Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

DH and I going part time to deliberately reduce wages

890 replies

Bucketheadbucketbum · 18/03/2023 13:35

Just working out the free childcare hours and actually DH and I will be muxh better off if we both dropped to 3- 4 day week to deliberately reduce our incomes. Would obviously be nice way to live too! Anyone else doing same? Seems mental but we've looked at it 100 times over and it's true!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Ilikepinacoladass · 20/03/2023 22:01

stickystick · 20/03/2023 21:57

@Ilikepinacoladass

In parts of Switzerland single people with dependant children (or elderly) living with them are taxed differently from single people without dependants and married/partnered co-habitants.

Say a married couple earn 60k and 40k respectively. Their combined income is taxed as if they both earned 50k.
A single mother with kids who earns 100k would also pay tax as if she earned 50k.

That just seems unfair on the one in the couple that earns 40k? To be paying tax as is you are earning 50k? Not all couples pool their income together? So the one earning less might be paying more tax than their earning for an not making up so it in a shared pool of money.

AviMav · 20/03/2023 21:59

Ilikepinacoladass · 20/03/2023 21:46

It still sounds like you're assuming couples / households pool their income together / share the bills equally, which just isn't the case a lot of the time!

The majority of couples do split household bills if they live together. People who don't do this are in the minority. It's not the majority where one person pays all the bills and the other person lives practically free within the same household yet they date.

You shouldn't assume this is the norm/common.

Ilikepinacoladass · 20/03/2023 21:57

And not really sure why it would only apply to couples? That's the bit that makes me think it's being assumed they are pooling money together?

Why would it not be applied to housemates, as they are also as likely as couples to be sharing the bills?

stickystick · 20/03/2023 21:57

@Ilikepinacoladass

In parts of Switzerland single people with dependant children (or elderly) living with them are taxed differently from single people without dependants and married/partnered co-habitants.

Say a married couple earn 60k and 40k respectively. Their combined income is taxed as if they both earned 50k.
A single mother with kids who earns 100k would also pay tax as if she earned 50k.

Ilikepinacoladass · 20/03/2023 21:56

ThinkingMeat · 20/03/2023 21:50

Not at all. Addressed this point already in earlier response to you. It wouldn't change anything for couples at all or prevent them from keeping finances separate.

So if there was a woman living on her own, and then her boyfriend who earns a lot more than her moved in (making them a 'household'), would she then start getting taxed more than when she lived on her own?

What if she wasn't benefitting financially much from this guy moving in, if he wasn't paying 50% towards the bills etc and they weren't joining their spare money together.

Doesn't it seem a bit wrong that she'd be also losing out tax wise?

ThinkingMeat · 20/03/2023 21:50

Ilikepinacoladass · 20/03/2023 21:46

It still sounds like you're assuming couples / households pool their income together / share the bills equally, which just isn't the case a lot of the time!

Not at all. Addressed this point already in earlier response to you. It wouldn't change anything for couples at all or prevent them from keeping finances separate.

ThinkingMeat · 20/03/2023 21:49

Of course it would still be more expensive to live on your own! You'd still be covering everything yourself. If you have children covering all their childcare and expenses alone. That's fine and expected. Doesn't mean you should also be taxed more as well so have even less of the same earnings left after tax to meet those higher expenses!

In those systems which work just fine, obviously people in shared houses are classed as separate households for tax purposes. As are adult children living with parents etc. It's really not complicated to do at all, it's what is done in many countries because it's much fairer obviously, as the examples in the thread show.

Ilikepinacoladass · 20/03/2023 21:46

It still sounds like you're assuming couples / households pool their income together / share the bills equally, which just isn't the case a lot of the time!

Ilikepinacoladass · 20/03/2023 21:45

Do the people in the household have to be related / in a couple? To be honest I just think it makes sense that it's more expensive to live on your own, and not really the government's problem.

ThinkingMeat · 20/03/2023 21:45

No. Not a "tax break". They'd get the same as couples do now. Currently they are being penalised and taxed more on the same household earnings. Would just be giving them the same "tax breaks" that couples get now.

Ilikepinacoladass · 20/03/2023 21:42

ThinkingMeat · 20/03/2023 21:42

It wouldn't affect the setup couples have at all. It would simply mean single people don't pay more on the same money.

So people would get a tax break for being single?

ThinkingMeat · 20/03/2023 21:42

It wouldn't affect the setup couples have at all. It would simply mean single people don't pay more on the same money.

ThinkingMeat · 20/03/2023 21:40

As for getting taxed individually or as a couple.. I'm not sure, but think individually makes more sense. What about if a woman earns a lot less than her partner, she'll end up getting taxed a shed load, under the assumption they are pooling their earnings together.. which often isn't true! I may be misunderstanding it.

Yes I think you are misunderstanding how it works. It doesn't work like that in the many countries that apply tax on a household basis. The individuals in the household still have separate allowances. In some cases they can choose to transfer some or all between them depending which country if they wish to but that's a choice. They are not forced to combine finances at all, there is no impact on financial independence at all. That's a false argument against removing the discrepancy. The difference is that a single person wouldn't be penalised and have the thresholds applied at half the household income level.

Ilikepinacoladass · 20/03/2023 21:39

AviMav · 20/03/2023 21:21

Couples may not pool all their income together but if you are living together. THE BILLS are pooled together because you surely are going 50/50 or you should be. Which is a save all round. Being a single parent you don't have that option... the rest of your point is completely irrelevant

Of course it's a save all round. It's always going to be cheaper to share a house / bills, as I say that's why students nearly always do! It's a luxury to afford a place to yourself in a way.

And no, a lot of couples don't go 50/50 on bills as it happens. For many reasons. It doesn't matter what the 'should do'. You can't really base a tax policy on this assumption.

messybutfun · 20/03/2023 21:35

Let’s take for example an NHS practitioner - I believe the highest contribution rate to the pension scheme is 14.5%. Which will reduce the salary significantly. At the same time, this could also result in an additional tax charge if the value of the annual pension increase went over £40k. That’s why it’s being increased to £60k.

If doctors are not willing to work more for less, why would anybody else. They are smarter than most.

ThinkingMeat · 20/03/2023 21:34

It’s not the same. Child benefit was a universal benefit and worked perfectly well as such. There was absolutely no point in making it means tested and particularly in such a hamfisted and illogical way.

No point means testing childcare either. Exactly the same principle. Costs more to administer than it saves, much better for the money to benefit children than go on admin staff, hugely unfair to do on an individual income anyway in exactly the same way as child benefit.

AviMav · 20/03/2023 21:21

Couples may not pool all their income together but if you are living together. THE BILLS are pooled together because you surely are going 50/50 or you should be. Which is a save all round. Being a single parent you don't have that option... the rest of your point is completely irrelevant

Ilikepinacoladass · 20/03/2023 21:07

ThinkingMeat · 20/03/2023 20:41

Which is exactly the same stupidity and unfairness as removing funded nursery hours, tax free childcare or the personal allowance from a single parent earning £100k when a couple earning £199k still get all of these.

Or applying 20% tax to a single parent from £12.5k when a couple can earn £25k before they pay it.

Isn't this assuming that all couple pool their income together though, which is often not the case? At the end of the day they are still 2 separate people, which happen to share a house / car etc. Life is always going to be a bit harder if you have a child with someone who then decides to take no financial responsibility?

Blossomtoes · 20/03/2023 21:06

ThinkingMeat · 20/03/2023 20:41

Which is exactly the same stupidity and unfairness as removing funded nursery hours, tax free childcare or the personal allowance from a single parent earning £100k when a couple earning £199k still get all of these.

Or applying 20% tax to a single parent from £12.5k when a couple can earn £25k before they pay it.

It’s not the same. Child benefit was a universal benefit and worked perfectly well as such. There was absolutely no point in making it means tested and particularly in such a hamfisted and illogical way.

AviMav · 20/03/2023 20:58

@ThinkingMeat that's what they have left though after they have paid bills. £800 is someone's wage to pay rent, council tax, food and other utilities. From a low earners POV its not doable at all.

ThinkingMeat · 20/03/2023 20:43

AviMav · 20/03/2023 20:07

@HospitalitySux I agree with the majority of what you are saying. One huge difference is though that when you earn less or let's be Frank £900 per month or even £800 you are literally UNABLE to live on that amount of money. It's literally impossible not even with 1 child.

You absolutely NEED that top up!

Single parents earning higher salaries are often in a similar situation and are unable to live after the childcare costs and rent/ mortgage that has to be paid for them to live in the areas which enable them to have the job that earns the higher salary. If they move somewhere cheaper then they don't have the job.

ThinkingMeat · 20/03/2023 20:41

Blossomtoes · 20/03/2023 20:00

If it's wrong to 'work the system' when you earn £20k pa then it's wrong to 'work the system' when you earn £100k pa. And if it's ok on £100k then it's ok at £20k.

That’s irrefutable. So is the point about the effect of bottlenecks. The one that makes zero sense to me is child benefit, it should have continued to be a universal benefit. The utter insanity of removing it from a single parent on £50k and allowing a couple on £98k to keep it is beyond belief.

Which is exactly the same stupidity and unfairness as removing funded nursery hours, tax free childcare or the personal allowance from a single parent earning £100k when a couple earning £199k still get all of these.

Or applying 20% tax to a single parent from £12.5k when a couple can earn £25k before they pay it.

Ilikepinacoladass · 20/03/2023 20:28

ScruffyGiraffes · 20/03/2023 12:09

Obviously don't disagree that the govt should help out single parents at the lower end of the pay spectrum. But if you're earning enough to care for yourself and your kids, then living on your own without sharing the house is a lifestyle choice imo!

What? I should just move a random person into my two traumatised, autistic children's come to save money? I haven't asked for any "support" from the Government. Just for them to stop penalising me by taxing me MORE than other households with the same income.

It was more in response to @stickystick who said

"They never tire of telling me that it is “only fair” their income is taxed individually and not as a household, despite sharing all their bills and expenses…"

It makes sense that sharing a house will work out cheaper, that's why most students do it.. those people are also having the share the space, and live with someone else. It's not the governments fault that some people live on their own.

As for getting taxed individually or as a couple.. I'm not sure, but think individually makes more sense. What about if a woman earns a lot less than her partner, she'll end up getting taxed a shed load, under the assumption they are pooling their earnings together.. which often isn't true! I may be misunderstanding it.

clarehhh · 20/03/2023 20:17

Better to pay excess tax free into your pension and keep the jobs.

bigbabycooker · 20/03/2023 20:10

@HospitalitySux

I think that you are quite right.

I do think that the OP pays a lot of tax and that the system is messed up that it doesn't incentivise net contributors, but that doesn't mean I think what she is doing is more worthwhile than your work.

I think that the common thread here for you and OP is that we should have a system where everyone is better rewarded for working more (so far as they are able). If you don't work and can afford not to, no one should demonise you for it, but work should pay. The tax cliffs eat into that at the top and middle, as does the tax credit system for lower earners (frank field opposed it in new Labour days for that reason as he felt it would destabilise the system and devalue the work of the lowest paid and was sacked for it and he was right - there should instead have been better minimum wages for lower earners, with better support for those who could not work or who needed to retrain to use their skills).