Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do people get upset if I say that I don’t believe in love?

290 replies

CantAskAnyoneElse · 18/03/2023 15:10

To be clear, I son’t start lecturing anyone, it’s just that quite often friend or family members ask me how come I never have a partner etc.
Usually I just shrug my shoulders and try move the topic, but few times I’ve said honestly that I just don’t believe love is an actual thing.
Once again, I don’t start speeches, just quick honest remark and move the topic.
Never said anything about anyone else’s partners/lack off…

And let me tell you!
This does NOT go well.
People are adamant I am wrong, sad I’ve ’given up hope’ (I haven’t, it just was never there), soon I’ll meet someone and change my mind (doubtfull) and how I can’t say something like that.

Why not?
I do not understand, at all.

OP posts:
Lex345 · 19/03/2023 08:06

CantAskAnyoneElse · 19/03/2023 07:55

Can I ask you to expand a little bit on what you said earlier when you said you do care about people, but more because of the benefits you feel from that?

I mean I care about the people I choose to have in my life.
But I care about them because they bring substance (perhaps not the best word) in to my life. I like spending time with them, they listen to me (and I listen to them), we do things together, give advice (and sometimes even good advice 😂).
So, at the core of it, it’s selfish.

Do you care more about certain people than others? Is it the word love itself you have an issue with?

Yes, certain people.
I’m pretty indifferent towards people I don’t know.
And if I read/hear about something they maybe going through, it’s pretty much only if I can relate, it provokes me, but that’s just about my own feelings, right?
I don’t have issue with concept of love, I know there a believers out there, and that doesn’t bother me as long as they know it’s a personal thing.

For example, if I told you I care deeply for someone, would that be more believeable than if I said I loved them?

Belief is a personal thing.
I’m not here to argue about that.
Call it whatever suits you.

Ultimately, though, its pretty rude for someone to get upset with you for expressing how you feel when they asked!

Thank you!

Thank you for answering-I guess the way you have explained it is kind of what I would call love in some respects. What I believe to be love can certainly be selfish at times.

CantAskAnyoneElse · 19/03/2023 08:03

Than you @Wishawisha for you very sensible comments.
You articulated very well.

OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 19/03/2023 07:57

GeekyThings
Totally agree with you. Great post.

It's understandable that people are going to bit a bit "huh" if they're given a general statement that the central feeling in most human relationships doesn't exist.

Like other posters have said, there's a big difference between not being interested in romantic relationships/not being bothered about pursuing romantic relationships and stating that love doesn't exist as an entity.

The friends are rude for pushing questions about relationships though.

CantAskAnyoneElse · 19/03/2023 07:55

Can I ask you to expand a little bit on what you said earlier when you said you do care about people, but more because of the benefits you feel from that?

I mean I care about the people I choose to have in my life.
But I care about them because they bring substance (perhaps not the best word) in to my life. I like spending time with them, they listen to me (and I listen to them), we do things together, give advice (and sometimes even good advice 😂).
So, at the core of it, it’s selfish.

Do you care more about certain people than others? Is it the word love itself you have an issue with?

Yes, certain people.
I’m pretty indifferent towards people I don’t know.
And if I read/hear about something they maybe going through, it’s pretty much only if I can relate, it provokes me, but that’s just about my own feelings, right?
I don’t have issue with concept of love, I know there a believers out there, and that doesn’t bother me as long as they know it’s a personal thing.

For example, if I told you I care deeply for someone, would that be more believeable than if I said I loved them?

Belief is a personal thing.
I’m not here to argue about that.
Call it whatever suits you.

Ultimately, though, its pretty rude for someone to get upset with you for expressing how you feel when they asked!

Thank you!

OP posts:
Wishawisha · 19/03/2023 07:46

beastlyslumber · 19/03/2023 07:20

But if you were incapable of love would you be capable of fondness, like, caring etc? They all come from the same source, surely? It's a version of love, to care for someone.

I guess you could like someone for purely selfish reasons, just for how they reflect on you. But caring for someone takes a certain degree of selflessness, I.e. love.

I don’t know. I guess it could just be a scale of “fondness” and anything over a certain threshold would be “like” and over the next threshold would be defined as “love”. Or is it a completely different scale entirely, to jump from fondness/ like to love?

I can kind of see what the OP is saying because logically I can’t rationalise what exactly love is. If I liked person X a bit more than I already do, would that be love? But we know love exist even in other primates - we’ve seen evidence of gorillas etc carrying round their dead children because they can’t say goodbye and of primates that have been taught sign language talking about their parents many years after they last saw them and seeming to understand human emotions.

What I think the OP is missing about children is that of course not everyone loves their children. There are plenty of bad people out there. But most of us do love our children very intensely. I would absolutely die for them.

beastlyslumber · 19/03/2023 07:20

But if you were incapable of love would you be capable of fondness, like, caring etc? They all come from the same source, surely? It's a version of love, to care for someone.

I guess you could like someone for purely selfish reasons, just for how they reflect on you. But caring for someone takes a certain degree of selflessness, I.e. love.

Wishawisha · 19/03/2023 07:13

beastlyslumber · 19/03/2023 06:43

Why do you find that extreme? What makes you trustworthy when you've admitted you don't believe in love? What's to stop you from harming others? Genuinely, I don't understand.

The opposite of love is hatred. The absence of love leaves indifference. What makes you a trustworthy person when you've admitted that your feelings can by necessity only run from hatred to indifference?

Why do you think you should be trusted around vulnerable people? I'm genuinely asking. If you don't have any love for anyone, what's to stop you from harming them, either deliberately or carelessly?

Only hatred to indifference?

But presumably you have friends and a acquaintances that you don’t love but who you are more than indifferent about? I just don’t think the scale of human emotion is just hatred, indifference and love.

I love my family and a few, dear friends but most friends I wouldn’t say I love. I don’t love any of my friend’s children but I am fond of them and care for them; it’s a long way from indifference. I would say it was quite extreme to actually love all the people in your life? - no one does that, surely?

GeekyThings · 19/03/2023 07:07

I think it's understandable why people get upset when you say you don't believe in love because the statement essentially encompasses passing judgement on their relationships. People get pissed off when other people do that.

Saying that, it's pretty rude to ask people about their relationship status in the first place, so I'd say that falls into tit for tat to me being as they've started it!

As to whether or not love exists, well, it obviously and objectively does, so saying you don't believe in it because you haven't experienced it would be a bit like me saying I don't believe Australia because I've never been there. Or gravity because I can't see it. Or Boris Johnson because I don't want to. I can say them all I like, it doesn't make them true (sadly in that last instance). It just confuses people and makes them uncomfortable, hence the long thread of comments about that afterwards!

LolaSmiles · 19/03/2023 06:49

*Literally my next sentence was:

” To be clear, never said anything to anyone.”*

*I have no idea why you left that out.

You must have some kind of agenda to purposefully leave out the very next thing that clearly stated I have never said it out loud.*

I didn't say you said that out loud.

I was commenting on how having that world view is likely to come across if you're telling people love doesn't exist.

And then build a scenario around something that has not happened.

You have started a thread saying you've told people you don't think love exists and have asked about why people respond as they do.

Now saying you've told people love doesn't exist is a fake scenario that hasn't happened.

Just to clear this out, I don’t want anyone to think Lola’s LIES are something I’ve done or said.

Your first post says you've told people you don't think love exists.

It seems like you're resting a lot of your irritation on the fact that whilst you've told people you don't think love exists, because you've not specifically said to individuals "and I think ..... About your relationship" they're not allowed to comment on the fact that you've made a blanket statement that does imply things about their relationships.

beastlyslumber · 19/03/2023 06:43

CantAskAnyoneElse · 19/03/2023 06:02

Hi!
And thank you.

It doesn’t have to be about agreeing and disagreeing, I like hearing different views on things.

I’m still fascinated about the one who was so extreme that they said they wouldn’t trust me with their child or pet 🥹
I mean, bless!

Why do you find that extreme? What makes you trustworthy when you've admitted you don't believe in love? What's to stop you from harming others? Genuinely, I don't understand.

The opposite of love is hatred. The absence of love leaves indifference. What makes you a trustworthy person when you've admitted that your feelings can by necessity only run from hatred to indifference?

Why do you think you should be trusted around vulnerable people? I'm genuinely asking. If you don't have any love for anyone, what's to stop you from harming them, either deliberately or carelessly?

Lex345 · 19/03/2023 06:37

I find this really interesting. Can I ask you to expand a little bit on what you said earlier when you said you do care about people, but more because of the benefits you feel from that? Do you care more about certain people than others? Is it the word love itself you have an issue with?

For example, if I told you I care deeply for someone, would that be more believeable than if I said I loved them?

Ultimately, though, its pretty rude for someone to get upset with you for expressing how you feel when they asked!

donttellmehesalive · 19/03/2023 06:34

How come you believe in all of the other emotions, just not love?

Presumably you believe in happiness, disappointment and shame because you have experienced them.

Just because you haven't experienced love doesn't mean it doesn't exist.

In rl people find your assertion odd because it seems narrow minded (I haven't experienced it so it doesn't exist) and suggests a social disorder.

CantAskAnyoneElse · 19/03/2023 06:02

OutsideLookingOut · 19/03/2023 01:14

Just want to say I find this really interesting OP. Also I love your responses. I see so much projection on the thread.
Not sure I agree or disagree yet with the premise.

Hi!
And thank you.

It doesn’t have to be about agreeing and disagreeing, I like hearing different views on things.

I’m still fascinated about the one who was so extreme that they said they wouldn’t trust me with their child or pet 🥹
I mean, bless!

OP posts:
MoreSleepPleasee · 19/03/2023 01:20

I feel sorry for you op. Love is the most wonderful feeling.

OutsideLookingOut · 19/03/2023 01:14

Just want to say I find this really interesting OP. Also I love your responses. I see so much projection on the thread.
Not sure I agree or disagree yet with the premise.

CandyLeBonBon · 19/03/2023 00:44

beastlyslumber · 19/03/2023 00:20

Hardly over dramatic. Saying that someone who doesn't feel love (of any kind, not just romantic) is probably autistic is a bit insulting towards autistic people. I know lots and they all have normal human emotions.

My son is autistic and he absolutely talks in these sorts of terms

beastlyslumber · 19/03/2023 00:20

Hardly over dramatic. Saying that someone who doesn't feel love (of any kind, not just romantic) is probably autistic is a bit insulting towards autistic people. I know lots and they all have normal human emotions.

Greenfairydust · 18/03/2023 22:52

''@BentleyRhythmAce

@beastlyslumber

Isn't that the definition of a psychopath? Someone unable to feel love? I don't know, but I do find it quite creepy.
Yep, this.''

No need to be overly dramatic.

Some people have no interest in romantic relationship (aromantic, asexual, simply not bothered with having a partner...) full stop. Some conditions like autism can also make it harder for people to have ''normal'' interactions with people. Some people go through trauma which makes it harder for them to relate and trust people.That doesn't mean all these people are Hannibal Lecters in the making.

Being a psychopath is not defined by not believing in love.

Instead they lack empathy, remorse and display various anti-social traits (lying, manipulating, law-breaking, hurting others) as well as difficulties controlling their behaviour in general.

Augend23 · 18/03/2023 22:35

I think what's really confusing me about this, is that you were asked about other emotions - i.e. sorrow

You said you feel that emotion.

If you met someone who said they didn't believe sorrow existed - i.e. they didn't believe anyone felt sorrow (rather than saying they had not felt sorrow), wouldn't you feel that was something they weren't qualified to say? Because YOU feel it, and you're the only one inside your head who can truly know or not know whether or not you do feel sorrow.

So if you're saying "I don't feel I have loved or been loved" that would be about you. But saying love doesn't exist at all, for anyone, you're saying that the thing the other person has experienced doesn't exist.

To me it's like saying "thoughts don't exist, they are just electrical impulses transmitted by neurons within the brain" - yup, that's right, that is what they are, doesn't mean they don't exist. Love may be oxytocin, or some other neurotransmitter/hormone/formation of electrical impulses combined with the above. But that's all anything we think, say or do is really, so the fact that it's composed of/caused by a set of neural impulses or whatever doesn't mean it doesn't exist.

IncompleteSenten · 18/03/2023 22:18

By that I mean step outside yourself for a moment and think of the people you know and what you've seen of relationships and behaviours and try to articulate what you understand/observe.

IncompleteSenten · 18/03/2023 22:17

What do you imagine love would feel like?

I know you don't believe there is such an emotion but you do know that many or most people do believe there is/feel that they experience it. If you were to describe it, this feeling people call love, what would you say?

Eddielizzard · 18/03/2023 21:28

So you have absolutely never, ever felt love for anyone, ever, at all?

CantAskAnyoneElse · 18/03/2023 21:24

Putple · 18/03/2023 20:57

Are you Autistic OP?
I can see you've been asked this a couple of times and you haven't answered, I'm just curious that's all :)

No, I am not.

I ignored them, because MN has a habit of pathologizing and everyone who doesn’t have exact same thinking pattern as them are queried about autism.
Absolute no offence to any one on the sectum, it has just become such a lazy fashion around here, that’s all.

OP posts:
Ohthebanality · 18/03/2023 21:21

Children who grow up in orphanages with no love fail to thrive.

Ohthebanality · 18/03/2023 21:20

Love is a chemical bonding mechanism which we need for parents to bring up children, for people to have children, to make us happy and to feel like we are cared for and protected. I don't think the human race could function without 'love'. Don't call it 'love', call it evolutionary bonding mechanism or something. Its the same thing though. Humans need it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread