Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

DH and I going part time to deliberately reduce wages

890 replies

Bucketheadbucketbum · 18/03/2023 13:35

Just working out the free childcare hours and actually DH and I will be muxh better off if we both dropped to 3- 4 day week to deliberately reduce our incomes. Would obviously be nice way to live too! Anyone else doing same? Seems mental but we've looked at it 100 times over and it's true!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 20:59

I'm not speaking for everyone on Mumsnet.

I've explained the factual distortions in the tax system that are disincentivising work for the people who pay most of the UK's tax (not the super rich!) resulting in low UK productivity and tax revenues and therefore no money to improve public services etc for everyone. This is fact. Hunt's own research stated this. The IFS have said it's a "dog's breakfast". The Times and FT and Guardian and others have written articles about it. So yes of course higher earning people cut down their hours because it's not worth them working more. This is factual and is happening across the economy, research shows it clearly and indisputably. This is bad for everyone.

I have also explained how single parents (almost all women) are doubly impacted by this, giving the example of my own situation, because these tax thresholds are doubly punitive for us. Others in the same situation have also said so, on this thread and in the research. We pay huge amounts of tax and can barely afford to live because the UK tax system applies all of these thresholds on an individual not household basis, impoverishing us and our children. So for us, even less incentive to work more and actually, unsurprisingly, many do not bother or give up entirely.

I've seen the calculations. If I'd never bothered at all, with degree and professional qualifications and all the hard work to build a career and buy a house and instead claimed benefits we would have TWICE the disposable income per month that we do now. That is disgusting.

I want to work. I want to contribute. I always have done so. I should however be left with enough to provide my children with a decent life, when I'm paying £34k per year into the pot to help other people. And to be able to take a promotion without us then having LESS money per month than we do now and being unable to pay my mortgage.

If you want a country where there's money to pay for services and benefits then making it impossible for higher earners to better their circumstances by working more - while bettering everyone else's at the same time by paying even more in - then penalising them to the extent that it's not worthwhile for them to work is not a good idea.

Lostinalibrary · 18/03/2023 20:51

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 20:38

I missed this, is it their plan?

Last year they were talking about imposing even higher taxes at £80k. That will be the end for us, I just won't be able to do it anymore. It will be impossible.

It will bankrupt the country. As a couple we laughed a 60k increase in salary out the door as it all goes to Hunt. What is the point? As a single parent I don’t know how you cope. People are so blinded by “six figure salary” they have no comprehension how much you are paying in tax to fund them. Literally. Taxed at 100% oh no that’s not enough; taxed at +100% pay more. As you said, this country will be the country it deserves.

AviMav · 18/03/2023 20:46

@ScruffyGiraffes I'm not sure you can assume and speak for everyone on MN. The rents in the North have crept up massively. £1000 per month and that's for a shitty area.

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 20:38

I missed this, is it their plan?

Last year they were talking about imposing even higher taxes at £80k. That will be the end for us, I just won't be able to do it anymore. It will be impossible.

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 20:36

Have you got a huge mortgage though? This is said often on here but it's usually thr more you earn the more you are spending.

Because ultimately people manage on a lot less. How do you think they manage?

People manage on far less because they live in far less expensive places. This is what so many people on this thread do not seem to be able to comprehend: to earn high salaries most people have to live in expensive parts of the country. Particularly if your commute can't be too long because you have to get back for childcare pickups. So then, from net pay (assuming you make zero pension contribution) of £5.5k from £100k salary, you can easily have to pay £2.5k as rent/ mortgage. Then £2k for childcare. That leaves £1000 per month for Council tax, utilities, food, clothes, activites, birthdays, Christmas, etc. Not exactly living the high life, is it?

Yes I could move to a cheaper area. And then I wouldn't earn this salary. So the point is moot. Especially given my job doesn't exist elsewhere in the UK, anyway. If I am paying £34k tax per year why shouldn't my children also have a decent standard of living? And why should I have to turn down promotions because they would make us WORSE off? How does this benefit anybody, when me taking the promotion and payrise would mean more tax revenue to help everyone else, even if they let me keep at least some of it?

MarshaBradyo · 18/03/2023 20:34

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 20:30

If they increase the tax rates on us any further, like Labour's plan to start higher rate tax at £80k, my children will lose their home. At that point they'll be better off with me dead and the life insurance payout to support them for the rest of their childhood, because I literally won't be able to provide for them anymore.

I missed this, is it their plan?

I’m sorry you must feel very stressed. I know no one can reassure you but just support

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 20:30

If they increase the tax rates on us any further, like Labour's plan to start higher rate tax at £80k, my children will lose their home. At that point they'll be better off with me dead and the life insurance payout to support them for the rest of their childhood, because I literally won't be able to provide for them anymore.

AviMav · 18/03/2023 20:28

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 20:25

I pay £34k per year in tax! Yet struggle to feed the kids properly, can't afford a camping holiday or heat the house enough, people have no idea. They think we're rich? I'd laugh if it wasn't so ridiculous. We've been bled dry and have nothing left to give, we can barley cover our own essential living costs.

Have you got a huge mortgage though? This is said often on here but it's usually thr more you earn the more you are spending.

Because ultimately people manage on a lot less. How do you think they manage?

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 20:25

I pay £34k per year in tax! Yet struggle to feed the kids properly, can't afford a camping holiday or heat the house enough, people have no idea. They think we're rich? I'd laugh if it wasn't so ridiculous. We've been bled dry and have nothing left to give, we can barley cover our own essential living costs.

Badbudgeter · 18/03/2023 20:25

Whiteroomjoy · 18/03/2023 13:49

Is that true? I’m long past childcare needs but I’d have thought it was based on gross salary not net?

if it is net then, yep, absolutely 5hey should do this along with loads of other people- quite a loophole for Gov to have made

It is true. It’s the same for UC you can max out pension contributions and get UC which seems crazy. It costs the government a fortune to keep the elderly on low incomes though. So perhaps it’d better if people have some help now and can provide for themselves in old days age.

bigbabycooker · 18/03/2023 20:18

@Ilikepinacoladass

I'm not in this situation (I work 3 days, to earn £100k, rather than £150k, which would barely pay be any more at all net of childcare, so I am basically the OP and have chosen more leisure with my kids), so I can't speak for that poster, but...

I think you are being extremely disingenuous to claim that all the things that a SAHM might do if her partner just goes to work and doesn't have much capacity to help out in the week are replaced by a cleaner. If you have to do all the drop offs, all the picks ups, make and attend all the appointments, book all clubs, buy all shopping and clothes (or else give up your weekend family time so that you can both share it) and you are still basically paying to work net of childcare, I can totally see how you might feel that you have a much higher quality of life with your kids than working, whether or not you like your job. In this country, nursing shifts are also very family unfriendly - in France, you can do an 8 hour shift, allowing you to not work nights and see your kids at one or both ends of the day, whereas in the U.K., most NHS shifts are 12 hours, so you can't. It's a very rational decision to decide that this is a bit crappy and one that you can't really get too sniffy about (which is what your post sounded like) if you can leave at 5pm in an office job.

Blablablanamechangagain · 18/03/2023 20:13

Fragrantandfoolish · 18/03/2023 13:41

Surprised at the responses. I wonder if it’s because it’s child care. If someone posted me and my husband are going to go part time so we can claim universal credit id suspect the responses would be different

This. 100%

Yes childcare is expensive
So are mortgages
So are utilities, food, fuel etc etc.

If you CAN afford it, just be bloody thankful.

People (women) have fought TIRELESSLY for what the government have announced, so they can go to work and contribute to society and support their families.

Not so people who have never been in the position where they don't need help, shirk off work to claim what is essentially, a benefit.

Bucketheadbucketbum · 18/03/2023 20:12

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 20:09

There's seems to be some inexplicable "inability" to understand the difference between choosing not to work more only to have most of the money that you have earned confiscated (or even being charged to work more in cases like mine!) and people receiving money as welfare from other people who have earned it and paid it for them.

Exactly

OP posts:
ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 20:12

100% this. And the answer is simple- to work less. Thebonly surprising thing is that the government don't seem to care that this is the outcome

It is. And there's no other option because even if I work more, we'll have less take home pay!

But with 10% inflation and rising mortgage rates and childcare costs and food costs etc, it means that we are struggling more and more to even cover the basic living costs despite me on paper earning what most people consider a high salary. I am now having to get rid of the ancient car. We can't afford to have one anymore. On £100k salary. That is how punitive it is on single parents.

Bucketheadbucketbum · 18/03/2023 20:11

Dibblydoodahdah · 18/03/2023 20:04

@aroomwithaperfectview it’s not exactly the same is it. These are people who are actually paying tax!

Exactly. We pay a tonne of tax. We've now got to the point where earning what we do is taxed so much and we miss out on other items eg tax free childcare that we are financially worse off than if we earnt less. To come out the other side of this conundrum we'd both need to ean 50% more again than we do, which is not practical or possible in the forseeable

So, we have made the conscious decision to work less in order to earn less and be at home more. And net net net will will actually be miles better off!!!! Bananas

OP posts:
ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 20:09

Dibblydoodahdah · 18/03/2023 20:04

@aroomwithaperfectview it’s not exactly the same is it. These are people who are actually paying tax!

There's seems to be some inexplicable "inability" to understand the difference between choosing not to work more only to have most of the money that you have earned confiscated (or even being charged to work more in cases like mine!) and people receiving money as welfare from other people who have earned it and paid it for them.

Bucketheadbucketbum · 18/03/2023 20:07

mishmased · 18/03/2023 19:14

This is so unfair.

100% this. And the answer is simple- to work less. Thebonly surprising thing is that the government don't seem to care that this is the outcome

OP posts:
AcornGreen · 18/03/2023 20:06
Biscuit
VestaTilley · 18/03/2023 20:05

YABU.

Chonk · 18/03/2023 20:04

Ovidnaso · 18/03/2023 19:03

Not among all the people I know who stayed renting their council homes rather than buy them because they wanted other people to benefit from them after their deaths.

Stop invalidating people's motives and morals. Perhaps you wouldn't behave morally, but others do.

And council housing is meant to be for everyone. People who start earning more over the course of a lifetime aren't to blame if greedy landlords charge too much for private housing.

@Ovidnaso Yes that's great, a good decision on their behalf. But your original comment said 'people choose to live in council housing because it's an ethical way to live, contributing to society and local communities'. Please clarify how someone continuing to live in council housing when they can easily afford a private rental benefits society, because I really can't see it.

Dibblydoodahdah · 18/03/2023 20:04

@aroomwithaperfectview it’s not exactly the same is it. These are people who are actually paying tax!

aroomwithaperfectview · 18/03/2023 20:02

Haraebo · 18/03/2023 14:56

If someone from the lower class plays the system to get extra benefits, they get called the scum of the earth. They get called scroungers and are spat on. But let's face it, THEY are the people that need help.

When it comes to people that CAN afford nice things and CAN afford to pay for childcare but then play the system in order to get something for nothing, that's ok?

That's why this country is fucking shit.

Exactly !

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 19:59

And it disadvantages you career wise in the long term compared to your child free (probably mostly male, being realistic) peers. They won't have the childcare cost impact so for them even though the tax is brutal it's worth pushing for that next promotion because they will still be better off. If the have a wife/partner who is a SAHM (as many do at that level IME) then they won't be bothered about childcare costs even if they do have kids.

And they wonder why we have a gender sex pay gap...

Yep. Been treading water for a few years now since husband left when they were babies. But now ready to focus on work more, work want to promote me. I have had to say no, because the increase in salary would leave us with so much LESS money per month that I'd no longer be able to pay the mortgage.

Happyvalleyfan · 18/03/2023 19:56

The only other thing to consider OP- does your job really have the flexibility of decreasing and increasing sessions as quickly as required?
It would take some planning for me to reduce my sessions to LFTE and then increase it again. I may not be able to increase within same role as funding may go to someone else.
Also- my child was a young 4 yo starting school. After this - she could not use any free hours at nursery and you cannot use mainly to cover holiday clubs.

StatisticallyChallenged · 18/03/2023 19:53

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 19:45

Yes this is our situation

Its really a no brainer to reduce hours and associated financial and emotional/ family costs of working all hours.

Complete no brainer. And until the tax code is fixed there will be hundreds of thousands of people in the same situation - the very people we really need to be working more if we want productivity and tax revenues to rise - will continue doing the same.

It's just harder for me because there's only one of me, so by the time I've paid living expenses and childcare there is barely enough left for us to survive. And no way for us to improve it either, because the state would take more than 100%, much more. We'd be way worse off.

In your situation with two of you, I'd absolutely cut down the hours, enjoy your children and not bother at all about it all.

And it disadvantages you career wise in the long term compared to your child free (probably mostly male, being realistic) peers. They won't have the childcare cost impact so for them even though the tax is brutal it's worth pushing for that next promotion because they will still be better off. If the have a wife/partner who is a SAHM (as many do at that level IME) then they won't be bothered about childcare costs even if they do have kids.

And they wonder why we have a gender sex pay gap...

Swipe left for the next trending thread