Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

DH and I going part time to deliberately reduce wages

890 replies

Bucketheadbucketbum · 18/03/2023 13:35

Just working out the free childcare hours and actually DH and I will be muxh better off if we both dropped to 3- 4 day week to deliberately reduce our incomes. Would obviously be nice way to live too! Anyone else doing same? Seems mental but we've looked at it 100 times over and it's true!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Blossomtoes · 21/03/2023 16:54

Names, even!

Blossomtoes · 21/03/2023 16:52

Children do not get an allowance in the UK system though.

They do. Everyone, regardless of age, has a personal allowance. It’s why some wealthy people stash money away in their kids’ named.

mackthepony · 21/03/2023 16:11

Work smarter, not harder OP.

It's your life and you only live it once.

Good for you

AviMav · 21/03/2023 16:06

Ilikepinacoladass · 21/03/2023 14:53

Single parents aren't always sole parents though, if the single parent was getting additional tax benefits and then also sharing child costs with the non resident parent / getting decent child support, couples might see that as unfair?

That would be none of the couples business. You are really clutching at straws. In the eyes of the law and it is also well known universally that CMS is a unreliable. There's reasons why CMS is not means tested.

ThinkingMeat · 21/03/2023 16:04

Or, like the OP, find they would be working more for free. Or actually be paying more to work more and have less money and less time with their children.

How messed up.

Anybody who thinks this is a sensible system must want to be poorer than they are because that is what will happen. So obvious it's not even a question. The less tax revenue, the less services and help for those in need. Why would you want people who pay a lot of tax not to work more and tell them "tough, work more for free, and don't dare use services you're funding by the way!" Confused

Same nonsense in the arguments that penalising single parents must happen to be fair to couples although the evidence shows this will make the couples poorer too. It's all part of the same weird idea that I cannot quite "get my head around".

I don't understand the mentality at all. It is very interesting from a psychological perspective but I can't "get it" still. Other than it is just about jealousy and grabbiness and "me me me" and not being able to see wider effects and long term impacts that - even if not caring about others, just from a self-interested perspective - mean these are bad ideas. It reminds me of that saying "cut off your nose to spite your face", but surely most of the UK population could not be that vindictive just to try to make themselves feel better than others even when it makes them worse off too, and so support policies that do that? I do not understand why enough people support this crazy waste of money that it is allowed to go on when t
evidence shows clearly these policies will make others poorer and also make them poorer. And spending the same money in a different way would have the opposite effect. I really do want to understand but cannot find a way to explain it. Would make a very interesting case study.

ThinkingMeat · 21/03/2023 15:44

Blossomtoes · 21/03/2023 14:35

That makes complete sense @ThinkingMeat. You’ve made such persuasive arguments that you’ve changed my mind. I entirely approve of single parents using their children’s personal allowances.

I am glad you have read and thought about it. I know it takes a lot for people to reconsider their views.

Children do not get an allowance in the UK system though. This is why the tax codes for single parents need adjusting as there is no asjustment made for the fact there is only one adult in the household to earn or look after the children (or pay for that while they do), and no allowance either for having dependents.

A couple with no children will pay less tax than a parent for four children on the same earnings.

This is insanity. This is a big reason there is such low UK tax revenue, such a big gender paygap and also why there is so little money for services and to help people who cannot work. Many people who could work more and want to cannot for financial reasons or find they would not be better off by doing so because of this ridiculous system, so instead have to be supported when that money could go to people who are disabled and can't work.

I am pleased you have seen the need for changing it. I hope more people do. The issues with the crazy tax treatment here of single parents but also the means testing that stops couples working more as well at certain levels of earnings because they would get no significant benefit from it. If people in the UK do not put their prejudices aside and start to look at what will actually work and help everything then the UK will continue to get poorer year by year.

ThinkingMeat · 21/03/2023 15:24

Ilikepinacoladass · 21/03/2023 14:53

Single parents aren't always sole parents though, if the single parent was getting additional tax benefits and then also sharing child costs with the non resident parent / getting decent child support, couples might see that as unfair?

Obviously when saying "universal" for child benefit and childcare funds I don't mean a separated couple could both claim it, only one just as now.

In terms of the tax, yes the two separated parents should get allowances as two separate households, for all of the reasons I explained already. They each have a household to fund so will have higher costs. That is "a feature not a bug". But each household will have only one person's time each day to earn to pay for that house or be with their children. It will be much harder for them to reach the same household income as a couple living together. So you don't compound the fact that their household income will be lower while trying to pay all the costs for the home on their own, by also taking them a higher % on the same household income that they have earned on their own as one person not two (while usually also needing to pay much more childcare as well!).

They will not be getting an advantage on you. They will always be at a disadvantage. As someone said (I think you?) of course it costs more to live separately and always will. Fine. But you don't have to "stamp down" on them too and then tax them more as well on the same income even though they obviously can earn less in half the time available each day. That is just crazy, which is why other countries have provisions in their tax systems to avoid increasing the disadvantage by penalising through tax like this on top of the inevitable inbuilt disadvantage that will always be there just through practical reality.

These people will never be in a better situation that a couple who can both earn, or one earn and one not so have no childcare to pay, or share it all as they see fit. Never. Of course not. Will always be poorer as they have to pay alone. Why would you tax them more on the same earnings and well?

It really is a very peculiar thing to the UK to see this kind of argument where people would be worried that a single parent might be better off than they are and should pay for a house alone but from less net income for the same earnings because otherwise it might be unfair on a family with two adults to earn or be with children, if the couple didn't also get to keep more of the same household income. Effectively you are saying you want single parent households doing the job of two parents to subsidise couples who have the same household income. That can never be ok, if you step back and be rational.

And as I have tried to explain, this "but it's mot fair to meeeeee" attitude makes everyone poorer in the end. You object to what I proposed even though it would not
make you a penny poorer because you feel it might help a household at a disadvantage to you and that would not be "fair" in your opinion. Even though all research shows that in the long term if this happened then it would make your household richer also: it would increase tax revenue and reduce the need for welfare so either mean better pubic services for your family or lower taxes for your family. But you couldn't bear to see some people in a worse situation get what you consider to be "help" (when actually it's just removing existing unfairness) even if it actually benefitted you as well in the long run.

That is what is wrong with the UK.

This whole thread shows the same thing, around the tax thresholds and making it pointless for people to work more, as well as the single parent issue.

People will reap what they sew. Tried to persuade people with facts and research but if UK mentality is that you would rather things don't get better for others and for you in case you feel they might benefit more than you then I can see how you have ended up where you are. And what will happen in the next ten years: it won't be good.

StatisticallyChallenged · 21/03/2023 15:16

Other countries do recognise children in their parent's tax - it's a way of recognising the additional costs and allowing parents to keep more of their income. The general idea is that it replaces certain benefits and removes some families from means tested benefits. Not all families , but some

So you wouldn't have child benefit at all. For those on means tested benefits it's rolled in there by increasing child elements. For everyone else it's part of tax allowance. No child benefit admin at all. Thousands of working families who are currently claiming UC no longer do so, because you're no longer taking their money via tax only to hand it back via benefits.

Childcare is challenging because the amount the govt is willing to pay doesn't cover what it costs to provide it. So free childcare might mean no childcare - but it should be heavily subsidised but done so simply and directly with the provider, not via a dogs dinner of benefits and claims.

But there are many improvements available and the main point is that the current system sucks.

Blossomtoes · 21/03/2023 15:11

StatisticallyChallenged · 21/03/2023 14:55

There's no reason they'd have to be the same - if you were doing such a big rethink as any of the options discussed you would obviously assess what was the correct value too. So it could be that the child personal allowance is 1/2 of an adults, for example.

Yes, that makes sense.

ThinkingMeat · 21/03/2023 15:02

Blossomtoes · 21/03/2023 14:48

a couple has 2x adult personal allowance, a single parent with 2 kids has 1x adult and 2x child personal allowances.

So a single parent would be better off than a couple - currently children’s personal allowances are the same as adults’. I can’t see that flying at the ballot box.

Children do not earn money, unless they are a Hollywood star or something. Grin There is no reduction to parents' tax bill in the UK for having children, no allowance applied.

Agree to do so would muddy the waters and also probably be quite unfair to childfree people who already pay towards schools etc. Obviously this benefits them too in longer terms but this might be too much to propose, I agree.

What I suggested is much simpler and less controversial, taking the best parts from systems elsewhere that could be applied to existing UK system easily without much extra costs, and based on research on long term outcomes of the other systems and what has worked.

A) Make child benefit and childcare funding universal for all households
B) Make tax allowances/ threshold allowances transferrable between couples on an opt in basis
C) Give single parents the same allowances as the couple for all thresholds.

This is simple, can be done overnight, saves a lot of money in admin, reduces poverty and need for welfare and increases tax revenue. And nobody will lose money from the "status quo".

Then watch the work rates and tax revenue increase and decide what to spend it on. Maybe also get some better politicians so it is spent on something good.

StatisticallyChallenged · 21/03/2023 15:00

Ilikepinacoladass · 21/03/2023 14:53

Single parents aren't always sole parents though, if the single parent was getting additional tax benefits and then also sharing child costs with the non resident parent / getting decent child support, couples might see that as unfair?

It's what already happens with benefits. Maintenance is ignored. Assume it's also the case for child benefit and childcare 100k threshold actually, as maintenence isn't taxable income AFAIK.

StatisticallyChallenged · 21/03/2023 14:55

Blossomtoes · 21/03/2023 14:48

a couple has 2x adult personal allowance, a single parent with 2 kids has 1x adult and 2x child personal allowances.

So a single parent would be better off than a couple - currently children’s personal allowances are the same as adults’. I can’t see that flying at the ballot box.

There's no reason they'd have to be the same - if you were doing such a big rethink as any of the options discussed you would obviously assess what was the correct value too. So it could be that the child personal allowance is 1/2 of an adults, for example.

Ilikepinacoladass · 21/03/2023 14:53

Single parents aren't always sole parents though, if the single parent was getting additional tax benefits and then also sharing child costs with the non resident parent / getting decent child support, couples might see that as unfair?

Blossomtoes · 21/03/2023 14:48

a couple has 2x adult personal allowance, a single parent with 2 kids has 1x adult and 2x child personal allowances.

So a single parent would be better off than a couple - currently children’s personal allowances are the same as adults’. I can’t see that flying at the ballot box.

StatisticallyChallenged · 21/03/2023 14:43

Yes, for clarity I meant an allowance which the parents would be able to use against their income. So a single adult has a personal allowance, a couple has 2x adult personal allowance, a single parent with 2 kids has 1x adult and 2x child personal allowances.

All of these should be transferable within the family so a family with two parents earning 40k each can in theory pay the same tax as a family with one parent earning 80k and the other staying at home.

Blossomtoes · 21/03/2023 14:35

That makes complete sense @ThinkingMeat. You’ve made such persuasive arguments that you’ve changed my mind. I entirely approve of single parents using their children’s personal allowances.

ThinkingMeat · 21/03/2023 14:31

Blossomtoes · 21/03/2023 14:21

Don’t children already have tax allowances? It would make sense if those could be transferred to single parents. There’d still be the issue of identifying single parent households, though. I guess one way would be via council tax discounts.

Not difficult. UK makes such analyses already for many benefits. Also Council tax as you say. Many other countries do it, it isn't difficult. HMRC have addresses for all registered taxpayers, they know how many adults at each address and easy to identify fraud. Houses of HMO are registered so occupants would be considered separate. Tick a box on HMRC website for adult child living at home so they get a separate allowance.

Systems to "police" this would be far less expensive than means testing child benefit and childcare and welfare and then claiming back welfare overpaid and sanctioning and appeals for that and on and on.

It sounds like excuses. "It can't be done, too hard". It can, easily. It is, in many countries. It's not hard. It would cost much less than the UK system now and have better outcomes. Research shows this clearly because it has been done already elsewhere.

Blossomtoes · 21/03/2023 14:27

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 21/03/2023 14:22

You mean the personal allowance?

Yes.

StarmanBobby · 21/03/2023 14:27

Go for it. Your children will benefit from you being around more, and the fact that you're likely to have a better work/life balance.
Going PT because of kids WILL affect your career though, generations of women are proof of that, but you may feel it's still worth it.

Blossomtoes · 21/03/2023 14:25

Yes.

ThinkingMeat · 21/03/2023 14:25

Ilikepinacoladass · 21/03/2023 13:43

Definitely in support of more help / benefits for single parents. Especially as we are facing population decline in the UK. I read an interesting piece that suggested making life easier for single parents can help reverse this.

I guess in terms of giving single people the same tax allowances as if they were a couple just doesn't sit right with me as it seems to be treating single people as if they are one half of a couple / that being a couple is the 'norm'.

Also don't totally understand what the system being suggested is, but think we need to be careful about not making people vulnerable to financial abuse, which I think taxing people based on joint income rather than separately could lend itself to.

No, it wouldn't. I did explain. Couples choosing to combine finances (example one worker and one parent at home) could choose to transfer non-working person's allowance to the worker. As they see fit. But opt-in, so nobody forced to combine finances. Either could revoke with a simple form online even if they did combine, so total autonomy. Lower earner in a couple if decide not to transfer allowances would be taxed exactly as they are now. No impact on couples at all except the added benefit that as in Denmark currently if they wanted to transfer allowance between them they could. Whether they did or not, their total allowance for the household would remain as now. No disadvantage to anybody in a couple. Some optional increased benefits. But no problem with keeping finances separate if chosen. The argument to disadvantage single parents to protect "financial independence" of women in couples is so obviously false, not necessary. I question the motives to make this argument as clearly that is not part of the change being discussed at all.

It would just be adjusting tax %s applied to single parents - so not changing the tax arrangements of couples - they would not be taxed a higher % on the same household income, taxed just as they are now. As you said before a single person will obviously have higher outgoings per person because they pay for a whole household and bills alone. That is fine and expected. What they should not be having is also being taxed more on the same income so they have less net pay to start with from the same household earnings, then trying to pay all of those double expenses (that a couple will split in some way) from a lower amount of after tax pay than the couple can keep when the couple earns the same amount. That "double whammy" makes it almost impossible to do successfully. Hence the high amount of poverty and lower outcomes for those households. Is this what we want, to make those households so poor they rely on welfare long term or can't work more or end up with poor health etc.?

You compound that problem if eligibility for things like child benefit or childcare are also based on a single income not household income. So "triple whammy". If they must be means tested then household income would be much fairer, but as explained before cheaper and better outcomes not to means test these for any family regardless of couple/ single. It costs more money and you then spend money on funding staff at DWP and HMRC instead of giving the money to children. Makes no sense.

Why would people want to charge a household more tax for the same income if it is already at a disadvantage of having only one parent and less adult time to split between earning or looking after the children? Couples who both work get twice the tax free allowances, can earn twice as much before they pay higher rate tax or lose their personal allowance, yet still can share childcare between them even if both working full time. To tax a single parent the same as them on the same household income still gives them a big advantage, just would avoid "stamping down" on the single parent even more on top of the inbuilt disadvantage.

In some couples where one works and one not, allowing the transfer of tax allowances if they wish would put them in the same position as those who both work and respect that it's up to families to make this decision, from the outside it should be identical: same household incomes attract the same tax. Then single parent should get the same allowances as the couple however they split them (or choose to keep them separate!), so that the same household income means the same amount of tax. It really isn't complicated and it is so obviously much fairer, I do not understand why anybody would have an issue. The single parent doesn't have the benefit that couple with one who works and one not working has, of one parent at home full time so no childcare cost, so will still be worse off. Don't worry no single parents will suddenly be getting an advantage over others! The two working parent family still has an advantage with two people to earn more, two people to share childcare. The couple with one worker has a worker who can work without restrictions on time due to childcare and no childcare cost. And both get to split costs as they wish when the single parent will pay alone. Because as you say of course living alone it costs more, and this is fine. But that cost should hit once, not three times compounded and then taxed more as well for the same household income! That is absolute madness. I don't see how any rational person could think that is fair. Or crazy to suggest households be charged the same on the same income no matter what their setup. It's not a "tax break" as somebody said, just basic fairness.

If we want these families of single paremts to be able to provide better for themselves, have better outcomes, need less welfare, then why would people not give them a chance to do that and "level the playing field" to get rid of the poverty traps shown in so much research on the UK system. It will still be much more expensive for them and always will be but insane to also penalise them through higher % tax on top, then people complain many don't work/ work enough. Confused UK system seems designed to make that not possible for them. Will never be the same as having two adults and will always cost more and that is understood but why design a tax system to make another level of disadvantage on top?

Easy fix that many countries do. Have explained the different approaches and what has been shown to work. Won't impact you if in a couple except over time there will be more tax revenue so you will get better public services or lower taxes. Or maybe UK Government will spend it all on broken PPE or moats or something but in any case single parents and their children would have better lives at no cost to you.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 21/03/2023 14:22

Blossomtoes · 21/03/2023 14:21

Don’t children already have tax allowances? It would make sense if those could be transferred to single parents. There’d still be the issue of identifying single parent households, though. I guess one way would be via council tax discounts.

You mean the personal allowance?

Blossomtoes · 21/03/2023 14:21

Don’t children already have tax allowances? It would make sense if those could be transferred to single parents. There’d still be the issue of identifying single parent households, though. I guess one way would be via council tax discounts.

Mycatsgoldtooth · 21/03/2023 14:19

So many clever posters on this thread, it’s actually being a joy to read some of the breakdowns of policy.

StatisticallyChallenged · 21/03/2023 14:10

An alternative is having tax allowances for children too - so a single parent wouldn't have the allowance of a couple, but they would have an additional allowance to reflect the household composition.