Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

DH and I going part time to deliberately reduce wages

890 replies

Bucketheadbucketbum · 18/03/2023 13:35

Just working out the free childcare hours and actually DH and I will be muxh better off if we both dropped to 3- 4 day week to deliberately reduce our incomes. Would obviously be nice way to live too! Anyone else doing same? Seems mental but we've looked at it 100 times over and it's true!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
aroomwithaperfectview · 18/03/2023 19:51

LizzieSiddal · 18/03/2023 13:41

Sounds like you don’t care that other tax payers will be working to pay for your child when you could actually afford to pay for it yourself.

Each to their own I suppose.

As a single mum for 10 years and working full time with quite a long commute too, this would have never crossed my mind.

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 19:48

mishmased · 18/03/2023 19:36

@ScruffyGiraffes absolutely no to working more hours, no way. Your kids need to see their parent. I'm sorry the system is so bent on penalising regular income earners as opposed to those with wealth.

Thank you. The screwing of single parents trying to do two jobs - providing financially and childcare - in 24 hours not 48 by hammering them with half the tax free allowance, imposing higher rate tax at half the household income, withdrawing nursery funding and child benefit and personal allowance at half the household income, is why households like mine with a high salary on paper are living on the poverty line. Not even joking. Worrying about how to pay food and electricity with £100k salary! Because we are penalised and taxed twice as much. But nobody seems to care or want to change it.

Chonk · 18/03/2023 19:47

@mishmased No, just deluded 😂

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 19:45

Yes this is our situation

Its really a no brainer to reduce hours and associated financial and emotional/ family costs of working all hours.

Complete no brainer. And until the tax code is fixed there will be hundreds of thousands of people in the same situation - the very people we really need to be working more if we want productivity and tax revenues to rise - will continue doing the same.

It's just harder for me because there's only one of me, so by the time I've paid living expenses and childcare there is barely enough left for us to survive. And no way for us to improve it either, because the state would take more than 100%, much more. We'd be way worse off.

In your situation with two of you, I'd absolutely cut down the hours, enjoy your children and not bother at all about it all.

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 19:39

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 19:35

Exactly. If you work 25% more ton earn less than 5% more net, why do it? Unless you need the 5% to keep your head above water. Which thankfully we don't. We get 25% more time each with our family and a lot less stress

Yes. A completely rational decision, and obviously the best one.

People in receipt of direct tax transfers of money from higher earners through universal credit make these kinds of decisions all the time. Say how they are "entitled" to the money they didn't even earn, and that most of us happily provide for them. Yet are apparently aghast that you'd decide to work a little less to keep more of the money you DID earn and spend more time with your own children, rather than work even more and see your kids less to give them even more money? Some serious cognitive dissonance from some posters not to be able to grasp why you'd make this entirely rational choice and utilise the public goods that YOU have paid for, for yourselves AND subsidised for everyone else. And even with the cut in hours will continue to be subsidising for them!

It's a no brainer and you're making the right choice, OP. The only rational choice really. It's just bonkers that the system is set up so that this is your only rational choice. That's why the economy is tanking.

For me, I wouldn't even get the 5% net increase for each hour worked. In fact, if I worked just a few more hours I'd receive a 15% DECREASE in net income. So no, until the tax system is fixed, I won't be doing any more work.

Sorry, typo. 35% decrease in net income! I can't imagine why anybody thinks I'd spend less time with my children to do that.

Ilikepinacoladass · 18/03/2023 19:39

bigbabycooker · 18/03/2023 19:31

@Ilikepinacoladass

I assume that the poster meant that basically the childcare cost as a household if she worked made them worse off, which is how lots of people do assess it. I mean, if you are partnered with a high earner and do more than your fair share at home so that they can earn the dough that pays your mortgage, frankly it's hard working for no real financial household benefit. Obviously, you can still accrue pension and for some careers by working it is essential because stepping off really costs you, but that last argument isn't so true of nursing because it is unlikely you won't be able to go back at a good grade (or you can do an occasional shift to keep hand in as OP does). Totally makes sense not to work just to pay your childcare bill with young kids.

I think that's true if you actually don't want to work. If you enjoy your job / wouldn't like being a SAHP then it's not really a valid reason, if you have a high earning partner. Again you're choice if you do more than fair share at home, could the Mr High Earner not hire a cleaner?

stinkfaceison · 18/03/2023 19:37

stinkfaceison · 18/03/2023 19:37

You do whatever it takes for your family and work life balance .?

Sorry about the ? Typo

AngryBirdsNoMore · 18/03/2023 19:37

How much do you both earn OP?

stinkfaceison · 18/03/2023 19:37

You do whatever it takes for your family and work life balance .?

mishmased · 18/03/2023 19:36

@ScruffyGiraffes absolutely no to working more hours, no way. Your kids need to see their parent. I'm sorry the system is so bent on penalising regular income earners as opposed to those with wealth.

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 19:35

Exactly. If you work 25% more ton earn less than 5% more net, why do it? Unless you need the 5% to keep your head above water. Which thankfully we don't. We get 25% more time each with our family and a lot less stress

Yes. A completely rational decision, and obviously the best one.

People in receipt of direct tax transfers of money from higher earners through universal credit make these kinds of decisions all the time. Say how they are "entitled" to the money they didn't even earn, and that most of us happily provide for them. Yet are apparently aghast that you'd decide to work a little less to keep more of the money you DID earn and spend more time with your own children, rather than work even more and see your kids less to give them even more money? Some serious cognitive dissonance from some posters not to be able to grasp why you'd make this entirely rational choice and utilise the public goods that YOU have paid for, for yourselves AND subsidised for everyone else. And even with the cut in hours will continue to be subsidising for them!

It's a no brainer and you're making the right choice, OP. The only rational choice really. It's just bonkers that the system is set up so that this is your only rational choice. That's why the economy is tanking.

For me, I wouldn't even get the 5% net increase for each hour worked. In fact, if I worked just a few more hours I'd receive a 15% DECREASE in net income. So no, until the tax system is fixed, I won't be doing any more work.

bigbabycooker · 18/03/2023 19:31

@Ilikepinacoladass

I assume that the poster meant that basically the childcare cost as a household if she worked made them worse off, which is how lots of people do assess it. I mean, if you are partnered with a high earner and do more than your fair share at home so that they can earn the dough that pays your mortgage, frankly it's hard working for no real financial household benefit. Obviously, you can still accrue pension and for some careers by working it is essential because stepping off really costs you, but that last argument isn't so true of nursing because it is unlikely you won't be able to go back at a good grade (or you can do an occasional shift to keep hand in as OP does). Totally makes sense not to work just to pay your childcare bill with young kids.

Ilikepinacoladass · 18/03/2023 19:29

I think do what you want to do, if you can reduce hours and still get by, and would like to work less / spend more time with the children then go for it!

I doubt in the long run it'll be financially beneficial though. Part time often means you can't go for certain promotions etc, as well as missitout on pension contributions.

Bucketheadbucketbum · 18/03/2023 19:29

Also deliberately spending less so less going round for other businesses and services etc

OP posts:
Bucketheadbucketbum · 18/03/2023 19:28

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 17:42

I'm so sorry for single earners, they're taxed really badly and unfairly. Can you put some into your pensions?

Yeah I could work more to put more into my pension.

But my children are young, and are already dealing with their father vanishing from their lives. They only have me.

On £100k salary as I said by the time tax and mortgage and childcare is paid there is less than £1000 per month to pay Council tax, utilities, food, commuting, clothes, clubs etc.

If I work more now or go for promotion we'll get no more net pay. So no reason for me to do it. My priority is to be here to support them emotionally now, because the tax system means I can't do any more for them financially. I don't need a higher pension contribution, I need more net pay so I can cover the mortgage increase and increased childcare and utility and food bill. But no matter what I do I can't achieve that, because the Government will take all the extra money I earn. So we'll just have to manage on even less and I'll cut my hours. And pay less in tax.

Yes this is our situation

Its really a no brainer to reduce hours and associated financial and emotional/ family costs of working all hours.

OP posts:
Ilikepinacoladass · 18/03/2023 19:25

IsGoodIsDon · 18/03/2023 13:49

I quit my job because of childcare. OH is a high earner and we’re couldn’t get the free 30hours, I’m a nurse and my wages were not high enough to cover childcare with any significant value so to ease stress at home I just quit. I now work agency at the same place less hours more money and can chooses when I work around my OHs hours. Not want the government wants either but I’m not working just to pay childcare and it’s not really much cheaper now the kids are at school as we have 3 DDs and wraparound care is still expensive.

If your OH is a high earner why on earth would all your salary be used up on childcare? Wouldn't at least half, or more come out of his salary? But if you were able to quit and that was your preference/ better for the family then why not I guess.

mishmased · 18/03/2023 19:17

Chonk · 18/03/2023 18:00

People choose to live in council housing because it's an ethical way to live, contributing to society and local communities.

@Ovidnaso What a load of shit. People stay in council housing because it's cheaper than private rentals. They don't live in council housing to benefit anyone but themselves.

@Chonk I thought the poster was being sarcastic 😂

Bucketheadbucketbum · 18/03/2023 19:15

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 15:43

This is why universal benefits work. No bottlenecks, and also they continue to get buy in from the people funding them for everyone else. Childcare, healthcare, pensions, education etc etc all survive on the principal of public buy-in. And that means that they need to be available to the people who pay for them as well as those who are being funded by others to have them. They are a public good, for us all. Of course largely paid for by higher earners but if everyone can access them that's fine. If they are paid for by one group and that group is excluded from accessing them, then they start to be resented, become a target and are gradually watered down or disappear. This is why means-testing state pension would be the death of it: the very people paying in far more than they get out would instead get nothing back? Before long the threshold for receiving it and the amount provided would lower so far it would be meaningless anyway. It's amazing how so many people are so consumed by envy that they will bite the hand that feeds them and refuse to support policies that will result in a healthy and functioning economy where everyone is provided for. If you just take and take from one group until over 100% of any payrises they get are taken off them, then obviously their support for funding these things will be lost and they will also start acting only in their own best interests.

Exactly. If you work 25% more ton earn less than 5% more net, why do it? Unless you need the 5% to keep your head above water. Which thankfully we don't. We get 25% more time each with our family and a lot less stress

OP posts:
mishmased · 18/03/2023 19:14

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 17:47

In the situation you’re in - you’d have to earn roughly about 50k to make any extra money. It will literally all be taken at source, loss of childcare, personal allowance, hitting 45%. As you know.

Yes. I'd need a 50% salary increase to make it worth working one extra hour. So much incentive! If it wasn't messing up our lives so much it would be laughable.

This is so unfair.

StatisticallyChallenged · 18/03/2023 19:10

Was literally just thinking the same re the withdrawals @ScruffyGiraffes . They don't make sense at all.

It would actually be better to just raise the tax rates for higher rates slightly (to effectively achieve the same amount of taxation overall but in a more gradual way), maybe bring in the additional rate earlier if necessary. That would remove the pinch points where you have really high marginal rates.

with 2 kids, between 50 and 60k you're looking at a nearly 19% effective additional tax just from the loss of CB. Plus 42% in Scotland income tax, 2% NI. 63% again, same as the 120-125k bottleness (and that's even worse once you factor in childcare issues)

It's not bloody surprising that people are disincentivised by that.

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 19:09

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 17:54

Well most educated professionals don’t earn over 100k, most don’t have young children. So yes I can see for individuals it’s a problem but if there is someone else to do the work it’s really not a problem for the taxman!

The studies show there are around 200,000 people affect by the punitive tax rates at £100k. Bear in mind each of these people is paying 15 times the tax of someone on minimum wage already. When you factor in the tax transfers to calculate the real effective tax rates of people on minimum wage, these higher earners are EACH paying hundreds of times the level of taxes of every minimum wage earner. So yes, this is a huge problem for the "tax man", and every person who wants there to be well funded state services, a state pension and benefits.

Sorry that should be 200,000 people at that earnings level with children, so hammered now with over 100% tax. There are many more earning at that level also but with mo children, who are also cutting down their hours because they consider the 75% tax rates to be not worth their extra time, either.

Ovidnaso · 18/03/2023 19:03

Chonk · 18/03/2023 18:40

@Ovidnaso That's as may be, but that's not why people who can afford to leave council housing decide to stay. Staying in council housing isn't an altruistic decision for the good of society. It's a selfish decision based on council housing being cheaper (and more reliable) than the private rental sector.

Not among all the people I know who stayed renting their council homes rather than buy them because they wanted other people to benefit from them after their deaths.

Stop invalidating people's motives and morals. Perhaps you wouldn't behave morally, but others do.

And council housing is meant to be for everyone. People who start earning more over the course of a lifetime aren't to blame if greedy landlords charge too much for private housing.

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 19:02

The personal allowance withdrawal and child benefit withdrawal need scrapping entirely. Both cost the state more to administer than they save AND create these disincentives to work more. It is a no brainer. This costs money and reduces tax revenue. There is no point in it.

Early years childcare/ education is a universal good that pays for itself and should be available to everyone just like pensions and healthcare and education for older children (and adults for that matter). The vast majority of higher tax payers are fine with paying this for everyone else, but it must be available to all, including them.

Penalising single adult households charging them double the tax on the same income is not acceptable, and has only been tolerated because over 90% of single parents are women. What is hugely disappointing is that other women do not campaign for this to change and stand side by side with those affected by it. Depressing.

Ultimately if you want well-funded welfare and services you need the people who pay the vast majority of that cost to be incentivised to work. If they face effective tax rates of 65% at £50k (as soon as they become net contributors) and 100% at £100k they won't. So there won't be the money to pay for it all, as we are now seeing.

Anybody who wants a functioning welfare state and services should want this fixed. But as we can see here, they do not. So it won't be.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 18/03/2023 18:59

StatisticallyChallenged · 18/03/2023 18:52

You could definitely do this, but given that the 100k threshold is already very steeply taxed (see my prev posts) it would need to be a very gradual tapering to avoid disincentive issues. I'd actually be inclined to say that if you were going to do that it probably shouldn't be in parallel with the loss of personal allowance, it's just too much of a deduction all at once.

Well the free hours are removed at 100k now so even a non-gradual tapering would offer more incentive than now, but broadly I agree. It's like with the 50-60k in England being both the 40% tax rate and CB withdrawal territory. They do it that way for administrative reasons afaik, but the flipside is the creation of more and steeper bottlenecks. To which people respond.

WeightoftheWorld · 18/03/2023 18:59

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 18:26

Exactly. There are public goods which we all fund and all should have access to: education, health, pensions. Early years care and education is part of that and is treated as such in pretty much every other developed economy. It isn't "welfare". Welfare is cash transfers to poorer households, like the UC payments which mean many pay -50% tax rates. Which most higher earners are happy to fund. But not to work more to fund if 100% of our additional earner income is taken to fund this plus public goods that apparently the people paying for for everyone should then be excluded from accessing also. No sane person would do that. So they aren't. So there's not enough money to pay for them because the net contributors are so heavily penalised they've stopped bothering to pay more in. Hardly surprising to anybody with half a brain.

This 100%. If everyone had access to these imperative public services on an equal basis - health, education, pensions - we wouldn't all be fighting amongst ourselves here tbh. When really we should be looking at those who really don't contribute according to their means, hoarding wealth, moving it out of the country- which is not people like doctors and head teachers.