Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

DH and I going part time to deliberately reduce wages

890 replies

Bucketheadbucketbum · 18/03/2023 13:35

Just working out the free childcare hours and actually DH and I will be muxh better off if we both dropped to 3- 4 day week to deliberately reduce our incomes. Would obviously be nice way to live too! Anyone else doing same? Seems mental but we've looked at it 100 times over and it's true!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
DaughterOfGaia · 18/03/2023 15:46

I always find it amazing that in western countries we view children and parents as tax burdens rather than viewing the children as future tax payers. This is why we have a retirement crisis happening world wide.

Madamecastafiore · 18/03/2023 15:46

I wouldn't do anything yet. The government might change and these new plans might be completely changed or not actually come into effect at all.

Makingupfactstosuitmyagenda · 18/03/2023 15:46

You are definitely not unreasonable to drop some hours and spend more time as a family. There are thresholds to lots of benefits - you are doing nothing worse than anyone who works and pumps cash in to their pension.

you are vvvvv u reasonable though to think you are ‘squeezed middle’ though on a household income of +200k or even with your drop to 198000 or thereabouts! You are probably in the top 3-5%!

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 15:45

A choice all the same though, there’s no compulsion to train and work without any kind of compensation and clearly anyone who has made that choice thinks or thought at one point it was worth it. If it stops being worth it I would suggest stop doing it.

You're not getting it. Of course it's a choice. And yes, they are stopping doing it: they are cutting down their hours in these stressful and skilled jobs that pay the majority of the country's tax revenue. Because it isn't worth them working full time for absolutely no benefit to their own families.

WinterMusings · 18/03/2023 15:45

Lostinalibrary · 18/03/2023 14:43

What they need to fix - you can earn £99.9k and take home MORE than someone on £135k. This is a known and well publicised effective tax rate of over 100%. The chancellor himself as been told it is directly impacting on the economy. Why would you work for all that extra to be be worse off? Issue is - it’s these people who pay the most tax. Professionals such as Drs, head teachers, engineers: they are the ones paying the tax to prop everything up. It’s not the millionaires and billionaires who avoid it.

Effectively taxing people at over 100% is not only stupid - it lowers the tax take and results in lower productivity. As they chancellor has been told repeatedly. It’s short sighted that people can’t see this monumental issue. It’s why economics should be compulsory at school.

@Lostinalibrary

practical economics should be taught, yes & maths in a practical way.

you'd think you'd need a better understanding of it all to be eligible to be given the role as Chancelor, but seemingly not 🤦🏻‍♀️

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 15:43

Hence · 18/03/2023 15:27

Good for you. Why shouldn't you benefit from this new free childcare scheme when you have paid so much in taxes all these years? I am glad you have found a way to make it work for your family. People on here get so jealous it is insane.

This is why universal benefits work. No bottlenecks, and also they continue to get buy in from the people funding them for everyone else. Childcare, healthcare, pensions, education etc etc all survive on the principal of public buy-in. And that means that they need to be available to the people who pay for them as well as those who are being funded by others to have them. They are a public good, for us all. Of course largely paid for by higher earners but if everyone can access them that's fine. If they are paid for by one group and that group is excluded from accessing them, then they start to be resented, become a target and are gradually watered down or disappear. This is why means-testing state pension would be the death of it: the very people paying in far more than they get out would instead get nothing back? Before long the threshold for receiving it and the amount provided would lower so far it would be meaningless anyway. It's amazing how so many people are so consumed by envy that they will bite the hand that feeds them and refuse to support policies that will result in a healthy and functioning economy where everyone is provided for. If you just take and take from one group until over 100% of any payrises they get are taken off them, then obviously their support for funding these things will be lost and they will also start acting only in their own best interests.

Tryingtokeepgoing · 18/03/2023 15:42

Dorisbonson · 18/03/2023 14:19

Get screwed as a higher earner. At 99.9k a year salary you get net 5500 a month, at 120k you get 6000 a month eg the extra 1666 a month you earn only gets you another net £500 a month - taxman has £1166 you get £500. You lose out free childcare at 100k. The government are decreasing the supertax threshold from 155k to 120k so we will pay another 5% on that bit too. At 155k you lose tax benefits on pension contributions.

Most high earners live in the SE so get screwed on higher house prices and stamp duty, we get screwed on train fares too.

For all the tax we pay, the NHS is knackered, schools teach woke fake biology, police don't investigate burglaries or stolen vehicles. The answer everyone has is to put taxes up - on who?

So for all this, I left the UK for work last year. I had planned to come back in 2 years but am terrified about Labour winning the next election and putting taxes up even more.

Pensions tapering starts at £240k - that was increased in 2020. It tops out at £312k. So I can’t see how anyone earning that much is better off going part time and reducing their salary to £99k just to get free childcare.

Take home, assuming a 10% pensions contribution, is around £11k on £240k It’s less than half that on £100k with a 10% pension contribution. Is free childcare really worth £5,500 a month? And actually the OP was talking about both partners doing the same - so reducing net income by £11k to gain free childcare… and a much reduced pension.

Not withstanding that, the tax system is a labyrinth of pitfalls, and New Labours enmeshing of benefits at every level of society, such that those on £100k are still entitled to benefits, has meant no party has the will to reform. Which is what they wanted…they really screwed the country over for multiple generations.

whittingtonmum · 18/03/2023 15:41

Do it. I don't think you will regret it.

KarmaStar · 18/03/2023 15:36

But if you're at home you don't need child care!why take up a much needed place?what about your pensions and savings?
Think long term before you do this.

Supergirl1958 · 18/03/2023 15:35

Merkins · 18/03/2023 15:22

20 years ago I earned £14,500 per annum and paid £15,000 in full time childcare for my twins. I was a single parent and, with tax credits, my gross income was around £20,000.

I fully support making it easier for people to work by providing free childcare, but hearing someone say they’ll reduce their income to £198,000 to take advantage is, frankly, sickening. This is supposed to help the poorest in society. Here we have extremely wealthy people lining their pockets to the detriment of the nurseries, and the quality of care they can provide for the children of people who desperately need good childcare so they can earn 10% of what the OP and her husband do.

👏. Well done you for doing that! I tip my hat to you x

7Worfs · 18/03/2023 15:34

Hardbackwriter · 18/03/2023 15:30

I think it's a bit of shame, if it's really so easy and consequence-free for you both to go part-time, that you're only considering this now because you think otherwise you might miss out on free money. We both work a four day week and I'd absolutely recommend it to anyone and especially both parents doing it, which I think is absolutely transformative compared to the more standard set-up of FT man, very PT woman.

But it’s not free free money… OP and her husband get fleeced pay at least £50-60k income tax annually. If they qualify for the 30hrs they will cost the taxpayer £4,387.50 annually. It’s just a tiny tax break.

Hardbackwriter · 18/03/2023 15:30

I think it's a bit of shame, if it's really so easy and consequence-free for you both to go part-time, that you're only considering this now because you think otherwise you might miss out on free money. We both work a four day week and I'd absolutely recommend it to anyone and especially both parents doing it, which I think is absolutely transformative compared to the more standard set-up of FT man, very PT woman.

Cornettoninja · 18/03/2023 15:30

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 15:13

High earners can of course access the same social safety nets as anyone else should they need to. Need being defined as you are unable to provide for yourself.

Ask yourself if you would work more hours so that the state could take 100% of the extra income you earned from doing so.

Depends what other factors were at play. As a country we generally put in a lot of unpaid hours across the board. People are receiving financial reward so clearly other things are motivating them. I certainly don’t agree with working for nothing but I also don’t think monetary gain is the only valuable component of working.

@ScruffyGiraffes

People don't "take a job with those salary levels". They work their arses off to get qualified and skilled enough to earn that money

A choice all the same though, there’s no compulsion to train and work without any kind of compensation and clearly anyone who has made that choice thinks or thought at one point it was worth it. If it stops being worth it I would suggest stop doing it.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 18/03/2023 15:28

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 15:25

@BashirWithTheGoodBeard exactly. There is so much research on it. Even the Guardian recognise the issue per my link upthread! We are not talking about rich people here. We're talking about the net contributors who we ALL need to work more for the economy to recover because they're the ones holding it up. This issue applies with the bottlenecks at £50k and £100k and also with universal credit tapering. It's the same issue: if it's not worth you working more because the tax is too punitive, obviously you won't. People need to drop the green eyed monster and step back and think "what would make the economy function better?"

Yes, it's really self indulgent for people to focus so much on whether they morally object to others acting in their own self interest. Nobody cares.

Hence · 18/03/2023 15:27

Good for you. Why shouldn't you benefit from this new free childcare scheme when you have paid so much in taxes all these years? I am glad you have found a way to make it work for your family. People on here get so jealous it is insane.

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 15:27

Surely it's obvious nobody will work more if it makes them poorer to do so?!

It's not rocket science. People will make the decisions that benefit their family.

The tax system is dysfunctional. The Government commissioned research that told them this and how to fix it. They didn't. Labour have no plans to either. Therefore everyone will continue to get poorer.

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 15:25

@BashirWithTheGoodBeard exactly. There is so much research on it. Even the Guardian recognise the issue per my link upthread! We are not talking about rich people here. We're talking about the net contributors who we ALL need to work more for the economy to recover because they're the ones holding it up. This issue applies with the bottlenecks at £50k and £100k and also with universal credit tapering. It's the same issue: if it's not worth you working more because the tax is too punitive, obviously you won't. People need to drop the green eyed monster and step back and think "what would make the economy function better?"

BorgQueen · 18/03/2023 15:25

People seem to be forgetting that free childcare only covers ‘school hours’ i.e. 9.00 - 3.00, so paid for wrap around care is necessary for most working parents. I don’t blame OP at all if she can drop a day or two.

Merkins · 18/03/2023 15:22

Glera · 18/03/2023 14:50

I'm on the fence with your post personally.

I'm reading between the lines that you both earn over 100k and by dropping hours, youll be eligible for free childcare hours. Whilst I can see why you're making the decision you are, you're absolutely not in the squeezed middle.

I'm sorry if I've misunderstood your circumstances but no matter where you live, a joint income of up to £200k is not the squeezed middle.

I wish you and your family all the best but perhaps keep an open mind for families who are truly on the threshold of the squeezed middle.

20 years ago I earned £14,500 per annum and paid £15,000 in full time childcare for my twins. I was a single parent and, with tax credits, my gross income was around £20,000.

I fully support making it easier for people to work by providing free childcare, but hearing someone say they’ll reduce their income to £198,000 to take advantage is, frankly, sickening. This is supposed to help the poorest in society. Here we have extremely wealthy people lining their pockets to the detriment of the nurseries, and the quality of care they can provide for the children of people who desperately need good childcare so they can earn 10% of what the OP and her husband do.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 18/03/2023 15:20

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 15:09

Exactly. Economic insanity. And anybody reliant on UC or public services should be the people campaigning hardest to get this fixed because those things simply won't be funded if the people paying for it are taxed 100% and obviously will then cut down work and stop providing that tax revenue. It amazes me how the green eyed monster stops people being able to see basic facts even when it's this obvious.

This is very true, and I say this as someone on the left.

We currently have a labour shortage. If we want people to work, we have to make work pay, which incidentally requires more than just the stick while we abandon the carrot. This is relevant at a wide variety of income levels because there are bottlenecks across the spectrum. The calculations the OP makes aren't too dissimilar to the ones my parents made twenty years ago about tax credits, or that people in my community make now in relation to UC. The principle is the same.

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 15:18

Cornettoninja · 18/03/2023 15:09

you can't really expect them to keep working full time out of the goodness of their hearts and donating their entire additional earnings to the state

Why are you painting high earners as indentured slaves with guns to their heads? People can work where ever they like.

I struggle to get behind your stance when you’re trying to paint high earners as people who’ve ended up in that position through no fault of their own with no personal benefit. Just don’t take a job at those salary levels if the tax and sums don’t work out personally for you but don’t pretend the situation is anything like those earning average or below wages whilst trying to piggy back on policies that should be better ringfenced for them.

(full disclosure - I pay for childcare, work, live in the south and DP, at least, is a high earner).

People don't "take a job with those salary levels". They work their arses off to get qualified and skilled enough to earn that money.

I worked 90-100 hour weeks throughout my 20s. I am now a lone parent, and damn right I should actually get more net pay if I sacrifice time with my children to work more hours. Why would I work more and have even less time with them to give 100% of the extra money I earn to the state to fund other people having more time with their children while mine spend even more time in childcare? Nobody would do that.

If you want to productivity and funding available for public services and benefits to increase then it needs to be worthwhile for the most productive workers in the economy to work more. We don't mind paying more than everyone else and subsidising others - even though I'm a lone parent I don't mind this. I won't, however, work more when the state will take 100% of that money. Or actually even more, we'd end up worse off than now.

sofia7 · 18/03/2023 15:16

My DH is considering paying more into his pension to fall under the earning limit for our next child due. We pay shit loads of tax! A full time nursery place is £500/ week, so £24,000 a year, out of net income currently as we don’t qualify for tax free childcare. £100,000 a year is not a fortune in an expensive part of the country.

NorthernDrizzle · 18/03/2023 15:16

The amount is 38 weeks x 15 hours at about £5-6 (£5.67 in some London brought) an hour. That is all you would benefit. 570 hours at say £6 an hour- even increased by 30% it is 570 hours x £7.80 an hour.

Jonei · 18/03/2023 15:15

It's just scamming the system. Again.

Lissaaaaaa · 18/03/2023 15:15

When I was a single mum I worked full time earning 40k. I paid £450 a month in rent.
so I dropped to three days a week and earned around 26k a year and as a result was entitled to all my rent of Of £450 being paid. So ended up better off by reducing my hours. I’d have been made to stay full time