Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

DH and I going part time to deliberately reduce wages

890 replies

Bucketheadbucketbum · 18/03/2023 13:35

Just working out the free childcare hours and actually DH and I will be muxh better off if we both dropped to 3- 4 day week to deliberately reduce our incomes. Would obviously be nice way to live too! Anyone else doing same? Seems mental but we've looked at it 100 times over and it's true!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
BungleandGeorge · 18/03/2023 17:19

Lostinalibrary · 18/03/2023 16:41

Many of these people are working in skilled shortage professions. That’s the problem. Engineering, tech, medicine, etc. They are literally hammering educated professionals who we need not only for tax but their skill set.

Well most educated professionals don’t earn over 100k, most don’t have young children. So yes I can see for individuals it’s a problem but if there is someone else to do the work it’s really not a problem for the taxman! It does cause problems in a very few cases for shortage professions around the various cut offs, especially if they have issues with large pension contributions.
there is more to consider than a very simple statement that anyone who agrees with this approach to
taxation must be stupid because it’s not as simple as you suggest. Few people hoarding wealth is not overall a good thing, large disparity between low and high wage earners is a problem and perhaps three people working less hours in a senior job is actually overall better than 2 people in terms of money and productivity into the economy overall.

mishmased · 18/03/2023 17:11

@ScruffyGiraffes I absolutely believe you. I don't earn up to those amounts but my job comes with working shift and that brings up my wages to just under €90k. Just back from mat leave and missing time time with my kids and I've decided to not work shift as contrary to what people think 90k gross does not equate to 7.5k net. I'm lucky to get 4.7k monthly.

Case in point, I recently got a bonus of about 12k, if I was cash it I will end up with €5760 out of 12k! So instead I'll buy shares at work to my limit and put the rest in my pension even though I'd love to have some in cash. Cashing means losing 52-55% so no.

To the op, absolutely do. If it gives you a better work/life balance definitely. Do whatever suits your family, you're still paying a massive amount of taxes.
I'm so sorry for single earners, they're taxed really badly and unfairly. Can you put some into your pensions?

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 18/03/2023 17:08

Anyone working part time when they could work full time is paying less tax than they are capable of. Same for anyone who has taken a school hours job as a ta / admin assistant etc when they previously had a higher paying career. Loads of people in mumsnet are in this category and I’ve never seen it suggested that there’s a moral imperative for them to maximise their earnings.

I wonder if that might be coming, though? Given that the government's plans to entice already retired over 55s back to the workplace aren't likely to plug the labour market holes and the promised childcare provision is hardly guaranteed to appear, parents of older or even adult children who just don't want to work full time might be seen as an untapped reserve who aren't doing their duty.

Emmamoo89 · 18/03/2023 17:08

Go for it 😊 ignore the judgey aholes x

Lostinalibrary · 18/03/2023 17:02

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 16:57

As a household - turned down a potential 60k (30 base) pay rise because of these issues (older children). By the time you factored in the huge amount going to the treasury, the commute, the extra expenses; it actually wasn’t worth it. Unless you are in these tax anomalies or can read the figures in black and white. People don’t get it.

I can absolutely believe it.

It now won't be worth me working more unless I get a payrise of at least £40k. And then only a very marginal difference of a couple of hundred pounds in take home pay, for all the extra stress and hours. Why would I bother?

We had exactly this. The 60k would have near enough gone all in tax. We then factored in the extra commute, childcare for SEND child, limiting my working for more trips. We would have been pretty much as is. For what? Never seeing each other as a family, losing the support network we provide for our older children. For 60k on paper which would in reality be pretty much breaking even. So yeah, not doing that. It’s criminal but that’s the reality and most professionals are starting to think why bother? So good luck to people wanting a functioning welfare system in 10 years. We are literally stifling people bettering themselves.

MarshaBradyo · 18/03/2023 17:00

I can understand it wrt childcare.

The work will still be done and taxes paid by someone else but the it just means the op benefits from something many others do already.

There comes a point where taking on more tax burden isn’t that great.

I agree with pp re tax them more mentality doesn’t always work that well.

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 16:58

This is shocking!

I know. I just wish more people would realise that and press for change. Because until it the tax code gets changed to make this better it really isn't worth people like me working any more or accepting promotions, that would mean we pay more tax that helps everyone else.

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 16:57

As a household - turned down a potential 60k (30 base) pay rise because of these issues (older children). By the time you factored in the huge amount going to the treasury, the commute, the extra expenses; it actually wasn’t worth it. Unless you are in these tax anomalies or can read the figures in black and white. People don’t get it.

I can absolutely believe it.

It now won't be worth me working more unless I get a payrise of at least £40k. And then only a very marginal difference of a couple of hundred pounds in take home pay, for all the extra stress and hours. Why would I bother?

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 16:54

Crumpetdisappointment · 18/03/2023 16:52

surely just one of you need to go part time, the other can be full time, pay towards pension etc,

Nope! Because of the dysfunctional way that - unlike in most comparable countries - these thresholds for tax etc are applied here on an individual and not household basis, it will be better for OP and her husband to both reduce their working hours.

Therefore less tax in the system to help support public services and low earners.

Don't blame them. Blame the chancellor who is in charge of this ridiculous tax code.

mishmased · 18/03/2023 16:52

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 16:10

And this, which nobody bothered to respond to, cannot be repeated enough. The judgement from people based on a headline salary figure who clearly have not the faintest comprehension of housing or childcare costs in other parts of the country, or that a family with two low earners and claiming UC will get a similar amount of take home pay in total to a lone parent earning £100k once support for housing costs and childcare etc for the low earner is factored in, and that they are not taxed on their UC, and that the lone parent is taxed more than them on their actual earnings even though they are doing everything! It's an unsustainable system, hence why it is falling apart. We've been bled dry already, my household has nothing left to give and I certainly won't be spending even less time with my children to pay 100% of my additional earnings to the state to give to others who - in many cases - have a lot more disposable income than I do.

And what of the single parents earning £100k, with small children in childcare? Taxed as much as a couple who can have one parent at home! Half the tax free allowance, higher rate tax imposed at half the household income, child benefit withdrawn at half the income, as are funded nursery hours and "tax free childcare" and the personal allowance.

Usually to earn that much as a lone parent to try to provide for their children with no state help they will have to be living in the SE so at least half of that net pay taken up with mortgage/ rent, and another £2k on childcare at least. End up even earning £100k having only £1000 or so left to pay council tax, food, commuting, utilities, and no help with nursery funding although they obviously need more childcare than a couple who have 47 hours per day to split earning and time with children between them. Yeah, living it up, big time. Rich. 🤣🤣🤣 And faced with over 100% tax rate if you try to work more or seek a promotion to get more net pay to cover the inflation. You have NO CLUE.

This is shocking!

Crumpetdisappointment · 18/03/2023 16:52

surely just one of you need to go part time, the other can be full time, pay towards pension etc,

begoneday · 18/03/2023 16:46

LizzieSiddal · 18/03/2023 13:41

Sounds like you don’t care that other tax payers will be working to pay for your child when you could actually afford to pay for it yourself.

Each to their own I suppose.

Tax payers are already paying for thousands of children whose parents don't work at all, so why should OP not get a better work life balance for her and her family ?

Lostinalibrary · 18/03/2023 16:45

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 16:38

Childcare payments are for a pretty short period of someone’s working life.

Ummm, no. What am I meant to do after school/ before school/ when I need to go on business trips/ how am I meant to cover 13 weeks of school holidays with 5 weeks of annual leave?

Childcare costs will persist in a large way throughout primary school, particularly for lone parents.

Even more so if you have children with SEN who can't cope in shared settings so have to have 1:1 care.

As a household - turned down a potential 60k (30 base) pay rise because of these issues (older children). By the time you factored in the huge amount going to the treasury, the commute, the extra expenses; it actually wasn’t worth it. Unless you are in these tax anomalies or can read the figures in black and white. People don’t get it.

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 16:42

I actually think people see 100k and think you clear near enough 8.5k a month

🤣🤣🤣

Maybe that's the issue. They have literally no idea.

Lostinalibrary · 18/03/2023 16:41

BungleandGeorge · 18/03/2023 16:33

@Lostinalibrary Unless you’re working in a profession with significant job shortages someone else will pick up your hours and pay tax on the salary? Childcare payments are for a pretty short period of someone’s working life. And perhaps it’s better for health, equality, money into the economy to have more people earning a senior salary working less hours each

Many of these people are working in skilled shortage professions. That’s the problem. Engineering, tech, medicine, etc. They are literally hammering educated professionals who we need not only for tax but their skill set.

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 16:38

Childcare payments are for a pretty short period of someone’s working life.

Ummm, no. What am I meant to do after school/ before school/ when I need to go on business trips/ how am I meant to cover 13 weeks of school holidays with 5 weeks of annual leave?

Childcare costs will persist in a large way throughout primary school, particularly for lone parents.

Even more so if you have children with SEN who can't cope in shared settings so have to have 1:1 care.

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 16:35

7Worfs · 18/03/2023 16:30

If I relied on UC, NHS, state schools etc. I’d be very worried about the people who contribute the most tax and hold the economy up - are having to restrict work as the “hidden” taxes make them worse off. In turn, it will make everyone worse off as they will not contribute as much tax as they could.

Well put.

Exactly.

Would love to hear the plans from politicians to change it.

Otherwise no, I won't be working more. I'll be continually cutting my hours (and living standards) as fiscal drag reduces our real earnings before the state confiscates it all.

Give me the same tax allowances etc as a household with two adults, get rid of the withdrawal of the personal allowance, and I'll take a promotion at work that I could easily get and work more hours and pay more tax than I do now.

Chancellor's choice, not mine.

BungleandGeorge · 18/03/2023 16:33

@Lostinalibrary Unless you’re working in a profession with significant job shortages someone else will pick up your hours and pay tax on the salary? Childcare payments are for a pretty short period of someone’s working life. And perhaps it’s better for health, equality, money into the economy to have more people earning a senior salary working less hours each

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 16:31

Because people can’t think in this country - that’s why. Yeah tax the rich 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 higher taxes for the rich. The rich with millions and billions - yeah them the top 1%. What they don’t realise is - they very rich don’t pay tax. The people who did well and persevered as a profession? Yeah them too - tax the rich 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

Absolutely. No grasp of economics. Who do they think has been paying for the NHS, education, everything? It's not the wealthy, of whom there are a very small number and who pay a much smaller percentage of tax anyway. It is the professionals on these salaries: engineers, headteachers, accountants, solicitors, builders, small business owners, etc. They have been hammered keeping everyone else afloat for over a decade. There is a limit on what they can, or will, pay.

It’s like clapping seals who cannot think logically. I do believe it is what will cause the ultimate downfall of the welfare state/NHS/education as we know it. It’s already started. People who have done well in their field are in the perverse position that a 35K pay rise can be 100% wiped out and they will be worse off. Therefore, people cut their hours.

It's so depressing how few people can engage with basic maths or economics. Even when explained like in this thread that this is one of the main reasons WHY there is no tax revenue to fund these things properly now, they still don't support fixing the problem. So it will continue not being worthwhile for those paying for it all to work more/ seek promotions, so there will be even less tax revenue. And then they'll all complain and say "why is there no funding?" 🙄🙄

Instead of thinking- “oh, hang on, let’s encourage these massive tax payers and net contributors to pay more. We will make the tax system so punitive they stop working.” I actually think people see 100k and think you clear near enough 8.5k a month. Reality is, with childcare, loss of allowance, no top ups (obviously), full loss of everything. You’ll often have a similar disposable to those who are working and are “topped up.” Difference is, the higher earner is paying for it. Stop them from working things will be cut as tax take falls.

Exactly. I guess because most of the lower earners pay pretty much no tax they have no idea how much of higher earners' salaries go on tax. And then as my example set out, how little is left once essential living costs are paid. We literally have no more money to give to them. None. And I'd be happy to up my work hours and go for promotion to better my children's future. Not going to sacrifice yet more time with them though, to give 100% of my earnings to the Government. Why would I? Nobody would!!

People will only have themselves to blame. Like clapping seals with no critical thinking.

Yep. No wonder the country is such a mess. It won't get better until these issues are addressed because the people we most need to work more to pay for everything have no incentive at all to do so.

I guess people do really get the country they deserve.

Cantstaystuckforever · 18/03/2023 16:31

A lot of people have done incorrect maths on this - eg if they currently pay for 40 hours for their DCs, assumed it will reduce by 3/4.

The reality isn't going to be like that, just like it isn't for most providers with 15 or 30 hours at 3. The govt will pay less than full cost and probably not school holidays, so people will have to make up the shortfall in govt payments by mandating longer days, charging extra for food etc

7Worfs · 18/03/2023 16:30

If I relied on UC, NHS, state schools etc. I’d be very worried about the people who contribute the most tax and hold the economy up - are having to restrict work as the “hidden” taxes make them worse off. In turn, it will make everyone worse off as they will not contribute as much tax as they could.

Well put.

latetothefisting · 18/03/2023 16:24

Not exactly the same but due to the tax threshold freeze by 2028 I will be into the higher rate so will be dropping my hours to stay under.

Hardbackwriter · 18/03/2023 16:23

Circe7 · 18/03/2023 16:12

Anyone working part time when they could work full time is paying less tax than they are capable of. Same for anyone who has taken a school hours job as a ta / admin assistant etc when they previously had a higher paying career. Loads of people in mumsnet are in this category and I’ve never seen it suggested that there’s a moral imperative for them to maximise their earnings.

I would make c. 95k full time but there is very little financial benefit to working five days rather than four after childcare costs and a horrendous impact on quality of life to doing so bearing in mind that full time is easily 60 hours per week. Am I doing something wrong by choosing to work 4 days? In my case there’s very little affect on career progression in working 4 days and if I want to work 5 days in future I can.

I wouldn’t make my life more stressful and lose out on seeing my children by working an extra day in order to be financially worse off. I don’t actually believe anyone would do this just for the good of society.

This is what I'm also amazed about in this thread - I agree that I never see this being applied elsewhere. We earn much less than OP and her partner but we also would earn more if we worked full-time. Since we both work 0.8 we still work more hours combined that most families I know with children as small as ours. I know loads of women with preschool children who don't work at all and no one seems to care about their tax dodging...

DH used to be a management consultant but is now a secondary school teacher - are people saying that's an actively immoral choice because he now pays so much less tax?!

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 16:21

Circe7 · 18/03/2023 16:15

@ScruffyGiraffes
I’m in this position as a single parent. I make a reasonable salary on paper but after childcare and mortgage have about £1k left. Luckily have small savings to last me until childcare expenses go down but would be really struggling if I didn’t.

I have no savings. As the higher earner I had to use them to pay the divorce costs and pay ex-H off so I could still provide a good home for my children. We are totally screwed by this system, penalised at every level of the tax system and left with far less money than people who never bothered to do the extreme working hours I did to get to this salary level. For years I paid happily to fund everyone else and now we are totally stitched up and have to listen to people bleating that I should work more for free to pay for more for them and have even less time with my children? Delusional.

I am sorry you are in this situation, too. Tax should be levied on a household basis as it is in most comparable economies. It is absolutely designed to disadvantage women and children to set it up this way. But nobody cares, because single parents not only deserve no respect but should be milked to fund everyone else!

Lostinalibrary · 18/03/2023 16:19

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 16:10

And this, which nobody bothered to respond to, cannot be repeated enough. The judgement from people based on a headline salary figure who clearly have not the faintest comprehension of housing or childcare costs in other parts of the country, or that a family with two low earners and claiming UC will get a similar amount of take home pay in total to a lone parent earning £100k once support for housing costs and childcare etc for the low earner is factored in, and that they are not taxed on their UC, and that the lone parent is taxed more than them on their actual earnings even though they are doing everything! It's an unsustainable system, hence why it is falling apart. We've been bled dry already, my household has nothing left to give and I certainly won't be spending even less time with my children to pay 100% of my additional earnings to the state to give to others who - in many cases - have a lot more disposable income than I do.

And what of the single parents earning £100k, with small children in childcare? Taxed as much as a couple who can have one parent at home! Half the tax free allowance, higher rate tax imposed at half the household income, child benefit withdrawn at half the income, as are funded nursery hours and "tax free childcare" and the personal allowance.

Usually to earn that much as a lone parent to try to provide for their children with no state help they will have to be living in the SE so at least half of that net pay taken up with mortgage/ rent, and another £2k on childcare at least. End up even earning £100k having only £1000 or so left to pay council tax, food, commuting, utilities, and no help with nursery funding although they obviously need more childcare than a couple who have 47 hours per day to split earning and time with children between them. Yeah, living it up, big time. Rich. 🤣🤣🤣 And faced with over 100% tax rate if you try to work more or seek a promotion to get more net pay to cover the inflation. You have NO CLUE.

Because people can’t think in this country - that’s why. Yeah tax the rich 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 higher taxes for the rich. The rich with millions and billions - yeah them the top 1%. What they don’t realise is - they very rich don’t pay tax. The people who did well and persevered as a profession? Yeah them too - tax the rich 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

It’s like clapping seals who cannot think logically. I do believe it is what will cause the ultimate downfall of the welfare state/NHS/education as we know it. It’s already started. People who have done well in their field are in the perverse position that a 35K pay rise can be 100% wiped out and they will be worse off. Therefore, people cut their hours.

Instead of thinking- “oh, hang on, let’s encourage these massive tax payers and net contributors to pay more. We will make the tax system so punitive they stop working.” I actually think people see 100k and think you clear near enough 8.5k a month. Reality is, with childcare, loss of allowance, no top ups (obviously), full loss of everything. You’ll often have a similar disposable to those who are working and are “topped up.” Difference is, the higher earner is paying for it. Stop them from working things will be cut as tax take falls.

People will only have themselves to blame. Like clapping seals with no critical thinking.