc etc. They have their own identities tied up with it, e.g. "I am a loving partner" And some of those people cannot tolerate the fact that there are people whose worldviews, if true or even partially true, would mean their worldview is flawed. I also think that anybody probing enough to cause you to say this sounds like they are unhealthily invested in proving to you the existence of love with your name on it.

Thatdarncat4 · 18/03/2023 20:40

Tibtilkobkob · 18/03/2023 20:36

I'm very familiar with qualitative research since I conduct it myself as part of my job. If you are familiar with it and aren't just spouting Google search just now then note that you said:
'Not sure comparing the two is quantifiable or qualitative in any way'
Presumably you meant to say 'Not sure the two could be quantified or compared qualitatively in any way' then?
Your comment made no sense. Still doesn't really even with edit as you were referencing the other poster's comment on hormonal reactions from fight or flight which isn't a qualitative topic.

So what I was saying is relevant and I just worded it incorrectly? Is that what you are telling me?

CantAskAnyoneElse · 18/03/2023 20:40

I think it’s because they believe you are saying it in a way that indicates a state of hopelessness or of being fundamentally alone in the world. I would feel a bit sad if one of my siblings said this because it would make me feel like they believe no-one would actually be able to love them iyswim. I am absolutely not saying that is how you actually feel btw just how people may feel if they care about you.

Aahh, okey.
This did not occure to me, I’ve never felt or connected hopelessness or loneliness to any of this.
Or someones ability to love, this is not something that has ever worried me.

And I think it hasn’t been meaningful to me, because watching all these people have these relationships and then break-up’s, someone new, no that wasn’t it, okey now this, no - get rid…
Round and round.
Like was there actually anything there, ever.
To be clear, never said anything to anyone.
But this love thing just seems to be such a fickle and demanding beast to me.

It is interesting that if someone were to care about me, as in worrying about me with this kind of thinking, it would be such a waste of time!
Human mind and it’s projecting, I guess!

OP posts:
ChildcareIsBroken · 18/03/2023 20:39

To be honest love brings happiness but also hurt, so life without it might be sensible. And it's your life, so as long as you're not hurting anyone why would you need to change?

Ohthebanality · 18/03/2023 20:39

@CantAskAnyoneElse I didn't mean to be condescending. And no, of course not every parent would die for their children. Some are cruel and abuse their children and even kill them. Or walk away from them and have nothing to do with them.
But you are saying you don't believe it's possible that a parent would love their child enough to die for them. That is not true.

Butchyrestingface · 18/03/2023 20:37

If you tell people that you don't think YOU are capable of love, then I imagine you'll probably get a different response. They may feel quite sorry for you still, but probably won't be as defensive, or believe that you're making judgements about THEIR relationships.

I'd try to rephrasing your view if expressing it is causing problems for you.

Tibtilkobkob · 18/03/2023 20:36

Thatdarncat4 · 18/03/2023 20:22

If I had been chased by a tiger and I wanted to compare it the feeling of love would I not want it to be researched like this?
What is an example of qualitative psychology research?
A good example of a qualitative research method would be unstructured interviews which generate qualitative data through the use of open questions. This allows the respondent to talk in some depth, choosing their own words. This helps the researcher develop a real sense of a person's understanding of a situation.

I'm very familiar with qualitative research since I conduct it myself as part of my job. If you are familiar with it and aren't just spouting Google search just now then note that you said:
'Not sure comparing the two is quantifiable or qualitative in any way'
Presumably you meant to say 'Not sure the two could be quantified or compared qualitatively in any way' then?
Your comment made no sense. Still doesn't really even with edit as you were referencing the other poster's comment on hormonal reactions from fight or flight which isn't a qualitative topic.

Ohthebanality · 18/03/2023 20:33

@Thatdarncat4 Wow spiteful? How did you get that from my post. I was just trying to explain how a mother loves her child more than herself? How she would put the child first. If they were starving, for instance, she would feed the child before herself. That the love is unconditional. It is one of the most powerful emotions there is. It is not always there of course, my mother didn't love me at all. I grew up unloved. But I have experienced love for my children.
One of the best books I have read about love is Sophie's Choice by William Styron. It's beautiful and devastating, I would really recommend it OP.

Noicant · 18/03/2023 20:29

I think it’s because they believe you are saying it in a way that indicates a state of hopelessness or of being fundamentally alone in the world. I would feel a bit sad if one of my siblings said this because it would make me feel like they believe no-one would actually be able to love them iyswim. I am absolutely not saying that is how you actually feel btw just how people may feel if they care about you.

Objective hat on there is nothing wrong with the statement. Maybe “love” is just a biological quirk which encourages a mild level of co-dependency for the continuation of the species sort of thing. Clearly it has a function as a concept for us as a species, probably so that we can co-operate. I wouldn’t have a problem with someone saying that, I’d be interested in knowing what you mean by that.

BelindaMelinda · 18/03/2023 20:26

I imagine that people get upset for many reasons - genuine upset for you, anger, offence or irritation as your statement implies that they can't love or be loved either - or, just downright frustration because your statement is stupid and you're infuriating in your insistence.

If you believe love is not for you or that you're incapable of loving or being loved, that's one thing. If you truly believe no one in the world can love someone just because you don't - despite the wealth of evidence to the contrary - that's just odd and I'd imagine you have some kind of undiagnosed personality disorder or mental health issue.

Led9519 · 18/03/2023 20:23

If you understand that at least some parents would sacrifice their lives because they love their children (and if given the choice I would in a heartbeat) then you must say that is love. (You need not get hung up on if MOST would and it’s not prove able either way.) So that is type of love.

If you’re specifically talking about romantic love then what do you define it is that you don’t believe in it?

Also… my relationship is completely self serving. Why would I be with someone altruistically? My husband makes me laugh, does things I can’t (diy mostly) and helps me where I need it. I wouldn’t be with him if I didn’t get something out of the relationship. I am sure he gets things out of it too… I do most of the cooking and we have children together.
We just enjoy each others company, the only differentiator from friendship is a physical relationship that makes it romantic but otherwise we’re just good friends who choose to live our lives together…. That attachment is all love is. And there are examples all around you. It’s not exactly the same as ghosts or God where there isn’t proof!

You say it’s all hormones and fight or flight etc. Well yes, doesn’t make it not real. Humans are just hormones, instincts, evolution and hell it all comes down to electric impulses in a melon sized organ in your head. That doesn’t make things less real?!

So I’d question your definition of ‘believe’ (the evidence is all around you) and ‘love’ and wonder if you understand it?

In simple terms if you’d like to know why people don’t like it… a lot of us experience love (attachment) day to day, and have meaningful relationships with others. Saying you don’t believe in it doesn’t align with the group and humans are group animals where attachment is important and often live saving (I.e being cared for when ill, I wonder what other species if any does this?). So you’re being ostracized for a deviant view which threatens the group. Simple really.

BentleyRhythmAce · 18/03/2023 20:23

beastlyslumber · 18/03/2023 18:42

Isn't that the definition of a psychopath? Someone unable to feel love? I don't know, but I do find it quite creepy.

Yep, this.

GinAndTony · 18/03/2023 20:22

Maybe people would respond better if you limited your statement to yourself- you’re not capable of feeling love- rather than trying to claim it doesn’t exist for others. They obviously know better than you do about their own feelings.

They shouldn’t quiz you about why you’re single though- that sounds annoying.

Thatdarncat4 · 18/03/2023 20:22

If I had been chased by a tiger and I wanted to compare it the feeling of love would I not want it to be researched like this?
What is an example of qualitative psychology research?
A good example of a qualitative research method would be unstructured interviews which generate qualitative data through the use of open questions. This allows the respondent to talk in some depth, choosing their own words. This helps the researcher develop a real sense of a person's understanding of a situation.

Theeaglesoared · 18/03/2023 20:20

Life without love - what is that? Even if it's just a love for nature, that's what gives life meaning.

CantFindTheBeat · 18/03/2023 20:17

I can see why you would feel that way, OP, given what you've said about your parents.

I'm sorry they didn't show you love or care.

Thai doesn't mean that love doesn't exist. It means it hasn't existed for you.

I'd like to think my kids know they are loved by all the big and small things they've experienced since they were small. And the fact that they're told every time we speak, even now as adults.

Of course not every parent is a good parent. Some, as we sadly know, are downright evil. But the majority aren't.

With some exceptions, parents, especially mothers, are hard-wired to love, care for and put their babies first. That's how the human race has survived.

I've run into the road for my dog, let alone my child, I love him so much. Its instinct to protect those you love and care for.

CantAskAnyoneElse · 18/03/2023 20:16

beastlyslumber · 18/03/2023 20:09

Because love is a primal human emotion. It is what bonds us together and what brings meaning to life. It's the source of awe, empathy, creativity and beauty. Many people even believe that God is love.

I would run from you because you are telling me that none of that means anything to you. The absence of ability to love would worry me, and the fact that you don't think it's even real for other people is frightening. I would not be able to trust you around me, my kids or my animals, without that shared human understanding of what's important. I think you are lacking something utterly fundamental.

😄Thank you for answering!

Yes, I see now it would be good for us both to go different directions.
All the best!

OP posts:
Greenfairydust · 18/03/2023 20:16

OP I should have said that I am also someone who genuinely has never experienced love.

I had parents who claim to love me but then went on to hurt me. Same with men: pretended to like me as a person when all the wanted was sex and had no interest in me as an actual human being.

So my experience of love was that the word was mostly used to justify shitty behaviour and to get something out of me...

I am very happy on my own now and feel absolutely no need for close relationship with anyone.

The only love I truly feel is for animals and my creative interests. Never for people.

Thatdarncat4 · 18/03/2023 20:16

Tibtilkobkob · 18/03/2023 20:12

Did you deliberately miss the point they made or just didn't read their comment at all?
You also used 'qualitative' incorrectly.

If you say so it must be true.

Tibtilkobkob · 18/03/2023 20:12

Thatdarncat4 · 18/03/2023 20:04

Running from a tiger is physiologically recognized as the fight or flight response not the love response 🤣 Not sure comparing the two is quantifiable or qualitative in any way but please do let us know if your love feels the same as being chased by a tiger and then we can get on researching this fact!

Did you deliberately miss the point they made or just didn't read their comment at all?
You also used 'qualitative' incorrectly.

TheFlis12345 · 18/03/2023 20:09

It’s very odd to say you don’t believe in something that the majority of people in the world have experienced.

Are you just articulating yourself badly? Do you really genuinely believe nobody actually experiences it? Or do you just think it’s not something you personally have or will experience?

beastlyslumber · 18/03/2023 20:09

CantAskAnyoneElse · 18/03/2023 19:50

May I ask why?
Can you rationalize a bit?

I’d understand if someone would ’run a long way’ if they heard someone likes to kick dogs, or have anger issues or hell keep asking why someone is never in a relationship.
Totally get it.

But just because they aren’t much of a believer of concept of love, why?
I still care, I wish people well, I listen to other’s (relationship) problems/happy news and adjust accordingly.
Why would you run a long way from me?
I don’t understand.

Because love is a primal human emotion. It is what bonds us together and what brings meaning to life. It's the source of awe, empathy, creativity and beauty. Many people even believe that God is love.

I would run from you because you are telling me that none of that means anything to you. The absence of ability to love would worry me, and the fact that you don't think it's even real for other people is frightening. I would not be able to trust you around me, my kids or my animals, without that shared human understanding of what's important. I think you are lacking something utterly fundamental.

Greenfairydust · 18/03/2023 20:09

Well the OP is entitled to her own beliefs and feelings.

It seems people are getting very agitated by the concept of someone not believing in love and calling her ''bitter'' is rather immature.

I do think genuine, selfless love does exist. Meaning the type of unconditional love that does not depend on what you can get out of the other person.

But in my opinion it is also very rare.

A lot of relationship are often transactional and unequal and ''love'' comes with strings attached to it.

I can completely understand how people who might not have a happy childhood and/or who might then also find themselves with selfish/abusive partners as adults would come to a conclusion that love does not exist.

If you are let down by people over and over again, there is little reason to believe in love...

Thatdarncat4 · 18/03/2023 20:04

NeverDropYourMooncup · 18/03/2023 19:59

It's because you are wrong. Love is real.

You may not experience it or ever feel it, but it genuinely exists.

You might as well claim that Tigers don't exist because you haven't personally experienced one chasing you - and if you were to assert that reports of the human biological, physiological and psychological responses elicited by being in the presence of something really big and carnivorous are therefore imaginary, people would say that you're wrong there as well.

Running from a tiger is physiologically recognized as the fight or flight response not the love response 🤣 Not sure comparing the two is quantifiable or qualitative in any way but please do let us know if your love feels the same as being chased by a tiger and then we can get on researching this fact!

Swipe left for the next trending thread