Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do people get upset if I say that I don’t believe in love?

290 replies

CantAskAnyoneElse · 18/03/2023 15:10

To be clear, I son’t start lecturing anyone, it’s just that quite often friend or family members ask me how come I never have a partner etc.
Usually I just shrug my shoulders and try move the topic, but few times I’ve said honestly that I just don’t believe love is an actual thing.
Once again, I don’t start speeches, just quick honest remark and move the topic.
Never said anything about anyone else’s partners/lack off…

And let me tell you!
This does NOT go well.
People are adamant I am wrong, sad I’ve ’given up hope’ (I haven’t, it just was never there), soon I’ll meet someone and change my mind (doubtfull) and how I can’t say something like that.

Why not?
I do not understand, at all.

OP posts:
CantAskAnyoneElse · 18/03/2023 21:18

LolaSmiles · 18/03/2023 20:55

And I think it hasn’t been meaningful to me, because watching all these people have these relationships and then break-up’s, someone new, no that wasn’t it, okey now this, no - get rid…
Round and round.
Like was there actually anything there, ever.
No wonder they're taking your statements about love not being real personally. Just there the way you're talking about it minimises and dismisses people's experiences in favour of a really bitter worldview.

I don't think you can go around telling people you don't think love exists and then be surprised that they work out that you be think their relationships are based on nothing.

Literally my next sentence was:
” To be clear, never said anything to anyone.”

I have no idea why you left that out.
You must have some kind of agenda to purposefully leave out the very next thing that clearly stated I have never said it out loud.
And then build a scenario around something that has not happened.

Just to clear this out, I don’t want anyone to think Lola’s LIES are something I’ve done or said.

OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 18/03/2023 21:17

toodlesofoodles
I think it's a bit different to the god analogy though. If someone says "I don't believe God exists" they are saying by extension that they don't believe that the god of someone else's faith exists. You're right it's a you do you situation, and the person wouldn't be saying other people should stop their religious acts. It's a different opinion on something with limited evidence either way.

But for someone to say that they don't think love exists, they are saying that other people's human relationships aren't based on love. Like they're sitting there with the truth and all the people who have loving relationships are foolish for believing their relationships are based on something that is documented. It's really insulting. Though they say they've not shared it openly, you can see that the OP's got such a bitter outlook on other people's relationship and it would be difficult to avoid that sense of bitterness coming across.

Thatdarncat4 · 18/03/2023 21:12

Tabitha888 · 18/03/2023 21:07

Love is real, it a chemical reaction in the brain... Google it

So one definition of love and hopefully your definition of love has been proven to cause the same chemical reaction in the brain for all those that experience love which includes your your definition of love? BTW what is your definition of love? Please enlighten me and provide the link to the research you are eluding to. Thanks 😊

Regularsizedrudy · 18/03/2023 21:11

And I don’t think ’most’ would ’happily’ die for their kids, that’s silly.
Self preservation would kick in pretty soon.

Surely if your looking at it from a biological something or other “kicking in”, it would make more sense to believe parents would die for their children, the natural instinct to pass on their family line or whatever. Isn’t that what all animals are set up to do by evolution? So you could of course argue that this isn’t true love and just biology taking over our monkey brains. But then aren’t we all just monkeys ascribing meaning to things?

toodlesofoodles · 18/03/2023 21:10

I think you do you. I don't believe in god, I tell people I don't but I don't tell them they also shouldn't.

You not thinking love is a thing doesn't mean I don't love my DH. I'm sorry your family can't get their heads around your difference in viewpoint OP, that must be hard for you. If you feel love towards them then just reply I love you all I just don't believe in romantic love and change the subject Flowers

Tabitha888 · 18/03/2023 21:07

Love is real, it a chemical reaction in the brain... Google it

usethedata · 18/03/2023 21:05

I think yours is a very philosophical view on what love is. It sounds similar to the debate on whether altruism truly exists as in all examples of apparent altruism you could argue that the altruist does in fact benefit in some way, even in just the feel good factor of a charitable act.

So your argument is that even what others call love is, to you, a mutually beneficial situation or exchange, and therefore it is not real. This is where I question it. Does the fact that it is mutually beneficial really mean that it is not real? If I think about my children, I feel a strength of what I call love for them that is very powerful and feels unconditional. I feel like there is nothing they could do that would make me stop loving them. And I very often make small and big choices that benefit them and hinder me. But I can't say that it I don't get anything back from that relationship either. I get immense joy at their laughter, amusement at their humour and so on. Amd probably there is some evolutionary aspect of continuing the species in there too although not something I think about.

But we will have to differ on our opinion of whether the fact that it is mutually beneficial means it is not really love?

What I think many people will struggle with is that yours is not a conventional or common view, and your insistence that you do not believe love exists for anyone feels like you are saying that what i describe as my love for my kids is either nonsense or a lie.

And I also don't think whether you believe love exists or not is the reason you are single. You have acknowledged that what others may call love you may call some sort of mutually beneficial relationship, however transitory. That still leaves the question of why you don't want that! So really the answer is still that this is not a type of relationship that you want

ThereIbledit · 18/03/2023 21:02

@Butchyrestingface
I’d be lying if I’d just say ”I’m unable to love”.
Not following how this is a lie. You're NOT able to love, surely that's the truth? Other people can, but you, apparently, not.

But she doesn't believe that love exists.

I don't believe that flying humans exist.
I'm somebody who is unable to fly.

The latter implies that I believe that other people can fly. (let's not complicate the hypothetical by bringing in planes and jetpacks please!).

Not to mention in the love example, if you go around telling people who sound interfering and nosey that you're unable to love, they're going to take that as even more of a challenge to prove you wrong 🙃

Thatdarncat4 · 18/03/2023 21:01

Tibtilkobkob · 18/03/2023 20:56

It was never the main point of my comment which was the fact you (wilfully or not) misinterpreted pp's comment but I suppose it suits you to divert onto this instead. Re qualitative: I explained exactly what I meant in my last comment. Re-read if unsure.

Sorry but you’re rambling now!

Notegoat · 18/03/2023 21:00

’And I don’t think ’most’ would ’happily’ die for their kids, that’s silly. Self preservation would kick in pretty soon’

It sounds like it’s something you are incapable of and don’t understand. You find it easier to say it doesn’t exist rather than recognising that it’s something lacking in you. Most parents would risk their own life to save their child. Many people would do that for any child, even a stranger. People drown trying to save their dogs FFS.

Thatdarncat4 · 18/03/2023 20:58

Ohthebanality · 18/03/2023 20:47

@Thatdarncat4 Your reply to my post was nasty. I may not have expressed myself that well but I meant no harm. There was no need to say the things you did to me.

I apologize if I misinterpreted you saying it’s ‘your loss’ to the OP as a personal insult to the OP. If you did not mean it as an insult I stand corrected.

Putple · 18/03/2023 20:57

Are you Autistic OP?
I can see you've been asked this a couple of times and you haven't answered, I'm just curious that's all :)

Tibtilkobkob · 18/03/2023 20:56

It was never the main point of my comment which was the fact you (wilfully or not) misinterpreted pp's comment but I suppose it suits you to divert onto this instead. Re qualitative: I explained exactly what I meant in my last comment. Re-read if unsure.

LolaSmiles · 18/03/2023 20:55

And I think it hasn’t been meaningful to me, because watching all these people have these relationships and then break-up’s, someone new, no that wasn’t it, okey now this, no - get rid…
Round and round.
Like was there actually anything there, ever.
No wonder they're taking your statements about love not being real personally. Just there the way you're talking about it minimises and dismisses people's experiences in favour of a really bitter worldview.

I don't think you can go around telling people you don't think love exists and then be surprised that they work out that you be think their relationships are based on nothing.

Butchyrestingface · 18/03/2023 20:52

I’d be lying if I’d just say ”I’m unable to love”.

Not following how this is a lie. You're NOT able to love, surely that's the truth? Other people can, but you, apparently, not.

Siameasy · 18/03/2023 20:52

Romantic love is a social construct. Lust is real but we have to call it “love” due to restrictions around extra-marital sex.
Even in songs, much of the time when they say “love” they mean sex.
I truly only love my child in that “die for you” way. For me that feeling was instant, upon discovering the pregnancy.
I feel I love my cats as well in a different way and I do love my sibling’s children to a degree, probably because we are biologically related.

ThereIbledit · 18/03/2023 20:51

@Butchyrestingface

"I don't believe that love exists"
"I don't believe that I am capable of love"

They aren't the same statement, I imagine that's why OP says she would be lying if she phrased it that way.

She's not telling other people that they don't believe that they are in love with somebody. She's not telling them that she thinks they are lying. It sounds like she acknowledges that other people believe that they feel love. It's just that she believes that the thing that they believe they feel is a biochemical reaction, and not the abstract concept of love.

CantAskAnyoneElse · 18/03/2023 20:50

Butchyrestingface · 18/03/2023 20:44

But I’d be lying.
It’s not about capability.
I don’t like lying.

How is it lying?

Do you think other people are lying when they tell you that DO they love someone?

I’d be lying if I’d just say ”I’m unable to love”.
Alright, maybe I could say a little effective way and say I’m just not that fussed about it.
That would be honest, without going into detail and it couldn't possible (I hope not) taken personally.

OP posts:
GhostsJulianforPrimeMinister · 18/03/2023 20:48

I've found your outlook on this very interesting read so far and just thought I'd add some AI into the mix.

Thatdarncat4 · 18/03/2023 20:47

CantFindTheBeat · 18/03/2023 20:42

All words are 'made up words', @Thatdarncat4.

That's how language works!!!!

Of course 'love' exists. It's the word we use for all those feelings and behaviours you've listed.

Which have been evidenced and well documented throughout history.

Whether everyone loves, experiences love, to what degree and what form can be debated. But by your own comments, it exists.

Oh, and by the way, you were very nasty to a poster based on three lines of text. That doesn't seem to fit with your self-professed philosophical mindset.

A word doesn’t make it fact. Because it’s made up.

Ohthebanality · 18/03/2023 20:47

@Thatdarncat4 Your reply to my post was nasty. I may not have expressed myself that well but I meant no harm. There was no need to say the things you did to me.

GhostsJulianforPrimeMinister · 18/03/2023 20:47

I asked ChatGPT and this is its answer it's given.

Yes, love exists. Love is a complex and multifaceted emotion that can be experienced in many different ways. It is a fundamental human emotion that has been described and explored in literature, art, and science throughout history. Love can be expressed and experienced in many different forms, such as romantic love, familial love, platonic love, and love for oneself, among others.
Love is often characterized by feelings of attachment, intimacy, and caring, and it can have a profound impact on our lives and relationships with others. Scientific research has shown that love can have many positive effects on our physical and mental well-being, including reducing stress, improving mood, and strengthening social connections.
While love can be difficult to define and can take on many different forms, its existence can be observed through the behaviors and emotions of individuals who experience it. Overall, love is a very real and powerful emotion that is an important aspect of the human experience.

Thatdarncat4 · 18/03/2023 20:45

Tibtilkobkob · 18/03/2023 20:36

I'm very familiar with qualitative research since I conduct it myself as part of my job. If you are familiar with it and aren't just spouting Google search just now then note that you said:
'Not sure comparing the two is quantifiable or qualitative in any way'
Presumably you meant to say 'Not sure the two could be quantified or compared qualitatively in any way' then?
Your comment made no sense. Still doesn't really even with edit as you were referencing the other poster's comment on hormonal reactions from fight or flight which isn't a qualitative topic.

Loads of qualitative research published on fight or flight too I mean I’m not a scientist so obviously you must know best because you said so 😂

Butchyrestingface · 18/03/2023 20:44

But I’d be lying.
It’s not about capability.
I don’t like lying.

How is it lying?

Do you think other people are lying when they tell you that DO they love someone?

CantFindTheBeat · 18/03/2023 20:42

Thatdarncat4 · 18/03/2023 15:40

My husband and I both quandary the meaning of life and talk about love as a concept. We both love philosophy. It’s just a made up word really. The question is can you trust, care, feel physical, emotional and social gratification from having another person in your life? Well that’s what we came up with. Not sure it’s true though.

If you are born you will die that is the only truth in life. Whether love exists or not is never going to be a truth.

All words are 'made up words', @Thatdarncat4.

That's how language works!!!!

Of course 'love' exists. It's the word we use for all those feelings and behaviours you've listed.

Which have been evidenced and well documented throughout history.

Whether everyone loves, experiences love, to what degree and what form can be debated. But by your own comments, it exists.

Oh, and by the way, you were very nasty to a poster based on three lines of text. That doesn't seem to fit with your self-professed philosophical mindset.

Swipe left for the next trending thread