Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

DH and I going part time to deliberately reduce wages

890 replies

Bucketheadbucketbum · 18/03/2023 13:35

Just working out the free childcare hours and actually DH and I will be muxh better off if we both dropped to 3- 4 day week to deliberately reduce our incomes. Would obviously be nice way to live too! Anyone else doing same? Seems mental but we've looked at it 100 times over and it's true!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
floralqueen · 18/03/2023 22:21

I would. As long as you can go back ft when the childcare isn't needed if government allows for this then you're entitled to it.

StatisticallyChallenged · 18/03/2023 22:07

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 21:52

Thank you for listening and understanding.

Tbh by then they probably won't want to promote me, as I'll be deemed too old to be worth bothering with, best years of career progression gone.

Crap for me. Crap for my kids. Also crap for the taxpayer who could get a lot more money out of me if I was allowed to take a promotion and move up now without LOSING take home pay so my children lose their home.

Would promotion involve a lot of extra hours for you? If not (or if it's manageable), would it be worth just taking the promotion and stuffing the whole damn lot in your pension for now?

I know this wouldn't improve your current situation, but my thinking is that it would then put you on the path towards the next promotion or next job move which might get you over the point where it starts to make a difference to your take home pay (at which point you stop stuffing money in your pension like a crazy lady, accept the tax man eating that chunk, but at least start seeing some more money each month).

I think salary sacrifice for an EV would also be a way to pull it down and would improve your family life if you are having to get rid of your old car. Assuming your employer has a scheme of course.

Lostinalibrary · 18/03/2023 22:06

My husband was offered 60k more because anything less than a 50k rise would have been a net loss. Employers head hunting professionals at this level know this. The government know this. How sick is an economy that at 50k pay rise - higher than the average salary results in a net loss?

The system is broken and the real earners who are paying for it all are at breaking point and saying - no more.

The actual rich are laughing as you tear apart the ones paying for your benefits and public services as they deserve it. These are the “workers” who have done well for themselves. The actual generational rich are laughing at us all and paying no tax while you demand more of those doing the heavy lifting at over 100% effective tax.

The net result will be the public services and welfare services will collapse.

Mumoftwosweetboys · 18/03/2023 22:01

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 21:52

Thank you for listening and understanding.

Tbh by then they probably won't want to promote me, as I'll be deemed too old to be worth bothering with, best years of career progression gone.

Crap for me. Crap for my kids. Also crap for the taxpayer who could get a lot more money out of me if I was allowed to take a promotion and move up now without LOSING take home pay so my children lose their home.

@ScruffyGiraffes I've read your posts on this thread and it's shit for you. Literally penalised for working very hard (no doubt) to earn a "high salary". The actual rich are not being taxed enough (nowhere near) so it's the high earning hard working but not rich who are getting slammed on tax and in turn not entitled to support (eg childcare).

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 21:59

What I am, however, saying is that it is absolutely ludicrous, as some have done, to suggest that someone who decides not to work more at £100k because it will actually cost them money (and who is paying for someone else's benefits) is in any way comparable to someone not working much and cheating the system out of benefits.

^ This.

Mumoftwosweetboys · 18/03/2023 21:55

Zoe303 · 18/03/2023 21:45

I am wondering the same as we won’t be eligible for any childcare support with the new system, we both do contract work and could take a few extra weeks off in between contacts to take us to below the threshold (with the bonus of getting some extra time with our DS too!)

I can see why it seems unfair to some as we can afford the childcare but the cliff edge all or nothing threshold feels a bit unfair and puts us in a position where we would be better off earning £20k or so less.

Yes exactly @Zoe303 . It's not even tapered. It's all or nothing and makes no sense whatsoever.

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 21:52

bigbabycooker · 18/03/2023 21:46

@ScruffyGiraffes

I am really sorry. That is crap. You have tried really hard and I agree with you.

Thank you for listening and understanding.

Tbh by then they probably won't want to promote me, as I'll be deemed too old to be worth bothering with, best years of career progression gone.

Crap for me. Crap for my kids. Also crap for the taxpayer who could get a lot more money out of me if I was allowed to take a promotion and move up now without LOSING take home pay so my children lose their home.

StatisticallyChallenged · 18/03/2023 21:51

Florissant · 18/03/2023 21:46

Well put. Why work when other people can shoulder the load?

With two parents earning just a smidge under 100k each they'll be paying approx 66k in tax per year as a family.

Hardly expecting other people to shoulder the load...they're shouldering many people's loads with that tax contribution.

StatisticallyChallenged · 18/03/2023 21:50

bigbabycooker · 18/03/2023 21:43

And yes @ScruffyGiraffes, the other thing that people are missing is that your people on £100k, even working part time, are likely doing long days and taking on responsibilities beyond a simple 9-5. I'm not saying, before people jump down my throat, that people on lower salaries don't have important jobs - they do. What I am, however, saying is that it is absolutely ludicrous, as some have done, to suggest that someone who decides not to work more at £100k because it will actually cost them money (and who is paying for someone else's benefits) is in any way comparable to someone not working much and cheating the system out of benefits.

Exactly, this isn't someone saying "I'm not going to work and contribute", it's saying "I think £33k is quite enough tax for one year, and if I earn more I'll take home less due to the childcare cliff edge so nah."

With two parents paying that kind of tax I think it's safe to say they'll still be massive net contributors.

Florissant · 18/03/2023 21:49

Ovidnaso · 18/03/2023 14:45

Erm, because council housing is an ethical housing system whereby the rent those good earners pay goes back into the community and the treasury, rather than paying private landlords.
People choose to live in council housing because it's an ethical way to live, contributing to society and local communities.

What a load of bollocks.

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 21:49

Yes that's an absolutely ridiculous idea, that working less to avoid the punitive taxes (as any sane person would! Nobody works for free?!) while still paying huge amounts of tax that cover all of your own state services and provide a large amount of money to be given to others on lower incomes is in any way comparable to people receiving money they didn't earn, or worse deliberately manipulating the system to receive more than they should of money they didn't earn. It's not remotely comparable, unless we decide that all people (and their time) are state property. 🤣

Mumoftwosweetboys · 18/03/2023 21:47

WeightoftheWorld · 18/03/2023 17:24

Actually laughed out loud as some PPs suggesting people should work longer hours away from their family for free just to pay more taxes when they already are net contributors. As if any of those people suggesting this would ever do this themselves! Farcical.

Some great points on the thread here about the punitive nature of our tax system on senior professionals that a lot of people won't (can't?) engage with. I say that as someone who has no skin in that game as our gross household income is only around £45k hah. However we do both work part-time and that decision was partly related to the cost of childcare which is an issue that does also need addressing. I have absolutely no faith at all in the government's recent announcements on this though. Let's see where we are in September 2025, almost certainly under a Labour government then anyway.

Exactly @WeightoftheWorld. I agree with every word you say.

I'm a well paid senior professional (over £100k) but after tax, net take home is nowhere near what others might expect. Then factor in childcare and mortgage (in my case in London) and you're really not left with loads after. No wonder people like OP want to reduce hours rather than be worse off. Irritating that people don't understand that OP has to date been a high tax contributor and will continue to be even on reduced hours.

Soon enough we'll be telling lower paid professions (eg teachers who are UNDERPAID) or other lower paid jobs that they need second jobs to pay more tax or that they must switch to a five day a week (or why not six days?!) higher paid job to contribute more tax!

Florissant · 18/03/2023 21:46

LizzieSiddal · 18/03/2023 13:41

Sounds like you don’t care that other tax payers will be working to pay for your child when you could actually afford to pay for it yourself.

Each to their own I suppose.

Well put. Why work when other people can shoulder the load?

bigbabycooker · 18/03/2023 21:46

@ScruffyGiraffes

I am really sorry. That is crap. You have tried really hard and I agree with you.

StatisticallyChallenged · 18/03/2023 21:45

MoltenLasagne · 18/03/2023 21:44

I understand OP, I went to 4 days a week after having DC1 because I didn't want him in full time.

What astounded me was although my salary went from £60k to £50k, my take home pay only dropped from £3,200 a month to £3,000 a month. The extra day at nursery would have been £80 a week.

So I'd have lost a day a week with my kid and it would have cost me money!

And you'd have lost child benefit too

Zoe303 · 18/03/2023 21:45

I am wondering the same as we won’t be eligible for any childcare support with the new system, we both do contract work and could take a few extra weeks off in between contacts to take us to below the threshold (with the bonus of getting some extra time with our DS too!)

I can see why it seems unfair to some as we can afford the childcare but the cliff edge all or nothing threshold feels a bit unfair and puts us in a position where we would be better off earning £20k or so less.

MoltenLasagne · 18/03/2023 21:44

I understand OP, I went to 4 days a week after having DC1 because I didn't want him in full time.

What astounded me was although my salary went from £60k to £50k, my take home pay only dropped from £3,200 a month to £3,000 a month. The extra day at nursery would have been £80 a week.

So I'd have lost a day a week with my kid and it would have cost me money!

bigbabycooker · 18/03/2023 21:43

And yes @ScruffyGiraffes, the other thing that people are missing is that your people on £100k, even working part time, are likely doing long days and taking on responsibilities beyond a simple 9-5. I'm not saying, before people jump down my throat, that people on lower salaries don't have important jobs - they do. What I am, however, saying is that it is absolutely ludicrous, as some have done, to suggest that someone who decides not to work more at £100k because it will actually cost them money (and who is paying for someone else's benefits) is in any way comparable to someone not working much and cheating the system out of benefits.

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 21:43

mishmased · 18/03/2023 21:23

@AviMav people manage on a lot less because they pay a lot less tax. Someone on 35k will not lose almost 40% of their income. They will not lose cb, depending on how many kids they have they might get childcare support. These are supports that people like @ScruffyGiraffes are losing coupled with being a single parent.
I don't think someone on 35k will pay a third of their gross income on taxes. @ScruffyGiraffes taxes literally is someone's full time wage. She is struggling due to lack of support that low income families get and in some cases some people get the equivalent.
Why is the point in training for years, not seeing your kids, paying for childcare and giving most of your wages to the taxman?
These are the same people that shouldn't have kids 'if they're going to have them in childcare all day' according to some.

Thank you. I'm glad some people do understand it at least. I really don't know what to do anymore. Always worked hard, have paid so much tax to support others and not begrudged it, but when we are being taxed so much we can barely afford to live surely that is too much?

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 21:41

bigbabycooker · 18/03/2023 21:16

@ScruffyGiraffes

I'm really sorry and I can totally understand how this has happened to you. The system is shit. I hope that your employer can reward you in a few years' time, when the childcare hurdle is not so massive.

Both of my children have SEN and cannot do holiday clubs etc, need 1:1 nannies. No support with that either because guess what? SS not interested and say "you have a job, just fund it yourself". So I'll have a £2k+ per month childcare bill for the next 6 years, at least.

So no, sadly, if the penalisation of single parents in the tax code isn't removed, or these punitive tax rates at my earning level, I can accept no promotions and there is literally nothing I can do to improve our living standard. And if any Government decides to increase taxes on us even more because according to them we are rich, we will lose our home and despite all of this work to provide for them I will have completely failed. That is the brink we are being pushed towards by these policies, when people take over a third of my income as tax to give to other people who get to spend way more time with their children than I do with mine, and then tell us we are "rich" when we can't afford food anymore unless I sell our car.

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 21:34

It’s like clapping seals who cannot think logically. I do believe it is what will cause the ultimate downfall of the welfare state/NHS/education as we know it. It’s already started. People who have done well in their field are in the perverse position that a 35K pay rise can be 100% wiped out and they will be worse off. Therefore, people cut their hours.

Instead of thinking- “oh, hang on, let’s encourage these massive tax payers and net contributors to pay more. We will make the tax system so punitive they stop working.” I actually think people see 100k and think you clear near enough 8.5k a month. Reality is, with childcare, loss of allowance, no top ups (obviously), full loss of everything. You’ll often have a similar disposable to those who are working and are “topped up.” Difference is, the higher earner is paying for it. Stop them from working things will be cut as tax take falls.

People will only have themselves to blame. Like clapping seals with no critical thinking.

^^ This needed posting again because @Lostinalibrary articulted the problem so clearly.

mishmased · 18/03/2023 21:23

@AviMav people manage on a lot less because they pay a lot less tax. Someone on 35k will not lose almost 40% of their income. They will not lose cb, depending on how many kids they have they might get childcare support. These are supports that people like @ScruffyGiraffes are losing coupled with being a single parent.
I don't think someone on 35k will pay a third of their gross income on taxes. @ScruffyGiraffes taxes literally is someone's full time wage. She is struggling due to lack of support that low income families get and in some cases some people get the equivalent.
Why is the point in training for years, not seeing your kids, paying for childcare and giving most of your wages to the taxman?
These are the same people that shouldn't have kids 'if they're going to have them in childcare all day' according to some.

bigbabycooker · 18/03/2023 21:16

@ScruffyGiraffes

I'm really sorry and I can totally understand how this has happened to you. The system is shit. I hope that your employer can reward you in a few years' time, when the childcare hurdle is not so massive.

mishmased · 18/03/2023 21:13

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 19:59

And it disadvantages you career wise in the long term compared to your child free (probably mostly male, being realistic) peers. They won't have the childcare cost impact so for them even though the tax is brutal it's worth pushing for that next promotion because they will still be better off. If the have a wife/partner who is a SAHM (as many do at that level IME) then they won't be bothered about childcare costs even if they do have kids.

And they wonder why we have a gender sex pay gap...

Yep. Been treading water for a few years now since husband left when they were babies. But now ready to focus on work more, work want to promote me. I have had to say no, because the increase in salary would leave us with so much LESS money per month that I'd no longer be able to pay the mortgage.

This is wrong, I'm beyond shocked.

GirlOfTudor · 18/03/2023 21:10

Are you referring to the 15 or 30 hrs free childcare?

Swipe left for the next trending thread