Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

DH and I going part time to deliberately reduce wages

890 replies

Bucketheadbucketbum · 18/03/2023 13:35

Just working out the free childcare hours and actually DH and I will be muxh better off if we both dropped to 3- 4 day week to deliberately reduce our incomes. Would obviously be nice way to live too! Anyone else doing same? Seems mental but we've looked at it 100 times over and it's true!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Dibblydoodahdah · 19/03/2023 08:59

@Yoyo2021 what the fuck is shameful about spending more time with your children knowing that you won’t be any worse off financially?

Any why can’t you and some other people on this thread get it into your economically illiterate heads that the OP and people
like her are not taking anything from the tax payer? THEY ARE NET CONTRIBUTORS. Do you know what that means?

Dibblydoodahdah · 19/03/2023 08:54

@HistoryFanatic and what’s your definition of poor?! Come on tell us how much you earn?

I’ll tell you something. I am not funding a health system I can’t use.

Dyslexicwonder · 19/03/2023 08:36

Dyslexicwonder · 19/03/2023 08:32

DH and I deliberately earnt 49,000 each throughout the DC's primarly school years. Doing this enabled us to:

  1. Be there for school pick up 4/5 evenings
  2. Pay almost no HRT after pension contributions
  3. Retain CHB
  4. Have a decent quality of living (Sept 2011- June 2015) by being a little bit careful including employing a nanny/ housekeeper for 8 hours ,we came home to cooked meal on the day of week we both WOTH

We only gave this up when we could earn circa 80K before that it wasn't worth it.

If I had preschoolers now I would absolutely work pt to keep my earnings under 100K, it would be entirely counterproductive not to.

It is also worth noting that there is a marginal tax rate of 63% between 100-125k,couple this with losing your entitlement to free childcare and anyone can see the logic. If someone has the ability to earn this sort of salary you can hardly expect them not to be able to work this out for themselves.

StatisticallyChallenged · 19/03/2023 08:32

Yoyo2021 · 19/03/2023 08:23

Only just seen they are earning.

If you’re earning that much you really should not be looking to the tax payer to help you out. Shameful.

However, anybody on universal credit in a light touch group preparing to drop hours or not in a few months I heard will be caller to weekly appointments.

This is to stop people being so benefit dependent.

Would you accept a tiny pay rise - say £10 a month - knowing that it would reduce your income after tax and childcare by 1/3? And that you would not get back to the position you were in before until you'd had a 50% pay rise?

Dyslexicwonder · 19/03/2023 08:32

DH and I deliberately earnt 49,000 each throughout the DC's primarly school years. Doing this enabled us to:

  1. Be there for school pick up 4/5 evenings
  2. Pay almost no HRT after pension contributions
  3. Retain CHB
  4. Have a decent quality of living (Sept 2011- June 2015) by being a little bit careful including employing a nanny/ housekeeper for 8 hours ,we came home to cooked meal on the day of week we both WOTH

We only gave this up when we could earn circa 80K before that it wasn't worth it.

If I had preschoolers now I would absolutely work pt to keep my earnings under 100K, it would be entirely counterproductive not to.

bigbabycooker · 19/03/2023 08:28

@HistoryFanatic

I don't think that OP ever said she was being altruistic at all. Why should OP work more to be poorer? You wouldn't expect someone on UC to work more if it meant that they wouldn't get housing benefit and would have to move somewhere crappier- it is the same thing! It's the government who sets these stupid cliff edges. What is more, there are some places in London and the south east where, particularly now mortgages have risen, people need two big incomes to afford the not mansion that they are raising their kids in and OP may need to be close to London for work. The U.K. is screwed - there are a tiny number of people paying tax for everyone else and who spent their 20s toiling away in the office late every night and are going to try to juggle those jobs with having kids but the answer is always going to be to tax them more and more.

MarshaBradyo · 19/03/2023 08:28

HistoryFanatic · 19/03/2023 08:25

She can but pay private ideally so those who are poor dont have to wait for so long.

Not sure you’re being serious. If you got your set up you’d likely find people not hanging around to pay the tax at all.

Can you make up their shortfall?

HistoryFanatic · 19/03/2023 08:25

Dibblydoodahdah · 19/03/2023 08:11

@HistoryFanatic so she’s not even allowed to use the NHS now. You expect her to pay shit loads of tax for other people to use the NHS but she can’t?!! How much tax do you pay by the way?

She can but pay private ideally so those who are poor dont have to wait for so long.

Yoyo2021 · 19/03/2023 08:23

ScruffyGiraffes · 19/03/2023 00:36

Lol! Of course they won't when they'd still be paying more than most people's annual salary in tax and neither of them claiming any benefits?!

Only just seen they are earning.

If you’re earning that much you really should not be looking to the tax payer to help you out. Shameful.

However, anybody on universal credit in a light touch group preparing to drop hours or not in a few months I heard will be caller to weekly appointments.

This is to stop people being so benefit dependent.

Hardbackwriter · 19/03/2023 08:20

Mumoftwosweetboys · 19/03/2023 08:16

@Zoe303 unless any other changes are announced you'll be entitled to 15 hours for your 3+ year old. Everyone is.
What's not quite clear to me is whether the expansion to 9 months to 2 years will also have the 15/30 hour distinction

My understanding is it will not - the 15 hours at 3 is because this is the part badged as for the child, so it doesn't get taken away if you earn too much in the same way as you can be a millionaire but still send your kids to state school - it's their entitlement to an education, not yours. The expansion down to 9 months is being badged entirely as childcare for working parents so I don't think there will be any 15 hour universal aspect.

Mumoftwosweetboys · 19/03/2023 08:16

@Zoe303 unless any other changes are announced you'll be entitled to 15 hours for your 3+ year old. Everyone is.
What's not quite clear to me is whether the expansion to 9 months to 2 years will also have the 15/30 hour distinction

Dibblydoodahdah · 19/03/2023 08:11

@HistoryFanatic so she’s not even allowed to use the NHS now. You expect her to pay shit loads of tax for other people to use the NHS but she can’t?!! How much tax do you pay by the way?

StatisticallyChallenged · 19/03/2023 08:07

If they earn under 100k they are entitled to it though. It's up to them if they choose to earn under 100k.

I'm not dressing anything up as altruistic but I am being realistic- if the govt create such a perverse system people will make decisions based on these cliff edges.

If your boss said "I'd like you to work an extra two hours this week" and you knew that working those two hours would result in you having roughly 1/3 less income for the entire year, would you work them?

Lasttraintolondon · 19/03/2023 08:07

OP is right.

The tax system is broken. The cliff edge is real. Anyone with basic maths and a grasp of human nature can see people won't work more for free. It's astonishingly naive to think differently. It's essentially having a go at someone for not doing voluntary work!

They are already massive tax payers/contributors and still will be if they do fewer hours. It is not immoral to work less.

The only pity is that early years funding isn't enough for nurseries and causes them difficulties.

HistoryFanatic · 19/03/2023 08:01

Don't dress it up as altruistic.

HistoryFanatic · 19/03/2023 07:49

Hardbackwriter · 19/03/2023 07:16

If she was in UC there would be no expectation at all that they both worked full-time with a preschool child. In fact, the expectation is that you don't have to work at all until the child is 3, then you only have to work 16 hours until they're 5, then you only have to work 25 hours until they're 12. I haven't seen much outrage over this despite the fact that it clearly supports people working less than they could 'at the expense of others'.

Again, I really don't get the backlash to OP here. If she had just posted saying that she had two young children and her and her partner both worked full-time she'd have got lots of faux-concern head tilts, 'could you not look to go part-time?', 'they're only little once', 'I don't understand why people have children just to put them in nursery', etc. She might have got the odd comment about considering her own pension but absolutely no one would have said that this was an ideal scenario because it maximised their tax contributions.

She is trying to play the system to get something she isn't entitled to and she can well afford to pay for.

StatisticallyChallenged · 19/03/2023 07:48

HistoryFanatic · 19/03/2023 07:38

Don't call yourself the squeezed middle, OP BTW. I don't think you know what that is. I don't have much sympathy. If you can afford to pay childcare, health care etc you pay it.

Do you know the sort of cliff edge these families are hitting?

Here's an article which has worked out the numbers - for a family with two kids in London, tipping over that threshold would instantly cost them approximately £27k per year in net income. That's not reasonable or affordable. That's after already paying more tax per year than the govt would pay for childcare for those two children.

I don't believe that if you were previously earning 99k and were given a 2% pay rise you would just shrug and accept being over 2k per month worse off.

ifamagazine.com/article/hunts-new-childcare-plans-make-punitive-100000-earnings-cliff-edge-eye-watering/

HistoryFanatic · 19/03/2023 07:38

Don't call yourself the squeezed middle, OP BTW. I don't think you know what that is. I don't have much sympathy. If you can afford to pay childcare, health care etc you pay it.

StatisticallyChallenged · 19/03/2023 07:36

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 23:16

Would promotion involve a lot of extra hours for you? If not (or if it's manageable), would it be worth just taking the promotion and stuffing the whole damn lot in your pension for now?

I know this wouldn't improve your current situation, but my thinking is that it would then put you on the path towards the next promotion or next job move which might get you over the point where it starts to make a difference to your take home pay (at which point you stop stuffing money in your pension like a crazy lady, accept the tax man eating that chunk, but at least start seeing some more money each month).

I think salary sacrifice for an EV would also be a way to pull it down and would improve your family life if you are having to get rid of your old car. Assuming your employer has a scheme of course.

Thanks for the suggestions. Per this budget apparently now I could stuff enough from the next promotion up into pension without breaching the £100k of post-pension earnings and therefore losing tens of thousands in net pay and losing the house. We'd still get no more money as net pay from me taking the promotion which is what we desperately need and is not allowed, but as a stepping stone it might be worth it IF we could trust that the higher pension contribution allowances would be maintained while I was stuck in that situation. Then it might just about be doable - to get no more money now but put it into pension and just work work work for the next promotion when we might actually be allowed to keep some of the money in my monthy salary in a few years time followimg a second promotion.

But, if I took the promotion then Labour reverse the pension changes as they have pledged to, if in power in just over a year, those higher pension contributions would not be allowed, then huge cliff-edge effective tax rates would kick in for breaching the £100k threshold where we'd lose tens of thousands of net pay overnight. We'd be screwed and lose our home, even though on paper I'd have a higher salary than now, because I can't actually access any of that money as net pay because of this tax system. I just can't take that risk as the sole provider for two children, that politicians will just take our home away (for the crime of being promoted!). Although I suppose that'll happen anyway if Labour get in if they raise taxes further on anyone earning over £80k as they said previously. I genuinely have no more money to pay any more rises. There's nothing left. Labour don't seem remotely interested in equalising the tax system to give single parents the same allowances as couples, any more than the Tories are. Nobody is on our side.

We'd only be better off in terms of actual take home pay if I get two promotions, and I'd need another 4-5 years to get to the second one. I'd have to sacrifice yet more time with my children in what's left of their childhoods after they've been through a huge trauma already, on a hope and prayer that politicians won't reduce pension contribution limits again and by doing so make us homeless and bankrupt while I work for the second promotion. It's just too risky.

Benefits like EVs still count as taxable income so sadly that wouldn't help escape this cliff edge where if you hit £100k you are hit with an extra tax bill of tens of thousands of pounds, just for earning £1 more.

It is such a mess. I want to carry on with my career and do more for my children but until these tax issues are solved we are paralysed, treading water and desperately trying not to drown.

Thank you for your replies though, and to everyone who's been supportive. A lot of the time it's like speaking to a brick wall and nobody cares so it means a lot and I really hope more women will stand up politically to campaign to end the tax discrimination against single mothers, it does so much damage.

I'm not 100% sure re the childcare side but I think specifically EVs under salary sacrifice might work. Normally the value of salary sacrifice to be declared is the higher of the salary given up or the bik charge, but for EVs it's always the bik charge. Done under s/s this reduces your net taxable income - the sacrificed money isn't on your p60. I don't think HMRC make it clear and it's not covered in their examples but I think the crucial bit is it's already off the net taxable income number.

"Calculate a non-cash benefit
For any non-cash benefits, you need to work out the value of the benefit.

If you set up a new salary sacrifice arrangement, you’ll need to work out the value of a non-cash benefit by using the higher of the:

amount of the salary given up
earnings charge under the normal benefit in kind rules
For cars with CO2 emissions of no more than 75g/km, you should always use the earnings charge under the normal benefit in kind rules"

Completely get why you wouldn't take the risk but worth mentioning for others in same boat. Even if labour get in it will be a couple of years before they can mess with the allowances and thresholds so you could be back out the other side by then, depending on career trajectory of course. It's a gamble though and an absurd position to put anyone in.

Bucketheadbucketbum · 19/03/2023 07:32

ScruffyGiraffes · 18/03/2023 20:59

I'm not speaking for everyone on Mumsnet.

I've explained the factual distortions in the tax system that are disincentivising work for the people who pay most of the UK's tax (not the super rich!) resulting in low UK productivity and tax revenues and therefore no money to improve public services etc for everyone. This is fact. Hunt's own research stated this. The IFS have said it's a "dog's breakfast". The Times and FT and Guardian and others have written articles about it. So yes of course higher earning people cut down their hours because it's not worth them working more. This is factual and is happening across the economy, research shows it clearly and indisputably. This is bad for everyone.

I have also explained how single parents (almost all women) are doubly impacted by this, giving the example of my own situation, because these tax thresholds are doubly punitive for us. Others in the same situation have also said so, on this thread and in the research. We pay huge amounts of tax and can barely afford to live because the UK tax system applies all of these thresholds on an individual not household basis, impoverishing us and our children. So for us, even less incentive to work more and actually, unsurprisingly, many do not bother or give up entirely.

I've seen the calculations. If I'd never bothered at all, with degree and professional qualifications and all the hard work to build a career and buy a house and instead claimed benefits we would have TWICE the disposable income per month that we do now. That is disgusting.

I want to work. I want to contribute. I always have done so. I should however be left with enough to provide my children with a decent life, when I'm paying £34k per year into the pot to help other people. And to be able to take a promotion without us then having LESS money per month than we do now and being unable to pay my mortgage.

If you want a country where there's money to pay for services and benefits then making it impossible for higher earners to better their circumstances by working more - while bettering everyone else's at the same time by paying even more in - then penalising them to the extent that it's not worthwhile for them to work is not a good idea.

Exactly this

We decided our options are to cut hours and deliberately earn less or emigrate

OP posts:
Dibblydoodahdah · 19/03/2023 07:31

@EmmaDilemma5 is it unethical for stay at home parents to get NI credits when paying zero into the system? Because there’s nothing unethical about having a better work life balance so you get to see your kids more when you are still paying enough tax to cover what you take from the system.

You are not paying anything for people earning £100k plus. They are net contributors. You are paying for people who don’t contribute enough tax in comparison to the amount they take from the system. That’s assuming you are a net contributor yourself.

EmmaDilemma5 · 19/03/2023 07:24

It's unethical and it's paid for by the rest of us.

But yeah, if you're the kind of people who think about yourselves before anyone else, and play systems to get all you can, then, do it.

But don't boast about it on a public forum and don't call yourself the squeezed middle. You're the tight higher earners; you always want more.

Hardbackwriter · 19/03/2023 07:16

HistoryFanatic · 19/03/2023 06:53

Imagine the different reaction if OP was saying they are working less or giving up their job because they want more universal credit.

I am not sure on the moral area on this.

If she was in UC there would be no expectation at all that they both worked full-time with a preschool child. In fact, the expectation is that you don't have to work at all until the child is 3, then you only have to work 16 hours until they're 5, then you only have to work 25 hours until they're 12. I haven't seen much outrage over this despite the fact that it clearly supports people working less than they could 'at the expense of others'.

Again, I really don't get the backlash to OP here. If she had just posted saying that she had two young children and her and her partner both worked full-time she'd have got lots of faux-concern head tilts, 'could you not look to go part-time?', 'they're only little once', 'I don't understand why people have children just to put them in nursery', etc. She might have got the odd comment about considering her own pension but absolutely no one would have said that this was an ideal scenario because it maximised their tax contributions.

Zoe303 · 19/03/2023 06:59

I have a question - my DS is 2 at the moment and a while ago when we were looking ahead at the free hours for when he turns 3 we thought that as high earners we’d be eligible for 15 free hours instead of 30. Has the new system got rid of that completely so high earners get zero hours? We thought that was the case but I can’t find anything definitive. Or was there never 15 hours for high earners?

HistoryFanatic · 19/03/2023 06:53

Imagine the different reaction if OP was saying they are working less or giving up their job because they want more universal credit.

I am not sure on the moral area on this.