Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

DH and I going part time to deliberately reduce wages

890 replies

Bucketheadbucketbum · 18/03/2023 13:35

Just working out the free childcare hours and actually DH and I will be muxh better off if we both dropped to 3- 4 day week to deliberately reduce our incomes. Would obviously be nice way to live too! Anyone else doing same? Seems mental but we've looked at it 100 times over and it's true!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
derbylass81 · 18/03/2023 14:39

Bucketheadbucketbum · 18/03/2023 14:29

Quite a few of our colleagues talking similar now- they really need to fix it!

So why are you doing it if you admit it isn't right and the government need to fix it?

I don't understand this mentality. Just because you can doesn't mean you should.

HalfWomanHalfChocolate · 18/03/2023 14:39

I don’t understand the anger here.

I was working 4 days a week when I first went back after Dc2. We didn’t have any free hours at first, she was about 1yo, and we paid around £1k per month for childcare . i was earning just under £100k at 4 days pw.

When DC got to 3 we were eligible for the free 30 hours because I earned under £100k (DH earns much less). Of course, childcare wasn’t entirely free because it only covers term time etc so we still paid a bit, but much less than when we were funding it completely. Particularly as the free hours could stretch further over 4 days.

Had I increased my hours when DC was 3 I’d have tipped into the over £100k bracket. We’d have lost the free childcare hours (worth several hundred a month), I’d have had to pay an extra day’s childcare, AND in that tax bracket you lose your personal allowance, so are effectively double taxed between £100k and £125k. I would have increased my hours, had less time with my Dc and have actually had significantly less money (after childcare) than I did on a 4 day week. So no, the extra free childcare hours (which does nearly cover a 5–day week of full time work) did NOT make me feel obliged to increase my hours when my DC was 3.

I was not wanting to increase my hours anyway, but as I am on a defined benefit scheme I wouldn’t have had the option of fiddling about with pension contributions.

I can’t see why reducing hours when DC is 3 is any more morally reprehensible than me NOT increasing my hours when I got some funded childcare hours, for just one of the 3 years my Dc was at nursery, and I was contributing as a higher rate taxpayer the whole time.

I don’t regard that as scamming the taxpayer and I think it is ridiculous that anyone would think so. As a high earner I am a net contributor and just like anyone else I can decide where, on the sliding scale of working more or less, I wish to balance my life. And so can OP. The hard threshold for childcare hours is a bit ridiculous, as is the threshold for child benefit applying to individual income and not household income, because it can disincentivise people from working more hours, but the govt can fix that if they actually want to.

As an aside, I do think working part time has affected my career trajectory but we made that decision for family and caring reasons, not purely financial, and it was necessary for us even with the negative impact it’s had from that side. But I would take that into consideration in making a decision as it’s not just about money now, as others have said.

Ovidnaso · 18/03/2023 14:38

A four day week is a much more healthy life balance, so what any policy should be working towards long term.

Lipfloss · 18/03/2023 14:37

Bucketheadbucketbum · 18/03/2023 14:29

Quite a few of our colleagues talking similar now- they really need to fix it!

Fix what? If you and your colleagues can afford to and want to go part time then good for them and for you! The hours aren't as good as they seem really and no guarantee all settings will offer them.

Mariposa26 · 18/03/2023 14:35

Nolimittomylove · 18/03/2023 14:31

Disgusting. I hope when your child no longer gets the free childcare, you can’t increase your hours and are stuck with less money.

Why? Assuming the OP and her partner have paid a lot into the system over the years as high earners, and are now taking steps to benefit from the way it has been set up. I’m interested to know why they is disgusting. Are high earners meant to just pay in at a much higher rate forever and never take out?

Stopthatknocking · 18/03/2023 14:32

If you both earn over £100k, pay for your own childcare.
You are not 'the squeezed middle' as you claim, you are both very high earners.

Playing the system by reducing your income and expecting the government to pay this tiny rate to nurseries, who can then only afford to pay thier staff minimum wage to look after your child when you can well afford it yourself is just horrible behaviour.

Musicsoundsbetter22 · 18/03/2023 14:31

Do people really think this will all actually happen as set out? The time line is
long for it to actually start and then be established and there are many issues with the whole policy.

One of them is the Tory party generally being shit houses and also a not too distant general election.

Risky making big life decisions around a policy that hasn’t come to fruition.

Nolimittomylove · 18/03/2023 14:31

Disgusting. I hope when your child no longer gets the free childcare, you can’t increase your hours and are stuck with less money.

YukoandHiro · 18/03/2023 14:30

*pinch years

Although it does feel like a punch tbf

catshreddedthesofa · 18/03/2023 14:30

We are close to but not at the limit. By the time our baby is old enough to qualify I suspect we could be in the same position, so was thinking about doing the same.

It seems mad, but what a better way to live.

YukoandHiro · 18/03/2023 14:30

In the short term (2-3 years) you will be better off. In the long term over the next 20-25 years you will be considerably worse off. Please think about your future prospects not just these awful punch years

Bucketheadbucketbum · 18/03/2023 14:29

Quite a few of our colleagues talking similar now- they really need to fix it!

OP posts:
Bucketheadbucketbum · 18/03/2023 14:28

Dorisbonson · 18/03/2023 14:19

Get screwed as a higher earner. At 99.9k a year salary you get net 5500 a month, at 120k you get 6000 a month eg the extra 1666 a month you earn only gets you another net £500 a month - taxman has £1166 you get £500. You lose out free childcare at 100k. The government are decreasing the supertax threshold from 155k to 120k so we will pay another 5% on that bit too. At 155k you lose tax benefits on pension contributions.

Most high earners live in the SE so get screwed on higher house prices and stamp duty, we get screwed on train fares too.

For all the tax we pay, the NHS is knackered, schools teach woke fake biology, police don't investigate burglaries or stolen vehicles. The answer everyone has is to put taxes up - on who?

So for all this, I left the UK for work last year. I had planned to come back in 2 years but am terrified about Labour winning the next election and putting taxes up even more.

This is exactly our situation

In the current tax set up We will have a MUCH nicer family life and general existence by both working and earning less

OP posts:
AviMav · 18/03/2023 14:27

Sneakyblinders · 18/03/2023 14:12

i think there's a bit of a difference between factoring in 'free childcare' when making a change to working hours - for example if you were part time before considering going up to full time hours.

but for both of you to deliberately drop down to 3/4 days a week for the sole purpose of claiming these benefits I find really distasteful.

In this economy people need to do what's best for them. If this works for OP and her family good for them. Sour 🍇

Oblomov23 · 18/03/2023 14:26

Sounds great. Shocked at the responses.

Sleepygrumpyandnothappy · 18/03/2023 14:25

Bernadinetta · 18/03/2023 14:23

They’re not doing it to spend more time with the children- the children will be in childcare.

I assume the child will also drop from five days to two-three!

Bernadinetta · 18/03/2023 14:23

Sleepygrumpyandnothappy · 18/03/2023 14:22

Really surprised at the responses here. It’s not unusual or unreasonable for two people with big jobs (both the op and her partner appear to be earning over £100k) to cut down their hours to spend more time with young children. And here they have a financial incentive too. NI contributions etc will still be very high.

DP will likely cross £100k before our DS starts school - hopefully I will too - and of course this is in the mix.

They’re not doing it to spend more time with the children- the children will be in childcare.

shattered25 · 18/03/2023 14:23

lljkk · 18/03/2023 13:54

Can someone talk me thru why what OP plans to do will hurt other tax payers?

Oh it's just apparently tax pays for everything in England and no one wants to pay tax for anyone to possibly benefit of their minimal contribution but they also expect to reap benefits of every service available. As obviously their tax contribution has not only paid for every child, disabled person and pensioner but also paid off every healthcare, operation and care home fees they may have too 😂

Bernadinetta · 18/03/2023 14:22

Dorisbonson · 18/03/2023 14:19

Get screwed as a higher earner. At 99.9k a year salary you get net 5500 a month, at 120k you get 6000 a month eg the extra 1666 a month you earn only gets you another net £500 a month - taxman has £1166 you get £500. You lose out free childcare at 100k. The government are decreasing the supertax threshold from 155k to 120k so we will pay another 5% on that bit too. At 155k you lose tax benefits on pension contributions.

Most high earners live in the SE so get screwed on higher house prices and stamp duty, we get screwed on train fares too.

For all the tax we pay, the NHS is knackered, schools teach woke fake biology, police don't investigate burglaries or stolen vehicles. The answer everyone has is to put taxes up - on who?

So for all this, I left the UK for work last year. I had planned to come back in 2 years but am terrified about Labour winning the next election and putting taxes up even more.

Boo hoo, poor you only earning £6000 a month, what a hardship.

Sleepygrumpyandnothappy · 18/03/2023 14:22

Really surprised at the responses here. It’s not unusual or unreasonable for two people with big jobs (both the op and her partner appear to be earning over £100k) to cut down their hours to spend more time with young children. And here they have a financial incentive too. NI contributions etc will still be very high.

DP will likely cross £100k before our DS starts school - hopefully I will too - and of course this is in the mix.

Dorisbonson · 18/03/2023 14:19

DannyZukosSmile · 18/03/2023 13:58

You won't be the first to do this. I know someone who purposely does a smaller amount of hours every March or April, to drop her normal monthly wage of £1150-ish to £800-850, so she can fill in an HC1 and get full help with health costs all year. Free prescriptions, free dental, £60 voucher towards glasses, free eye tests, help with travel costs to hospital or specialists etc....

£350-ish wage loss to potentially save multiple 100s over a year. (£750 to £900 typically.) She doesn't have to worry about a filling dropping out or a tooth chipping or needing multiple prescriptions etc, as it's all covered.

That's how ridiculous things are in this country. You are only OK if you're a very high earner/rich, OR if you are financially poor, coz you get lots of help from the Government.

I know a few people who are/were on less than £20K a year joint income whose young adult children got 1000s thrown at them in grants and bursaries, and they had more money at uni than many students who had parents on £45-55K a year joint income. The ones whose parents were proper loaded were OK, but the students of the middle earners were fucked, because they got NOTHING, but their parents were not well off enough to give them anything.

@Bucketheadbucketbum Ignore the naysayers and the haters calling you grabby and lazy etc... they're just jealous and bitter. Most people would give their left arm to work only 3 days a week and have more time with their children. And as I say, it's the SYSTEM making you do this. If most jobs paid a lot better and gave people good money/plenty of surplus income, people would not be inclined to do this.

Get screwed as a higher earner. At 99.9k a year salary you get net 5500 a month, at 120k you get 6000 a month eg the extra 1666 a month you earn only gets you another net £500 a month - taxman has £1166 you get £500. You lose out free childcare at 100k. The government are decreasing the supertax threshold from 155k to 120k so we will pay another 5% on that bit too. At 155k you lose tax benefits on pension contributions.

Most high earners live in the SE so get screwed on higher house prices and stamp duty, we get screwed on train fares too.

For all the tax we pay, the NHS is knackered, schools teach woke fake biology, police don't investigate burglaries or stolen vehicles. The answer everyone has is to put taxes up - on who?

So for all this, I left the UK for work last year. I had planned to come back in 2 years but am terrified about Labour winning the next election and putting taxes up even more.

Babyroobs · 18/03/2023 14:17

Yes I think a lot will do this , drop to 3 days a week now that the free hours would fully cover it. Who wants to be working full time with young kids, it's gruelling. Not unreasonable to expect one of a couple to work full time though. I just feel sad there wasn't this level of help around when mine were small, we worked around each other for years which really took it's toll. I don't begrudge others now getting the help though although think it will backfire for the government because many on good wages were managing the childcare costs and will now do as you are suggesting..

NoSquirrels · 18/03/2023 14:16

Bucketheadbucketbum · 18/03/2023 14:07

Yes we can - we both do sessional work , just drop some sessions. Never have before because didn't want to drop wages but now in that "squeezed middle" where actually if earned less would pay less tax and get more benefits! Mad house!

Are you “squeezed middle” if you’re earning over £100K a year?

Butterfly44 · 18/03/2023 14:16

Depends on your occupations. Some jobs require full time staff, if you go part time would they have to backfill? Later if you wanted to go back up you may not be able to. It's not an automatic right. You can ask though.

Parker231 · 18/03/2023 14:15

Fragrantandfoolish · 18/03/2023 13:41

Surprised at the responses. I wonder if it’s because it’s child care. If someone posted me and my husband are going to go part time so we can claim universal credit id suspect the responses would be different

Are you confident that your childcare provider will offer the new hours - many won’t as they won’t be able to afford it as the government contributions are so low. There are likely to be less childcare providers not more.