Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

DH and I going part time to deliberately reduce wages

890 replies

Bucketheadbucketbum · 18/03/2023 13:35

Just working out the free childcare hours and actually DH and I will be muxh better off if we both dropped to 3- 4 day week to deliberately reduce our incomes. Would obviously be nice way to live too! Anyone else doing same? Seems mental but we've looked at it 100 times over and it's true!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
WeightoftheWorld · 18/03/2023 18:54

MarshaBradyo · 18/03/2023 17:33

Chatting to someone re this the other day and both work slightly reduced days. The dc are a bit older but where it really helps is all the non school days that keep cropping up.

AL ran out but can swap around days to cover. Will

Let's see where we are in September 2025, almost certainly under a Labour government then anyway.

Not sure Labour will help much, they can say a line on taxation but anyone with a clue can see tax changes behaviour and hammering people has adverse impacts on public funds.

Oh, my comment about the next government being a Labour one wasn't said with any hope that things will improve under them, apologies if it came across that way. More just a comment that the childcare promises that aren't due to come in to force until well after this government have gone is just waffle really, God knows what the next government will decide to do.

StatisticallyChallenged · 18/03/2023 18:52

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 18/03/2023 18:16

I read pro rata as meaning removed according to income, like with CB between 50% and 60%, but I could have got that wrong. Agree it wouldn't make workable to do it based on hours.

You could definitely do this, but given that the 100k threshold is already very steeply taxed (see my prev posts) it would need to be a very gradual tapering to avoid disincentive issues. I'd actually be inclined to say that if you were going to do that it probably shouldn't be in parallel with the loss of personal allowance, it's just too much of a deduction all at once.

AngryBirdsNoMore · 18/03/2023 18:50

I think there might be a spectrum when people are saying ‘high earner’ here…

OP how much do you and your DH earn?

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 18:49

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 17:42

I'm so sorry for single earners, they're taxed really badly and unfairly. Can you put some into your pensions?

Yeah I could work more to put more into my pension.

But my children are young, and are already dealing with their father vanishing from their lives. They only have me.

On £100k salary as I said by the time tax and mortgage and childcare is paid there is less than £1000 per month to pay Council tax, utilities, food, commuting, clothes, clubs etc.

If I work more now or go for promotion we'll get no more net pay. So no reason for me to do it. My priority is to be here to support them emotionally now, because the tax system means I can't do any more for them financially. I don't need a higher pension contribution, I need more net pay so I can cover the mortgage increase and increased childcare and utility and food bill. But no matter what I do I can't achieve that, because the Government will take all the extra money I earn. So we'll just have to manage on even less and I'll cut my hours. And pay less in tax.

In fact if I earn just a little bit more - as I'm unlikely to get a £50k payrise increasing my pay by 50% in one go - for a time we'd be even worse off. Because the immediately tax rate would be well over 100%. As the graph indicates, if I earn a few more pounds, my take home pay could drop by tens of thousands of pounds. And then I would not be able to house and feed my children.

Great system.

Littlefish · 18/03/2023 18:49

Before you even consider doing this, please look at the reality of using funded hours.

It is up to each setting how many funded places they offer, how the funded hours are offered, and how much they charge for 'extras', including extra hours.

It's absolutely not as simple as just getting 15/30 hours 'free'.

Added to which, unless there is a huge hike in the amount paid to nurseries and childminders, there simply aren't going to be enough settings and places available for all those needing them.

Chonk · 18/03/2023 18:40

Ovidnaso · 18/03/2023 18:17

That's not true. The reason many people campaigned for, set up and maintained affordable housing was with a vision of a better and fairer society. Many people believe it immoral to allow private ownership of a basic human right just as they believe it immoral to have a separate private health or education.

Obviously it's also cheaper because the (moral) idea is to allow people live affordably in communities, which is why the profits went back to councils to maintain and build properties before the government redirected it to the treasury, meaning council tenants effectively pay extra taxes.

@Ovidnaso That's as may be, but that's not why people who can afford to leave council housing decide to stay. Staying in council housing isn't an altruistic decision for the good of society. It's a selfish decision based on council housing being cheaper (and more reliable) than the private rental sector.

Lostinalibrary · 18/03/2023 18:40

I don’t know if it’s economic illiteracy, poor comprehension, unable to read data, ignorance or all of the above. A single parent on 100k would need to earn 50k before seeing any rise in net income. Facts are out there. Why would you bother earning more? Makes no sense. Even as a couple, we were in the situation where a 60k rise in income would result in 12k a year more. That’s 48k to the tax man. Why bother? Especially when the 12k would evaporate in costs related to the new job.

In a way, when it all collapses and there is no safety net anymore and it all goes I’m looking forward to the told you so moment. You cannot tax people like that and expect a productive country. I’ve not seen one higher earner ever say they don’t want to pay more than their fair share? Working for free? Why would you…

The people supporting the welfare system are not the mega rich who are hoarding wealth. They are professionals who have worked hard and are hit with a ceiling on earnings. Stopping them paying anymore in tax. Financial experts have literally told the chancellor this is damaging the economy. What do they know though in comparison to mumsnet posters. It would be funny if it wasn’t such a disaster unfolding for everyone.

onlythesparrow · 18/03/2023 18:38

Just be aware that the hours are not 'free'. They're funded- pretty poorly. Most nurseries charge something extra just to be able to stay afloat. Meals, consumables etc. Or they may only allow funded hours or be used in certain sessions so it'll always cost the parents something. Best not to make any decisions based on the hours being 'free'- you'll be hard pushed to find anywhere that it really is actually free to you.

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 18:28

Bahhhhhumbug · 18/03/2023 18:08

The 100k threshold should be pro rata which would stop people working the system and deliberately cutting their hours to claim the childcare.

Great idea. Make it more punitive then the people paying for the services and benefits for everyone else will cut their hours even more.

The economic illiteracy on this thread is astonishing. I knew it was bad but my God, I thought Mumsnet generally had reasonably intelligent people on it compared to an average cross section of society, in which case these responses are terrifying.

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 18:26

HalfWomanHalfChocolate · 18/03/2023 18:02

Interesting perspectives here. Quite a few people seem to confuse the childcare free hours with welfare. It’s not the same thing at all.

The free childcare is not a welfare payment that is aimed at helping the poorest. There are lots of benefits that are (and for the avoidance of doubt, I wholly support the idea of a decent welfare system) but this particular benefit doesn’t exist for that reason. It is an economic incentive to get people to work rather than stay at home with children, for the benefit of the economy. Particularly given that the Uk has some of the highest childcare costs in the world, which impacts on the skilled workforce and then on the wider economy.

Because of this it is meant to incentivise everyone and not just the poorest, because that’s what the economy needs. However, I guess the govt felt it would be indefensible to give it to the very ‘richest’, so they set a £100k individual ceiling for
eligibility. The problem is that is a very blunt tool because, as lots of people have said here, £100k does not correlate to the kind of wealth that makes childcare costs immaterial, it coincides with the loss of the personal tax allowance which makes earning above £100k, with childcare costs, actually loss-making for some people and it also actually coincides with the salary ranges of quite a large skilled workforce (professionals such as hospital consultants etc). Not everyone can offset with pension contributions - the NHS pension scheme, for example, is defined benefit and defined contribution, just in or out. So actually, it will have some undesired effects (to the detriment of the wider economy) unless the cliff edge is softened.

It’s not misdirected welfare, but it is poorly thought out taxation and policy for a section of the population which is a net contributor, and which the economy particularly needs to be incentivised to work.

Exactly. There are public goods which we all fund and all should have access to: education, health, pensions. Early years care and education is part of that and is treated as such in pretty much every other developed economy. It isn't "welfare". Welfare is cash transfers to poorer households, like the UC payments which mean many pay -50% tax rates. Which most higher earners are happy to fund. But not to work more to fund if 100% of our additional earner income is taken to fund this plus public goods that apparently the people paying for for everyone should then be excluded from accessing also. No sane person would do that. So they aren't. So there's not enough money to pay for them because the net contributors are so heavily penalised they've stopped bothering to pay more in. Hardly surprising to anybody with half a brain.

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 18:21

😆 I’d suggest they have a word with their employer because working over 14 hours a day 7 days a week is illegal.

Pathetic. Clearly you know very few people who work in law, medicine, finance. What do you think their employer will say about it?!

WeAllLikeVindaloo · 18/03/2023 18:19

You will be lucky if you have a nursery to send your child/ren to. This new scheme is going to send a lot more under.

You do realise nurseries get around 50% less per hour per child from the governments “free” hours. And they are supposed pay for overheads, qualified staff, food and all the other expenses? There is nowhere for this money to come from. Private nurseries are becoming dictated by the government and are already in a crisis.
if they want to help all parties they would be offering a subsidy or top up scheme where nursery’s get a fair fee. Then guess what, your fees will be cheaper because we’re not trying to make up the funds from everywhere else.

Btw I’m qualified nursery nurse, with two children. So I see both sides. But its okay, you do you with you with your 100k+ salary.

Ovidnaso · 18/03/2023 18:17

Chonk · 18/03/2023 18:00

People choose to live in council housing because it's an ethical way to live, contributing to society and local communities.

@Ovidnaso What a load of shit. People stay in council housing because it's cheaper than private rentals. They don't live in council housing to benefit anyone but themselves.

That's not true. The reason many people campaigned for, set up and maintained affordable housing was with a vision of a better and fairer society. Many people believe it immoral to allow private ownership of a basic human right just as they believe it immoral to have a separate private health or education.

Obviously it's also cheaper because the (moral) idea is to allow people live affordably in communities, which is why the profits went back to councils to maintain and build properties before the government redirected it to the treasury, meaning council tenants effectively pay extra taxes.

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 18:16

The later graphs are about the effect of these idiotic tax policies on productivity and living standards over time.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 18/03/2023 18:16

I read pro rata as meaning removed according to income, like with CB between 50% and 60%, but I could have got that wrong. Agree it wouldn't make workable to do it based on hours.

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 18:16

None of those graphs relate to people specifically earning over 100k. Perhaps put some actual evidence from a variety of sources rataher than name calling?

I posted the graph showing that tax effect earlier in the thread. Here it is again.

DH and I going part time to deliberately reduce wages
ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 18:15

Few people hoarding wealth is not overall a good thing

The people earning the types of salaries we're talking about are not "hoarding wealth". 🤣 They have no wealth!! It is ALL taken up by tax and rent/ mortgage plus childcare. We have no savings AT ALL. No safety net. I can barely afford food and heat and light after commuting costs.

I think this is part of the problem. People having no clue about the amount the is taken in tax and the living costs in different parts of the country. Yes salaries are higher, for a reason! Because it costs so much to live here! There is nothing left, we're already bled dry. We have a lot less money to live on than families on lower wages, many of whom are going on holidays etc. All of those years working 100 hour weeks for this, it is a kick in the teeth if epic proportions. An no, I will mot be working more hours and leaving my children for even more hours to pay over 100% tax to "be kind" to everyone else. 🤣 While we are left struggling for money for food.

StatisticallyChallenged · 18/03/2023 18:14

Pro rata would be problematic as many people on higher salaries don't have straightforward working hours. Someone working 4 days a week in a high earning role may well still be working 40 hours a week.

And that high earner working 40 hours over 4 days will be contributing a lot more than someone working 35 hours a week in a minimum wage 9-5 role.

BungleandGeorge · 18/03/2023 18:14

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 18:01

The evidence is copious. Shame we have a population who are too stupid to understand the economics and push for the policies to fix it, when it would benefit everyone.

None of those graphs relate to people specifically earning over 100k. Perhaps put some actual evidence from a variety of sources rataher than name calling?

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 18/03/2023 18:12

Bahhhhhumbug · 18/03/2023 18:08

The 100k threshold should be pro rata which would stop people working the system and deliberately cutting their hours to claim the childcare.

It is weird that it's not. Even with pro rata you can still have bottlenecks, like the 50-60k threshold for those with DC, so I'm not saying it's a panacea or anything. But cliff edge is just asking for people not to bother.

Very interesting to hear about the Scottish examples @StatisticallyChallenged

Bahhhhhumbug · 18/03/2023 18:08

The 100k threshold should be pro rata which would stop people working the system and deliberately cutting their hours to claim the childcare.

StatisticallyChallenged · 18/03/2023 18:06

As others have said there are some really nasty bottlenecks in the tax system which inevitably result in people taking them in to consideration when they plan their family life. I'm in Scotland, so we don't have the 100k childcare threshold but we have different tax bands which create similar disincentives.

For example, here higher rate tax is going up to 42% starting at just £43,663. In rUK, that threshold is at £50271, which aligns with the point where NI drops from 12% to 2%. In Scotland they don't align, so income between £43663 and £50271 is effectively being taxed at 54%, whereas income between £50271 and £99.9k is only taked at 44% altogether. Plus factor in student loans which many people earning those salaries will have...

Then you hit 100k. Now you're losing the personal allowance at £1 for every £2 over it. So between £100k and £125k you have an effective tax rate of 65% including NI. But then once you go above that, you go to 47%... and at 100k you also lose tax free childcare (which effectively saves 2k net per child per year, so if you have 2 children that's 4k after tax.)

So let's say you're earning 99.9k and have 2 kids using childcare in Scotland. You're offered a 20k pay rise. I'll assume a not extravagent 6% pension contribution.

Of that 20k:

  • £12,600 goes in tax (42% plus loss of personal allowance)
  • £400 in NI
  • £1200 in pension contributions
  • Potentially still student loans at 9% = £1800
  • extra childcare due to loss of TFC = £4000
So you get precisely zero extra in your pocket, or £1800 if you have paid off student loans.

Or you could work say 4 days in the new role (if possible) and have a virtually identical income, use less paid childcare and end up better off financially as a result.

Lostinalibrary · 18/03/2023 18:06

BungleandGeorge · 18/03/2023 17:59

I don’t quite follow as you haven’t put why your commuting costs would have increased by £50 per day due to a pay rise? And commuting costs have nothing to do with taxation, you got a pay increase of 1k and would need to
go into a bit more detail regarding pay before and after the pay rise to make any sense of this (which obviously isn’t expected on a public forum!). The difference between earning 90k and 120k is about 1.1k per month. It’s hardly a small amount? If it involves working extra hours or increasing your commute by such a large amount it costs £50 extra a day fair enough, you’re free to decide it’s not worth it. However you are earning significantly more despite the extra taxation.

I am just saying. We turned down a potential increase as a household because 60k converted to about 12k per year after deductions. So we decided as a family not to bother. Especially as that extra would’ve gone on commuting costs. DH is a high earner anyway. Which means a 60k payrise would’ve been about 12k. You’d have to be nuts to take that extra responsibility to have the tax man take most of it.

BungleandGeorge · 18/03/2023 18:06

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 17:46

If you think it's "great" that parent who has done exactly what we're all instructed to do: gone to uni, done gruelling professional qualifications and then worked 90-100 hours per week for over a decade (paying a ton of tax to support everyone else) is then left with less disposable income than many people on UC and barely able to cover food and utility bills despite having worked like that to achieve a £100k salary, then there's something seriously wrong with your view of society. And no wonder then that vanishingly few people bother to put in that kind of effort in the first place, when in the end you end up broke AND vilified for having bothered in the first place.

😆 I’d suggest they have a word with their employer because working over 14 hours a day 7 days a week is illegal.

www.lse.ac.uk/News/Latest-news-from-LSE/2020/L-December/Tax-cuts-for-the-rich

Soapnutty · 18/03/2023 18:05

The answer everyone has is to put taxes up - on who?

wealth tax on assets of super rich, not income.